FMLA baby bonding father — does California PFL work differently for dads?
My daughter was born three weeks ago and I've been trying to figure out how the leave situation works for me as the dad. My wife went on disability before the birth and her claim flipped to PFL bonding after. Mine is totally separate — no pregnancy disability before it, just straight PFL bonding from day one. I kept seeing FMLA mentioned everywhere when I was researching, and honestly I thought FMLA and PFL were the same thing or at least handled together. Turns out they're different beasts. From what I can piece together, California PFL actually pays you but doesn't lock in your job, and FMLA is the job protection side but doesn't pay you anything. My HR department pointed me to both, which made it even more confusing at first. I filed my PFL bonding claim in SDI Online about two weeks ago and uploaded my daughter's birth certificate as the proof of relationship. The claim still shows pending. I haven't gotten a Notice of Computation yet and no first payment either. Is this normal for a dad filing his own separate bonding claim? Did I do it right by uploading the birth certificate, or was I supposed to mail something?
80 comments

Sophia Clark
Two weeks pending is right at the edge of what EDD says is normal — they say deciding a claim can take up to 14 days. The birth certificate upload in SDI Online is the right move for a dad filing his own bonding claim, that's the proof of relationship they need. If day 14 passes with no Notice of Computation, log into SDI Online, open your claim, and hit Request Claim Update. Pick the right request type and explain the situation in a couple sentences. That usually gets eyes on it.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorDay 14 landed yesterday with nothing, so I sent the Request Claim Update this morning. The SDI Online confirmation said it went through. How long does it usually take for them to actually respond to one of those?
0 coins
Sophia Clark
Responses to the Request Claim Update vary — some people hear back within a few days through SDI Online, others have to follow up. EDD also sends stuff by mail so keep an eye on your physical mailbox too, not just the portal.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
The PFL vs. FMLA thing tripped me up too when my son was born. I thought getting PFL approved meant my job was automatically protected. It's not — PFL pays the benefits but EDD itself says it doesn't protect your job. The job protection piece is CFRA here in California or FMLA federally, and whether either one covers you depends on your employer and your situation. HR is the right place to ask about the job side.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorHR told me I qualified for CFRA leave so at least that piece is handled. I just want the PFL payments to come through now.
0 coins
Madison Allen
Yep, the two run at the same time for a lot of people. CFRA holds the job, PFL pays you while you're out. Neither one covers everything by itself.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Exactly this. I made the mistake of thinking PFL approval meant I was set on the job front too. Had to scramble to file the CFRA paperwork separately with HR. Now I always tell people to handle both tracks at the same time.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Denial letter in my mailbox, twelve days after I filed my own bonding claim last spring, was not what I expected to open. The Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) said I hadn't met the base period wage requirement, but I'd been at my job for over two years. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent — it holds on the line for you so you end up talking to a live person. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the base period they used didn't include my most recent quarter's wages, which explained the gap. She confirmed I had 30 days from the date on the DE 2514 to appeal using the DE 1000A and that I could file it online or by mail. I filed the appeal the same afternoon.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorDid the appeal end up working out for you? I'm hoping I don't get a denial but good to know there's a path if I do.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Appeal went through and the claim was approved. The 30-day window on the DE 2514 is real so I wouldn't sit on it if you get one.
0 coins
Emily Parker
The base period thing catches people off guard. The wages EDD looks at aren't necessarily your most recent paycheck — it's a specific 12-month window from roughly 5 to 18 months before the claim starts. If your job or income changed recently you might fall into an unexpected gap.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Dads filing their own bonding claim is still something a lot of people don't realize they can do. When my partner gave birth I assumed all the PFL would go through her claim. A coworker set me straight — each parent can file separately and use up to eight weeks of their own PFL. We both ended up filing and both got approved. The key for me was having the birth certificate ready to upload as the proof of relationship.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Wait, do both parents get eight weeks each, or is it eight weeks shared between the two of you?
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Each parent files from their own SDI contributions, so it's eight weeks per parent — not shared. Her eight weeks are from her payroll withholding, mine are from mine.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
To be exact, the eight weeks is per claim, but the same person only gets eight weeks total across bonding, care and military assist within any 12-month period. So if a dad took five weeks bonding and then needed to care for a sick parent later in the same year, he'd have three weeks left for the care claim, not a fresh eight.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
That's a really good point I hadn't thought about. I used all eight weeks on the bonding claim so it won't affect me this year, but that's worth knowing going forward.
0 coins
Zara Perez
My bonding claim went pending for 11 days and I was absolutely spiraling. Every day I'd check SDI Online and see the same pending status and convince myself something was wrong with the birth certificate I uploaded. Then on day 12 the Notice of Computation showed up in the mail and two days later I got the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification for the first payment. Try to hold on a bit longer if you can before panicking.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorThe Electronic Benefit Payment Notification — does that come by mail too or does it show up in SDI Online?
0 coins
Zara Perez
Mine came by mail but I think you can also see payment info in SDI Online once it's processed. I checked both.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
EDD mails both the Notice of Computation and the DE 2500E (the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification) but the payment activity does show up in your claim on SDI Online as well. It doesn't hurt to watch both.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Nobody told me there was NO waiting period for PFL. I kept preparing myself for seven unpaid days at the start like I'd heard about with disability claims. When the first payment showed up and covered from day one I was genuinely confused and thought they'd made an error. Had to look it up — PFL has no benefit waiting period, that's only on the disability side. Saved me from filing a question I didn't need to file.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
I made that exact same assumption and held off spending anything for the first week expecting nothing to come. When the payment came through faster than I planned for I felt pretty silly about all the stress.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorThis is actually really helpful to know. I had mentally written off the first week as unpaid because someone in my office said there's a waiting period. Good to hear that's not PFL.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Yeah the seven-day waiting period is a disability thing, not PFL. Easy to mix up since both run through EDD and SDI.
0 coins
Ella Russell
EDD's phone line during my bonding claim wait last year was something else. I called four mornings in a row and either got a busy signal or got disconnected partway through. I finally sent a Request Claim Update in SDI Online instead of trying the phone again, and that ended up getting answered. For the actual claim status at least, the online message might be faster than trying to get a human.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorHave you found any particular time of day that works better for the phone? I may need to call if the Request Claim Update doesn't move things along.
0 coins
Ella Russell
I tried early morning the first few days thinking that would beat the rush. Didn't help for me but I know some people say they've had better luck. I genuinely can't say there's a magic hour — the online route ended up being more reliable for my situation.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
EDD's PFL line is 1-877-238-4373, open 8 to 5 Monday through Friday. If you need a Spanish line it's 1-877-379-3819. For something like a pending status question the Request Claim Update in SDI Online is a solid first try before burning time on hold.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
My claim cleared pending after 10 days and the Notice of Computation was in the mailbox the following day. The weekly benefit amount on mine was lower than I expected — I went to the benefits calculator on EDD's site before filing and the estimate was in the right ballpark, but the actual number on the notice was a bit different. If you haven't used the calculator yet it's worth running your wages through just so the notice doesn't surprise you.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorThe notice amount being lower than the calculator estimate — did you ever figure out why they were different?
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
The calculator uses the wages you enter yourself and I'd put in a rough number. EDD uses your actual reported earnings from the base period, which ended up being slightly different from my estimate. Not a huge gap but noticeable.
0 coins
Emily Parker
The base period looks at the highest quarter of wages from 5 to 18 months before the claim starts, not your current pay. If you got a raise recently or changed jobs, the base period might reflect older, lower wages. The notice is the real number.
0 coins
Gavin King
Proof of relationship received date was blank in SDI Online, ten days after I uploaded my son's birth certificate, even though I had the confirmation that the upload went through. I got on the phone with an EDD agent using Claimyr — waited on hold with EDD and ended up speaking to someone directly. The agent confirmed the birth certificate had been received and matched to my claim, that it just hadn't reflected in the portal view yet, and told me the claim was still within the normal review window. First payment came through three days after that call.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorThe portal not showing the document as received even after upload is exactly what I'm worried about. Does the agent actually have visibility into what documents EDD has versus what SDI Online shows?
0 coins
Gavin King
In my case the agent could see the document on their end even though the portal hadn't updated. That was the whole point of calling — the portal view and EDD's internal records weren't matching, and the agent confirmed what was actually there.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
The SDI Online upload confirmation is proof you sent it, but the status display doesn't always update immediately. If EDD has what they need, the claim can move forward even if the portal looks like it's still waiting.
0 coins
Madison Allen
Eight weeks feels like a lot until you're actually in it. I took all eight straight through after my son was born and it still wasn't enough time. I know some dads split it up — take a few weeks right after birth and save the rest. The PFL rules let you break it up as long as all eight weeks are used within 12 months of the birth. If you plan to go back part-time for a bit and then take more weeks, just make sure you're reporting your work days and wages to EDD when you do.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
If you go back part-time, do you have to file a whole new claim for the remaining weeks or does the original claim keep paying for the days you're not working?
0 coins
Madison Allen
If you're going back part-time while still on leave you report the days and hours you're working and EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form. You fill it out and send it back and benefits continue for the days you're not working. It's the same claim, not a new one. If you go back full-time and want to use remaining weeks later, that's when you'd file a new claim.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
The Continued Claim Certification is the DE 2580GF by the way — EDD mails it once you report you're working part of the time. Benefits stop if you don't return it, so don't sit on it when it arrives.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
HR at my last job tried to tell me I had to use all my vacation time before PFL would kick in, which made me really anxious about the first few weeks. That's not quite how it works — an employer can require you to take paid time off at the same time as PFL, but PFL itself doesn't have a waiting period you have to fill with vacation first. The EDD side starts when your leave starts. The vacation-plus-PFL combo just can't add up to more than your normal wages, excluding overtime.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorMy employer is requiring me to use two weeks of accrued vacation at the start, running at the same time as PFL. Is that normal?
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Completely normal and legal. As long as the vacation pay plus the PFL doesn't add up to more than your regular wages, EDD pays the PFL portion and you get the vacation from your employer. Net result is you end up close to your normal take-home for those weeks.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
The cap is wages excluding overtime — so if someone's regular pay plus the PFL benefit is more than their usual paycheck without overtime, there could be an adjustment. Most people end up at or just under normal.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
PFL payment method question came up for me after I filed — I'd set up direct deposit in SDI Online when I filed and then worried I'd done it wrong because nothing showed up in my bank for two weeks. Eventually the claim was approved and the first deposit landed. Direct deposit through SDI Online is only available if you filed online, which you did, so you should be good as long as you set it up during the application.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorI did set up direct deposit when I filed. The SDI Online application walked me through it. Good to know that's the right path.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
The two-week wait after the claim is complete before the first payment is typical — EDD says most payments go out within two weeks of a properly completed claim. The pending status before that is just them verifying everything.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Taxes on PFL tripped me up at the end of the year. I didn't know EDD sends a 1099-G in January covering what they paid out the previous year. California doesn't tax PFL but depending on your federal situation there may be more to it. I'd talk to a tax professional about the federal side rather than guessing — I made assumptions I shouldn't have.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
EDD's site has a tax information page on PFL that's worth reading before year-end. And yeah, a tax person is the right call for the federal question. I'm not touching that one.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorNoted, I'll flag this for January. Wasn't even on my radar while dealing with the pending claim.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
My first payment date was what I had to call about — the Notice of Computation had come and the claim was approved, but the payment just wasn't in my account on the date I expected based on when I filed. I tried Claimyr to reach a live EDD agent rather than sitting on hold for hours. The agent looked up my claim and told me the payment had been issued two days prior and gave me the exact date it processed, which was three business days before it would hit my bank with direct deposit. I stopped refreshing my bank app after that.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Did the agent say whether the processing date EDD uses is different from when the money actually lands in an account?
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
She said the payment issued date and the deposit date aren't always the same day — there's a processing gap between EDD releasing it and the bank posting it. She gave me the issued date, not the bank arrival date, which explained the difference I was seeing.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Same thing happened to me — saw 'payment issued' in SDI Online a day or two before it actually posted to my account. It's normal but nobody warns you about the gap.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Proof of relationship is the piece dads most often mess up, based on what I've read in this forum. A birth certificate is the right document if you're listed on it. If you're not on the birth certificate yet — like if it hadn't been issued yet or the paternity process is still going — EDD also takes a Declaration of Paternity (CS-909) or some other documents. For adoptive or foster dads it's different documents entirely, like an Adoptive Placement Agreement or a foster care agency letter.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
What about if the birth certificate was delayed — like the hospital was slow issuing it? Can you file without it and send it later?
0 coins
Nathan Kim
You can file and use the receipt number to track the claim, then get the proof of relationship to EDD as soon as you have it. The 41-day deadline is from the start of your leave, not from when the birth certificate is ready. So file on time and then follow up with the document.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
If EDD needs the document to complete the claim they'll indicate what's missing. The worst thing to do is wait to file until you have the certificate in hand if that's going to push you past 41 days.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
My wife's claim process and mine were totally separate and that confused me at first too. She went from pregnancy disability straight into her PFL bonding — EDD mailed her a DE 2501FP when the disability part ended and she filed that for the bonding transition. Mine was a fresh SDI Online filing with the birth certificate upload. The two claims run independently, we just had to make sure our leave dates didn't overlap in a way that complicated either claim.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorThe DE 2501FP — is that the form specifically for moms transitioning from disability to bonding? I want to make sure I'm not supposed to be using that form.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Correct, the DE 2501FP is for a birth mother coming off a pregnancy disability claim. As a dad with no disability claim before this, you don't use it. Your path is the SDI Online filing with proof of relationship, which is what you did.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
The DE 2501FP is only for the new mother transitioning from disability. It's specifically designed for that path and requires no additional documents. Dads, adoptive parents, and foster parents go through the standard SDI Online bonding claim process.
0 coins
Emily Parker
EDD rejected my bonding claim the first time because I'd filed too early — submitted it about five days before my leave actually started. The rule is you can't file earlier than the first day of your leave. I had to refile once my leave began. If you're seeing your original filing date, make sure it was on or after your first day of leave and not before.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorI filed on the third day of my leave so that should be fine, right? I didn't file before it started.
0 coins
Emily Parker
Filing on day three of your leave is exactly right — no earlier than the first day, no later than 41 days from the start. You're in the valid window.
0 coins
Zara Perez
The 41-day deadline from the start of leave is the outer limit. EDD says filing late can cause you to lose some benefits if the late filing pushes past that window. Good habit to file within the first week if possible.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
EDD's Ask EDD form is worth knowing about if the Request Claim Update in SDI Online doesn't get you a response. It's a separate online contact form on EDD's site. I've used it twice — once it got an answer faster than a call would have, once it took longer. Having multiple contact options is useful.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorDidn't know about Ask EDD. I'll add that to the list if the Request Claim Update doesn't move anything in the next couple days.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Ask EDD is good for general questions but for something like a pending status where you want someone to look at your actual claim, the Request Claim Update in SDI Online tends to be more direct because it's tied to your claim ID.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
True — Request Claim Update goes to EDD with your claim context already attached. Ask EDD is more of a general inquiry line. Both are on the table but for a pending claim, the claim-specific message probably has the edge.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
No CFRA or FMLA question here, just a note — if you're at a smaller employer who doesn't qualify for CFRA, the job protection side might be different or not apply at all. PFL through EDD pays you no matter what size your employer is, but job protection is a separate legal question you have to work out with HR or an employment attorney. I learned this the hard way.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorMy employer confirmed CFRA coverage applies so I think I'm okay there. But good reminder that it's a separate track from the EDD claim.
0 coins
Madison Allen
EDD themselves say PFL provides benefit payments but not job protection. They're very clear about that. The job protection question is entirely between you and your employer under CFRA or FMLA. EDD has nothing to do with it.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Day 16 update if anyone follows this thread — pending broke today. Notice of Computation showed up in my physical mailbox and my SDI Online claim status changed at the same time. Weekly benefit amount was close to what the EDD calculator estimated. First payment should be within two weeks from here according to what I've read in this thread.
0 coins
Ryan Young
AuthorStill waiting on mine at day 15 but this gives me hope. Did yours show any update in SDI Online before the mail arrived or did both happen simultaneously?
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Both seemed to change on the same day — I checked SDI Online in the morning and saw the status update, then the paper notice was in my mailbox that afternoon. I don't know which one technically came first.
0 coins
Ryan Young
Closing the loop for anyone who finds this later — my claim went from pending to approved on day 17. The Notice of Computation came by mail and the SDI Online status updated the same day. First deposit hit my bank account six days after the notice. The birth certificate upload as proof of relationship was correct, the Request Claim Update I sent on day 14 may have helped move things, and the PFL vs. CFRA/FMLA confusion I had at the start is worth clarifying with HR early. EDD handles the pay, your employer handles the job protection. Keep both tracks going.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
Day 17 is completely within the normal range. Glad the deposit landed and the claim is running. The point about handling the EDD and HR tracks separately is the most useful thing new parents can know going in.
0 coins
Zara Perez
17 days to first deposit from filing is pretty much the standard experience for a bonding claim with no complications. Yours tracked exactly like mine did.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
The Request Claim Update probably did help — it flags the claim for review. Good outcome and thanks for the update.
0 coins