Back to California Paid Family Leave

Lim Wong

How do I complete certification for PFL appeal after my bonding claim got denied?

Got a denial on my PFL bonding claim about two weeks ago and I honestly don't even know where to start. The letter that came said I could appeal but I'm not sure what I need to do to actually make that happen. Like is there some kind of certification or additional form I have to fill out before the appeal is even considered? I filed on SDI Online for bonding with my daughter who was born in October, uploaded the birth certificate as the proof of relationship, and thought everything was fine until the denial notice showed up. I think I might have missed something on the original filing but I'm not sure what. Does anyone know how to complete certification for PFL appeal or what exactly I need to submit?

Those weeks of payments on my care claim got so confusing I couldn't tell which ones had gone through and which were still pending, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD on the line. The agent pulled up my account and told me exactly which weeks had been paid and when the next payment was scheduled to go out. Way more helpful than staring at SDI Online guessing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

My appeal denial question is kind of like this, I want to know if EDD even received my DE 1000A before the 30-day window closed. Gonna try Claimyr for that, what should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Pull up your denial notice, the DE 2514, and have the date it was issued in front of you plus your claim ID. The agent will check whether the appeal form came in and when.

0 coins

Glad that worked for you. Stared at SDI Online for days on my claim and nothing was updating.

0 coins

Asking EDD what specifically triggered the denial is the first thing to do before anything else, because the reason on that notice determines what your appeal needs to address. The notice you received should be a DE 2514, and it has an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, attached. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to submit the appeal, either through SDI Online or by mail to the address printed on the form itself.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

The notice I got does say DE 2514 at the top. I didn't realize the appeal form was already attached to it, I was looking for something separate to download.

0 coins

It comes right with the denial, yes. Fill in the DE 1000A section completely, explain why you disagree with the denial, and send it back before that 30-day mark.

0 coins

Does the appeal need new documents attached or just the form itself? I'm in a similar situation and I don't know if I should resend the birth certificate too.

0 coins

The phrase 'complete certification for PFL appeal' trips a lot of people up because it sounds like a separate certification process exists, but what EDD calls it is just the appeal itself via the DE 1000A. The certification language in the form is the section where you sign and declare the information is accurate. That's the part people sometimes skip and then the appeal gets kicked back.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

I had been reading 'certification' as some extra medical or legal document I needed to track down. So it's just the signature section on the DE 1000A?

0 coins

Exactly. Sign and date that declaration section. Without it the form is incomplete regardless of how well you wrote the rest of the appeal statement.

0 coins

This is a really common mix-up. The word certification shows up in PFL in a few different contexts, like the doctor's certification on care claims, and people import that meaning into appeals where it doesn't apply.

0 coins

What reason did the denial give? Mine said something vague too but it usually comes down to either the proof of relationship not matching up or wages not meeting the base period requirement. Those need different fixes on the appeal.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

Mine mentioned the proof of relationship. The birth certificate I uploaded, I wonder if the scan was too dark or something.

0 coins

On the appeal form write that you're including a clearer copy and attach it. Keep the original denial date in front of you so you don't miss the 30 days.

0 coins

yeah proof of relationship issues are really common for bonding claims, happened to a coworker of mine too

0 coins

EDD's phone line for PFL is a nightmare to reach on a normal day, let alone when you're trying to get specifics on a denial. I've called at 8 in the morning three separate times and either got the high-volume recording that ends the call or sat on hold until it disconnected. No resolution, nothing.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

I've had the same thing happen. Called twice after getting the denial and both times the line just cut me off before I got to anyone.

0 coins

It's genuinely maddening when you have a time-sensitive situation like an appeal window closing and you can't get a human on the line.

0 coins

Same. The line drops right when you think you're getting somewhere.

0 coins

The DE 2500E question came up on my own bonding claim right after the approval, I wasn't sure if I was looking at the right payment notification, so I tried Claimyr to get an agent. She confirmed the DE 2500E was the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification I should have gotten and told me the payment date it showed on my account.

0 coins

The DE 2500E detail matches what I was confused about too. Used Claimyr for a different thing on my claim, wanted to know how many of the eight weeks I had left in the 12-month window since I'd taken some weeks earlier in the year. Agent counted them off my claim and told me I had three weeks remaining. Went back into SDI Online after and tracked how I wanted to split those up.

0 coins

Three weeks left, that's a tighter window than I'd want to manage. I've been redialing since last Tuesday on my end and haven't gotten through once.

0 coins

Wait, the eight weeks for bonding and the eight weeks for a care claim, those are separate totals right? Like if I use all eight for bonding I still have eight for a care claim later?

0 coins

No, that's not how it works actually. It's eight weeks total across bonding, care and military assist combined within any 12-month period. So if you used five for bonding, you'd only have three left if a care claim came up in the same 12 months.

0 coins

I had no idea they shared the same pool. I assumed each type had its own eight weeks. That changes how I'm thinking about this.

0 coins

30 days goes faster than it sounds when you're dealing with a new baby and trying to figure out EDD paperwork. Get the appeal in first, explain the situation, attach the clearest copy of the birth certificate you have. You can always add more detail but you can't get that appeal window back.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

You're right, I keep researching instead of just filing the thing. I'll submit the DE 1000A today and attach a better scan.

0 coins

Good. Don't wait for a perfect appeal, get a complete one in on time.

0 coins

For the SDI Online route, you can submit the appeal right through your account there! Pull up the claim, look for the appeal option and it walks you through entering your statement and attaching any documents. So much easier than printing and mailing if you still have time before the 30 days.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

I didn't realize the appeal could be done in SDI Online directly. I was going to mail it. Is there any reason to prefer one over the other?

0 coins

Mailing is totally fine too, just make sure it goes to the address on the DE 1000A itself, not EDD's general address. Online just gives you a confirmation right away which is nice.

0 coins

Mailing to the address on the form is the right approach if you go paper. The general EDD mailing address is not where claim documents go.

0 coins

you got 30 days from the date on that letter not from when you got it so dont sleep on this, check the postmark date on the envelope too so you know exactly where you stand

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

The notice is dated November 3rd so I'm counting from there. I've got about two weeks left which is tight but workable.

0 coins

yeah get it in this week dont push it to the last day

0 coins

In your appeal statement, be specific. Say what document you submitted, when you submitted it, and why it should satisfy the proof of relationship requirement. Vague statements don't give the reviewer much to work with.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

So I should write something like: on this date I uploaded a birth certificate naming me as parent, here is why that meets the requirement?

0 coins

Exactly. Attach the clearest copy you have and reference it in the statement.

0 coins

Specificity matters a lot in these. The reviewer is going to compare what you say to what's in the file, so matching the dates and document names exactly helps.

0 coins

Before submitting the appeal, check in SDI Online whether the birth certificate upload actually shows as received on your claim. Sometimes documents upload without fully processing. If SDI Online doesn't reflect it, note that discrepancy in your appeal statement.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

How would I see that in SDI Online? Is it listed somewhere in the claim details?

0 coins

In your claim, look at the status and payment history section. It should show documents received. If you don't see it listed, that's worth flagging in the appeal.

0 coins

This is a good point. Having a record of exactly what SDI Online did or didn't show at the time you filed gives the reviewer something concrete to look at.

0 coins

Intermittent days reporting was the thing that tripped up my PFL claim after I went back to work part time, so I tried Claimyr to get through to EDD. The agent walked me through what the DE 2580GF was asking for and confirmed which weeks I still needed to certify the days I'd actually missed work. Got the form filled out right after that call.

0 coins

I've tried that EDD line probably eleven times across three different mornings and never gotten through. Something that claims to put you through to a live agent sounds like it has to be a catch somewhere.

0 coins

I had the same doubt, spent two weeks redialing before I tried it. What it does is stay on hold with EDD in your place and your phone rings when a live EDD agent picks up. The person I spoke to was an actual EDD employee, pulled up my file, confirmed the weeks and what the DE 2580GF needed from me.

0 coins

The DE 2580GF question is relevant to me too. My agent told me via Claimyr that my claim's start date was showing correctly and that the 41-day window from that date had been met, so the form was still eligible to process. Helped me stop second-guessing the timeline.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

Eleven tries and nothing, that's exactly where I am with the phone. I might look into this for my appeal question.

0 coins

the denial notice should tell you the specific code or reason. if it says something about wages or base period that's a totally different appeal than a proof of relationship issue

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

Mine specifically mentions the proof of relationship, so at least I know what I'm targeting.

0 coins

good, then the fix is clear, attach a better copy and explain it in the statement

0 coins

Got a DE 2514 on a PFL claim once and sat on it too long thinking I needed to gather more evidence first. Used Claimyr to get an agent and found out the denial was actually based on a data entry mismatch between my name on the claim and the name on my document. Easily fixable but I burned almost two weeks not knowing that.

0 coins

I've heard of Claimyr but I'm not entirely sure what it is or how it works. Could you explain it briefly?

0 coins

It stays on hold with EDD for you, and when an actual EDD employee picks up, your phone rings and you're on with them. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

That's helpful to know. I've been wanting to ask EDD about my own claim, specifically whether my appeal form was received and logged before the 30-day window closed on my denial notice.

0 coins

a name mismatch is such a small thing but those are the ones that derail everything. glad you caught it.

0 coins

to answer the original question more directly, the certification part people get confused about in a PFL appeal is literally just the declaration at the bottom of the DE 1000A where you confirm everything is true and you sign it. that's it, no separate form

0 coins

So there's no additional medical certification needed even for a bonding claim appeal? No doctor has to sign anything?

0 coins

nope, bonding claims don't have a doctor's certification at all, that's a care claim thing. the DE 1000A is what you file and you sign the declaration on it yourself

0 coins

Worth underlining: Part C and Part D, the care recipient statement and physician certification, only exist on care claims. A bonding appeal has no equivalent. The DE 1000A stands alone.

0 coins

my partner's bonding claim went through fine but she filed the same day as delivery. i wonder if timing on when you file affects how strict they are about the proof of relationship. anyone know if late filing changes what you need to submit?

0 coins

Filing late, past 41 days from when bonding leave started, can cost you benefits for the days before you filed. It doesn't change which documents you need to prove the relationship, those requirements are the same regardless of timing.

0 coins

ok so the document requirement is fixed, good to know. she got lucky filing early i guess.

0 coins

The 41-day window is firm enough that people should treat it like a hard deadline. Missing it doesn't disqualify you from PFL entirely but you can lose the earliest weeks of benefits.

0 coins

the 30-day appeal window and the 41-day filing deadline existing at the same time for different situations is the kind of thing EDD could explain a lot more clearly and they just don't

0 coins

They serve completely different purposes though. The 41 days is about when you filed the original claim relative to when leave started. The 30 days is about how long you have to contest a determination after it's issued. They apply at different stages.

0 coins

i know what they are, my point is EDD's materials don't make it obvious which one applies when and people miss both

0 coins

Agreed. The notices don't always make the deadlines stand out clearly.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD reverse a denial after an appeal? I'm asking because a friend is thinking about whether it's even worth going through the process or just re-filing from scratch.

0 coins

Re-filing doesn't undo the denied period. If the denial was about a specific window of time, filing again doesn't cover those weeks. The appeal is the right path.

0 coins

Tell your friend to appeal. Re-filing doesn't address whatever the denial reason was, it just starts a new claim going forward.

0 coins

That makes sense, I'll pass that along. The appeal it is.

0 coins

December 15th on my own claim was the date EDD said they received the appeal, and I'm still waiting on the outcome. The notice said up to 30 days to review but I haven't seen anything change in SDI Online yet.

0 coins

Appeal review timelines aren't something EDD publishes a fixed number for. Keep an eye on your SDI Online status and watch the mail, since any determination will come as a written notice.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'll keep checking both.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

Knowing they received it by a specific date at least gives you something to anchor to. Mine is going in this week so I'll be in the same waiting mode soon.

0 coins

if your denial was for proof of relationship and you have the birth certificate just get a fresh certified copy from the county and attach it to the appeal. dont rely on a phone photo or a scan that might be unreadable

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

I did use my phone to scan it originally. A certified copy from the county is probably a smarter move for the appeal.

0 coins

yeah county clerk can usually get you one same day or next day, way cleaner than any phone scan

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period before payments start, in case that detail is relevant to anyone here calculating how long they've been owed benefits during the denial period. Some people assume there are seven unpaid days at the start like disability, but that's a different program.

0 coins

I actually thought PFL had the same seven-day wait as SDI. So if the appeal wins, the benefits would go back to day one of the leave period?

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period, that's correct. If the appeal resolves in your favor, EDD would address the days that were denied based on what the determination says.

0 coins

The seven-day wait is a DI thing, not PFL. Worth knowing before you calculate how much you're owed going back.

0 coins

Lim Wong

Author

Okay I submitted the DE 1000A through SDI Online about an hour ago. Attached a much cleaner copy of the birth certificate and wrote a clear statement about when I uploaded the original and why the document meets the proof of relationship requirement. Hopefully that's enough. Thanks everyone for walking me through this.

0 coins

Good. You got it in with time left. Now you wait and watch the mail.

0 coins

You did the right thing going through SDI Online so you have a confirmation. Fingers crossed the reviewer sees it your way.

0 coins

Filing it is the hardest part when you're stressed about it. Hope it comes back in your favor.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure