Back to California Paid Family Leave

Jamal Washington

My disability log and how I tracked my California EDD PFL claim from day one

So I started keeping a disability log when my wife's mom got really sick back in August and I realized I had no idea how any of this worked. I'm the one taking her to appointments and staying with her when she can't be on her own, and I knew I'd need to file a PFL care claim with California EDD eventually. I grabbed a notebook and started writing down every single thing — when I called, what SDI Online showed, what days I was taking off work, all of it. I filed in SDI Online through myEDD a few weeks ago. Got my receipt number, wrote it down immediately. The claim is still sitting in pending status and I haven't gotten any kind of letter yet about what my benefit amount might be. I know Part C and Part D are involved for a care claim — Part C is my mother-in-law's own statement and Part D is her doctor's certification — and I confirmed with her doctor's office that they're submitting Part D online using my receipt number. I've been noting every date in this log. Has anyone else kept a running log like this? Did it help when things got confusing? And how long did it take before you heard something back after filing a care claim?

Keeping notes like that is probably the smartest thing you can do, honestly. My dad's care claim dragged on longer than I expected and I had dates mixed up everywhere. The 41-day window from when your leave starts is the one I'd track most carefully — Part D has to reach EDD within that window or you can lose benefits for days outside it. Your log already has your leave start date I assume?

0 coins

Yes, that's one of the first things I wrote down — the exact date I took my first day off for her. I didn't realize the 41 days ran from that date specifically, I thought it was from when I filed. Good to know.

0 coins

Same confusion I had. It's the leave start date that starts the clock, not the filing date. My doctor's office almost missed it because I gave them a later date by mistake.

0 coins

The pending stage felt endless when I was going through a care claim for my husband. EDD has up to 14 days to make an eligibility decision, so if you're under that you're technically still in normal territory. After 14 days I'd send a Request Claim Update in SDI Online — there's a way to do it right from the claim page.

0 coins

Filing date was about nine days ago so I'm still inside that window. I'll set a reminder for day 14 and send the update if nothing has moved.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update option was the only thing that got any movement on my claim. I was at day 16 with nothing and sent one, and the Notice of Computation showed up two days later. No idea if it was related but it felt like it.

0 coins

14 days is the stated window but I've seen people wait longer. Sending the update request doesn't hurt and at least it creates a record.

0 coins

Pending with no Notice of Computation yet is the part that stressed me out most on my own care claim. EDD hadn't matched my receipt number to the notice on their end, and I had no idea if the weekly amount they'd calculated was anywhere near what I expected. I went to claimyr.com (Claimyr) to get to an actual EDD Paid Family Leave agent on the phone. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the Notice of Computation had been generated but not yet mailed — she gave me the weekly benefit amount right off the claim. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Once I had that number I could actually plan around it.

0 coins

The weekly benefit amount is the piece I keep wondering about. My log has my wages written in but I have no way to know what the actual number will be until EDD calculates it. I might try this if the Notice still hasn't come by next week.

0 coins

EDD's calculator on their site gives you an estimate based on your wages. It won't be the exact number but it's close enough to plan around while you're waiting for the real notice.

0 coins

The estimate on EDD's site is a good starting point. The agent told me the actual figure on my notice was pretty close to the calculator's estimate, give or take.

0 coins

Part D is where my claim got stuck and your log will be crucial if the same happens to you. The doctor's office told me they submitted it online, but EDD had no record of it matched to my claim for over a week. If you have dates in that log of when the office said they submitted, you have something concrete to reference when you contact EDD.

0 coins

The doctor's office sent me a message saying they submitted it on a specific date, so I screenshotted that and taped it into the log. I figured that might matter later.

0 coins

That screenshot is exactly the kind of thing to have. I had to go back to my doctor's office with the receipt number a second time because the first submission apparently never went through. Logging the confirmation from them saved me from a longer argument.

0 coins

Receipt number is everything for Part D. Some offices are good about asking for it, others just try to submit without it and it doesn't match to anything EDD can find.

0 coins

Your log is going to pay off even more if EDD sends a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination instead of an approval — that's the letter that says they're not paying, and it comes with an appeal form. You'd want your dates and documentation right there already if you need to file that appeal within 30 days.

0 coins

I didn't even know that was a possible outcome at this stage. What would typically cause that kind of denial this early?

0 coins

Usually it's something like Part D not being received in time, or a question about whether enough wages with SDI withheld are in your base period. The notice should say the specific reason, and you have 30 days from the date on it to appeal using the DE 1000A form.

0 coins

Appeals aren't as scary as they sound. I appealed a denial on a care claim and the hearing was pretty straightforward once I had my documentation together. That appeal form, the DE 1000A, is what you file, and you can do it online or by mail.

0 coins

Something about the care claim process that tripped me up — I was under the impression Part C could be uploaded in SDI Online just like a proof of relationship document on a bonding claim. It can't, and doing so can actually slow things down. Part C has to go by mail on the paper form, and so does Part D unless the doctor's office submits it directly in SDI Online with your receipt number.

0 coins

I didn't try to upload either one, I just confirmed the doctor was submitting Part D through SDI Online. My mother-in-law mailed Part C herself last week. Is there any way to confirm EDD received it?

0 coins

There's no upload confirmation for mailed Part C, unfortunately. If the claim keeps sitting past 14 days, calling EDD and asking if Part C has been received is worth doing — an agent can tell you what's matched to the claim.

0 coins

Mailing Part C with a tracking number helped my peace of mind even if it doesn't change anything on EDD's end. At least you know when it arrived at the right address.

0 coins

Does the log help with reporting intermittent days? I'm asking because I'm a few weeks into a care claim myself and I go back to work two or three days a week when my sister's husband can cover. I wasn't sure if I need to report those work days somewhere or if EDD figures it out from the wages.

0 coins

You have to report it. The question to ask yourself is whether you told EDD upfront that you'd be working some days, because on the paper DE 2501F there's a spot for that. If you're already doing intermittent days, any wages you earn even before they're paid have to be reported to EDD. They'll send a Continued Claim Certification form and benefits stop if you don't return it.

0 coins

I filed in SDI Online, not on paper. Where does the reporting happen for an online claim?

0 coins

EDD sends the Continued Claim Certification, which is the DE 2580GF, and you fill it out for the days you worked and the wages. Not returning it is what stops payments, so keep an eye out for it. Your log is perfect for tracking which days you worked each week.

0 coins

Not reporting work days is the main way people end up with an overpayment notice. The certification form is EDD's way of reconciling what you said you'd be doing with what you actually did.

0 coins

I want to make sure I understand the total weeks correctly. My mother-in-law's care is going to go on for a while, and I was planning to do eight weeks of PFL for the care claim, then potentially bond with our new baby next spring. Is it eight weeks for each or is there a combined limit?

0 coins

The eight weeks is a combined limit across all PFL claim types within any 12-month period — bonding, care and military assist all draw from the same pool. So if you use five weeks for a care claim, only three weeks remain for bonding if the baby arrives within the same 12 months. Worth planning around.

0 coins

That changes my planning significantly. So the 12-month period — does it start from the first day I use PFL, or is it a calendar year?

0 coins

It runs from the start of whichever claim you open first. So if your care claim starts in October, the 12 months runs through the following October, and any bonding claim for a baby born in that window shares the same pool of eight weeks.

0 coins

I thought each type had its own eight weeks and I was completely wrong. I used six weeks on a care claim and was counting on a full eight for bonding the following spring and EDD set me straight when I called. Two weeks was all I had left.

0 coins

Payments pending with no update is where my stress peaked on my own care claim. The status in SDI Online hadn't moved in several days after what I thought was an approval, and I genuinely could not tell which weeks EDD had issued payment for and which were still open. I tried Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and she went through the payment history on my claim, week by week, and told me which ones had been paid and when the next payment was due. Knowing the actual schedule meant I could stop checking SDI Online every few hours.

0 coins

The every-few-hours checking is exactly where I am right now. Did she give you a reason why some weeks were still open?

0 coins

She said the Continued Claim Certification for those weeks hadn't been processed yet. Once she confirmed the weeks that were already paid I knew the remaining ones weren't lost, just pending. That was enough for me to stop spiraling about it.

0 coins

The payment history in SDI Online does show issued payments but it's not always clear which period each payment covers. Having an agent read it out line by line is a lot cleaner than trying to piece it together yourself.

0 coins

For anyone who's been told PFL has a one-week waiting period like disability does — that's not right. I went into my care claim thinking I'd lose the first week of benefits, and someone corrected me here before I did anything based on that assumption. PFL has no waiting period at all.

0 coins

I actually had the same misunderstanding. I thought the waiting period was standard across SDI programs. Good to know PFL doesn't have one.

0 coins

The waiting period is for Disability Insurance, which is a different claim. When a birth mother's pregnancy disability claim ends and she moves to a PFL bonding claim, the bonding side has no waiting period either. Different programs, different rules.

0 coins

Exactly. I confused them because they're both under the SDI umbrella, but the rules are different. PFL doesn't take that first week from you.

0 coins

The overpayment risk is real and your log protects you there. If EDD later says you were paid for days you actually worked and didn't report, your notes with the exact dates are your defense in an appeal. I got an overpayment notice on a care claim because my hours varied week to week and I lost track of what I'd reported.

0 coins

I've been logging every day I work and every day I'm with my mother-in-law separately, with start and end times. I didn't know if that level of detail would matter but now I'm glad I'm doing it.

0 coins

That level of detail is exactly right. When I appealed my overpayment I could only account for some of the days EDD cited because my own notes were inconsistent. Appeal was harder to win without clean records.

0 coins

Overpayment notices can be appealed within 30 days using the same DE 1000A form as any other denial. The notice itself will say the amount and the specific period EDD believes was overpaid, so you can compare that to your log day by day.

0 coins

My mother-in-law's doctor submitted Part D on a Tuesday and EDD still had no record of it matched to my claim by the following Friday. I ended up at the doctor's office in person with my receipt number on a piece of paper, and they resubmitted with it entered correctly. The original submission apparently went in without the receipt number attached.

0 coins

This is my specific fear. The office confirmed they submitted it but I have no way to know if it was submitted with the receipt number or not. How did you find out EDD had no record of it?

0 coins

I asked EDD directly by phone. The agent looked at my claim and said no Part D had been received. That sent me back to the doctor's office. Without that phone call I might have waited past the 41 days.

0 coins

The receipt number is what links the Part D to your specific claim on EDD's end. If it goes in without it, there's no way for EDD to automatically match it to you. Always confirm the office has it before they submit.

0 coins

The Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, was something I had no idea to expect. It just appeared in SDI Online one day after my care claim got approved and I didn't understand what it was or whether it meant my payment was actually on its way. I went through Claimyr to reach an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and told me the DE 2500E meant the first payment had been issued and what the payment method was. After that the actual deposit showed up within a couple of days.

0 coins

I hadn't even heard of the DE 2500E yet. So that's the one that shows up before the actual money moves?

0 coins

It's the notification that the first payment is coming. The agent confirmed the payment method on my claim — I'd set up direct deposit in SDI Online when I filed, and she confirmed that's where it would go.

0 coins

Payments go by debit card, direct deposit if you set it up in SDI Online, or by check. I didn't realize I had to actively choose direct deposit at filing time, I assumed it was default.

0 coins

PFL and job protection are two separate things and I wish someone had told me that before I filed. PFL pays you but EDD is very clear that it doesn't protect your job. That comes from CFRA or FMLA, which are separate laws with their own rules. When I asked my HR department and they explained CFRA separately from the PFL payment.

0 coins

My HR already flagged this — they said I'd be on CFRA leave for job protection and PFL for the payment side. They treated them as running at the same time. I didn't fully understand why until now.

0 coins

CFRA and PFL can run at the same time but whether CFRA covers your situation depends on your employer and the law, not on EDD. PFL is purely the payment. Keep that separation clear in your log too — it matters if anything goes sideways with your job.

0 coins

HR is the right place to ask about CFRA specifically. EDD handles the PFL payment side only. The Civil Rights Department's site covers CFRA rules if you want to read up on it.

0 coins

Filing date and leave start date being different tripped me up too. I filed my care claim two weeks after I actually started taking days off for my dad, which I later found out put me in a tighter spot with the 41 days. I still made it but just barely. File as early as you're eligible — no earlier than the first day of leave, no later than 41 days after it.

0 coins

I filed on day three of my leave, so I think I'm fine on that front. But it's a good thing to have in the log — I wrote the filing date and the leave start date as separate entries so there's no confusion.

0 coins

The difference between those two dates is exactly what can cost you benefits if Part D arrives late and you're trying to prove when things happened. Having both clearly logged is exactly right.

0 coins

EDD's benefit calculator on their site lets you put in your wages and get an estimate of the weekly amount before the Notice of Computation arrives. It's not guaranteed to match exactly but it'll get you close enough to plan your bills around.

0 coins

I've been hesitant to use it because I wasn't sure it reflected the right base period. My wages fluctuated a lot over the past year.

0 coins

It uses the highest-earning quarter from your base period, which runs from about five to eighteen months before your claim starts. If your highest quarter was recent and high, the estimate will reflect that. If your pay varied, the estimate might not land exactly on the notice amount.

0 coins

The notice itself is the final word. Use the calculator as a floor estimate for planning, but don't lock in any financial commitments until the Notice of Computation arrives and you have the actual number.

0 coins

Keeping a log also helps if you need to request a copy of any form EDD sent. I lost the original notice mailed to me and had to contact EDD to confirm the information on my claim. Having my own records of what I expected to see made that conversation go faster.

0 coins

I didn't even think about losing mail. I've been keeping paper copies in the log binder and photographing anything EDD sends before I file it.

0 coins

Photographing documents as they arrive is exactly right. The original notices have specific dates and claim IDs on them that might matter later, especially if you're ever checking an appeal timeline.

0 coins

Appeal deadlines run from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it. So logging the postmark date alongside the notice date gives you the clearest picture of how much time you actually have.

0 coins

Part of what makes a log useful is that SDI Online doesn't always show the full picture. It shows pending, it shows issued payments, but the detail behind why something is pending — which document is missing, which date EDD is waiting on — that's not visible online. The log plus a phone call fills that gap.

0 coins

That matches my experience so far. SDI Online shows pending and that's about it. No indication of whether it's pending because of a missing document or just because the 14-day window isn't up.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update in SDI Online sometimes triggers a message back with more detail, but it's inconsistent. Phone is more reliable when you actually need a specific answer about your claim's status.

0 coins

Calling EDD directly at 1-877-238-4373 on a weekday between 8 and 5 is the route for getting a real answer on what's holding a claim. Online tools are good for filing and checking payments but not for diagnosing a stuck claim.

0 coins

Taxes on PFL tripped up my planning. California doesn't tax PFL benefits, which I didn't know. EDD sends a 1099-G in January for benefits paid during the year. For the federal side I'd check EDD's tax information page or ask a tax professional — that side is more complicated than a forum can answer reliably.

0 coins

I had it backwards — I assumed California would tax it and federal wouldn't. Good to have that confirmed for the state side at least.

0 coins

The 1099-G is the form to watch for in January. Keep your log through the end of the year so when it arrives you can verify the totals match what you actually received.

0 coins

Federal tax on PFL is the kind of question for a tax professional or EDD's own tax page, not a forum. Too many variables and the answer depends on individual circumstances.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure