Back to California Disability

Omar Zaki

What is the cost of SDI to workers in California? Confused about my paystub deduction

Every time I look at my paystub I see a CASDI line being taken out and I honestly never paid much attention to it until now. I had to have a procedure done on my shoulder a few weeks back and my doctor says I'm going to be out of work for probably six to eight weeks. A coworker mentioned I should look into California EDD disability and when I started reading about SDI I realized that deduction I've been ignoring is actually what funds the whole thing. So I guess my questions are: what exactly am I paying, and when I'm out recovering, how does the benefit amount get calculated from that? I filed my claim on SDI Online yesterday and got my receipt number. My surgeon's office is supposed to submit the medical certification this week. I'm trying to figure out what I might realistically get paid while I'm recovering so I can plan my budget. The SDI Online claim shows pending right now which I expected but I'm not sure what happens next or what I should be watching for.

The CASDI deduction is coming straight out of your wages — it's your contribution, not your employer's. Workers fund SDI entirely through that paycheck line. So in a sense the "cost" of SDI to you personally is whatever that deduction has been adding up to on your stubs over the months or years you've worked. The benefit you get back is based on your earnings in a specific base period — roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim started — and EDD looks at whichever quarter in that window had your highest wages. From there they estimate somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of those weekly wages depending on your income level. The actual number you'll see is on the Notice of Computation that EDD mails out. That notice doesn't mean you're approved, just that EDD ran the calculation. Use the disability benefits calculator on EDD's site for a rough estimate before the notice shows up.

0 coins

The calculator helped me more than I expected — I plugged in my numbers from a recent W-2 and got pretty close to what my Notice of Computation ended up showing. Not exact but close enough to plan around.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Okay so the CASDI I've been paying is essentially the premium. Got it. I'll go find that calculator tonight. Do I need to do anything else while the claim is pending, or just wait for the medical certification to come in from the surgeon?

0 coins

While it's pending you mostly wait for two things: the surgeon's office to submit the medical certification and then EDD to process it. After EDD gets both sides of the claim, they contact you about status, usually within about two weeks. If the medical certification doesn't show up in SDI Online within a few days of the office submitting it, ask them to confirm they used the receipt number you gave them — that's how they find your specific claim.

0 coins

Piggyback on the calculator point — I went into my SDI claim last spring thinking I'd get paid close to my full salary and the actual number was lower than I guessed. Not bad, but not full pay either. The calculation pulls from a base period that might not include your most recent months if you just got a raise or changed jobs. So if your wages went up recently, the benefit might reflect older earnings. Worth knowing before you count on a specific amount.

0 coins

Months just before the claim are often not in the base period — there's a lag in which quarters EDD uses. My claim started in spring and the base period didn't include the last couple quarters at all. The notice spelled it out clearly though.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

That's actually useful context. I did get a small raise about four months ago so I'm curious whether that quarter makes it in. I guess the Notice of Computation will tell me which quarter they used.

0 coins

Exactly, the notice shows which quarter they based it on. You can also ask EDD directly if you want to know before the notice arrives — the number on the payment line is 1-800-480-3287, though getting through takes some patience.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim form ended up being the whole source of the delay I had. Filed for a back injury, gave the number to my doctor's office, but somehow they were searching by my name instead of the receipt number and couldn't locate the claim in SDI Online. Spent two weeks thinking the medical certification was in when it wasn't. Tried calling EDD but couldn't get through on my own. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed the certification hadn't been matched yet — just that the number my doctor's office was using was wrong. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once the office resubmitted with the correct receipt number, the pending status moved within a few days.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

The receipt number thing is something I would have completely overlooked. I sent my surgeon's office a screenshot of the SDI Online confirmation with the number on it — hope that's enough. I'll double-check with them.

0 coins

My doctor's office told me they had submitted but it turned out they were also using the wrong reference. The receipt number is on your SDI Online filing confirmation screen. If you can share that exact number with the provider, not just your name or SSN, that's how the claim gets matched.

0 coins

Sharing the actual screenshot was what finally worked for my provider too. They need that specific number, not just your personal details.

0 coins

Worth understanding what the waiting period means for your budget planning too. The first seven days of a new SDI claim are unpaid — that's by design, not because EDD is slow. So you won't see payment for those first seven days at all. Your first payment covers day eight onward. Knowing that up front saves a lot of confusion when people expect the full recovery period to be paid.

0 coins

Waiting period tripped me up completely — I expected payment from day one and then had to scramble when the first payment was smaller than I expected because those days weren't included.

0 coins

There's sometimes confusion between the waiting period and processing time. They're different things. The seven days is a permanent gap — those wages are just not paid, period. Processing time is on top of that. So your first check covers week two onward, and even that takes a couple weeks to process after EDD gets everything.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

So I should budget for at least two to three weeks before anything hits? That's helpful to know now rather than after the fact. I have some savings but I wanted to know the realistic timeline.

0 coins

Two to three weeks from when EDD gets both parts of your claim is a reasonable rough estimate. But EDD says most payments go out within two weeks of receiving a complete claim, so once the medical certification is in you're on the clock for that window.

0 coins

The 52-week cap is something worth knowing about for longer injuries. SDI pays up to 52 weeks on a single claim. Most shoulder recoveries wouldn't come close to that, but if complications ever push it longer your doctor would need to submit an extension form, the DE 2525XX. EDD sends that out with the final payment notice anyway so the provider knows when to act.

0 coins

Extension process caught me off guard — I assumed I'd have to file a whole new claim when my recovery took longer than expected. It's the same claim, just an additional certification from the doctor. Much easier than starting over.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Good to know there's a path if things drag on longer than the surgeon expects. Hopefully I won't need it but I'll keep that form name in mind.

0 coins

My situation was similar when I had my knee done — pending for a while, then the Notice of Computation showed up, then the first payment. The notice came before the payment in my case. It doesn't tell you that you're approved or when you'll be paid, it just shows the weekly amount EDD calculated. I kept refreshing SDI Online thinking the notice meant money was coming that day and it doesn't work that way.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me — the notice arrives and it feels like confirmation but EDD still needs to process the claim fully before payments start moving. The notice is really just the math, not the approval.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Knowing the notice is just the calculation and not an approval will save me some anxiety. I'll stop refreshing constantly after I get it.

0 coins

The only number on that notice that matters for planning is the weekly benefit amount. Everything else you're waiting to hear about eligibility comes separately, by mail or in SDI Online.

0 coins

The SDI deduction showing on your paystub as CASDI does not come back to you as a tax refund or anything like that — it goes into the SDI fund. And California doesn't tax your SDI benefits on the state side. The federal side depends on factors I'd leave to a tax professional or EDD's own tax information page, but state taxes on the benefit itself are not a thing you have to plan for in California.

0 coins

California side is clean — no state tax on SDI benefits. The federal picture is less clear-cut and I'd check EDD's tax information page or talk to someone who knows your full situation before assuming either way.

0 coins

Always good to flag that the CASDI line is not something you can avoid if you work in California — it's mandatory. But the tradeoff is you've been building eligibility the whole time you've been paying it, so a claim like this is exactly what it's for.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim took longer than I expected to nail down — SDI Online showed the first payment as issued but it didn't show up on my Money Network card for several more days. Called EDD using Claimyr and an agent told me the specific date the payment was processed and confirmed it had gone to the card. Knowing the actual issued date helped me figure out how long to wait before following up again.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Money Network card — is that what EDD uses now? I thought it was a Bank of America card. When I set up my claim I didn't see that option clearly.

0 coins

EDD's card is now through Money Network, not Bank of America. That changed a while back. If you filed on SDI Online you can also choose direct deposit instead of the card — worth setting that up during the claim if you haven't already so you're not waiting for a card to arrive in the mail.

0 coins

Direct deposit was faster for me than waiting for the card to show up. Set it up in SDI Online before my first payment and it went straight to my bank account.

0 coins

Something that doesn't come up enough in these conversations: the CASDI line you've been paying is based on wages up to a limit each year — once you hit that limit the deductions stop for the rest of the year. If you've been at the same job a while you may have noticed the deduction disappearing near the end of some years. The rate and the limit are on EDD's site; your paystub just shows what was actually taken.

0 coins

Wage limit is worth checking against your own W-2 each year just to understand where you are in it. EDD's site has the current numbers.

0 coins

Never noticed the deductions stopping until someone pointed it out to me. It makes sense once you understand how the annual cap works.

0 coins

Can I ask a question that's maybe dumb — my husband mentioned I should file for unemployment while I'm out for my surgery recovery since I'm not working. That's wrong, right? I was under the impression disability and unemployment are completely separate and you can't collect both at the same time.

0 coins

Unemployment and disability are mutually exclusive for the same days. Unemployment requires you to be ready, able and available to work every week you claim it. If you're recovering from surgery and can't work, you don't meet that requirement. SDI is what covers days you're medically unable to work. The two don't overlap.

0 coins

That's what I thought. My husband had heard something about being able to collect during a gap between jobs and got confused. We're definitely in SDI territory here, not unemployment.

0 coins

The gap-between-jobs version he heard about is regular unemployment — that's for when you're able to work but don't have a job yet. Completely different situation from being out on medical leave. DI is what you file when a doctor says you can't do your job right now.

0 coins

The DE 2593 is worth knowing about before it shows up — EDD sends it after your fifth automatic payment and you have 20 days to send it back confirming you're still unable to work. I didn't know that form existed and almost missed the deadline. Mine arrived in a stack of mail I hadn't opened. Called EDD to ask whether mine had been received; used Claimyr and the agent confirmed the form had come in and was being processed, so I didn't need to worry about the deadline anymore.

0 coins

DE 2593 caught me completely by surprise on my first claim too. It looks kind of generic and easy to miss in a pile of mail. I'd recommend flagging anything from EDD as important before you even know what's inside.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Twenty days sounds like enough time but I can see how it would sneak up on someone who's recovering and not on top of their mail. I'll set a reminder to watch for it around the five-payment mark.

0 coins

The five payments cover ten weeks since they come every two weeks. So roughly ten weeks into your claim, start watching for it.

0 coins

EDD also offers automatic payment where you don't have to certify every two weeks — if you're on that, the DE 2593 is the form they send instead of the regular biweekly certification. Good system once you understand it, confusing before you do.

0 coins

What happens if the surgeon decides I need longer than eight weeks? Does EDD cut me off automatically or does the doctor have some way to extend?

0 coins

You don't file a new claim if you need more time. Your doctor submits a supplementary certificate — the DE 2525XX — which extends the same claim. EDD sends that form out with the notice for your final payment so your provider knows it's time to act. No gap in benefits if the doctor gets it in before the original end date runs out.

0 coins

That's a relief. I was picturing having to restart the whole filing process if something came up. Good to know it's just an extension on the same claim.

0 coins

Notice of Determination arrived in my mailbox after a complication on my claim — EDD wasn't going to pay one stretch of weeks and the notice had an appeal form attached. Filed the appeal within the 30-day window on the notice. While I was putting my response together I used Claimyr and talked to an agent who confirmed which weeks were showing as not payable on my claim, which helped me know exactly what to address in the appeal letter.

0 coins

Appeal window is 30 days from the date printed on the notice, not the date you receive it. Worth paying attention to the actual date on the form rather than when it arrived. If you miss it you can still appeal but you'd have to explain the delay to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

The date on the notice was about three days before I even opened the envelope. So yes, that clock starts on EDD's end, not when it hits your mailbox.

0 coins

Keeping the envelope with the postmark is a good habit — if there's ever a question about when something arrived, the envelope is better evidence than your memory of opening it.

0 coins

Does workers' comp come into this at all? My coworker keeps saying I should file workers' comp for my shoulder. I injured it at work lifting equipment. I hadn't mentioned that part because I thought SDI was the simpler option.

0 coins

Work injuries are workers' compensation, not DI. EDD says it's not common to get both SDI and workers' comp at the same time, though there are exceptions. If your shoulder injury happened on the job, that's a different claim type with a different process — typically through your employer's workers' comp insurer, not EDD. Worth clarifying with your employer and possibly a workers' comp attorney before filing SDI for a work injury.

0 coins

Mine was actually not at work — I was trying to say my coworker is in a different situation. I just wanted to make sure I was using the right program for my own non-work injury. SDI is correct for me.

0 coins

Got it, then SDI is the right lane for a non-work injury. Workers' comp is specifically for injuries that happen in the course of employment. Good that you clarified.

0 coins

Planning question from someone about two months ahead of you in a similar recovery — do you know yet whether your employer has a Voluntary Plan instead of state SDI? Some larger employers run their own disability plan and your CASDI deduction might look slightly different as a result. The benefit calculation can vary. Worth asking HR if you're not sure which plan you're under.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

HR confirmed I'm under state SDI, not a voluntary plan, so I think I'm following the right process by going through EDD directly. Good thing to double-check though.

0 coins

Voluntary Plan employers handle disability claims differently and the EDD SDI Online process may not apply the same way. For standard state SDI, what everyone's described in this thread is correct.

0 coins

If the medical certification still hasn't appeared as received in SDI Online a week or so after your surgeon's office says they submitted it, your fastest move is to send a message through SDI Online under Request Claim Update — pick the type that fits and write out your question. You can also try the EDD disability line at 1-800-480-3287 if you need to talk to someone. Getting through takes patience but it's the most direct way to find out whether the certification matched to your claim.

0 coins

Request Claim Update in SDI Online moved faster than I expected for a certification question — heard back within a few days. Phone took longer but was more useful when I needed a specific answer fast.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

I'll start with the Request Claim Update path and escalate to the phone if I don't hear back. Thanks for the specifics.

0 coins

The original question about cost kind of gets philosophical when you think about it — you've technically been paying into SDI for every paycheck you've earned, and the "cost" is baked into what you never see. Using it isn't a favor or a handout, it's literally the program functioning as designed. People sometimes feel weird about filing like they're asking for something extra when actually they've been funding it all along.

0 coins

That reframe helped me when I first filed. Felt strange to be on the receiving end of a benefit after years of paying in. But the whole point of the deduction was always this exact scenario.

0 coins

Same feeling here — took a minute to get past the idea that filing was somehow a burden on the system. The deduction is specifically so the program exists when workers need it.

0 coins

For anyone trying to figure out what to expect on the amount: the EDD disability benefits calculator on EDD's site is the best starting point before your Notice of Computation arrives. Put in your quarterly wages from your W-2 and it gives you a reasonable estimate. The notice itself will show the actual number EDD calculated, and if something looks off — like they used a quarter with lower wages than you expected — you can ask EDD how they determined the base period.

0 coins

Calculator on EDD's site is also useful after you get the notice, just to double-check the math. Mine matched exactly, but it's good to verify.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Running it tonight. I found myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ when I filed, so I'll look for the calculator from there or on edd.ca.gov directly.

0 coins

The calculator is on edd.ca.gov, separate from the SDI Online portal in myEDD. It doesn't require you to log in — just enter your quarterly earnings and it gives you an estimate.

0 coins

Eight weeks out is actually enough time to see multiple EDD milestones — the initial pending, the Notice of Computation, the first payment, possibly the DE 2593 if you're close to ten weeks. Keeping a simple log of dates on your claim helps a lot. Date you filed, date the medical certification came in, date the notice arrived, date of each payment. That way if anything ever needs an appeal you have a timeline ready.

0 coins

Date log saved me when I had a question about a week that wasn't showing as paid. Had the exact dates from my own notes and knew right away which weeks to ask about.

0 coins

Even just a folder in email where you screenshot each SDI Online status change works. EDD communication is mostly by mail but keeping your own record of the online side fills in gaps.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

Author

Setting up a simple notes doc now. Logged the filing date and receipt number already. I'll add the medical certification confirmation date as soon as the surgeon's office sends it over.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure