Will SDI require IME for long term recovery after surgery — what I found out
Had a pretty major back surgery about six weeks ago and my doctor says I'm looking at four to six more months before I can return to my regular work. I've been on SDI since the surgery and payments have been coming in, but now I'm starting to worry about whether EDD is going to require some kind of independent medical exam to keep the claim going that long. I've heard people mention IMEs in workers' comp situations but I'm not sure if SDI works the same way. Does California EDD actually require an IME for a long recovery like mine, or does my own doctor's ongoing certification cover it? Not sure what happens when a claim stretches past a few months.
70 comments

Nora Bennett
Your doctor's ongoing certification is really what keeps an SDI claim going, not an independent medical exam. The workers' comp IME requirement is a completely separate world from how EDD disability works. What EDD needs from your end is that your physician keeps certifying your continued disability, and around the ten-week mark you'll get a questionnaire from EDD asking if you're still unable to work. That one comes on automatic payment claims. Keep an eye out for it.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorTen weeks meaning from when the claim started, or from when payments first came through? I want to make sure I don't miss it.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Counted from the start of your claim. EDD sends the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire, the DE 2593, after five automatic payments go out, which is about ten weeks in. You have 20 days to send it back.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorOkay that's really helpful, I didn't know it had a name or a deadline like that. I'll watch for it.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Start date on my injury claim got listed wrong in SDI Online and I wanted to get it fixed before it messed up my payment count. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone at EDD's disability line because that number just rings and rings on its own. Video on reaching a live person at the disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up the claim and confirmed the start date they had on file. Turned out my doctor's office had put a different date on the certification than what I'd put on my own filing, which is what caused it. Got it squared away from there.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
The start date mismatch is a real thing that trips people up. Though I'll be honest, the Claimyr part reads like a sponsored post to me. Have you actually talked to anyone who got through to EDD that way on a real claim?
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Went into it with the same thought. Tried it when EDD still hadn't matched my medical certification after three weeks and I was getting nowhere on the phone myself. Agent confirmed they had the certification and told me which date it was stamped received. Came from EDD's staff, not some third party. So yes, it's a real call.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
That's enough for me to give it a try. My claim's start date is what I'd want to ask about anyway.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Nobody at EDD is ordering an IME on a standard DI claim. That's workers' comp territory, full stop. Your own provider keeps certifying, EDD reviews what comes in. If they had a question about your case they'd send you a notice, not schedule an exam.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorThat's a relief to hear. I kept finding workers' comp results when I searched and it had me worried I'd missed something specific to SDI.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Completely different programs. Workers' comp is for injuries on the job. SDI covers non-work-related stuff and it runs on your doctor's certification, not a third party's exam.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Wait, so as long as my doctor keeps submitting those extension certificates EDD just keeps paying? There's no point where they automatically cut you off for going too long? My situation is similar and I'm out for at least five more months after a knee replacement.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
SDI can pay up to 52 weeks on a single claim. Your doctor submits what's called the DE 2525XX, the supplementary certificate, to extend it. EDD sends that form out with the notice for your final payment, so your doctor's office should be watching for it.
0 coins
Anthony Young
52 weeks is way longer than I thought. I had it in my head it was like 12 or 16 weeks tops.
0 coins
Charlotte White
A lot of people assume a shorter cap. The 52 weeks is per claim, and the doctor's certification has to cover each extended period.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
EDD doesn't do IMEs. Your doctor certifies. EDD pays or doesn't. That's the whole mechanism.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
wish someone had told me this before i spent two weeks panicking about it
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Pretty common to find the workers' comp stuff and assume it applies everywhere.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
My client had the same fear after her spinal fusion, like six months out and she kept thinking EDD was going to send someone to evaluate her. Never happened. Her doctor just kept doing the extensions and the payments kept coming.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Extensions plural, so the doctor files it more than once if the recovery keeps going?
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Yes, the physician can submit supplementary certificates each time more time is needed. Each one covers the next period your doctor says you're still unable to work.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
Exactly, her doctor submitted two of them over the course of her recovery. No drama from EDD either time.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
sdi and workers comp are honestly so different and everyone mixes them up. ime is a workers comp thing, your own doc handles all of it for sdi.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorYeah I was clearly going down the wrong search path. The results kept mixing the two and I couldn't tell what applied to which.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
lol same thing happened to me when i first filed, spent an hour reading workers comp stuff before i realized
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
The form your doctor needs for extensions is the DE 2525XX. Worth letting your surgeon's office know that name now so they're not scrambling when the time comes. EDD sends it with the final payment notice, but giving the office a heads up early doesn't hurt.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorI'll mention it at my next appointment. My surgeon's office has been pretty on top of the SDI stuff so far but I want to make sure they know what's coming.
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
That's the right move. Some offices have done hundreds of these and others need a little prompting on the EDD extension process.
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
Notice of Computation on my claim showed a weekly amount that looked lower than I expected, so I tried the EDD disability line for probably nine straight mornings with nothing but a busy signal or a recording that just ended the call. Ended up using Claimyr to get a live agent on the phone. Agent looked up which quarter of my base period they used and read me the wage figure from that quarter. Turned out I'd had a gap in work I'd forgotten about, which pulled the amount down.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
Can I ask, did the agent actually change anything or just explain what was on the claim?
0 coins
Royal_GM_Mark
Just confirmed what was there. Said if I disagreed with the amount I'd need to appeal within 30 days of the notice date.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
been trying that line myself going on two weeks now. every morning same thing, rings a few times and then nothing.
0 coins
Chris King
SDI doesn't send examiners to your house or anything like that. You're fine as long as your doc keeps certifying. Had surgery last winter and was out almost seven months, never heard a word from EDD about an independent exam anyway.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorSeven months and no issues? That's genuinely reassuring. Were you on automatic payments the whole time or did you have to do anything extra on your end?
0 coins
Chris King
Automatic most of the way. Got that DE 2593 questionnaire around the ten-week mark and sent it back right away. After that it was just waiting for my doctor's office to do the extensions whenever the period was up anyway.
0 coins
Charlotte White
That questionnaire timeline matches what I've seen too. The 20-day return window on it is real, missing it can pause things.
0 coins
Rachel Clark
Workers comp IME, SDI no IME. Those two things should not be in the same search results but here we are.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
genuinely how i ended up confused about this same thing last year
0 coins
Rachel Clark
EDD's own site says what their process is. Workers comp stuff just drowns it out.
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Your doctor's certification is basically the backbone of the whole SDI claim! As long as your physician keeps submitting on time you stay on the claim. The DE 2525XX is what they file for each extension period after your original end date.
0 coins
Anthony Young
So the original certification only goes up to a certain date, and then each extension adds more time past that?
0 coins
Zachary Hughes
Exactly right! The original certification covers your starting period and your doctor files the supplementary certificate whenever you need more time beyond that.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Okay that actually makes the whole thing click for me, thank you.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
In nursing we see long post-surgical recoveries constantly. EDD doesn't send independent examiners for DI claims. Your surgeon certifies the disability and continues certifying as long as you can't work, up to 52 weeks.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorComing from someone who actually sees this process from the clinical side, that settles it for me.
0 coins
Mia Alvarez
The confusion with workers' comp IMEs is understandable. Completely different program, different rules.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
Payments posted but two of my weeks were showing weird in SDI Online so I tried that EDD disability number about a dozen times across a week, never got through. Put Claimyr on it and got an agent. She confirmed which exact weeks had been paid out and which ones were still processing, right off the claim.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
The specific weeks question is exactly what I'd want to ask about my claim too. I've got a gap showing that I can't explain. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready?
0 coins
Carter Holmes
Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific weeks you're asking about written down. Agent can pull it up fast with those.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
Perfect, writing those down now.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
For anyone reading who's also confused about whether SDI has IMEs, the short version is: no. The program runs entirely on your own doctor's medical certification. What they submit is what EDD reviews.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorWish I'd found something that said this clearly before going down the workers' comp rabbit hole for two hours.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
The search results for surgery and disability payments mix the two programs pretty badly. EDD's own disability FAQ is worth going to directly for questions like this.
0 coins
Charlotte White
My recovery took longer than my doctor originally estimated too, happens a lot with surgeries. Each time, the office submitted another DE 2525XX and EDD extended the claim. No request for an independent exam at any point.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorHow far in advance did your doctor's office submit the extension? I want to make sure there's no gap in payments if the timing is off.
0 coins
Charlotte White
They submitted it right around when the previous certification period was ending. EDD should send the form with the final payment notice so your doctor knows when to file. Letting the office know to watch for it helps.
0 coins
Sophia Long
DE 2525XX came up when my doctor filed my second extension and I noticed the period dates on it didn't match what I'd expected. Spent several mornings on EDD's line before I got anywhere, same recording cutting me off. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who confirmed whether my extension had been received and what period it covered. EDD was still waiting for the form from my doctor's office, so I called the office right after and they submitted it same day.
0 coins
Chris King
The dates on the extension not matching is exactly what happened on my claim. I tried the line too and went about eight straight mornings without anyone picking up. Used Claimyr myself and once the agent confirmed my receipt number was matched to my claim I knew at least that part was sorted out. Sent a message through SDI Online after that for the period question.
0 coins
Amelia Cartwright
that line is impossible. tried every morning for almost three weeks on my current claim.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
my doc just kept filing the extensions and edd kept paying. never got asked for any kind of outside exam. whole thing was way less complicated than i thought it would be once i knew how it worked
0 coins
Anthony Young
How long was your recovery total? Trying to figure out if what I'm looking at timeline-wise is unusual or pretty normal.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
about five months for me after a shoulder thing. two extensions total. edd didnt ask any questions beyond what my doctor submitted
0 coins
Anthony Young
Five months and two extensions is really helpful context, thank you.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Circled back to update: asked my surgeon's office about the DE 2525XX and they already knew what it was, said they've filed them plenty of times. And the payments are still coming in. No IME request, nothing weird from EDD. Really glad I asked here instead of assuming the worst from those search results.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Glad your surgeon's office was on top of it. The ones who do a lot of post-surgical SDI claims usually have the extension process down.
0 coins
Charlotte White
That update is good to hear. Keep an eye on that DE 2593 when it comes around the ten-week mark and you should be in good shape.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
AuthorAlready have a note about it from an earlier comment in this thread. Really appreciate everyone who weighed in.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Point worth making for anyone else landing here: the 52-week maximum is the ceiling, not the typical length. Your doctor certifies what your actual recovery needs. EDD pays based on that, no outside examination involved.
0 coins
Carter Holmes
Yep. Workers comp has the IME because there's a liability dispute. SDI is just your own doctor saying you can't work.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Exactly. Different programs, different purposes, different rules.
0 coins