Back to California Paid Family Leave

QuantumQuasar

Do new fathers apply for SDI first only paid family leave, or is it different for dads?

So my wife is due in February and I've been trying to figure out the whole leave situation before the baby gets here. I work at a distribution center, decent hours, but I want to take at least a few weeks off when the baby comes. Someone at work told me I need to file for SDI first and then switch to PFL, same as my wife would do. But she's the one who's pregnant, not me. Do new fathers apply for SDI first only paid family leave, or does that SDI step not apply to dads at all? I don't want to file the wrong thing and mess up the timing. Any help appreciated, got enough going on already with getting the nursery done anyway.

Dads go straight to PFL bonding, no SDI step first. SDI is for your wife because her body is recovering from the childbirth. You're not disabled, so there's nothing to file there. File the PFL bonding claim in SDI Online, upload the birth certificate or the paternity declaration once you have it, and you're set.

0 coins

Got it, that makes sense. So I don't even touch the SDI application at all?

0 coins

Correct. SDI Online is where you file, but you're filing a PFL claim, not a DI claim. Different program, same website.

0 coins

Yeah the coworker who told you SDI first was thinking of the mom's process. Dads skip that whole part.

0 coins

My husband went through this last spring. He was so confused about the same thing because everyone kept saying SDI and he thought he had to do that disability part too. He went straight to PFL in SDI Online and it was actually pretty smooth once he found the right application. The birth certificate was all he needed for the proof of relationship.

0 coins

That's exactly what confused me, everyone says SDI but they mean the website not the actual disability program. What was his timeline like from filing to first payment?

0 coins

He filed the day I came home from the hospital, got the Notice of Computation maybe four or five days later, and the first payment came about a week and a half after that. He chose direct deposit which I think helped.

0 coins

Wait the Notice of Computation isn't the approval letter? I thought getting that meant you were approved. I'm stressed now.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows your potential weekly benefit amount, it isn't a confirmation that you've been approved. The actual first payment notification comes separately. EDD still has to determine eligibility after they receive the claim.

0 coins

Around two weeks after I filed my PFL bonding claim the status still said pending and I had no idea if any payment had actually processed. EDD's phone line was impossible for me, tried mornings for three days straight and kept getting cut off. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to talk to an actual EDD agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent looked at my claim and told me the first payment had been issued on a specific date and that I should see it hit my debit card within a few days. That was the confirmation I needed because checking the status screen alone wasn't telling me much.

0 coins

Benefit timing is exactly what I need to know about my claim too. Going to try Claimyr for it. What did you have ready when the agent picked up?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and the claim ID from SDI Online. The agent pulled everything up fast once I gave those.

0 coins

Two weeks of pending with no info sounds awful. Glad that worked out for you.

0 coins

edd phone line is brutal i gave up after like 4 tries in one morning

0 coins

The question every new dad should ask EDD is whether they filed under the right program, because the SDI Online site handles both DI and PFL and it is easy to land on the wrong form. For bonding, specifically, you want the PFL application, not the DI application. The form number on the paper version is the DE 2501F if you want to double check what you submitted.

0 coins

Is there a way to see in SDI Online which one I actually filed if I already submitted?

0 coins

Log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open SDI Online. The claim type shows next to the claim ID, it will say Paid Family Leave or Disability Insurance so you can confirm right there.

0 coins

This is a good point. The landing page when you click Apply for Benefits can be a little ambiguous and I could see someone clicking the wrong thing if they were rushing.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD ever told me straight up that the SDI waiting period doesn't apply to PFL. I assumed there were seven unpaid days at the start like disability has, so I delayed filing thinking it didn't matter. Turns out PFL has no waiting period at all. Those first days I sat on could have been paid days.

0 coins

PFL has no benefit waiting period, that is correct. The seven-day wait belongs to Disability Insurance only. EDD is pretty clear about it on their site but it doesn't get mentioned much when people talk casually about leave.

0 coins

Filed December 2nd, leave started December 2nd, first eligible day was December 2nd. No waiting days lost. That's one thing PFL actually has going for it.

0 coins

Wait, so there's truly zero waiting period? I thought everyone had to sit out a week unpaid at the start.

0 coins

Zero waiting period for PFL, yes. If your leave starts on a Monday, Monday is your first eligible day.

0 coins

File as soon as the baby is born, don't wait around. You've got 41 days from when your leave starts before you lose the ability to claim days at the beginning. Miss that and EDD won't pay you for those early days.

0 coins

41 days, got it. So I should file basically as soon as we're home from the hospital?

0 coins

Day one or two home, yes. No reason to wait and plenty of reason not to.

0 coins

Does the 41 days start from the birth date or from the date you actually start your leave? What if you take a few days of vacation first?

0 coins

The 41-day deadline runs from the date your PFL leave actually starts, not from the birth. So if you use vacation for the first few days and then start your PFL on day four, the 41 days begins on day four.

0 coins

Leave balance was something I completely lost track of on my own claim. My wife and I both took bonding leave for our daughter and I got confused about how many weeks I had left after she took hers. I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent who confirmed that the eight weeks is a per-person limit, so my wife's weeks and mine are separate totals, not shared. The agent also confirmed exactly how many of my weeks I still had available in the 12-month window, which I hadn't been able to figure out from the SDI Online status screen alone.

0 coins

Tracking remaining weeks was what had me going in circles too after I took some time intermittently. Used Claimyr as well, and once the agent confirmed which weeks had been paid and when my next payment cycle was due I was able to plan the rest of my leave around it. The SDI Online screen just wasn't showing me that breakdown clearly.

0 coins

been trying to get through to edd for a week on the leave balance question. maybe ill try that route.

0 coins

Wait so each parent really does get their own eight weeks? I assumed it was a family total you split between the two of you.

0 coins

Each parent files their own separate PFL bonding claim with their own employer's SDI contributions. The eight-week maximum is per claimant. The only combined limit is within one person's own claims across bonding, care and military assist in a 12-month period.

0 coins

Okay I'm a first-timer reading this and now I have a question. If my husband files the PFL bonding claim, does he need to upload a birth certificate right when he files, or can he submit it after? I'm worried the baby might arrive before we have the official certificate from the county.

0 coins

A Declaration of Paternity, the CS-909 form, is an acceptable proof of relationship too, and that document is usually signed at the hospital before you even go home. So if the official birth certificate isn't back from the county yet, the paternity declaration works in its place.

0 coins

Thank you, that's such a relief. We didn't know that was an option.

0 coins

The hospital gave us that declaration form before we even left. It was like one of ten things they handed us in a folder. Definitely use it if the birth certificate isn't back yet.

0 coins

Proof of relationship tripped my brother-in-law up because he thought he could just upload a photo of the hospital bracelet or something. EDD has a specific short list: birth certificate, the CS-909 Declaration of Paternity, an Adoptive Placement Agreement, or a foster care agency letter. That's it, nothing informal.

0 coins

Good to know. We'll be getting the CS-909 at the hospital so sounds like we're covered.

0 coins

EDD is not known for accepting creative substitutes, so sticking to that list is smart.

0 coins

my cousin tried to send a photo of the discharge paperwork and edd kicked it back. gotta be one of the actual documents

0 coins

Direct deposit versus the debit card is worth deciding before you file, not after. Direct deposit is only available if you file through SDI Online. Paper filers get the debit card automatically. Processing tends to go a bit faster with direct deposit in my experience.

0 coins

Filing online is easier anyway. Setting up direct deposit at the same time makes sense.

0 coins

Confirm your bank routing and account numbers before you start the SDI Online application so you have them ready. Avoids having to log back in and change it later.

0 coins

December 14th I filed with direct deposit, first payment showed December 26th. The debit card can add a few days on top of processing for the card itself to arrive by mail.

0 coins

Bonding leave can be split up into pieces, which not everyone realizes! You don't have to take your eight weeks all at once. As long as all of it is used within 12 months of the baby's birth, you can go back to work and then take more weeks later.

0 coins

Oh that's really useful actually. I was planning to take six weeks straight but good to know I could save two for later if something comes up.

0 coins

Splitting it up takes a little more coordination with EDD but it's doable. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification form when you're taking leave intermittently, and you have to return it or the payments stop.

0 coins

Used four weeks when the baby came, saved the other four for when my wife went back to work. Worked out well for us.

0 coins

PFL doesn't protect your job. Worth knowing before you tell your employer you're leaving for eight weeks.

0 coins

So what does protect my job while I'm on PFL?

0 coins

California Family Rights Act, CFRA, is what most people rely on for job protection during bonding leave. Whether it applies depends on your employer and situation. EDD handles the PFL pay, but for the job protection piece you'd want to talk to your employer's HR about CFRA coverage.

0 coins

EDD says it plainly on their site. PFL pays you, it does not hold your job.

0 coins

Receipt number is the one thing people forget to screenshot when they submit. The confirmation page shows it once and if you close the browser without saving it, tracking your claim or giving the number to a doctor's office becomes harder. Write it down somewhere.

0 coins

Noted. Screenshotting that page as soon as we're done filing.

0 coins

I had it because I screenshotted it but honestly I forgot to check it for two weeks. It shows up in SDI Online under your claim once you log in too so it's not completely lost if you miss it.

0 coins

Saving the confirmation page is going in my checklist for the hospital bag honestly.

0 coins

The 41-day window was what worried me most when my husband filed his bonding claim for our granddaughter's placement. He kept second-guessing the leave start date, which matters a lot because that is what the 41 days counts from. I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent because we had spent two mornings dialing and not getting through once. The agent confirmed the exact start date EDD had on the claim and told us we were still well within the filing window.

0 coins

Two mornings and not through once sounds exactly right for that line. I've tried on seven different days over the past three weeks, never past the recorded message. Hard to believe that actually works.

0 coins

My experience was that it did work. The person I spoke with was an EDD employee, answered questions about the claim specifically, and I could check what the agent said against what later showed up in SDI Online.

0 coins

I had the same doubt but a friend of mine had talked to EDD through it about her DE 2500E and the agent confirmed the payment notification had been sent and explained what to look for. That was enough for her.

0 coins

Start date confusion is real. Mine will be the day I stop working, not the day of the birth, right? Those might be different days if she delivers on a Wednesday.

0 coins

The leave start date is the first day you're actually off work and not receiving regular wages, yes. If the birth is on a Wednesday and you work through Tuesday, Wednesday is your start date.

0 coins

my coworker asked hr before filing and hr told him he needed to do sdi first then pfl. hr was wrong. dont let hr be your only source on this stuff

0 coins

HR gets this wrong pretty often. They confuse the mom's process with the dad's process.

0 coins

The confusion makes some sense because on the same team, the mom does have an SDI claim before PFL, so HR sees both programs used and assumes both apply to everyone. The distinction is that mom files SDI because she's the one physically recovering.

0 coins

yeah makes sense why theyd mix it up but still worth checking edd.ca.gov directly

0 coins

does the weekly benefit amount show on the notice of computation before or after they decide eligibility? i got mine but still pending.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation comes before eligibility is determined. It shows what your potential weekly amount would be based on your wages. Pending just means they're still reviewing. The actual payment notice comes after they make the eligibility decision.

0 coins

ok that makes sense thanks

0 coins

EDD's benefit calculator on their site gives an estimate before you even file, so you can compare it to what the Notice of Computation shows and make sure the numbers line up.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you realize it's shared across bonding, care claims and military assist all in the same 12 months. Take eight weeks bonding with the baby, you've got nothing left if a parent gets sick that same year.

0 coins

Wait the eight weeks is the total across all PFL types combined? Not eight weeks each?

0 coins

Eight weeks total per person per 12-month period, covering bonding, care and military assist together. If you use five weeks bonding you have three weeks left for anything else in those 12 months.

0 coins

Most people find this out too late. Plan accordingly.

0 coins

Wages while on PFL leave still get reported to EDD if you pick up any shifts or freelance work during that time. Even wages you haven't received yet. EDD sends a Continued Claim Certification and if you don't return it, payments stop. Not reporting can lead to an overpayment situation.

0 coins

I don't plan to work at all during leave but good to know for the intermittent option later.

0 coins

The EDD form for that is the DE 2580GF. If you ever shift to intermittent leave mid-claim, that is the form they will send you to report the days you work.

0 coins

Exactly. It's pretty painless to fill out but you have to send it back promptly or the payments pause.

0 coins

The SDI Online versus paper filing question matters for one specific reason beyond direct deposit: EDD can typically process online claims faster because everything is already in the system. Paper claims add whatever time the mail takes in both directions.

0 coins

File online. No reason to mail paper in this era.

0 coins

Is there any reason someone would need to file on paper instead of online?

0 coins

Mostly if someone doesn't have reliable internet access or runs into a technical issue with myEDD. For most people SDI Online is the right move.

0 coins

New dads also need to know their PFL benefit is calculated off their own wage history, not their wife's. Base period is wages they paid into SDI on. Doesn't matter what she earned.

0 coins

Makes sense, we have different employers anyway. So my benefit amount comes from my own CASDI contributions on my paystubs.

0 coins

Right. Look for CASDI on your paystubs, that's your contribution. The Notice of Computation will show what your weekly rate works out to based on your wages in the base period.

0 coins

The base period is the wages from about five to eighteen months before the claim starts. EDD pulls the highest quarter within that window. The calculator on EDD's site gives you an estimate if you want to know before you file.

0 coins

PFL appeal rights are on the denial notice too if it comes to that. DE 1000A is the form, 30 days to file it. Worth knowing before you need it.

0 coins

Hoping it doesn't come to that but good to have in the back of the mind.

0 coins

The Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, the DE 2514, is what EDD sends if they find you ineligible. The appeal form comes with it. Thirty days from the date on that notice is the window.

0 coins

Miss the 30 days and you're in harder territory. Don't sit on it.

0 coins

February due dates are good timing for leave planning. You'll have the full 12 months from birth to use your eight weeks, which runs through February next year. Gives you flexibility if you want to split the time.

0 coins

That's actually how I've been thinking about it. Take six weeks right after birth, maybe keep two for later in the year.

0 coins

Just make sure to file before the 41 days when you take that second chunk. Well, I think you file a new claim for the second round but someone who knows more should confirm that.

0 coins

For the second block of time: if you've already gone back to full-time work with weeks still left, you file a new DE 2501F when you're ready to take those remaining weeks. EDD tracks the total used across your 12-month window.

0 coins

Filing a new claim for the second block is easy enough. I'll note that down.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure