Back to California Disability

Ella Cofer

What start date to use when filing SDI claim for first time — California EDD

So I had a pretty bad fall at home about two weeks ago and my doctor told me I can't go back to my job stocking shelves for at least six weeks. I've never filed for SDI before and I'm honestly kind of lost on the basics. The thing tripping me up most is what start date to use when filing SDI claim for first time. Like is it the day I got hurt? The day my doctor officially told me to stay home? The first day I missed work? I'm not sure if those are even the same date for everyone. My injury was on a Monday, I saw the doctor Tuesday, and she said don't go back until further notice. I missed work starting that Monday. So which date do I actually put? I don't want to mess it up and lose days of benefits because I picked wrong. Also does the date I put affect the waiting period somehow? Any help appreciated.

The date that tripped me up too when I first filed was exactly this one. What EDD wants is the first day you were unable to do your regular work because of your injury or illness, not the date of the doctor visit and not the first day you missed a paycheck. In your case, if Monday was the day you physically could not do your job, that is your disability start date. The seven-day waiting period counts from that date, so getting it right does affect which day your first payment can begin.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes sense. So for me Monday is the right answer since that's the day I genuinely couldn't work, even though I didn't see the doctor until Tuesday.

0 coins

Yep the doctor visit date and the disability start date are two separate things. A lot of people mix those up on their first claim and it causes delays.

0 coins

Does the doctor have to agree with the date you put? Like what if she writes a different date on the medical certification part?

0 coins

Weeks 3 and 4 on my claim were showing as not paid and I could not figure out why, so I ended up reaching EDD through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after burning through way too many mornings on the hold line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me those two weeks were still showing pending because my doctor's office had submitted the certification under the wrong receipt number, so the medical cert wasn't matched to my claim at all. Once I had that confirmed I went right back to the office with the right number and they resubmitted.

0 coins

What did you even say when the agent picked up, like do you just read them your claim ID?

0 coins

Claim ID and my Social, and then just explained which weeks looked wrong. Agent had the whole thing up in maybe a minute.

0 coins

Been dialing that 800 number before 8 every morning for about nine days now. Never once got a person. Good to know there's another way.

0 coins

To add some precision to what was said above: EDD's guidance says to file no earlier than nine days after your disability begins. So if your disability started Monday the 3rd, the earliest you could file would be Wednesday the 12th. The 49-day deadline runs from that same start date, so you want to use the accurate first day of disability and file within that window.

0 coins

Nine days after, not before, got it. I was actually worried I might be filing too late already. I'm at day 13 from the injury so I should still be fine.

0 coins

You have until 49 days from the start date, so at day 13 you have plenty of time. File as soon as you can so the medical certification deadline doesn't sneak up.

0 coins

Is the 49 days for the claimant part or the doctor part or both?

0 coins

Both the claimant's statement and the medical certification from the provider need to be in within 49 days of the disability start date, or EDD may disqualify the claim.

0 coins

My first SDI claim I put the date I called my doctor's office instead of the actual day I stopped working and it caused a whole mess. The rep I eventually reached said the start date should be the first day you were actually unable to perform your normal duties. For a physical job like yours that sounds like it really is Monday.

0 coins

Ugh glad you said that, I was second-guessing myself and almost put Tuesday. Monday it is.

0 coins

Same mistake I made on my first one. Cost me a day.

0 coins

just use the day you got hurt if thats when you couldnt do the job, dont overthink it

0 coins

This. Don't sit there debating. First day you couldn't work, done.

0 coins

Mostly right but worth double-checking with your doctor that the date she'll write on the medical certification matches what you file, so they're not off by a day and causing a flag on the claim.

0 coins

From a documentation standpoint: before you file, write down the exact date of the injury, the date of your first doctor visit, and the first day you were absent from work. If all three are different dates, the disability start date is the earliest one on which you were medically unable to do your job. Keep that documentation handy because if EDD ever questions the start date you'll want it.

0 coins

That's really practical, I'm going to write those three dates down right now.

0 coins

Keeping a simple log like that helped me enormously when my claim got questioned later. Even a note in your phone with dates is better than relying on memory.

0 coins

Also screenshot anything SDI Online shows you after you file, like the receipt number and what start date it accepted. Easy to forget those details once the claim is moving.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came up on my claim when I needed more time off than my original certification covered. The form went in from my provider's office but nothing changed in SDI Online for about two weeks, so I used Claimyr to get EDD's disability line and talked to an agent. She looked up my claim and confirmed the extension form had been received but was still being processed, and told me the final payment notice, the DE 2500E, would go out before the extension payment started.

0 coins

My extension question is exactly that, whether the DE 2525XX my doctor submitted actually made it to EDD, so I'm going to try Claimyr for it. Any particular account info I should have ready?

0 coins

Have your claim ID, Social Security number and the date your provider said they submitted the form. That's what the agent asked me for right away.

0 coins

Good to know about the DE 2525XX. My doctor mentioned I might need more time too, so I'll keep that form name in mind.

0 coins

The start date question also matters for the waiting period thing so get it exactly right. EDD does not pay the first seven days of a claim, and those seven days run from whatever start date you give them. Put a date that's too late and you're just shortening your own benefit window for no reason.

0 coins

Wait so the seven days is not like a processing delay, it's actually just unpaid no matter what?

0 coins

Correct. EDD calls it the waiting period and it is non-payable by design. The eighth day is the first day a payment can actually be issued for.

0 coins

Okay so I really do want the earliest accurate date, because every day I leave off the front end is just a free waiting-period day I'm handing to EDD.

0 coins

Exactly right. And once you're past the seven-day waiting period the benefit payments can begin, assuming the medical certification is in and matches your claim.

0 coins

Don't put a date earlier than you can actually support. If your doctor writes one date and you put something two days earlier, you're asking for a mismatch that slows everything down. Keep your start date lined up with what your provider will certify.

0 coins

This is the real answer. A mismatch between what you file and what the doctor certifies is how claims get stuck.

0 coins

My doctor already said the injury was on Monday so her certification should line up with that date.

0 coins

Now I'm worried about my own situation reading all of this. I had surgery and my first day post-surgery I technically could not work, but I pre-scheduled my procedure so I already knew the date weeks in advance. Can I use the surgery date as the start date even though I kind of planned for it?

0 coins

Planned procedures count the same way. The start date is the first day the medical condition prevented you from doing your regular work, whether the surgery was scheduled months ahead or was an emergency.

0 coins

My knee surgery was totally scheduled and I used the day of the procedure as my start date, no issue at all. EDD's concern is when you couldn't work, not whether you saw it coming.

0 coins

That's a relief, thank you. I was scared I'd have to put some earlier date because I'd had pre-op appointments.

0 coins

The claim start date on my first SDI filing turned out to match my actual disability date perfectly, but I still wasn't sure EDD had the right date in their system after I filed. I rang Claimyr and landed on the phone with a disability agent who pulled up the claim and read me back the start date they had on file. It matched what I entered, so that confirmed everything was recorded right and I didn't need to change anything.

0 coins

My provider used a different base quarter than I expected, so I went through SDI Online and confirmed the claim start date matched what I filed. After that the agent I reached confirmed which quarter of my wages they were actually using. Knowing the exact quarter helped me understand the weekly amount on my Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Three weeks trying that disability line before I tried anything different. Good to know someone got an actual person.

0 coins

Knowing the date in their system matches what you entered is something I hadn't even thought to check. Useful to know.

0 coins

For a physical job, the injury date and the first day unable to work are usually the same. File with that date, give the receipt number to your provider right away, and make sure they submit the certification within 49 days.

0 coins

Short and clear, thank you. Receipt number to the doctor immediately, got it.

0 coins

yeah dont forget to give the doctor that number, my coworker forgot and his claim sat forever

0 coins

Worth mentioning that SDI Online will ask you to identify the start date during the filing process, and what you enter becomes the anchor for the whole claim, the waiting period, the base period wage calculation, and the certification deadline. Take a moment to confirm the date before you submit the form.

0 coins

The base period part is important. EDD looks at wages in a 12-month base period that is set by your claim start date. If your start date is off by even a few days and crosses a quarter boundary, it could change which wages get used in the calculation.

0 coins

I did not know the start date affects the wage calculation too. That makes it even more important to get right.

0 coins

The weekly benefit amount is estimated from the highest-paid quarter in that base period, so a quarter boundary shift can matter. The Notice of Computation will show what EDD actually used, and if it looks off you can ask EDD to explain it.

0 coins

Had my own Notice of Computation question a few weeks back and I finally got a live EDD agent through Claimyr after days of that phone line cutting me off at the two-hour mark. Agent confirmed the weekly amount on my DE 429D and explained which quarter of my wages they had used in the base period for my claim.

0 coins

The hold line does that to everyone. I've redialed before 8 AM three mornings in a row and gotten that same recording. Genuinely didn't think anything could cut through.

0 coins

I know, I felt the same way before I tried it. The agent I reached was a real EDD staffer who had my actual claim on her screen and gave me the specifics on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

been at that number for about two weeks, just noise every time. maybe ill try that.

0 coins

Also just to flag for anyone reading: the date you put is not set in stone forever if you genuinely made an error. Contact EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update option or Ask EDD to report the correction as soon as you notice it, before payments start if possible.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to fix it. I'll double check the date before I hit submit so hopefully I won't need to.

0 coins

Fixing a start date after the claim is moving is possible but annoying. Get it right on the first try.

0 coins

Does it matter if you're salaried vs hourly for picking the start date? Like does EDD care about your work schedule when determining it?

0 coins

EDD's rule is the same regardless of how you're paid. The start date is when you couldn't do your regular or customary work, full stop. How your employer pays you doesn't change the definition.

0 coins

The only place your pay structure matters is in the wage calculation for the benefit amount. The start date itself is purely about when the disability prevented you from working.

0 coins

My client came in for a cut last week and was stressing about this exact same thing. She's a teacher and wasn't sure whether to use the last day she was in the classroom or the first day of her leave. For her it was the same day, but the way she described it, the first day she physically couldn't do the job is what the SDI Online form is actually asking for.

0 coins

Teachers sometimes have a gap there because the school year timing can be weird. But same rule applies to everyone.

0 coins

My sister is a teacher and had the same question. Same answer.

0 coins

While you're in SDI Online filling it out, write down the receipt number the moment it appears on your screen. That number is what your doctor needs to find the claim and submit the certification. Do not leave that screen without noting it somewhere.

0 coins

Is the receipt number different from the claim ID? I keep seeing both mentioned and I'm not sure if they're the same thing.

0 coins

They are different. The receipt number is generated right when you submit the claimant's statement and is what the provider uses to look up the claim on their end. The claim ID is what you use when checking your claim status as the claimant. Both are worth saving.

0 coins

Okay writing both down immediately after I file. Thank you for clarifying that.

0 coins

been off three weeks now, still havent filed because i got confused on exactly this question. this thread helped. filing tonight.

0 coins

Filing tonight is the right move. At three weeks you're using up days within your 49-day window, so the sooner the better.

0 coins

Get it in tonight and text your doctor's office tomorrow morning so they know to look for the receipt number and submit the medical cert.

0 coins

To loop back to the original question one more time: the clearest way to think about it is to ask yourself what was the last day you could have shown up and done your job. The day after that is your start date. For a stocking job where you need to be on your feet and lifting, a fall injury probably made that clear pretty immediately.

0 coins

That framing actually really helps. The day after the last day I could have worked. For me that's definitely Monday, the day of the fall.

0 coins

Simple way to put it. That's the answer.

0 coins

Nine days after disability begins is the earliest you can file. Forty-nine days is the deadline. First day you couldn't do the job is the start date. That's really the whole answer to your question.

0 coins

Thank you. I'm going to file tonight. Monday's date, everything else follows from there.

0 coins

good luck, make sure the doctor knows to submit fast

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure