Back to California Disability

Paolo Ricci

What is the SDI max you can actually get from California EDD?

Okay so I've been going back and forth on this for a few days and I can't get a straight answer. I'm about three weeks into a leave after back surgery and my claim finally got approved, but the weekly amount on my Notice of Computation seems really low to me. Like I was making decent money before this and I expected SDI to cover more of it. What exactly is the SDI max benefit you can get, and does it change based on what you earned? My surgeon's office submitted the medical certification pretty quickly after I filed in SDI Online, so at least that part went smoothly. I just want to understand if there's any way to know whether EDD calculated my benefit right or if I should be asking them to look at it again. Is the max amount the same for everyone or does it vary?

Waiting period question first — did EDD count your first seven days as unpaid? Because a lot of people think those days are a processing delay when they're actually just not payable no matter what. For my own claim after a wrist injury I had the same confusion, and I ended up phoning EDD to sort out a few things at once. Getting through took a while and I eventually used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach someone on the disability line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed my waiting period ran from my first day out, so my first actual payment covered day 8 through day 14. Once I understood that the weekly amount wasn't going to change, I could focus on whether the base period wages were right, which is a separate thing from the max.

0 coins

No I didn't realize the first seven days were automatically unpaid, I think I was counting them as part of why my payment looked short. So the amount on the Notice of Computation is the actual weekly rate for every payable week after those first seven?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is exactly that — the weekly rate EDD calculated for your payable weeks, starting from day eight. The seven-day waiting period doesn't shrink that number, it just means those first seven days don't get paid.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period threw me off too. I kept thinking EDD was holding money back but they're really just not paying those days at all. After that your weekly amount should be consistent each payment.

0 coins

The benefit amount isn't a flat number for everyone — ask yourself which quarter of your earnings was highest in the 12 months or so before your claim started, because EDD bases the calculation on that. The weekly rate ends up being somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of what you made in that highest quarter, stretched into a weekly figure. EDD has a disability benefits calculator on their site where you can plug in your wages and see an estimate. If the number on your Notice of Computation is way off from what the calculator shows, that's worth asking EDD about.

0 coins

That calculator is actually super helpful, I hadn't found it before. The estimate I got is higher than what my notice shows, so now I'm wondering if EDD used the wrong quarter.

0 coins

If the calculator estimate doesn't match your notice, the base period quarters are the first place to look. Your notice should say which period they used. If the wages look wrong for one of those quarters, that's the conversation to have with EDD.

0 coins

Worth double-checking your paystubs against whatever wages EDD has on file. Employers report SDI wages to EDD but errors do happen, and the fix usually means providing your own documentation.

0 coins

Can you share what the notice actually shows? Not asking for exact dollar amounts but like — did it list a base period with four quarters? Sometimes people get confused because the base period isn't the most recent 12 months, it ends a few months before the claim starts, so your most recent paychecks might not even be in the calculation.

0 coins

Mine lists a 12-month period that ended about five months before my surgery date, so my last few months of higher pay didn't make it in. That's probably why the amount seems low.

0 coins

Five months before is pretty typical. The base period locks in before you file and you can't move it, so the wages from those recent high-earning months just don't count. That said, if the highest quarter inside that locked period still looks short compared to what your W-2 shows for those months, it's worth checking whether your employer reported everything correctly.

0 coins

My situation was similar — my wages went up right before I had to go out and that raise didn't land in the base period at all. It felt unfair but EDD explained it's just how the calculation windows work.

0 coins

Something people don't always realize is that the 52-week cap on benefits isn't connected to the weekly amount. You could be getting the highest weekly rate possible and still hit the 52-week maximum and lose benefits. For most people recovering from surgery that's not a concern, but if you're dealing with a longer recovery you should know that clock starts at day one of the claim, not day 8.

0 coins

Fifty-two weeks is a lot longer than I expect to be out, but good to know. My surgeon is estimating 10 to 12 weeks total so I should be well under that.

0 coins

The 52-week thing surprised me when I looked into it. I was worried about a long recovery and I wanted to know if I'd have to file a new claim after. Good to know it's the outer limit, not a target.

0 coins

For shorter recoveries it really doesn't come into play. The more practical thing is making sure your extension gets filed if your doctor keeps you out past the original end date, because that's where people miss payments.

0 coins

Is there any way to request a reconsideration of the benefit amount without filing a full appeal? I'm in a similar boat with my notice showing less than I expected and I'm not sure I want to go through the whole appeals process if there's a simpler route.

0 coins

Reconsideration requests aren't a formal EDD procedure the way appeals are. What you can do is contact EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update or by phone and ask them to verify which wages are on file for your base period quarters. If there's an error in the wages, that gets corrected without an appeal. If the wages are correct but you still disagree with how the amount was calculated, then the appeal process is the path, and you have 30 days from the date on the notice to file.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. Contacting EDD to check the wages first before deciding about an appeal sounds like the right order of things.

0 coins

How long after the medical certification came in did you get the Notice of Computation? I filed two weeks ago, my doctor submitted the certification within a few days, and I still don't have a notice. Starting to wonder if EDD even received it.

0 coins

EDD typically reaches out about claim status within 14 days of getting a completed claim — meaning both your part and the medical certification. If you're past that window, logging into SDI Online and sending a Request Claim Update asking whether the certification was received is the fastest first step before calling.

0 coins

SDI Online still shows pending for me. I'll try the Request Claim Update option, hadn't used that before.

0 coins

The pending status can sit for a while even after everything's in. I didn't get any update in SDI Online until the notice and the first payment basically arrived at the same time.

0 coins

Does the SDI max weekly benefit work differently if your employer offers short-term disability on top of SDI? Mine does and I'm trying to figure out how to coordinate them.

0 coins

How EDD treats employer-paid short-term disability alongside SDI depends on the specific plan details, and that's not something anyone here can answer reliably. Your employer's HR should be able to tell you how their plan works, and EDD handles the SDI side based on what you report. The two systems are separate and yours might have rules about coordination.

0 coins

Okay so I need to ask HR specifically about how their plan works with SDI before I assume they add together cleanly. Makes sense.

0 coins

My employer's plan said it paid the difference between SDI and my regular salary, so EDD paid SDI and the employer plan filled in the rest. But it varied by employer and I wouldn't assume any two plans work the same way.

0 coins

Base period question I actually called EDD about — my Notice of Computation listed a base period that didn't include my two highest-earning quarters because I had switched jobs earlier that year. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on EDD's disability line. The agent told me which four quarters made up my base period and confirmed the wages EDD had on file from my old employer matched what that employer had reported. The wages were correct — the lower amount on my notice was just because my higher-earning quarters fell outside the base period window, not an EDD error.

0 coins

That's exactly what I think happened to me too. The base period window just doesn't include my recent higher-pay months. Good to know the wages themselves can at least be verified that way.

0 coins

The base period timing gets a lot of people. Switching jobs or getting a raise close to when you go out on disability almost always means your highest recent earnings aren't in the calculation.

0 coins

Knowing the agent was able to confirm which wages EDD had on file is actually useful. At least you can rule out a reporting error and know the lower amount is just a timing thing.

0 coins

How do you know if you're getting the 70 percent rate versus the 90 percent? My notice just shows a weekly amount, it doesn't explain which percentage EDD used.

0 coins

The percentage EDD applies depends on where your highest-quarter wages fall relative to the state average weekly wage, so lower earners get closer to 90 percent and higher earners get closer to 70 percent. The notice doesn't spell out the percentage — it just shows the resulting weekly benefit. If you want to see how the number was derived, the disability benefits calculator on EDD's site shows the formula when you enter your quarterly wages.

0 coins

Got it. My wages are pretty high so I'm probably at the lower end of the range, which explains why the percentage feels small when I compare it to my regular paycheck.

0 coins

Does anyone know whether the SDI max calculation looks at gross wages or net wages? I've always paid the CASDI deduction out of my gross check but I'm not totally sure EDD uses the same number.

0 coins

EDD uses the wages subject to SDI contributions, which is based on your gross wages — the CASDI deduction on your paystub comes out of gross pay. So yes, it's your gross earnings in the base period quarters that drive the benefit amount, not what you took home after taxes.

0 coins

Makes sense. My paystub shows the deduction on the gross line so I figured as much, but good to have it confirmed.

0 coins

The gross versus net confusion is real. I thought it might be net for a while and was calculating everything wrong. EDD's calculator cleared it up for me pretty fast.

0 coins

What actually happens if you're still out after 52 weeks? Do you just get cut off with no notice or does EDD send something explaining the claim is ending?

0 coins

EDD will send a final payment notice — it's the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E — when your claim is wrapping up. That notice also comes with the form your doctor needs to submit if you need more time, which is the DE 2525XX, the supplementary certificate. You don't file a new DI claim for an extension, your existing claim continues if the doctor certifies it. But at 52 weeks DI benefits do end regardless, so if you've hit that ceiling and still can't work, that's a different conversation entirely.

0 coins

The DE 2500E form is good to know about. I didn't realize the extension form came attached to the final payment notice — I thought I'd have to find it somewhere separately.

0 coins

My extension was delayed because my doctor's office thought they had to file a new claim. Knowing it's the DE 2525XX and that EDD sends it with the payment notice would have saved me a week of back and forth.

0 coins

Payment method ended up being something I had to phone EDD about directly. SDI Online showed my claim had moved past pending but I had no idea whether payments were going to a card, direct deposit or a check in the mail. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me to an EDD disability agent who checked my claim and told me I was set up for the Money Network debit card because I hadn't enrolled in direct deposit when I filed in SDI Online. The agent said I could switch to direct deposit through SDI Online while the claim was active.

0 coins

The Money Network card — I didn't even know that was EDD's card. I was looking for something that said Bank of America on it because I thought that's what California still used.

0 coins

EDD's card is Money Network now, not Bank of America. That's the one that shows up. If you enrolled in direct deposit it goes to your bank instead, but the default when you don't choose is the Money Network card.

0 coins

Useful to know — I hadn't enrolled in direct deposit either and I was also looking for a Bank of America card. Good heads-up that it'll be the Money Network one.

0 coins

Is SDI taxable? I keep seeing different answers online and I can't tell if I should be setting aside part of each payment for taxes or not.

0 coins

California does not tax SDI benefits — that part is consistent. Whether they're taxable at the federal level depends on your situation, and that's not a one-size answer. EDD has a tax information page that covers the basics and for anything specific to your return a tax professional is the right resource. EDD itself isn't going to give you tax advice on the phone.

0 coins

Okay so California side is clear, federal side I need to look into more carefully. I'll check EDD's tax information page and maybe talk to someone before the end of the year.

0 coins

The federal part tripped me up last time. Don't just assume you're in the clear on both — worth a quick check with a tax person if you're not sure.

0 coins

Can you go back to work part time and still keep some SDI benefits? My recovery is going well and my employer is offering light duty a few hours a week but I don't want to lose the whole payment.

0 coins

You can go back part time and still receive some DI benefit, but you have to report what you're earning to EDD. How EDD pays out a partial week is their call to make based on what you report — nobody here can promise a formula. The key thing is that you report it accurately and promptly, because an overpayment notice is a lot more complicated to deal with than just reporting honestly upfront.

0 coins

Reporting it honestly upfront makes sense. I didn't want to risk an overpayment situation. I'll report the hours and let EDD do the math.

0 coins

An overpayment for not reporting part-time hours is a real thing and appealing it is a pain. Much easier to just report as you go.

0 coins

Medical certification question I had to phone EDD about — my surgeon submitted the certification but my claim sat pending for a week past the 14-day window EDD usually works within. I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach EDD's disability line. The agent looked up my claim and told me the certification had come in but the receipt number my surgeon's office used didn't match the one from my original filing, so it was sitting unmatched. EDD sent a letter about it, which I hadn't received yet. The agent told me to have the surgeon's office resubmit with the correct receipt number.

0 coins

The receipt number mismatch — that never occurred to me as something that could cause a delay. I gave my surgeon's office the receipt number right after I filed but I never confirmed they actually used it.

0 coins

It's worth confirming with the office. The receipt number is what ties their Part B submission to your Part A filing, and without that match EDD can't process the certification.

0 coins

I had to send my doctor's office the receipt number twice because the first time it didn't make it into whoever's hands actually did the SDI Online submission. A short follow-up with the office to verify they have the right number is worth the extra step.

0 coins

Is there any chance your employer made a mistake reporting your wages to EDD? I ask because that happened to my coworker and his SDI benefit was noticeably lower than it should have been until EDD corrected the wage record.

0 coins

Employer reporting errors do happen and they can lower the benefit amount if EDD has lower wages on file than what you actually earned. The way to check is to ask EDD — by phone or through the Request Claim Update in SDI Online — what wages are on file for each quarter in your base period, then compare that to your own paystubs or W-2. If there's a discrepancy, your documentation is what moves the correction forward.

0 coins

The W-2 comparison is the right move. That's what my coworker ended up doing and once EDD had the corrected wage record the benefit amount got recalculated.

0 coins

Employer reporting errors are more common than people realize. If you have your pay stubs from the base period quarters it's worth a quick check against whatever EDD has on file before you just accept the lower amount.

0 coins

What if someone's on SDI and then gets laid off? Does the SDI keep paying or does it stop and switch to unemployment?

0 coins

DI pays for the days you can't work because of the medical condition. Unemployment is for when you're able and available to work. Those two things can't overlap — EDD won't pay both for the same days. If you get laid off while you're still medically unable to work, your DI claim continues for the days you're unable to work. When your doctor clears you to return to work, that's when you can file for unemployment if you need it. EDD decides each claim on its own facts, so for anything specific to your situation the right step is to contact EDD directly.

0 coins

So the determining factor is really whether the doctor has cleared you to work or not — if you're still out medically, DI stays active regardless of the job situation?

0 coins

That's the basic framework — DI is for when you can't work, unemployment is for when you can but don't have a job. What EDD does with your specific case is theirs to decide, so don't take my word as a guarantee. Contact EDD if the layoff actually happens mid-claim.

0 coins

The DI and unemployment interaction question is one I'd definitely want answered by EDD directly and not by people online. Too many variables.

0 coins

Does the weekly SDI max stay the same the whole claim or can it change mid-claim if the state changes the formula?

0 coins

Your weekly benefit amount gets set at the start of the claim based on the base period wages at that time. It doesn't change mid-claim if the state adjusts how future claims are calculated. What's on your Notice of Computation is the rate you'll get for the duration of your claim, assuming your hours and situation stay consistent.

0 coins

So whatever the notice says at the start is locked in for the whole claim. That's actually helpful to know — I was worried a mid-year rate change would affect payments already in progress.

0 coins

Locked in from the notice is a good way to think about it. At least it makes budgeting a little more predictable once you know what the weekly amount is.

0 coins

How long does it typically take to get to the SDI max weekly benefit threshold? Like is it possible to have a high enough base period wage to hit whatever the ceiling is for the year?

0 coins

If your highest base period quarter is high enough, your calculated rate can reach the maximum weekly benefit for the year that your claim started. EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site will tell you if your wages push you to that ceiling — if the calculator spits out the same number as your notice, you're probably at the max. If the calculator shows higher than your notice, it's worth verifying the wages EDD used.

0 coins

That's a clean way to check it. I'll run the calculator and see where I land.

0 coins

The calculator is surprisingly straightforward. I used it before my claim even started just to know what to expect and it was pretty close to what my notice ended up saying.

0 coins

What's the EDD phone number for disability questions? I keep finding different numbers and I'm not sure which one to call.

0 coins

The disability line is 1-800-480-3287 for English and 1-866-658-8846 for Spanish. TTY is 1-800-563-2441. Agents are available Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Pacific, and EDD offices close on state holidays.

0 coins

Great, I had the right English number at least. Good to have the Spanish and TTY lines too.

0 coins

High call volume on that line is real, especially mid-week mornings from what I've seen. SDI Online's Request Claim Update or the Ask EDD form can be faster for questions that don't need a live person.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure