Back to California Paid Family Leave

Amara Okonkwo

California EDD PFL and unemployment benefits number — can you collect both at once?

Okay so I've been going back and forth on this and I can't figure out if I'm allowed to collect both at the same time. My wife's dad got really sick back in October and I've been the one taking him to his treatments and staying with him during the days. I filed a PFL care claim through SDI Online about three weeks ago and got approved, so payments have been coming in. But here's my thing — I got laid off two weeks before I even started taking care of him, so technically I was unemployed when all this started. My old boss said I might still be able to file for unemployment on top of the PFL since they're separate programs. I'm not sure if that's how it works. The SDI Online portal doesn't really show me anything about whether I'm eligible for both. Has anyone been in a situation where PFL and unemployment overlapped? I don't want to get hit with an overpayment notice later.

Two days a week I'd been going into the clinic with my dad since his condition worsened, and the second round of payments never landed in my account. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD, and the agent pulled up my claim and walked me through which weeks I had reported and which ones were sitting unprocessed because EDD was still waiting on my Continued Claim Certification — the DE 2580GF. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent confirmed the DE 2580GF hadn't been returned on two of the weeks, so those days were just sitting there. I sent it in that same afternoon and payments released within a few days. To the original question about unemployment and PFL at the same time — EDD won't pay both for the same day. You get one or the other, not both.

0 coins

That part at the end is exactly what I was afraid of. So even though my layoff came first, I can't collect unemployment on the same days I'm getting PFL payments?

0 coins

Exactly. EDD pays one at a time for any given day. If PFL is covering a day, unemployment isn't paying that day too.

0 coins

The DE 2580GF trips so many people up. If you don't send it back your payments just stop with no warning.

0 coins

Your former boss gave you some bad information there. PFL and unemployment benefits don't stack on the same days — EDD is explicit that you can't get both for the same period. The way it usually works is that if unemployment started first and then you file PFL, your unemployment claim gets suspended for the PFL period. The two programs are separate but they can't both pay you for the same days you're out.

0 coins

So does unemployment just pause while I'm on PFL, or do I lose those weeks entirely?

0 coins

You'd want to contact the unemployment side of EDD to get clarity on how your specific claim is affected — that part is outside PFL's rules, so I don't want to guess at the details.

0 coins

My HR told me the same thing your boss told you, that you could get both. That advice cost me a week of confusion and a letter from EDD I had to sort out.

0 coins

Went through almost the same situation last year — care claim for my mom while I was between jobs. I asked EDD directly when I finally got through on the phone, and the rep confirmed they look at whether you're getting unemployment payments for the same days as PFL. If you are, one of them has to give. The PFL care claim doesn't go away, but the overlap is the problem. Report everything accurately and don't assume both are running in the background at once.

0 coins

Reporting everything accurately is what I'm most worried about — I don't want to trigger an overpayment months later because I misunderstood the rules at the start.

0 coins

An overpayment notice from EDD is brutal to deal with. Getting it right now is so much easier.

0 coins

Exactly — if you're uncertain, send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online explaining the situation. At least then there's a record that you tried to flag it.

0 coins

I want to push back a little on what someone said upthread about unemployment just 'pausing.' It doesn't automatically pause. You have to actively report to the unemployment side that you filed PFL and that you're receiving benefits. If you don't, you could end up collecting both by accident, and then EDD sends an overpayment notice. The systems don't always talk to each other the way you'd expect.

0 coins

This is true. I had a family member who didn't realize she needed to report her PFL to the UI side and got an overpayment letter about four months later. It was a whole ordeal.

0 coins

Okay so I need to proactively contact both programs and let them each know what's going on. I hadn't thought about having to manage both at the same time.

0 coins

Exactly. PFL doesn't notify UI automatically on your behalf. You have to close the loop yourself.

0 coins

The thing that caught me completely off guard on my care claim was the Part D. My mom's doctor submitted it online but EDD said they hadn't received it. Turned out the receipt number the doctor's office used was off by a digit. If you're managing a care claim, double check that the doctor has your exact receipt number from when you filed.

0 coins

Mine is a care claim too — I didn't even know the doctor's office could submit Part D online. I just assumed everything was mailed.

0 coins

They can go either way — mail or SDI Online with your receipt number. The safe bet is to give them the number in writing so there's no transcription error.

0 coins

Part D confusion is so common. I had to drop off a printed copy of my receipt number at my dad's specialist's front desk because I didn't trust them to get it right otherwise.

0 coins

To be really clear about the unemployment number question: PFL is not unemployment insurance, and EDD treats them completely differently. PFL comes out of the SDI fund — you see CASDI withheld on your paystubs. Unemployment comes out of a different fund paid by your employer. They look similar because both replace wages, but the eligibility rules, the reasons you file, and the payment rules are all separate. The overlap prohibition is the clearest rule: same days, only one pays.

0 coins

I always thought SDI and PFL were totally different programs. TIL they're actually part of the same system — PFL is under SDI.

0 coins

Right — PFL is part of SDI. Disability Insurance, which covers your own illness or injury, is also under SDI. PFL covers bonding and care. All three are funded by CASDI withholding.

0 coins

That actually clears something up for me. I see CASDI on my paystubs and wondered what was actually covered by it.

0 coins

My denial notice — the DE 2514 — showed up about two weeks after I filed my care claim for my spouse. I didn't understand the reason listed, so I used Claimyr to get an agent on the PFL line. The agent looked at the claim and confirmed EDD hadn't received Part D within the 41-day window, which is why the DE 2514 was issued. The agent said I had the right to appeal within 30 days using the DE 1000A that came with the notice. I filed the appeal the same week.

0 coins

That 41-day window is really strict? Like there's no grace period?

0 coins

The agent didn't mention any grace period. The 41 days from when your leave starts is the deadline to get Part D to EDD, and missing it was exactly why my claim got denied.

0 coins

The 41-day deadline for Part D is one of those things nobody tells you about when you file. I almost missed it because I assumed EDD would remind me.

0 coins

Something I'd add for anyone reading this — if you're taking the care leave intermittently, like two or three days a week, you have to report those work days. EDD sends the DE 2580GF to certify, and if you don't return it your payments stop. I didn't return mine fast enough once and had to phone EDD to sort out which weeks were affected.

0 coins

I'm going in with my father-in-law three days a week usually, so this is my situation exactly. How do I report those days — just through SDI Online?

0 coins

You return the DE 2580GF EDD mails you. It lists the weeks and you mark which days you worked and what you earned. Mail it back and EDD processes from there.

0 coins

Don't sit on the DE 2580GF when it arrives. It has a return date and EDD stops payments if it doesn't come back in time.

0 coins

Real talk — I tried calling EDD at 1-877-238-4373 for two days straight for a question about my bonding claim's proof of relationship document. Never got through. If you need to actually speak with someone, that number is brutal to get through on during peak times.

0 coins

Have you found a better time to try? I need to sort out the unemployment overlap question and I think I need to actually talk to someone.

0 coins

I had slightly more luck calling right when they open at 8 a.m. Pacific, but even that isn't guaranteed.

0 coins

The hold times on PFL calls are genuinely terrible some weeks. I've had the line just drop me after 40 minutes.

0 coins

For the overlap question specifically — I'd also look at this from the overpayment angle. If EDD finds out later that you were receiving both PFL and unemployment for the same days, you could get an overpayment notice from one or both programs. Appealing an overpayment is possible within 30 days, using the DE 1000A, but it's a lot of stress you can avoid by sorting this out now.

0 coins

Can you appeal an overpayment the same way you'd appeal a denial?

0 coins

Same form — the DE 1000A — and the same 30-day window from the date on the notice. The form comes with the overpayment notice.

0 coins

Appealing an overpayment doesn't automatically stop the overpayment demand though. EDD still considers it owed while the appeal is pending.

0 coins

I think the confusion around 'unemployment benefits number' and PFL happens because a lot of people assume they're calling the same line or dealing with the same program. PFL has its own phone line: 1-877-238-4373 for English. Unemployment is a totally separate line. If you call the PFL line about unemployment questions they'll just redirect you, and vice versa.

0 coins

That's actually useful to know. I wasn't sure if there was a single EDD number that handled everything.

0 coins

There isn't. PFL and DI share the SDI line, and unemployment has its own line. Different staff, different systems.

0 coins

Learning this the hard way was not fun. I spent 25 minutes on hold for PFL and when I finally got someone they said they couldn't help me with an unemployment question at all.

0 coins

For anyone also navigating a care claim for a family member who can't do much themselves — make sure your father-in-law or whoever is the care recipient signs Part C. EDD won't process the care claim without it and it has to be mailed, not uploaded online. I almost uploaded mine and someone in another forum thread caught it.

0 coins

I did not know you couldn't upload Part C. I was literally about to scan and upload it through SDI Online. Thank you for catching that.

0 coins

Mailing it is the rule. Same for Part D — the doctor can mail it or submit it through SDI Online with your receipt number, but neither one gets uploaded by you.

0 coins

Uploading Part C or Part D can actually delay the claim. EDD flags it differently from a mailed form.

0 coins

My care claim for my grandmother sat at 'pending' for 11 days before anything moved. The notice I eventually got was the Notice of Computation — the DE 429DF — which showed my potential weekly benefit amount. That's not an approval, just what you'd get if approved. The actual eligibility decision came later.

0 coins

Mine already came — I'm approved and receiving payments. The uncertainty now is just the unemployment overlap issue.

0 coins

If you're already approved and paid, the overlap question is about whether the UI side has been notified. That's the loose end to tie up.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation confuses so many people into thinking their claim is approved. It just shows the potential amount.

0 coins

Fourteen months ago I got laid off and then immediately filed PFL bonding for my daughter who'd just been placed with us through foster care. EDD required a foster care agency letter as the proof of relationship document, and I didn't know that at first — I sent the wrong thing. The placement agreement wasn't the same as the agency letter, apparently.

0 coins

For a foster placement, what's the right document to send?

0 coins

EDD accepted a letter from the foster care agency confirming the placement. That's different from the Adoptive Placement Agreement, which is a different document for adoption. The foster care agency letter is what they want for foster bonding.

0 coins

The list of accepted proof of relationship documents is longer than most people realize — birth certificate, Declaration of Paternity, foster care agency letter, Adoptive Placement Agreement. Each situation has the right one.

0 coins

Proof of relationship on my bonding claim had been received, the agent told me — I used Claimyr to reach someone on the PFL line because the status in SDI Online hadn't updated after I'd mailed the birth certificate eleven days earlier. The agent confirmed EDD had received it and it was matched to my claim, just not yet reflected online. I didn't need to send anything else. That made the difference between mailing a second copy and just waiting.

0 coins

That's the kind of thing that would send me into a panic — no status update and not knowing if EDD got the document.

0 coins

Exactly. Knowing it was received and matched meant I didn't do anything unnecessary. The online status can lag.

0 coins

Status lag in SDI Online is real. What the agent sees is more current than what shows on the claimant's screen.

0 coins

Coming at this from the other direction — I've heard of people stopping their PFL early because they thought their unemployment would kick back in automatically. It doesn't. If you stop PFL and want to restart unemployment benefits, you have to file again or reopen your UI claim. The two programs don't hand off to each other on their own.

0 coins

So if I wanted to switch back to unemployment after the PFL care weeks are done, I'd have to contact UI separately and reopen?

0 coins

That's my understanding, yes. PFL ending doesn't automatically notify UI to restart anything.

0 coins

This is an important point. The programs are siloed from each other on EDD's end — you manage them separately even if you're the same person using both.

0 coins

Just to put a number on the leave itself — PFL gives you up to eight weeks within a 12-month period, and that eight weeks covers bonding, care and military assist together. It's not eight for bonding and a separate eight for care. If you use five weeks on a care claim and then have a baby in the same 12 months, you'd only have three weeks of PFL bonding left in that window.

0 coins

I had no idea all three types shared the same eight-week bank. That's really important to know if someone's situation involves more than one type of leave.

0 coins

Exactly — the eight weeks is the total pool. Use it in one claim, one type, or spread across types, as long as it's within the 12-month period.

0 coins

A lot of people learn about the shared pool too late. Someone using all eight for care and then bonding with a new child in the same window ends up with nothing left for bonding.

0 coins

For the PFL phone line, the official number is 1-877-238-4373 and they're available Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Pacific. If you need Spanish, the separate number is 1-877-379-3819. Those are the only numbers EDD lists for PFL — anything else floating around online is wrong.

0 coins

Good to have both numbers confirmed. I've seen a few different numbers posted in other forums and wasn't sure which was right.

0 coins

The ones on edd.ca.gov are the ones to trust. If you press 3 on the English line it connects you to free interpreter services in other languages too.

0 coins

Bookmarking those numbers. I've dialed wrong numbers before and wasted time before realizing.

0 coins

EDD does not pay PFL for the same days as disability either, worth mentioning. If a birth mother is on a pregnancy disability claim, PFL bonding starts after that ends — they don't overlap. The mother gets the DE 2501FP form to transition from disability to PFL bonding. Each program pays separately for its own period.

0 coins

My situation is a care claim, not a birth, so the disability overlap doesn't apply to me — but it's good to understand the full picture.

0 coins

Right, your care claim is clean on that front. The pregnancy-to-bonding transition is its own path and it's separate from what you're dealing with.

0 coins

The DE 2501FP is a thing a lot of new moms don't know exists. The hospital or EDD mails it, but sometimes people miss it and lose bonding weeks because they don't file in time.

0 coins

One more thing on the overpayment risk — if EDD finds the overlap and issues an overpayment notice, you have 30 days from that notice to appeal using the DE 1000A. Missing the appeal window means the overpayment stands. So if any notice arrives, read it immediately and don't set it aside.

0 coins

I keep all my EDD mail now specifically because of things like this. The 30-day window is not long when you're managing everything else.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD notices have dates on them and the clock starts from that date. File the appeal before the 30 days are up regardless of what else is going on.

0 coins

If you disagree with any EDD decision, appeal first and work out the details after. Missing the window to appeal is the worst outcome.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure