Back to California Paid Family Leave

Liv Park

California EDD PFL and unemployment number — can you collect both at the same time?

Okay so I've been going back and forth on this and I can't figure out the answer. I took PFL to bond with my daughter back in the spring, used about five weeks of it, and then my company did a round of layoffs right in the middle of my leave. HR told me I could file for unemployment since I was technically still an employee who got laid off. So I did — filed for UI while my PFL bonding claim was still active. Now I'm getting letters from both and I honestly don't know if I was supposed to do that. Can you collect PFL and unemployment at the same time? Or does collecting one cancel out the other? I still have three weeks of PFL bonding left that I haven't used and my daughter is only seven months so I'm within the 12-month window. I want to use those remaining weeks but I don't want to trigger an overpayment situation on either side. Really hoping someone here has dealt with something like this.

Had something similar happen to a friend of mine — wait, actually, let me answer the real question first. PFL and unemployment don't pay for the same days. EDD's rule is you get one or the other on any given day, never both. If you were collecting unemployment benefits for the same days your PFL bonding claim was paying out, that's going to be a problem. EDD tracks this and when they find overlapping benefit days, an overpayment notice usually follows.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Filing for UI while PFL was still active was the mistake then. I genuinely didn't know they couldn't overlap. How do I find out exactly which days overlapped?

0 coins

Check both claim portals — your PFL payment history in SDI Online will show which specific days EDD paid out on your bonding claim. Cross-reference that with the UI payment dates. If there's overlap, getting ahead of it and contacting EDD directly is better than waiting for them to find it.

0 coins

EDD caught this exact thing on my neighbor's claim, the overlapping days triggered an automatic overpayment notice from the PFL side. The notice came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) stapled to it. So if you haven't gotten that notice yet, it might be on the way.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Okay that's what I was afraid of. If the overpayment notice comes, the appeal is within 30 days right?

0 coins

Thirty days from the date on the notice, yes. File the appeal in SDI Online or mail the DE 1000A — whichever you do, don't wait until day 29 to decide.

0 coins

Agreed, the 30-day window goes fast when you're stressed. Appeal the overpayment if you think the overlap days are wrong in their calculation, not just because you owe something.

0 coins

Weeks left after the layoff are what threw me off on my own bonding claim. My situation was different — I'd used four weeks bonding with my twins, then tried to restart the remaining weeks three months later when the job situation settled. I didn't know whether EDD would still let me use them. I got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — Claimyr holds for you so you end up talking to a live person on the PFL line. The agent pulled up my claim and told me I had four weeks remaining in my 12-month period and that my window closed at a specific date in November. That was exactly what I needed to know before I refiled. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

That's actually useful — knowing the exact close date. I'm within my 12 months for sure but pinning down how many weeks I actually have left before I do anything else makes sense.

0 coins

Knowing your remaining weeks before you restart is smart because if you file a new DE 2501F claiming days that are inside your unemployment payment period, it'll flag immediately.

0 coins

My coworker collected unemployment and thought PFL was just a separate account she could also draw from simultaneously. EDD does not treat them that way. PFL doesn't pay for any day that unemployment is also covering — if unemployment is active and paying, those days simply can't be PFL days too. She had to repay the overlap.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

So the fix going forward is to stop collecting unemployment before resuming PFL, not running them in parallel. Got it.

0 coins

Exactly. Close out or pause UI for the weeks you want to use as PFL bonding. They can't cover the same ground.

0 coins

There's also the question of whether you're still actively looking for work while on PFL bonding, since unemployment requires that. Being on PFL to care for or bond with a child kind of contradicts the "available for work" requirement UI needs.

0 coins

Confused about something — does the layoff actually end the PFL claim automatically? Like does losing the job cut off the remaining bonding weeks entirely?

0 coins

PFL doesn't require you to be currently employed — the eligibility is based on whether you had the SDI withholding (the CASDI deduction) during your base period wages. Getting laid off during leave doesn't eliminate the remaining weeks, as long as the 12-month bonding window is still open.

0 coins

So the job loss doesn't wipe out the unused PFL weeks. That's clearer, thanks.

0 coins

Right, it's based on your wage history before the claim, not your current employment status at the time you use the weeks.

0 coins

Ended up in a similar tangle and found no clean way to run both simultaneously. What I did when my employment ended during leave: paused PFL voluntarily by just not certifying further on that claim, collected unemployment while job searching, then when I found new work I never went back to finish the PFL weeks because my 12-month window had lapsed by then. That part stung.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

That's the trap — if the 12-month window closes while you're on UI you just lose those remaining weeks entirely.

0 coins

Lost three weeks because I didn't pay attention to the calendar. If your daughter is seven months, run the numbers on exactly when that 12-month clock hits.

0 coins

The 12 months run from the birth date, not from the first day you filed, so double check that date.

0 coins

Does PFL have a waiting period that eats into the leftover weeks? Asking because I thought there were seven unpaid days when you restart a claim.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all — none of that seven-day thing. That's Disability Insurance, which is a completely separate program. PFL bonding has no unpaid waiting days, so your leftover weeks pay from day one when you restart.

0 coins

Oh I had that backwards entirely, good to know. I would've sat out a week for nothing.

0 coins

Is the overpayment automatically a problem or can you argue that you weren't told the two couldn't overlap? Like is ignorance a valid appeal argument?

0 coins

Ignorance of the rule isn't typically the strongest appeal ground — the appeal is better used to dispute the facts, like if EDD has the wrong days listed in the overlap calculation. If the days they say overlapped actually didn't, that's something to fight. But 'I didn't know' is harder.

0 coins

Makes sense. Facts over feelings when it comes to EDD appeals.

0 coins

You can also appeal an overpayment notice — not necessarily to say you don't owe anything, but to work out whether the amount is calculated correctly. And if you disagree with their math, the DE 1000A is the form to file within 30 days of the notice date.

0 coins

My layoff happened before I'd even started PFL, so I filed unemployment first, then wanted to file PFL bonding for the same newborn afterward. EDD said I had to report any days where UI had already paid when I did eventually open the PFL claim. I was really confused about how to report that correctly.

0 coins

Reporting the UI days on the PFL claim is the right move — EDD reconciles the two and pays PFL only for days not already covered by UI. You shouldn't get double-paid and they check.

0 coins

Ended up calling EDD and doing it right. The agent just walked me through which days to mark and confirmed the PFL-only days on my claim.

0 coins

Filing the bonding claim after a layoff was confusing for me too. I wasn't sure whether the 41-day deadline still applied since I was already past a few weeks of leave before the job ended. I kept second-guessing whether the clock had already run. I tried Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and ended up talking to someone who pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file, and told me I was still inside the 41 days. That cleared it up — I filed the same afternoon.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Knowing your exact start date EDD has recorded versus what you think it is — that's a real gap that can bite you.

0 coins

The 41-day window starts from the first day of leave, not the filing date. Getting that date confirmed by an agent is smart before you do anything else.

0 coins

Something people get wrong: they think CFRA gives them job protection and PFL pays them, so they're the same thing. Had a coworker insist her PFL claim was protecting her job during leave. It doesn't. PFL is the wage replacement; job protection is a separate legal question under CFRA or FMLA and depends on her employer and eligibility. Worth knowing the difference especially if a layoff during leave is on the table.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Yeah, HR specifically told me my CFRA protection had lapsed before the layoff happened. The PFL payment side and the job protection side were two entirely different things.

0 coins

Exactly, and knowing they're separate tells you why getting laid off didn't end your PFL eligibility — EDD's benefit is based on your wage history, not whether your employer kept your position.

0 coins

What if someone restarts PFL bonding after UI but their base period wages are from before they were employed? Like if the layoff happened early enough that there aren't much wages in the base period anymore?

0 coins

The base period wages for PFL are from 5 to 18 months before the claim start date. The benefit amount comes off those wages — your Notice of Computation shows the actual weekly amount. If you don't have enough CASDI-withheld wages in the base period, the weekly benefit could be low or eligibility could be an issue. The calculator on EDD's site gives you an estimate.

0 coins

Run the calculator first, then decide. That makes sense before filing anything.

0 coins

When I filed my bonding claim after also having some UI weeks in the mix, the SDI Online confirmation gave me a receipt number. I held onto that because the agent later needed it to look up which days on my claim were showing as pending versus paid.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Keeping that receipt number has come up a few times in this thread. I should screenshot my confirmation pages more carefully.

0 coins

Always save it right when you file. Harder to find later and you'll need it if anything gets tangled.

0 coins

Can I ask — after you stop UI and go back to PFL bonding, do you have to file a brand-new PFL claim or is it still the same claim you interrupted?

0 coins

If you interrupted a claim and want to use the remaining weeks, you contact EDD. If you returned to full-time work and used all your weeks, and want to use days later, that's when a new DE 2501F gets filed. The right path depends on how you left the original claim — worth confirming with EDD if you're not sure which applies.

0 coins

Phoning EDD to confirm which route before filing anything is probably the safer call.

0 coins

My claim got stuck right after a gap in certifying — I hadn't reported that I'd returned to part-time work for a few weeks and EDD sent a Continued Claim Certification (DE 2580GF) that I almost missed. Benefits stopped until I returned it. Reporting wages and work, even one day a week, isn't optional.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

How did you get the DE 2580GF — was it in SDI Online or mailed?

0 coins

Mailed, but I'd also check SDI Online under the claim. I almost didn't see the paper one before the deadline.

0 coins

Not reporting wages even for a week or two is exactly how overpayments happen on PFL claims. EDD finds out and the overpayment notice appears later.

0 coins

I was on PFL bonding, used six of the eight weeks, then my partner also wanted to file PFL bonding for the same baby. Someone told me we each had our own eight weeks. That's not right though is it?

0 coins

Each parent files their own separate PFL bonding claim — two different claims, two different claimants, each eligible for up to eight weeks within their own 12-month period. The eight weeks isn't shared between parents. So yes, your partner can file for their own bonding weeks independently of your claim.

0 coins

Oh that's actually a relief. I thought we were splitting one pool of weeks between us.

0 coins

Different claimants, different claims. The only limit is each person's own 12-month window from placement or birth.

0 coins

Payment ended up coming by check for my care claim even though I'd signed up expecting a debit card — apparently my payment method hadn't been confirmed through SDI Online. I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and they checked my claim and confirmed the payment method EDD had on file, which turned out to be the paper check option. I switched it to direct deposit for the next payment through SDI Online after that.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Payment method being what EDD has on file versus what you expected it to be — that's worth verifying early in the claim.

0 coins

Check it in SDI Online right after filing. The agent confirmed I could update it there and it would apply going forward.

0 coins

Coming at this from a different angle: if you do end up with an overpayment notice and decide not to appeal, PFL overpayments don't just disappear. EDD will collect. Dealing with the notice directly — either appealing if the math is wrong or setting up a resolution — is better than ignoring it.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Appeal within 30 days if the calculation looks wrong, otherwise deal with it head-on. That's the takeaway I'm getting.

0 coins

Exactly. The 30-day clock starts from the date on the notice, not when you receive it, so open and read it immediately.

0 coins

One thing that helped me keep everything straight: treat the 12-month window as the hard boundary and work backward from your daughter's birth date. Figure out how many bonding weeks you've used across any claim periods, then decide whether to restart PFL or let it go. The number left matters more than anything else right now.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Running the math from her birth date is exactly what I'm doing this weekend. Five weeks used, three left, and her birthday is next month so the window closes then.

0 coins

Then file or confirm with EDD before that date. Three weeks is worth recovering if you can.

0 coins

Don't file and just hope — confirm the remaining weeks with EDD first so there are no surprises on the payment side.

0 coins

Receipt number was the first thing the EDD agent asked me for when I reached them — I hadn't saved it from my original filing and had to dig through old emails to find the confirmation. I ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr for my own bonding claim and they looked up the receipt number from my account, confirmed the claim ID and told me the status EDD had recorded. Saved me a ton of guessing about whether my filing had gone through at all.

0 coins

Liv Park

Author

Screenshotting the confirmation page right at filing so the receipt number is easy to find — that's a habit I need to build.

0 coins

Even a photo of the screen works. The receipt number is the first thing any agent needs to find your claim.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD reverse an overpayment assessment after an appeal? Just wondering if the appeals process actually changes anything.

0 coins

Appeals do get reviewed and the amount can change if the facts support it. If the overlap days EDD calculated aren't accurate — wrong dates, days you weren't paid on one of the programs — the appeal is the place to show that. No one can tell you the odds, but filing it with documentation is better than not filing.

0 coins

File the DE 1000A with every piece of documentation you have — screenshots of your UI payment dates, your PFL payment history from SDI Online. Make EDD show their math and then show yours.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure