Back to California Disability

Zainab Ahmed

When to apply for SDI before scheduled surgery integrated with employer leave

So my back surgery got scheduled for three weeks out and HR already knows, we've got a leave of absence lined up through work. What I can't figure out is the SDI piece. Do I file the disability claim now, or do I wait until after the surgery? My surgeon's office said they'll handle the medical certification but I don't know if they mean they'll submit it in SDI Online or just give me a paper form. Also my HR person mentioned something about the company having their own short-term disability that's supposed to coordinate with SDI but she was vague about the details. I've been reading around and it sounds like you can't file too early but also can't wait too long, so when exactly is the right window? And does the employer leave thing change the timing at all?

Filing timing is the piece a lot of people miss before a planned surgery. You can't file until nine days after your disability actually starts, so the surgery date is usually your start date. You have up to 49 days from that date to file and also for your surgeon to get the medical certification in. Most people with a scheduled procedure file around day nine, once they know the surgery happened and recovery has begun.

0 coins

So I'm reading that right, the nine days is after the surgery, not before? I kept thinking I needed to file in advance because of the employer leave timing.

0 coins

Correct. The disability start date is when you're actually unable to work, which for surgery is usually the day of the procedure. Nine days out from that is when you can file. Your employer leave running alongside it doesn't move that window.

0 coins

Does the nine-day thing mean there's nine days you don't get paid, or is it just when you're allowed to file? I'm confused about whether those are the same thing.

0 coins

Those are two different things. The first seven days of a new claim are an unpaid waiting period, that's the rule. The nine days is just the earliest you can file. You can get paid starting on day eight, once the claim is processed.

0 coins

The employer integration part is worth asking HR to spell out in writing before your surgery. Some employers pay something during the SDI waiting period or top up the weekly benefit, but how that works depends entirely on their own plan. EDD handles the SDI piece on their end regardless of what the employer pays.

0 coins

HR mentioned a 'coordination of benefits' thing but couldn't tell me the actual numbers. I'll push for the written policy before my surgery date.

0 coins

My job had the same thing and nobody explained it until I was already two weeks post-surgery trying to figure out why the amounts were different. Get it in writing before you go in, seriously.

0 coins

The SDI benefit itself is based on your wages from a base period about five to eighteen months before the claim starts. The Notice of Computation EDD sends will show your estimated weekly amount. What your employer adds on top is entirely separate from what EDD calculates.

0 coins

Receipt number from SDI Online was the thing I didn't know mattered until it caused me a problem. Filed my claim after my knee surgery, got a receipt number, didn't tell my doctor's office what it was. They submitted the certification a week later and it didn't match up. Had to phone EDD to sort it out. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the line because I couldn't get through on my own. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up the claim and confirmed the certification was in the system but filed under the wrong receipt number. Took a few days to clear but it did get sorted.

0 coins

My claim's been pending twelve days and I still can't tell if the medical certification even made it in. I've redialed that number every morning this week and hit a recording every single time. Going to try Claimyr for it. What do I need to have in front of me when I do?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the receipt number you got when you filed. The agent can pull the claim and tell you exactly what's been received and what's still missing.

0 coins

I didn't realize the receipt number was something I had to pass along to the surgeon. That would have been a problem for me too. Saving that before I even file.

0 coins

The 49-day deadline covers both things: your filing and your provider's medical certification. Both have to happen within 49 days of when your disability starts. Miss that window and EDD can disqualify the claim entirely. For a scheduled surgery where you know the date, there's no reason not to get Part A filed on day nine and hand the receipt number to your surgeon's office the same day.

0 coins

What counts as day one, the surgery day itself or the day after? I keep second-guessing this and I don't want to file wrong.

0 coins

The surgery date is day one of your disability period. Nine days after that is when you can file. So if your surgery is a Monday, the following Tuesday is day nine.

0 coins

And the surgeon's office has until day 49 from the surgery to submit? Not 49 days from when I file?

0 coins

Both deadlines run from the disability start date, not from when you file. So yes, your provider has 49 days from the surgery date to get the certification in, same clock you're on.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for SDI is basically decorative at this point. Called Monday through Thursday last week, hung up on twice, recording the other two days. If you have something time-sensitive before your surgery, budget a lot of mornings for it.

0 coins

Twelve days of the same. Some mornings I didn't even get the recording, it just dropped.

0 coins

This is what I was worried about. If something goes wrong with my claim after surgery I won't be in great shape to spend mornings redialing.

0 coins

lol the recording that ends the call is my villain origin story with EDD. I've had claims process fine with zero phone contact but the one time I actually needed to ask something it was three weeks of nothing.

0 coins

Your surgeon's office submitting through SDI Online is the faster option by a lot. When mine faxed a paper form it sat for over a week before anything moved. When my dentist's office used SDI Online for a different claim it showed up fast. Worth asking your surgeon's office which method they use before you go in.

0 coins

I'll ask them specifically about SDI Online vs. paper. Good to know the difference matters that much.

0 coins

The provider submits through SDI Online using the receipt number the claimant provides. If your surgeon's office says they'll mail Part B of the paper form, that's also valid, but as the previous commenter said, online tends to move faster.

0 coins

My provider mailed it and it took almost two weeks to show as received. Online is definitely faster.

0 coins

Does the SDI waiting period overlap with the employer leave or do you end up waiting twice? Like if my company covers the first week does the SDI waiting period still run at the same time?

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period runs from your disability start date regardless of what your employer pays during it. EDD's waiting period is about the SDI clock, not whether you have income from another source those days. They run at the same time.

0 coins

Okay that's actually a relief. I thought I might lose an extra week somewhere in there.

0 coins

Worth double-checking your employer's plan language too, some plans count EDD's waiting period days differently when calculating their own payout. HR can tell you how theirs works.

0 coins

Payment on my SDI claim after shoulder surgery came out different than what the Notice of Computation showed and I couldn't figure out why. Tried the disability line for a week straight, nothing. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr. She looked at the claim and said the first payment covered only part of a week because of where my waiting period fell, so the first check was smaller than the weekly amount. After that the payments matched the notice.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation showed a weekly amount but my first deposit was lower too. Used Claimyr for a different claim question and while I had the agent I asked about it. She confirmed the same thing, the waiting period end date cut into my first payable week so it was a partial. After that call I stopped worrying and the second payment was the full amount.

0 coins

wait so the first payment is almost always going to be less than what the notice says? nobody told me that before i filed

0 coins

Not always, it depends on where in the week your waiting period ends. If the period ends mid-week you get paid for fewer days that first time. The Notice of Computation shows the full weekly amount for complete weeks after that.

0 coins

spent two hours trying that line last week. good to know the first payment thing is normal and not a problem.

0 coins

My surgery is also scheduled and my company's plan is confusing me in the same way. HR said SDI and the company plan 'integrate' but I'm not sure if that means EDD pays me and the company tops it up, or the company pays and EDD pays nothing because I'm already covered. I think I might be getting the two mixed up.

0 coins

Whether your employer has a Voluntary Plan through EDD or just a separate benefit that runs alongside SDI, those are two different setups and HR really is the one to clarify which yours is. EDD's standard SDI is what most employees get through the CASDI deduction on their paystub. If you've been paying that deduction you likely have access to standard SDI regardless of what the employer plan does.

0 coins

I do see CASDI on my paystubs so at least I know I've been paying into it. I'll ask HR specifically whether it's a Voluntary Plan or just a top-up arrangement.

0 coins

Same confusion I had. 'Integration' and 'coordination' seem to mean different things depending on who's saying it. Getting the written policy from HR before surgery is now on my actual to-do list.

0 coins

For the base period question that comes up around planned surgeries: the weekly benefit is based on wages from roughly five to eighteen months before your claim start date, highest-paid quarter of the base period. If your surgery is scheduled a few weeks out that shouldn't change which quarter they use, but if you're wondering what your weekly amount might be you can run it on the wage calculator on EDD's site before you file.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about the base period. My hours were reduced for a few months earlier this year for unrelated reasons. Worth checking the calculator before I assume what the weekly amount will be.

0 coins

Exactly. If your hours were cut during the period EDD pulls from your weekly amount could be lower than you expect. The calculator on EDD's site gives you the estimate before the actual Notice of Computation arrives.

0 coins

Is the calculator on the main EDD site or do you have to log into SDI Online to use it?

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov, no login needed. Search for the DI benefit payment calculator.

0 coins

Surgeon's office told me they'd 'handle everything' and I believed them. They submitted the paper form but put the wrong claim ID on it. Spent three weeks trying to reach someone at EDD while recovering from abdominal surgery. Not the time you want an administrative problem. Verify with the office that they have your receipt number before you go in for the procedure.

0 coins

This is such a real thing. 'We'll take care of it' from a doctor's office and 'we'll take care of it' from EDD mean completely different things timeline-wise.

0 coins

Noted. I'm going to write the receipt number down on something physical and hand it to the office myself, not just assume they'll pull it.

0 coins

Print out the SDI Online confirmation page that shows the receipt number and bring a copy to your pre-op appointment. That's what I'd do over again.

0 coins

Employer leave and SDI running at the same time doesn't mean they're talking to each other. HR handles the leave side, EDD handles the SDI side. Neither one automatically updates the other. File with EDD on your own timeline, don't assume the employer leave triggers anything.

0 coins

Okay that clears something up. I think I was imagining they were linked because HR made it sound like a package deal.

0 coins

They feel linked because they cover the same absence period, but the filing, the forms, the approval, all of that is completely separate. Missing EDD's deadline because you thought the employer handled it is a problem people run into.

0 coins

HR told me the same thing that made it sound automatic. Filed on my own after reading threads like this one and it was a good thing I did.

0 coins

After the surgery, keeping track of the 49-day window for the medical certification is easier than it sounds because your surgeon will want a follow-up appointment anyway. That visit is a natural time to remind them to submit the certification if they haven't already.

0 coins

Good practical angle. I'll put a reminder on my phone for a week after the surgery to check SDI Online and see if the certification shows as received.

0 coins

Checking SDI Online is the right move. If two weeks pass after the surgery and there's nothing showing from your provider, that's the moment to contact the office and ask them to confirm it was submitted with your receipt number.

0 coins

DE 2593 is worth knowing about now even though it comes later. After ten weeks on the claim, EDD mails a Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire. You have twenty days to return it or benefits can stop. After back surgery mine arrived while I was still in a lot of pain and the return window snuck up on me. Used Claimyr to reach a disability agent after I'd missed it by a few days, nervous the whole time. Agent checked the account and said the form had come in and was processing, so I hadn't lost anything. Keep an eye out for it around week ten.

0 coins

Ten weeks out feels far from surgery prep but I've been trying that disability line for days on something much smaller and can't get a person. How is the line actually going to work for something time-sensitive like a missed form deadline?

0 coins

Tried the line myself every day for a week before using Claimyr. Got a live EDD agent within the morning I tried it. She could see the form status right on the account, no guessing.

0 coins

For anyone who is on automatic payment rather than the two-week DE 2500A, the DE 2593 is the thing to watch for around the ten-week mark. Twenty days to return it is the rule. If it doesn't come and you're past week ten, contact EDD and ask about it.

0 coins

Good to know that form exists. I would have had no idea something needed to come back to EDD mid-claim.

0 coins

the DE 2593 caught me off guard too. ten weeks feels fine until it doesn't.

0 coins

my coworker said you can apply for sdi before surgery because the doctor signs off ahead of time, like a pre-approval. is that actually how it works

0 coins

Filing before the disability starts isn't how SDI works. The claim starts when you're actually unable to do your job, usually the surgery date. Nine days after that is the earliest you can file. The medical certification from your provider comes in after, confirming the condition and the period you can't work.

0 coins

ok so your coworker was just wrong about that part. thanks

0 coins

The confusion probably comes from the provider needing to certify it after the fact, not in advance. Some providers ask the patient to file first, then they submit their part. The order is you file, you give the receipt number to your provider, they submit the certification.

0 coins

What happens if the surgery gets rescheduled after you've already filed? Does the claim just follow the new date or does something need to be corrected?

0 coins

If you haven't filed yet there's nothing to correct since the claim starts on the actual disability date anyway. If the surgery moves before you file, your start date just moves with it. If somehow a claim was already filed with the wrong start date you'd want to contact EDD to have it corrected before the medical certification goes in.

0 coins

This is actually a real possibility for me since my surgery date was moved once already. Good to know to hold off on filing until the surgery actually happens.

0 coins

That makes sense! I was imagining a scenario where you file, then the surgery gets pushed two weeks, and EDD thinks you're already disabled when you're not.

0 coins

Notice of Determination is the letter to watch for if EDD doesn't approve the claim. It comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, and the appeal window is 30 days from the date on the notice. Had surgery last spring and my claim got flagged for a reason I didn't understand. Filed with Claimyr to get a live agent and ask what the Notice of Determination actually meant. Agent looked at the claim and said EDD was waiting on the medical certification from my provider, that it hadn't been received yet under my claim ID. I went to the surgeon's office that afternoon with my receipt number and they resubmitted it. The appeal form would have been the wrong move, the certification was just the missing piece.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned and I'm not sure what it does.

0 coins

You put in your number and it handles being on hold with EDD for you. When an agent picks up, your phone rings and you're talking to them directly.

0 coins

Oh that's really useful actually. My claim has a pending extension and I've been dreading calling EDD about it. I'd want to ask whether the DE 2525XX from my provider came in correctly.

0 coins

Fourteen days of mornings I haven't gotten a live person on that line. Not one.

0 coins

PFL comes up a lot with pregnancy leaves and I want to flag it since people mix it up: if your surgery is for something like a birth or maternity situation, the SDI part covers the disability period and bonding after that is Paid Family Leave, which is a completely separate claim. For a regular scheduled surgery like a back or knee procedure, it's just SDI the whole time.

0 coins

I've been confusing those two programs the whole time I've been researching. PFL is for bonding and caring for family, SDI is for your own medical condition. Is that the right way to think about it?

0 coins

That's exactly right. SDI is when you can't work because of your own illness, injury, pregnancy or surgery. Paid Family Leave is when you need time to bond with a new child or care for a seriously ill family member. They're funded the same way through your CASDI paycheck deduction but they're separate claims.

0 coins

And PFL doesn't have the seven-day waiting period that SDI has. No lost first week on the bonding side.

0 coins

One more thing on the receipt number since it came up earlier: when you log into SDI Online through myEDD and file Part A, write that number down before you close the browser. The confirmation page shows it and it's not always easy to find again after. That number is what your surgeon's office needs to match the certification to your claim.

0 coins

I'm going to screenshot that page as soon as I file and send it straight to the surgeon's office email. No more hoping the office has the right number.

0 coins

That works. Some offices also want it on a printed form, so having it in writing both ways covers you.

0 coins

Does the receipt number change if you have to refile for any reason? Or is it the same for the life of the claim?

0 coins

Each time you file a new claim or amendment in SDI Online a new receipt number is generated. If you refile you'd need to give the new number to your provider.

0 coins

been dealing with a pending claim for eleven days now. doctor submitted but nothing updated. not sure if the system is slow or something is wrong.

0 coins

Eleven days with no update after the certification went in is worth following up on. EDD aims to have something to you within 14 days of receiving a completed claim. If day 14 passes without a Notice of Computation or any update, contact EDD and ask them to confirm both parts of the claim were received.

0 coins

alright ill try to reach them around day 14 if nothing changes

0 coins

Use the Request Claim Update feature in SDI Online first. It's under your claim ID and you can send a written question directly. Sometimes faster than waiting to get someone on the phone.

0 coins

The employer coordination stuff is not EDD's concern and EDD won't have any answers about it. They handle the SDI side. What your employer does on top of or instead of that is your HR department's business entirely. Keep those two conversations completely separate.

0 coins

Honestly that's the clearest it's been put to me. I kept thinking EDD and HR were coordinating with each other and I had to keep them both informed of everything.

0 coins

They're not talking to each other. File with EDD when the time comes, let HR know you're filing, that's it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure