Back to California Paid Family Leave

Mei Zhang

How long does take to respond to paid family leave appeal in California? Filed mine 3 weeks ago

I filed a PFL appeal about three weeks ago after getting a denial notice for my care claim. My dad has been pretty sick and I took time off work to bring him to appointments and help at home, so I really need this to work out. I sent back the DE 1000A with the denial notice attached, like it said to do, and mailed it in. SDI Online still shows the same denied status. I haven't gotten anything in the mail from EDD, no letter, nothing. Is it normal for it to just go quiet like this? How long does it take to respond to paid family leave appeal decisions once they receive it? I'm starting to wonder if they even got it. Has anyone been through this?

Waiting after mailing that DE 1000A is genuinely hard, especially with no acknowledgment. The appeal process moves to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board once EDD receives it, and from there timelines vary. The 30-day window to file from the date on the denial notice is what matters most, so as long as you sent it in time, the waiting is unfortunately normal.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

The 30-day part is what I keep double-checking. The notice was dated and I mailed the DE 1000A the same week, so I should be fine there. It's just the silence after that gets to me.

0 coins

the silence is the worst part. mine took weeks before anything moved.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and the weekly amount looked lower than I expected, so I had to figure out what base period they used. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after the phone line just played a recording and ended the call two mornings in a row. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which quarter they used for the highest wages, which explained the amount on my DE 429DF. For your situation, it might be worth phoning to confirm they received the appeal form before too much more time passes.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation piece you mentioned is exactly where I got stuck too, and I've used Claimyr as well! Once the agent looked at my claim, she confirmed the date my first payment was actually issued, which I couldn't see clearly in SDI Online. After that I knew what week to expect the next one. So helpful to have an actual person look at the account.

0 coins

How many mornings did you try that line before you found another way? I've been at it since Tuesday and it just cuts out every single time.

0 coins

I tried four or five times across two days before I did anything else. the line just played the same message and dropped me.

0 coins

You mailed the DE 1000A, that's the right move. Keep a copy of everything you sent and note the date you mailed it. If you paid for certified mail you have a tracking number, which is worth checking.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

I didn't send it certified, which I'm now wishing I had. I do have a copy of the form though. If I send another copy now would that cause any problem?

0 coins

Don't send a second one. Could create confusion. Phone EDD and ask if the appeal was received, that's the cleaner move.

0 coins

Phoning to confirm receipt is the right step. The number for PFL is 1-877-238-4373, Monday through Friday 8 to 5.

0 coins

Three weeks and nothing in the mail from EDD, that tracks with how they operate. The appeals board is separate from EDD itself, so your status in SDI Online might not update at all while it's pending over there. Don't count on the portal to tell you anything useful right now.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Wait, so SDI Online just won't update while an appeal is in process? I've been refreshing it every day thinking I'd see something change.

0 coins

Yeah, the system still shows the denial because that's what EDD determined. The appeals board is its own thing. You'd hear by mail when there's a hearing date or a decision.

0 coins

That's actually good context. I had no idea the appeals board was separate from EDD. Makes the silence make a little more sense.

0 coins

Did your denial notice say why they denied it? Mine got denied because the Part D came in after the 41 days and EDD said the claim was too late. I appealed but the reason matters a lot for what happens next anyway.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Mine said something about the relationship not being verified. My dad is my dad, so I'm not sure what they needed that I didn't send. I didn't realize there was a Part C statement he was supposed to sign and return separately.

0 coins

Part C is the care recipient's own statement, it goes on a paper form your dad fills out and mails in. If EDD didn't get that, the claim being denied for incomplete documentation makes sense. You can raise that in the appeal, and if you have proof Part C was sent, bring it to the hearing.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

I don't think he ever sent it. I didn't know it was his job to do that part. Can that still be fixed through the appeal or is it too late?

0 coins

The appeal is the right place to raise it. Explain the situation honestly. The board will hear your side. I can't tell you how they'll rule but it's worth making the case.

0 coins

30 days goes fast man. glad you got it in. the silence after is just how it goes, happened to my uncle too

0 coins

like weeks of nothing then suddenly a letter shows up. just check the mail every day

0 coins

that's pretty much exactly what happened with mine too

0 coins

After my bonding claim paid out the first few weeks and then just stopped, I had no idea which weeks EDD had covered and which ones were still pending. I called through Claimyr and talked to an agent who went through the payment history with me and said which weeks had been paid out and when the next payment was scheduled based on what I'd submitted. Really glad I did it because I was about to file something I didn't need to file.

0 coins

I'd want to see that for myself before trusting it honestly. I tried that line probably a dozen times over three weeks, mornings, afternoons, nothing. How did you actually end up speaking to someone?

0 coins

I get the skepticism, the line is brutal. But Claimyr held the line for me and my phone rang when a person picked up, and that person was an EDD agent who had my claim right in front of her. That's all I can say about my own experience.

0 coins

For what it's worth I've used Claimyr too. The agent I spoke with told me I had three weeks of the eight remaining in my 12-month window, which answered exactly what I'd been trying to calculate on my own from the payment history screen.

0 coins

Okay, three weeks left out of eight is useful information to know directly. I might give it a shot.

0 coins

The appeals board schedules a hearing. You'll get a notice with the date. Show up, bring your documents, tell your side. That's the whole process.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Is the hearing in person or can it be done by phone?

0 coins

Usually by phone. The notice will say.

0 coins

The notice will explain the hearing format? I didn't know that. Mine's still early but I keep wondering what that part looks like.

0 coins

My coworker waited about six weeks from mailing her appeal before she got the hearing notice. So three weeks in isn't that long yet, annoying as it is lol

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Six weeks total before even the hearing notice? So the actual decision would be even later than that.

0 coins

Yeah the hearing notice is just them saying here's your date. The decision comes after the hearing itself. It's a whole process.

0 coins

ugh I did not realize it took that long. filing an appeal felt like it would speed things up but it's really the opposite huh

0 coins

Did you appeal online or mail it? Online submissions at least have a timestamp.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Mailed it. I went with paper because the denial notice said I could and I was nervous about doing it online for something this important.

0 coins

Understandable. Just means you have no receipt. Worth phoning to confirm they have it.

0 coins

My care claim for my mom took forever and I just kept worrying the whole time. The fact that you filed within 30 days is what matters most right now.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Keeps coming back to the 30 days. At least I did that part right. Everything else feels uncertain.

0 coins

That's genuinely the most important step you could have taken. The rest is waiting and documenting.

0 coins

Bring everything to the hearing. The denial notice, any Part C or Part D you have copies of, any dates and records of when things were submitted. The board wants the facts, not just the form.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

I don't have a copy of Part C because my dad was supposed to send it and I don't think he did. Would it help to get him to fill one out now and bring it, or is it too late for that?

0 coins

Bring whatever you have. The board will hear the full situation. What was sent, what wasn't, and why. That context matters.

0 coins

My first PFL payment came through but then I got the DE 2500E and wasn't sure if I needed to do anything with it or if it just meant the payment was coming. Tried the phone line so many mornings and just kept getting cut off. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr and asked about my DE 2500E specifically. The agent confirmed it was the notification that the payment had already been issued and told me which bank account it went to for direct deposit, which I'd changed and was worried about.

0 coins

Wait what is Claimyr exactly? I've been trying to reach EDD about my own claim for days.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD while you go about your day, and your phone rings once an actual EDD employee picks up. That's basically it.

0 coins

Oh that's simpler than I thought. I'd want to ask about why my care claim is still showing denied even after I know Part D was submitted. That's what I'd bring up.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

I've been thinking about trying it too. My claim questions are piling up.

0 coins

six weeks sounds like forever when youre the one waiting. does the hearing notice come by mail or do they email you

0 coins

It comes by mail. The appeals board sends paper notices to the address on file, so make sure your address is current.

0 coins

ok good to know. my address changed recently so i should probably check that

0 coins

Intermittent days reporting was where I ran into trouble. I'd been going back to the clinic part-time since my mom's condition stabilized, and my second payment didn't come through. After too many dropped calls, I reached an agent using Claimyr and asked about the DE 2580GF. The agent said EDD had issued the Continued Claim Certification form and that it needed to be returned before they'd process the pending days.

0 coins

I've used Claimyr too and was relieved to get a person. When I asked about my claim, the agent told me my claim start date and confirmed I was still within the 41-day filing window, which was the one thing I'd been anxious about. Really glad I had actual confirmation instead of guessing.

0 coins

What did you do after the agent told you that the certification needed to come back? Did you send it the same day?

0 coins

In my case I mailed the form back that same afternoon. I didn't want to wait any longer than I had to.

0 coins

For your appeal, keep a log. Every call, every document, date sent, date received if possible. If you end up at the hearing, that log makes you look organized and helps your case.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

I've been keeping notes but not in any real format. I'll put together something more organized now. Good reminder.

0 coins

A simple list works fine. Date, what you did, what EDD sent back. That's all the board needs to follow the timeline.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD is going to phone you with updates. You're waiting for a letter. If you haven't heard anything after another two weeks, phone PFL directly and ask the agent to confirm your appeal is on file and what the status is.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Two more weeks and then phone. Got it. I'll mark my calendar so I don't just keep spiraling.

0 coins

yeah you kind of have to set a date or you just sit there checking the mailbox every hour

0 coins

Can both parents file a PFL bonding claim for the same baby? My partner and I both want to take time and I wasn't sure if only one of us can go through EDD for it.

0 coins

Each parent files their own separate claim, as long as each has CASDI withheld from their wages in the base period. The eight weeks per person are each counted within their own 12-month window, but it's worth knowing that bonding, care and military assist all share that one pool of eight weeks per claimant.

0 coins

So we could each take our own eight weeks, we just each have to have paid into SDI ourselves?

0 coins

Exactly. Each claim is separate and stands on its own base period. File in SDI Online under each person's own myEDD account.

0 coins

we did this and had no issues. both filed separately, both got approved. just make sure your own wages qualify

0 coins

The 30-day deadline to appeal is firm. EDD says it right on the DE 1000A. If you're within that, the appeal is valid regardless of whether SDI Online has updated. Confirm receipt by phone, document that call, and then wait for the hearing notice.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

I'm going to phone tomorrow and ask them to confirm receipt. That will at least give me something solid to hold onto.

0 coins

Ask for the name of whoever you speak with and note the time. Might be useful later.

0 coins

While you wait, get your dad to fill out a Part C now if he never sent one. Even if the original claim window passed, having it ready for the hearing shows good faith.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

I looked into this more and the Part C form is the DE 2501FC. Can he still fill it out even though it's past the original filing period?

0 coins

Bring it to the hearing and explain that you weren't aware he needed to submit it separately. The appeals board hears the full story.

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Okay I'll get the form to him this week and explain what it's for. At least I'll have something to show at the hearing.

0 coins

appeals take a while. not gonna sugarcoat it. but your situation with your dad sounds like a real care claim and the board will hear you out

0 coins

Mei Zhang

Author

Thank you, that actually helps. I know the Part C piece is a problem but at least I have a chance to explain it.

0 coins

Appeals exist for exactly this kind of situation. Missing a step because you didn't know isn't the same as not being eligible. Make your case clearly.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure