Back to California Disability

Ashley Adams

When can I file SDI claim after hip replacement surgery — do I wait or file right away?

Had my hip replacement done last Thursday and I'm already getting anxious about the money side of things. Boss gave me eight weeks off but I don't know when I'm supposed to actually file for SDI. My HR person said to wait until I'm back on my feet which makes zero sense to me. Do I file now or do I wait until I'm already out of work for a while? Don't want to miss some window and get disqualified.

The 49-day window is the one that matters most here. You have up to 49 days from the day your disability began to file and also for your surgeon's office to submit the medical certification, so waiting too long is the real risk. That said, EDD says not to file until at least nine days after the disability start date, which for a surgery is usually the day of the procedure. So you have a narrow opening at the front and a firm deadline at the back.

0 coins

So my surgery day counts as day one? That's what I needed to know.

0 coins

Yes, the surgery date is typically your disability start date. Count from there for both the nine-day wait to file and the 49-day outer limit.

0 coins

Wait so the nine days is just a waiting period before you can file, not the unpaid waiting period people keep talking about? Those are two different things?

0 coins

They are different. The nine days before filing is just when EDD says to wait before submitting your claim. The seven-day waiting period is the first week of your claim that simply isn't paid, no matter what.

0 coins

SDI Online showed my claim start date as a day later than I expected, which threw off everything I'd calculated. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. Video on reaching a live person on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the exact start date they had on file, which turned out to be the date my surgeon had entered, not the surgery date itself. Worth knowing your surgeon's office might list the first day you were actually restricted from work rather than the OR date.

0 coins

The start date mismatch is exactly what I ran into. Used Claimyr too after my claim sat in a weird limbo, and once I had an agent on the line she confirmed the medical certification had come in matched to a different start date than what I'd put on my end. Had to get the office to resubmit with the corrected date.

0 coins

been trying that disability line for three mornings straight, never got past the hold music. good to hear some people actually get through

0 coins

My surgeon's scheduler told me the date they put on the certification is the day I checked in for pre-op, not the actual surgery. Had no idea that could cause a mismatch until it was already a problem.

0 coins

Filed on day ten after my hip surgery, which was a Monday. The certification came from my orthopedic's office four days later. EDD processed everything and I had a Notice of Computation in my SDI Online inbox by day eighteen from my surgery date. The weekly amount on that notice was based on my highest-paid quarter in the base period, same as the calculator on EDD's site estimated.

0 coins

You got the Notice of Computation that fast? Mine took longer. Does that notice mean you're approved?

0 coins

No, the notice just shows the potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts. Approval shows up as an actual payment or a denial notice, not the computation notice itself.

0 coins

I keep thinking the Notice of Computation is the approval letter. I'm on day twelve post-surgery and I got that notice but no payment yet. Is that normal or should I be worried?

0 coins

Totally normal. The computation notice is just the math on what you might receive. Payment usually follows within two weeks of EDD getting both your part and the medical certification, but it isn't instant.

0 coins

HR telling you to wait until you're back on your feet is flat-out wrong advice. File as soon as you hit that nine-day mark. Every day you wait on the front end is a day you're burning inside that 49-day window, and if your surgeon's office is slow with the medical certification you need that buffer.

0 coins

Yeah that HR advice didn't sit right with me. Filing on day nine.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. HR had no clue how the SDI timeline worked.

0 coins

HR at my job told me I had to wait until after my short-term disability kicked in before filing SDI. Completely wrong. They're separate things.

0 coins

my roommate had a hip replacement and filed on like day 8 and EDD rejected it and made him refile, so dont jump the gun on that nine day thing

0 coins

Filing before nine days is early, yes, but the solution is to refile at the right time. The window that actually risks disqualification is missing the 49-day outer deadline, not filing a couple days early.

0 coins

Good to know. I'll count carefully and hit it on exactly day nine.

0 coins

Can someone explain how the medical certification part works? My surgeon's office said they'd handle it but I don't know what they're actually supposed to do or if I need to send them something first.

0 coins

After you file your part on SDI Online, you get a receipt number. Give that to your surgeon's office. They log into SDI Online, look up your claim with that number, and submit the medical certification directly. They shouldn't be mailing anything if they're doing it online.

0 coins

So I need to actually hand them the receipt number. I didn't realize that. I just told them I filed and assumed they'd find it somehow.

0 coins

The receipt number is how they locate your specific claim. Without it they're guessing, and the certification might not attach correctly.

0 coins

My orthopedist's front desk told me they already knew how to do it through SDI Online, but they still asked for my receipt number before they'd even start. Definitely send it over right after you file.

0 coins

Seven-day waiting period, no payment, every claim, no exceptions. File on time, make sure the certification gets in, then wait.

0 coins

So the first seven days I'm just out of luck? No payment at all for that week?

0 coins

Correct. Those days are on you. Payment starts on day eight.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period was just while EDD processes things. Didn't realize it's a permanent no-pay week built into every claim.

0 coins

Physical therapist was doing my mom's pre-surgical eval and mentioned she could certify the SDI claim. That didn't sound right to me, and sure enough, when I checked EDD's list, physical therapists aren't on it. Her orthopedic surgeon had to do it instead.

0 coins

You're right to flag that. The licensed health professionals EDD lists for DI certifications don't include physical therapists. Using one would likely result in an invalid certification.

0 coins

This is the kind of thing nobody tells you upfront. I almost asked my PT to do it.

0 coins

Surgeon, nurse practitioner, physician assistant are your safe bets. The list on EDD's site spells it out if you want to double-check.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation was the piece I needed to understand before my hip surgery claim made any sense to me. I actually reached an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask specifically about which quarter they'd used to calculate my weekly benefit amount. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the exact quarter, and the amount on the notice matched what the EDD calculator had projected when I'd entered those same wages. If your notice seems off, the calculator on EDD's site lets you check your own base period wages against it.

0 coins

I've been trying to get someone on that line for a week. Called every morning before eight, every afternoon after two, nothing. How are you people actually getting through?

0 coins

Spent two days the same way before I tried it. Claimyr held the line and I ended up talking to an agent without sitting there redialing.

0 coins

I've been on that line! Used Claimyr a while back when my receipt number wasn't showing up attached to my claim. The agent found that the certification had come in but under a slightly different form of my name. Got that cleared up same day.

0 coins

Alright, I'll look into it. My question is about the base period anyway, specifically which quarter they used, and I'd just want to make sure the amount is right before I count on it.

0 coins

What if my surgeon only clears me for light duty at six weeks but I can't actually do my job on light duty? My work is physical, same as the OP here. Does SDI stop at six weeks even if I still can't work?

0 coins

SDI pays as long as your licensed health professional certifies that you're unable to do your regular or customary work. If your surgeon says you're cleared for light duty but your actual job can't accommodate that, your provider can continue certifying that you're unable to perform your regular duties.

0 coins

Same concern here. Warehouse work isn't exactly light duty.

0 coins

Your doctor's certification language matters a lot in that situation. 'Light duty' on paper doesn't automatically cut off SDI if you genuinely can't do your job.

0 coins

Okay, I'll make sure to have an honest conversation with my surgeon about what my job actually requires.

0 coins

Went back to work part time at week seven after my knee surgery last year and didn't report it right away because I didn't know I was supposed to. Got an overpayment notice two months later. Report any hours you work to EDD as it happens, don't wait.

0 coins

Noted. I won't be doing anything part time for a while after hip replacement but good to know for later.

0 coins

how do you even report it, is there a form or do you do it in sdi online

0 coins

In SDI Online when you certify. There's a section for reporting wages if you worked any hours that week. Don't skip it even if it was just a few hours.

0 coins

EDD's automated line gives you payment info without waiting on hold for an agent. 1-800-480-3287 and follow the prompts. Saves a lot of grief.

0 coins

The automated line is fine for basic status but it won't tell you why something's pending or what's missing on your claim. Sometimes you need a human.

0 coins

Automated line confirmed I'd been paid. Didn't tell me what weeks. That still required a person.

0 coins

Just got out of a hip replacement myself two days ago, timing feels impossible to manage from a hospital bed. When they say file through SDI Online, is that through the myEDD portal or is it somewhere else?

0 coins

SDI Online is inside myEDD. Go to https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/, log in or create an account, and you'll find SDI Online from there.

0 coins

Okay. So I set up a myEDD account first if I don't have one, then access SDI Online inside that. Got it.

0 coins

You can also file on paper with the DE 2501 form if online is too much right now. But the online route through myEDD is faster and you get the receipt number right away to pass to your surgeon.

0 coins

Eleven weeks on a workers' comp claim with a shoulder injury before EDD and my employer's insurance got sorted out. Just want to make sure everyone here knows hip replacement from an accident at work is a whole different process, that goes through workers' comp first, not SDI. If yours was degenerative or elective, you're fine on the SDI route.

0 coins

Mine was degenerative, no work injury. Pure wear and tear on the joint. So SDI applies.

0 coins

Right, a non-work injury or illness goes through SDI. A work-related injury goes through workers' comp. EDD is clear that it's not common to receive both at the same time, though there are exceptions.

0 coins

Glad someone said that. I was going to ask about it.

0 coins

The DE 2593 questionnaire trips people up. After five automatic payments, EDD sends it and you have to return it within 20 days or benefits stop. Mark your calendar once payments start, because that form arriving and sitting unopened has derailed more people than the original filing did.

0 coins

Nobody mentioned this form to me. After five payments meaning ten weeks in?

0 coins

Five bi-weekly payments, so yes, roughly ten weeks from your first payment. If you're not on automatic payment you get the DE 2500A every two weeks instead.

0 coins

How do you know if you're on automatic payment versus the other kind?

0 coins

Your SDI Online account shows your payment type. If you filed online you're likely set up for the DE 2500A every two weeks unless EDD switched you to automatic, which they can do.

0 coins

Those weeks around week eight when I wondered if I'd need longer to recover, the DE 2525XX extension form is what your doctor files, not you. EDD sends it to your provider with the final payment notice. I ended up talking to a live agent through Claimyr about whether the extension had been submitted yet. The agent told me the DE 2525XX hadn't come in from my surgeon's office as of that date, so I was able to contact the office before the gap in payments hit.

0 coins

What's Claimyr?

0 coins

It's a service that waits on that EDD line in your place, so when an agent picks up, your phone rings instead of you sitting there for hours. I'd been trying that number every day for about a week before I tried it.

0 coins

Oh that's actually useful. My question would be whether the medical certification even came in from my surgeon's office yet. That's what I'd want to ask about.

0 coins

The SDI Online message center can sometimes show that too. Worth checking in your account first, but if the status is unclear an agent can confirm exactly what EDD has on file.

0 coins

Does anyone know if SDI covers the full eight weeks after a hip replacement or is it based on what your doctor says? I keep seeing different numbers and I'm confused.

0 coins

The duration is entirely based on your doctor's certification. EDD pays for the period your licensed provider certifies you can't do your regular work, up to 52 weeks total for a DI claim. There's no fixed eight-week rule from EDD's side.

0 coins

So my surgeon decides how long, essentially. That makes more sense than what I read somewhere.

0 coins

My surgeon gave me eight weeks on the initial certification. If I need more he said he'd extend it.

0 coins

My surgeon told me he'd certify eight weeks and then we'd see. If he thinks I need more time, what actually happens on the EDD side? Do I file a whole new claim?

0 coins

No new claim needed. Your surgeon submits the DE 2525XX, which is the supplementary certificate, to extend the existing claim. EDD sends that form to your provider with the notice about your final payment, so your surgeon's office should be watching for it.

0 coins

That's a relief. I was afraid I'd have to start the whole process over and go back to the beginning of the queue or something.

0 coins

The final payment notice triggers the extension process. EDD mails the DE 2525XX with that notice so your provider knows to file it if they're recommending more time off.

0 coins

Had my pre-op appointment yesterday and the nurse practitioner said she could certify the SDI claim instead of the surgeon if needed. Is that actually allowed?

0 coins

Yes, nurse practitioners are on EDD's list of licensed health professionals who can certify a DI claim. Your surgeon isn't the only option.

0 coins

That's handy to know. Some practices have the NP handle all the paperwork stuff and the surgeon just does the surgery.

0 coins

The direct deposit option only exists if you filed online through SDI Online. Paper filers get the Money Network prepaid debit card automatically. Worth setting up direct deposit in your account if you want payments to hit your bank account instead.

0 coins

wait the edd card changed from bank of america? when did that happen

0 coins

The card is Money Network now, not Bank of America. If you're expecting a specific card in the mail, that's the one to look for.

0 coins

I set up direct deposit when I filed and payments have gone straight to my account. Much easier than dealing with a card.

0 coins

Finally filed on day ten after my procedure and I want to say this thread helped me understand the receipt number thing before I even got to the certification step. Surgeon's office had it within an hour and confirmed they'd submitted the medical certification by end of day. Now I wait and watch SDI Online!

0 coins

That's the right move. Good luck with the recovery.

0 coins

This is encouraging to hear. I'm about to file mine and was nervous about every step.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure