Back to California Paid Family Leave

Liam Duke

How to calculate what percentage of salary PFL pays — my Notice of Computation was way lower than I expected

So I just got my Notice of Computation in the mail and I'm honestly kind of panicking. The weekly amount on there is quite a bit less than half my actual paycheck and I have no idea how EDD got to that number. I work part time at a dental office and also pick up shifts at a spa on weekends so my income is a little complicated. I filed my PFL bonding claim in SDI Online about three days after my daughter was born and I uploaded her birth certificate the same day. I thought PFL was supposed to replace most of my wages but the notice doesn't say anything about how they calculated it, just the weekly amount. Can someone walk me through how to calculate what percentage of salary PFL pays so I can figure out if EDD even used both of my jobs? I don't want to appeal if the number is actually right but I also can't go eight weeks on that amount.

PFL looks at your highest-earning quarter in the base period, which runs from about 5 to 18 months before your claim started. If one of your jobs didn't report wages in that window, EDD might not see it. The calculator on EDD's site gives an estimate so you can check the math yourself.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

Wait, so it only uses the highest single quarter, not the whole year? That might actually explain everything. The spa shifts were really inconsistent and probably low in my best quarter.

0 coins

Yep, the base period thing catches a lot of people off guard. The calculator is worth running even just to sanity-check the notice.

0 coins

The benefit comes out to roughly 70 to 90 percent of the wages in that highest quarter, divided into a weekly amount. The percentage goes up for lower earners and down a bit for higher earners. Your Notice of Computation should list the base period quarters, so you can see which one EDD picked.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

Mine just shows the weekly benefit amount, not the breakdown by quarter. Is there somewhere in SDI Online I can see the quarterly wages they used?

0 coins

The notice itself should have the base period quarters listed, usually on the back or a second page. Worth checking again before you assume it's missing.

0 coins

If you still can't find the quarterly breakdown, the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online lets you send EDD a message asking them to confirm which wages they used.

0 coins

Intermittent schedule tripped me up with the percentage question too. After I went back two days a week the second payment came in lower and I could not figure out why. I got through to EDD using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and the agent pulled up my DE 2580GF and told me which days had been certified and which were still pending. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Turned out I had not reported two of my work days on the certification so the system had counted them as benefit days and then clawed part of it back.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim had a similar issue where something looked off on what deposited. I've used Claimyr too, the agent confirmed my direct deposit was set right and that the lower deposit was just the prorated days at the end of my claim period. Cleared it right up.

0 coins

Tried that line six mornings in a row before giving up. Recording every time.

0 coins

Yeah the recording thing was happening to me too, tried for a week straight before I found another way. Thats why having the DE 2580GF handy before you get through matters, the agent goes right to it.

0 coins

The percentage math is real but EDD also only counts wages where CASDI was withheld. If your spa job classified you as an independent contractor and didn't take out SDI, those wages disappear from the calculation entirely.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

Oh no. My spa 1099s me for some of those shifts. So those wages just don't count at all?

0 coins

Correct. Only W-2 wages with CASDI on the stub go into the base period. 1099 income isn't in the SDI system.

0 coins

This is a really important point that a lot of people miss. If you have a mix of W-2 and 1099 work, your PFL benefit is based only on the W-2 side, which can make the amount feel shockingly low.

0 coins

Eight weeks total, not eight per reason. Some folks think they get a separate eight for bonding and another eight if they need to care for someone sick in the same year. That's not how it works. One pot.

0 coins

Wait, really? I was told by a coworker that bonding and care are separate limits. So if I used six weeks for my son and my dad gets sick this year, I only have two weeks left for a care claim?

0 coins

That's right. All PFL comes out of the same eight weeks in a 12-month window. Your coworker had it wrong.

0 coins

This is SO easy to get mixed up. I told my sister the same wrong thing before I actually read the EDD paperwork. The 12-month clock starts from when you first use PFL.

0 coins

The notice shows a potential weekly amount but it doesn't mean you'll get exactly that every two weeks, lol. If you're doing intermittent days, each day pays one seventh of that weekly number so your deposits can look really random.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

I didn't realize it broke down by day like that. I was planning on taking the full eight weeks straight so hopefully mine won't vary but good to know.

0 coins

Yep, one-seventh per day. Makes the math pretty straightforward at least.

0 coins

my first claim i thought pfl was like unemployment and would be a flat percentage of your whole years income but its not, its the base period quarter thing and it threw me off so much

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

Honestly I thought the same thing. I assumed it would be based on my annual salary and that would be simple but nothing about this is simple.

0 coins

base period stuff is confusing yeah. took me a while to get it.

0 coins

A Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination came in the mail after my care claim was flagged, and the reason code on it made no sense to me. I ended up reaching EDD through Claimyr and the agent walked me through exactly what the determination said and confirmed I had 30 days to file an appeal using the DE 1000A if I disagreed. Ended up being a wage issue similar to what you're describing.

0 coins

An agent actually walked you through the determination letter? I've dialed that line maybe 15 times over three weeks and never got past the automated message. Sounds almost too convenient.

0 coins

Tried the line the same way for four days before that. I understand the doubt, I had it too. The agent was an actual EDD employee and read back the specific code on my determination. Nothing fancy, just finally got someone on the phone.

0 coins

I had a receipt number issue on my claim and used Claimyr to get through. The agent confirmed my receipt number was matched to the right claim ID in their system, which was the whole thing I needed to know before I could move forward!

0 coins

Alright, might be worth trying. I still need to ask EDD about my own quarterly wages in the base period.

0 coins

70 to 90 percent gets cited a lot but the exact slice depends on where your quarterly wages land. Lower earners get the higher replacement rate. The benefits calculator on EDD's site is the clearest way to see your own number before the notice arrives, or to check whether the notice matches.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

I wish I had used that calculator before filing so I would have had a ballpark. Going in blind made the notice feel like a gut punch.

0 coins

For anyone who hasn't gotten their notice yet, run the calculator first. It won't be exact but it'll put you in the right range.

0 coins

My bonding claim after my second baby, the notice came in lower than my first claim even though I made more money, and it was because the base period shifted and my highest quarter was during my maternity leave from the first baby when I earned almost nothing. Something to be aware of if you've had a gap.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

That's a really scary scenario I hadn't thought about. My daughter is my first so I don't have that issue, but that would be devastating.

0 coins

Base period timing can really work against someone who took leave recently. It's worth noting that EDD's base period is set by the claim date and there's no option to request an alternate period under PFL.

0 coins

EDD not explaining the math on the notice is a feature, apparently. You just get the number.

0 coins

Classic. Here's your amount, good luck figuring out why.

0 coins

And then good luck reaching someone who can explain it.

0 coins

Proof of relationship on my bonding claim took forever to show as received in SDI Online. I used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask, and the agent confirmed they had my birth certificate on file and it was matched to my claim. Such a relief to hear that directly instead of just watching the status say pending! The agent also mentioned my claim was still within the 14-day decision window so I just needed to wait it out.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned here but I don't know what it is.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's line for you so your phone rings when an actual PFL agent picks up. That's basically it.

0 coins

Oh, that's simple enough. I'd want to ask about the quarterly wage breakdown on my own notice, that would be the first thing I'd raise.

0 coins

I've been trying that number for two mornings and the recording hangs up after the menu. Might have to look into this.

0 coins

Dated February 11th, my own Notice of Computation came in and the weekly amount didn't match what the calculator had estimated. The difference was about one full quarter of wages that my second employer was late reporting to EDD. Worth checking whether your spa actually reported your W-2 wages on time for the base period quarters.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

How would I even know if the spa reported late? Is there a way to see the wages EDD has on file for me?

0 coins

You can send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online asking EDD to confirm the wages they have in your base period. If the spa was late, the wages may not be there yet and you'd need to ask EDD how to proceed.

0 coins

Employer wage reporting timing matters more than most people realize. If your employer filed late, the wages might just be absent, not wrong, which is a different conversation with EDD.

0 coins

Three Tuesdays straight I hit the same recording before it dropped the call. Finally got an EDD agent using Claimyr and asked about a payment that posted for a different amount than my weekly rate. The agent pulled it up and told me the payment date was for a partial week, the last four days of my claim, so the amount was four sevenths of my weekly benefit. That was it.

0 coins

Agent confirmed the four-sevenths breakdown right on the spot, that's exactly what I needed to understand about my own last payment. I used Claimyr for my claim too, asked about my Notice of Computation and the agent read me the quarterly wages EDD had on file. Turned out all three quarters in my base period had been reported correctly and the weekly amount was right. Knowing the actual numbers helped a lot.

0 coins

Can I ask what you had ready when you spoke with the agent about the notice? Trying to figure out what to have on hand.

0 coins

Claim ID, Social Security number, and the notice itself in front of me. Agent just needed those to pull everything up.

0 coins

Good to know. Been circling the same question on my own notice for a week.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared to ask this but does PFL have a waiting week the way I've heard unemployment does? Like seven days you don't get paid for at the start?

0 coins

No waiting period for PFL. Benefits start from day one of your leave. That waiting week is a disability thing, not bonding or care.

0 coins

Oh thank goodness. I had completely convinced myself there was one and was doing the math wrong the whole time.

0 coins

Glad someone asked because I had the same confused idea before my first claim.

0 coins

if your two jobs are both w-2 and both had casdi withheld you should be okay, edd just pulls both from the wage records. but if the spa 1099d you for some shifts like you said thats a problem

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

My dental office job is definitely W-2 with CASDI on every stub. The spa situation is messier, some shifts were W-2 and some were 1099. So maybe EDD got some spa wages but not all of them.

0 coins

Even partial W-2 wages from the spa would be in the system. Only the 1099 portion disappears.

0 coins

CFRA question piggybacking on this, sorry, does PFL protect your job while you're out bonding? My HR said it does but I want to double-check.

0 coins

PFL pays the benefit but it doesn't protect your job, EDD says that plainly. Job protection for bonding would come from CFRA or FMLA. Whether either of those covers your situation is a question for HR and those laws, not EDD.

0 coins

Okay that clarifies it, HR was probably talking about CFRA running at the same time. I'll ask them specifically about that.

0 coins

This mix-up is super common. PFL is the money, CFRA is the job protection, and they can run together but they're separate things.

0 coins

Birth certificate gets the job done for bonding proof if you're on the birth certificate. If you're not, there's the Declaration of Paternity form or a foster letter or adoption paperwork.

0 coins

I uploaded mine the first night and it showed as received in SDI Online pretty fast. No issues there.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

Mine was uploaded the same day I filed, so hopefully that part is fine. It's really the wage calculation that's the question for me.

0 coins

the dental office wages probably make up most of your base period anyway if the spa was 1099 some of the time. check the calculator and see what you get with just the dental job

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

That's actually a smart way to test it. If the calculator with just the dental wages matches my notice, then EDD got it right and it's just the missing 1099 income that makes it feel low.

0 coins

Pretty much yeah, that would at least tell you if EDD made an error or if the number is just what it is given your wage mix.

0 coins

PFL paying 70 to 90 percent sounds great on paper but 70 percent of a quarter where you got sick, took vacation, or had slow weeks can be way less than 70 percent of what you think of as your salary, lol. The base period quarter thing is the hidden gotcha.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

The quarter they picked for me might have been right before I picked up those extra spa shifts too, so the wages in it are lower than my current normal. I'm starting to think the notice might actually be correct and my income just looks different to EDD than it does to me.

0 coins

That's a pretty clear-eyed way to land on it. If the calculator with your W-2 wages matches the notice, you have your answer. If it doesn't, then you send a Request Claim Update.

0 coins

Liam Duke

Author

Alright, running the calculator tonight with just the dental wages and comparing to the notice. If it lines up I'll stop catastrophizing. Thank you all for helping me think through how to calculate what percentage of salary PFL pays, I didn't even know where to start.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure