Back to California Disability

StarSailor}

Will unemployment disqualification affect my SDI disability claim in California?

So I got hit with an unemployment disqualification a few months back, long story involving a dispute with my last employer, and now I'm actually out on disability through EDD. Back went out completely, can't lift anything, doc has me off work for at least six weeks. Filed the SDI claim and the medical cert went in fine. But now I'm sitting here wondering if that old unemployment disqualification is going to follow me into my disability claim and mess things up. Anyone know if the two are even connected? I don't want to get denied on the SDI side because of something that happened with unemployment. Already stressed enough anyway.

The Notice of Computation came through on my own claim about ten days after my doctor submitted the certification, and I had the same worry about a prior unemployment situation. Went back and forth on it for days. I ended up phoning EDD through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the regular line just rang into nothing every morning I tried. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the weekly benefit amount on my Notice of Computation, then explained that DI eligibility runs on its own track entirely. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The notice showed my potential weekly amount based on my highest-earning quarter, and the agent said nothing on the unemployment side carried over to affect that figure. Gave me a lot of peace of mind about where things stood.

0 coins

The 'regular line rang into nothing' part I believe, but the rest reads like something a company paid you to write. What was the actual point of calling if the notice already showed the amount?

0 coins

I had the same doubt at first, to be honest. Tried Claimyr myself after three weeks of getting nowhere with the line. The agent I reached confirmed my waiting period dates, the seven non-payable days at the start of my claim, and that my payable benefits began on day eight. That matched what EDD's own FAQ says. Nobody paid me to say that.

0 coins

Fair enough. I'll take that at face value. Still going to try the regular line a few more times before I go that route.

0 coins

The notice shows the potential amount but it doesn't tell you which quarter they used or whether the wages matched what you expected. That's what I needed confirmed, and the agent went through it with me.

0 coins

Unemployment disqualification and SDI are two separate programs. Getting cut off from one doesn't touch the other. Your back injury is what matters for the disability claim, not whatever happened with your former employer.

0 coins

That's what I was hoping to hear. So EDD doesn't cross-reference the two when they look at the SDI claim?

0 coins

They're separate systems. DI runs on wages and a medical certification. Your employer dispute isn't part of that.

0 coins

But wait, what if the disqualification was because of misconduct? Does that change anything on the SDI side?

0 coins

The reason for a UI disqualification doesn't factor into DI eligibility. DI is based on whether you have enough wages subject to SDI in the base period and whether a licensed provider certifies you can't do your regular work. The nature of your separation from the employer isn't a criterion EDD uses for the disability claim.

0 coins

EDD runs both programs and I always assumed they talk to each other but every agent I ever reached said they're handled completely independently. Which, honestly, tracks because even within EDD the left hand never seems to know what the right hand is doing.

0 coins

Accurate summary of the whole organization.

0 coins

That independence cuts in your favor here though. Your SDI claim stands on its own.

0 coins

I'm in a somewhat similar spot and this thread is the first place I've seen it addressed directly. Can I ask something: does the waiting period for SDI count even if you were technically still getting unemployment when you first got hurt? I confused myself reading about this.

0 coins

You can't collect unemployment and disability for the same days, that's EDD's own rule. If you were on UI and then became unable to work, the DI claim would start from when you became disabled and couldn't work anymore.

0 coins

So the seven-day waiting period would run from the disability start date, not from whenever unemployment ended?

0 coins

The waiting period is the first seven days of the DI claim, counted from the disability start date. The first payable day is day eight. It's not processing time, it's just a non-payable period that every new claim has at the front of it.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. I was mixing up the waiting period with how long it takes EDD to process things.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost this exact thing last year, UI disqualification and then a surgery right after, and her SDI came through with no problem at all. She said EDD never even mentioned the unemployment side when they were processing the disability.

0 coins

Good to know it played out that way.

0 coins

Makes sense given they're separate programs, but it's always reassuring to hear it actually worked out in practice.

0 coins

yeah the sdi and ui people dont even sit in the same building i think, definitely not the same system, your injury claim should be totally fine

0 coins

Whether they share a building is beside the point, but the separate systems part is right.

0 coins

Which weeks were paid on my claim got completely confusing after I went back part-time and I couldn't figure out which ones EDD had actually processed. I tried the disability line maybe a dozen times over two weeks, different mornings, and either got a busy signal or a recording. Eventually tried Claimyr and got an agent on the line. She went through my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been paid and which were still pending. Helped me figure out I hadn't missed reporting anything, the pending ones just hadn't cleared yet.

0 coins

When you got through, did you have your claim ID ready or just your Social Security number?

0 coins

Claim ID, Social, and the dates I was asking about. The agent pulled everything up pretty quickly once I had those in front of me.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. four mornings. nothing.

0 coins

To answer the original question directly: no, an unemployment disqualification doesn't disqualify you from SDI. The two programs have different eligibility criteria. DI cares about your wage history in the base period and whether a licensed provider certifies the disability. It doesn't care why you left your last job.

0 coins

Genuinely relieved to read this spelled out so clearly. My doc already submitted everything so now I just wait.

0 coins

Exactly. Once the medical certification is in and the claim is processing, you're on EDD's timeline. Hang in there.

0 coins

Both programs are under EDD but they're administered separately and eligibility criteria don't overlap. The SDI wage check runs off the base period quarters, not anything related to how or why employment ended.

0 coins

Does it matter which employer the wages came from? Like, can the wages from the job where I had the dispute still count toward the SDI base period?

0 coins

Wages subject to SDI deductions count toward the base period regardless of how that employment ended. The CASDI deduction you paid in is what matters, not the circumstances of the separation.

0 coins

That's a huge relief. I definitely had that deduction coming out of every check.

0 coins

You paid into SDI through that CASDI line on your paystub. That's your contribution. A UI disqualification doesn't claw that back.

0 coins

Never thought of it that way but that's a clean way to put it.

0 coins

Pay in, get hurt, file. That's the whole deal.

0 coins

wait so you CAN be collecting unemployment and then switch over to disability if you get hurt? i always thought you had to pick one when you apply and stick with it

0 coins

You can file for DI when you become unable to work, even if you were previously on UI. You just can't be paid by both for the same days. EDD's own rule is that you can't receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same period.

0 coins

oh okay so they don't cancel each other out forever just cant overlap. that makes more sense lol

0 coins

I was confused about this too, glad someone asked.

0 coins

There's a note in EDD's materials that unemployment requires you to be able and available for work every week you claim it. So once you're out on a disability, you don't meet that test anyway, which is why the transition to DI makes sense.

0 coins

EDD requiring you to be able to work while also being the program that pays you when you can't. The logic is impeccable.

0 coins

Different programs, different rules. Frustrating from a user perspective but that's the design.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came back needed on my claim after my doctor said I needed more time, and I had no idea how to get it submitted fast. Tried Claimyr and an agent picked up. She confirmed EDD had sent the extension form with my final payment notice and that my provider needed to submit it through SDI Online.

0 coins

I want to ask about my own extension situation, my doctor thinks I need more time but I haven't gotten any form yet. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your claim ID, your provider's name and their contact info, and the date your current certification period ends. The agent will look up which form is needed and what's already in the system.

0 coins

Extensions always make me nervous, good to know there's a way to actually get a person on the line to sort it out.

0 coins

Unemployment status and disability are assessed independently by EDD. Your medical certification and wage history are what drive the SDI decision. I've seen patients tie themselves in knots worrying about this.

0 coins

Ha, I've definitely been tying myself in knots. Doc said the same thing, just focus on resting.

0 coins

Rest and let the claim process. That's the job right now.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation showed up in SDI Online and I was so relieved I took a photo of it! That thing is not an approval though, just so everyone knows, it just shows the potential weekly amount.

0 coins

Correct, and it's worth reading carefully because it shows the base period quarters they used. If anything looks off you'd want to flag it early.

0 coins

Mine looked right but I didn't even know to check the quarters until someone told me. Good point!

0 coins

Where do you even find the base period details? Is it on the notice itself or do you have to look in SDI Online?

0 coins

It's on the Notice of Computation. The DE 429D will show the period and the wages used to calculate the amount.

0 coins

Got a Notice of Determination on a prior claim once. Filed the appeal within the 30-day window and sent the DE 1000A with a written explanation. Took a while but it got sorted.

0 coins

That form is the appeal form, right? Just want to make sure I know it in case I ever need it.

0 coins

DE 1000A is the appeal form, yes. It's on the notice itself if EDD sends one. 30 days from the date on the notice.

0 coins

I did not know there was a specific form for that. Filing that away in case.

0 coins

my buddy was on ui then hurt his wrist and filed sdi and they just processed it normally nobody asked about the ui thing at all

0 coins

That tracks with how the programs work. The SDI side processes based on what's in front of them, not history from a separate program.

0 coins

Had a client in my chair last week going through almost this exact worry. I told her what I knew but I didn't know enough to really help. Sending her to this thread.

0 coins

Between the people here who've actually gone through it and the ones who actually know the rules, pretty solid answers in this thread.

0 coins

For anyone checking base period wages: the base period looks at a 12-month stretch of four quarters, and the weekly benefit estimate comes from the highest-paid quarter in that window. The actual amount is what the Notice of Computation says, not what the EDD calculator estimates. Use the calculator to get a ballpark but wait for the notice for the real number.

0 coins

Is the calculator on EDD's main site or somewhere specific in SDI Online?

0 coins

It's on EDD's site, under disability benefits. You don't need to log in to use it, just enter your quarterly wages.

0 coins

I used it before filing and it was pretty close to what the notice ended up showing. Good to know the notice is the final word on it though.

0 coins

To anyone still worried about the unemployment-to-disability question: the moment you became unable to do your regular work is when DI kicks in. That's the line. What was happening on the UI side before that is a separate story EDD isn't going to bring into the disability file.

0 coins

Yep. Clean cut between the two programs at that point.

0 coins

And frankly the two sides of EDD are barely talking to each other anyway, so it's not like someone's cross-referencing your files in real time.

0 coins

been out six weeks with a shoulder thing and nobody mentioned anything about my earlier ui issue when the sdi came through. pretty smooth actually.

0 coins

Six weeks in and still going, that's good to know. How's the claim holding up payment-wise?

0 coins

payments hitting fine. waiting on the DE 2593 questionnaire they send around ten weeks. not looking forward to that form.

0 coins

Fill that one out and return it within 20 days or the benefits can pause. It's the continued eligibility check EDD sends around the ten-week mark.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure