Back to California Paid Family Leave

Yuki Tanaka

How to appeal paid family leave overpayment caused by employer paying wages

Filed my PFL bonding claim back in September, took the full eight weeks starting when my daughter was born. August 15th was my first payment, and everything looked fine until three weeks ago when I got an overpayment notice. Turns out my employer kept paying me partial wages during those weeks and apparently the total of my wages plus PFL exceeded what I normally make. I didn't realize I was supposed to report those wages to EDD while I was on leave. The overpayment notice lists the total amount they say I owe back and includes an Appeal Form DE 1000A. My question is whether I actually have a valid case to appeal this. The employer paying wages part wasn't something I arranged, they just continued my pay automatically, and I had no idea it would affect my PFL. Has anyone appealed an overpayment that happened this way? What do I put in the appeal and do I have 30 days from the date on the notice?

November 3rd my PFL payment for week six still hadn't landed, four days after it was supposed to, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent because I'd spent three mornings redialing and hitting the busy signal every single time. The agent pulled up my account and told me the payment for weeks five and six had actually been issued on October 31st and would hit my debit card within two business days. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Anyway, to your actual question: the 30 days on the appeal runs from the mailing date printed on the overpayment notice, so count from that date, not from when you received it.

0 coins

Three mornings redialing and you got through? I've tried that line more times than I can count and it just disconnects me every single time around 8:15. What is Claimyr exactly, is it some kind of service?

0 coins

It waits in line with EDD in your place, basically, and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's really the whole thing. And yeah the line drops me constantly too, that's exactly why I tried something different.

0 coins

Huh okay. I've been trying to figure out if EDD received my proof of relationship, might give this a shot then.

0 coins

The payment date thing is good to know. Mine hit two days after the agent said it would, so the info they give you is pretty accurate in my experience.

0 coins

The 30-day clock does run from the mailing date on the notice, so check that carefully. The Appeal Form DE 1000A comes with the overpayment notice and you can file it online or by mail. For the appeal itself, what matters most is explaining that you did not know the wages would be reported or that the wages plus PFL would exceed your normal pay, and that the employer's decision to continue paying you was not something you controlled or arranged.

0 coins

Thank you, that framing helps. The wages really were automatic on my employer's side, I genuinely had no idea they kept paying until I checked my bank statements weeks later.

0 coins

EDD's own materials say wages excluding overtime combined with PFL can't exceed normal weekly wages, so the rule existed, but not knowing it happened doesn't mean the appeal fails. The appeal is where you explain the circumstances.

0 coins

So the fact that I didn't set it up and didn't know about it is relevant, just not a guarantee. Got it, I'll make sure to explain all of that clearly on the form.

0 coins

Report the wages, appeal the overpayment, explain what happened. Those are your three things. The employer continuing to pay you is not unusual, plenty of companies do it without telling their workers it creates a problem with EDD.

0 coins

Same thing happened to a guy at my job. Employer kept his sick bank going and he ended up with an overpayment notice. Appealed it, took a few weeks to hear back.

0 coins

Exactly. The appeal is the right move, especially when the worker had no hand in setting up the double payment.

0 coins

Appealing doesn't erase the overpayment automatically though. EDD still decides.

0 coins

The overpayment notice coming months after the fact is what gets me. You're supposed to report wages in real time but EDD takes forever to catch it and then hits you with one big bill. Appeal it, absolutely, just be ready for the process to drag.

0 coins

edd does this all the time man its so frustrating, same thing happened with my sisters claim

0 coins

And then the burden is on you to prove your case even when the employer is the one who kept paying. The system is not set up in your favor.

0 coins

Worth pointing out that even if the appeal doesn't fully eliminate the overpayment, there's also a waiver option in some cases. The appeal and the waiver are separate things though, so it's worth asking EDD which path fits the situation.

0 coins

Good point. I didn't know the waiver was separate from the appeal. Does anyone know if you file both at the same time or one first?

0 coins

Bonding claim last spring and I ran into a weird situation where I went back part time after week four but kept getting full payments. Tried for two weeks to reach EDD to ask how many of my eight weeks were still on the clock before I burned through them. Used Claimyr and talked to an agent who checked the claim and told me I had three weeks and two days left in my 12-month window. Helped me plan the rest of the leave without accidentally losing days anyway.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? I keep seeing that name and I'm not totally sure what it does, sorry if that's a dumb question.

0 coins

Not dumb at all. Basically it handles the hold time with EDD for you so you end up on the phone with an actual agent without spending your whole morning redialing. That's really it.

0 coins

Oh okay that makes sense. I'd probably use it to ask about the 41-day deadline on my care claim because I'm not sure my doctor submitted Part D in time and I'm kind of panicking about it.

0 coins

The doctor can submit Part D in SDI Online using your receipt number, so if you haven't given the office that number it's worth doing today.

0 coins

Wait, I thought you weren't supposed to work at all while on PFL. Can your employer just pay you while you're on leave and that's allowed? I'm confused about how wages and PFL are supposed to work together because I start leave next month and I do not want to end up in this situation.

0 coins

Employers can pay wages, sick leave or vacation on top of PFL, but the total of your wages excluding overtime plus your PFL benefit can't go above what you normally earn. If it does, EDD considers the excess an overpayment. The key is reporting the wages to EDD as you receive them.

0 coins

Thank you, so I need to tell EDD if my employer pays me anything during my leave? Even if it's just a few days of sick time?

0 coins

Any wages, any paid time off, yes. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form and that's where you report it. Don't wait until the end of your leave.

0 coins

Okay I had no idea about the Continued Claim Certification. I'll ask my HR what their policy is so I know what to expect before my first week of leave.

0 coins

The De 1000A is a one-page form but the explanation section is where the whole appeal lives. Be specific about dates, the fact that you didn't know wages were continuing, and that you didn't earn more than your regular pay on purpose.

0 coins

The dates part is a good reminder. I'll pull my pay stubs from every week of leave to show exactly what came in and when.

0 coins

Cross-referencing the pay stubs against your PFL payment dates will make the timeline clear for whoever reviews the appeal. That kind of documentation makes a real difference.

0 coins

Does it matter that you didn't report the wages in real time? Like will EDD ding you extra for that or is the overpayment notice basically the whole consequence?

0 coins

Not reporting wages when they happen is what creates the overpayment. The notice is EDD's way of saying they found the discrepancy. The appeal is your chance to explain the circumstances around why wages weren't reported.

0 coins

Got it, so the overpayment itself is the result of the unreported wages, not some separate penalty on top of it. That's actually less scary than I thought lol.

0 coins

Correct. Appeal it with documentation and a clear explanation. That's the path forward.

0 coins

For the appeal, the standard is whether you were overpaid and whether you're at fault. The employer continuing your wages automatically and you not being aware of the reporting requirement could be relevant to both sides of that question. Document everything you can.

0 coins

Does the appeal go to EDD directly or to some separate appeals board?

0 coins

Filed with EDD using the DE 1000A and you can submit online or by mail. Where it goes from there is an administrative process, but starting with that form is the right first step.

0 coins

An ALJ at the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board typically hears it if EDD doesn't resolve it in your favor first. You'll get written notice of next steps.

0 coins

my company did this to me too they just kept direct depositing and i had no idea until the overpayment letter showed up. i panicked but filed the appeal and explained i didnt even know wages were coming in. still waiting to hear back but at least i filed before the 30 days.

0 coins

Glad you got the appeal in on time. Any sense yet of how long they take to respond?

0 coins

nothing yet its been like five weeks. people say it varies a lot so im just waiting

0 coins

Five weeks sounds about right from what I've heard. Hang in there.

0 coins

Before you write a single word on the DE 1000A, pull three things: the overpayment notice itself with the mailing date, all pay stubs covering the leave period, and your PFL payment history from SDI Online. Those are your foundation for the appeal.

0 coins

Already have the notice and pay stubs. Didn't think to pull the PFL payment history from SDI Online separately, that's a good addition.

0 coins

The payment history shows exactly which weeks EDD paid and what amounts, which you can line up against the wage weeks on your pay stubs to show the overlap clearly.

0 coins

Start date on my care claim got questioned by EDD because I filed close to the 41-day cutoff. Getting an agent on the phone to sort it out felt impossible until I tried Claimyr. The agent confirmed the claim start date they had on file and told me the original date I entered matched what they showed, so the 41 days was met. No issue in the end, but I'd have been spinning my wheels guessing otherwise.

0 coins

The Electronic Benefit Payment Notification came through on my claim about five days after I spoke with an EDD agent through Claimyr too. The agent had confirmed they'd issued the first payment and the DE 2500E showed up in the mail right after, which I hadn't expected so fast.

0 coins

What did the agent say exactly when you asked about the DE 2500E? Like did they give you a specific date it was mailed?

0 coins

They said the first payment had been issued and that the DE 2500E would follow by mail. They didn't give an exact date for the letter itself, just confirmed the payment was out.

0 coins

Good to know the DE 2500E follows after the payment is issued. I kept looking for it before anything else arrived and that's backwards apparently.

0 coins

If my employer paid me for a week and I didn't report it and there's now an overpayment, can I still appeal even if I technically should have reported it? I'm scared I already lost my chance to dispute it.

0 coins

Not reporting wages in real time is common and doesn't disqualify you from appealing. The appeal is where you explain the circumstances. As long as you file the DE 1000A within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice, you can make your case.

0 coins

Okay that's a relief. Mine arrived four days ago so I still have time. I'll get the form done this week.

0 coins

Filing it this week is smart. You don't want to cut it too close to the 30-day mark.

0 coins

My coworker was told she had to repay everything and she hadn't been paid by her employer at all, EDD had just made an error on the weekly amount. She appealed and got it overturned but the process took months. I know that's a different situation from wages overlapping but I wanted to share it because the appeal absolutely can work.

0 coins

That's reassuring to hear the appeal process can actually result in a reversal. How did she document the error in EDD's calculation?

0 coins

She went through her Notice of Computation line by line against her actual wages and showed that the weekly benefit amount they used was based on wrong wage data. Super detailed, she kept every scrap of paper.

0 coins

That's the right approach. The Notice of Computation shows the base period wages EDD used to calculate the benefit, so if anything there doesn't match actual W-2 wages it's documentable.

0 coins

Waited three weeks and the overpayment notice just showed up. No warning, just a letter. Thought I'd done everything right.

0 coins

EDD doesn't send a warning, they just send the notice. File the appeal before the 30 days and explain your situation on the form.

0 coins

Yeah I'm realizing that now. Filing this week.

0 coins

Patients sometimes ask me about PFL because I work with new parents. The wages-overlap issue comes up more than people expect. Employers often continue short-term disability or salary continuation without informing the employee it affects PFL. The appeal is the right step, and explaining clearly that the wages were not voluntary is key.

0 coins

Thank you, the salary continuation angle is exactly what I was worried about for my own leave. I'll double-check with HR whether they automatically continue pay.

0 coins

Ask HR specifically whether they continue any compensation during PFL and whether they notify EDD or expect you to. Clear that up before your first week.

0 coins

EDD's overpayment notices rarely explain the math clearly. Get the actual breakdown in writing or through SDI Online before you write your appeal so you know exactly what period they're claiming and why.

0 coins

The notice I have does list the weeks and amounts but I'm going to cross-check everything against my own records because you're right that I want to be sure the math is correct.

0 coins

Good call. If their numbers don't match yours, that goes in the appeal too.

0 coins

The employer-paid wages situation is genuinely tricky because a lot of companies have automatic salary continuation policies and never tell their employees that it creates a PFL issue. You're not alone in landing here without meaning to.

0 coins

Knowing it's common doesn't fix my situation but it does make me feel less like I did something obviously wrong. The lack of communication from the employer is a real part of this.

0 coins

Exactly, and that context belongs in your appeal explanation. It's part of why the wages went unreported.

0 coins

There's a difference between willful failure to report and not knowing wages were even coming in. Making that distinction clear in the appeal matters.

0 coins

EDD's own FAQs on paid family leave say wages excluding overtime plus PFL can't exceed normal weekly wages. If you can show your employer's payments plus the PFL benefit stayed at or below your normal wage in certain weeks, those weeks may not actually be an overpayment, so check the math week by week.

0 coins

That's worth doing. There were probably weeks where I wasn't paid the full salary because of how payroll fell. I'll check whether any weeks actually stayed within the limit.

0 coins

Week-by-week is exactly the right way to look at it. Some weeks might be fine and only the remaining ones are actually in dispute.

0 coins

This is getting complex but it's the kind of detail that could reduce what I owe significantly. Really appreciate the pointer.

0 coins

File the appeal, attach your pay stubs, write a clear one-paragraph explanation on the DE 1000A. Don't overthink the language. EDD reviewers read these all day, they know what an employer salary continuation situation looks like.

0 coins

Direct advice, appreciate it. I've been overthinking the wording but keeping it factual and straightforward is probably smarter than trying to make a legal argument.

0 coins

Factual and to the point. Dates, amounts, what happened, what you knew and when you knew it. That's your whole case.

0 coins

Is there any chance the appeal also stops collection while it's pending? I'm worried they'll try to take the money back through deductions on future benefits before the appeal is even decided.

0 coins

To ask EDD specifically about collection activity during your appeal, your best path is SDI Online's Request Claim Update or phoning the PFL line at 1-877-238-4373. That's a detail that depends on your specific notice and claim.

0 coins

Okay I'll check the notice first and then contact EDD if it's not clear. I didn't realize there was a formal way to submit questions through SDI Online.

0 coins

In myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ you open SDI Online, pick your claim, and find Request Claim Update. That's the online route for specific questions about your claim status.

0 coins

Honestly the hardest part of all of this is just figuring out that you have 30 days and that the clock starts on the mailing date not when you got the letter. I didn't know either until someone told me and those few days can matter a lot.

0 coins

Mailing date, not received date. That detail matters, especially if the letter sat in your mailbox for a few days.

0 coins

That gap between the mailing date and when it arrived is the first thing I checked when I read this thread. Mine was dated four days before I got it, so my actual window is a bit shorter than 30 days from today.

0 coins

File it today if you can honestly. No reason to wait lol.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure