Back to California Disability

Dmitry Smirnov

What is independent medical examination for SDI claim in California EDD?

My SDI claim got approved initially and I've been receiving payments for about six weeks now, but last week I got a letter from EDD saying they want me to attend something called an independent medical examination. I've never heard of this before and my doctor already submitted the medical certification when I first filed. I'm a grad student, so I don't have anyone around who's been through the California EDD disability system to ask. The letter gives a date and an address but doesn't explain much about what actually happens there or what the examiner is looking for. Does this mean EDD is questioning whether I'm actually disabled? Could this affect my current payments? Has anyone been through one of these for a DI claim and can tell me what to expect?

An independent medical examination for a California EDD disability claim is essentially EDD's way of having a physician they select review your condition, separate from your own treating doctor. It doesn't automatically mean they're about to deny you, but it does mean they want a second opinion on whether you meet the definition of being unable to do your regular work. Attend the appointment, bring any documentation of your condition you have, and be straightforward with the examiner.

0 coins

Does the examiner's opinion override what my own doctor certified? That's the part that worries me most.

0 coins

Not automatically. EDD weighs both. If the independent examiner disagrees with your doctor, EDD issues a determination and you have the right to appeal it within 30 days of that notice's date.

0 coins

Okay that's reassuring. I didn't know an appeal was an option at that point.

0 coins

DE 2525XX had been sitting with EDD for over two weeks on my extension request, and SDI Online wasn't updating at all. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live person on the disability line, and the agent pulled up my file and confirmed the form had been received but hadn't been matched to my claim yet, so she flagged it. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. On your independent medical exam question, attending is not optional. Missing it without notifying EDD can result in your payments stopping.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for you on that line? I've called early morning, tried different days, nothing gets through. Sounds like a service that makes promises it can't keep honestly.

0 coins

Three weeks of mornings the line dropped me. Used Claimyr on a Thursday and ended up speaking with an EDD agent who confirmed the DE 2525XX was in their system. That's all I can tell you, it worked for me.

0 coins

I tried Claimyr after reading about it and got through too! The agent told me my payments were going to the default Money Network card because I had never switched to direct deposit in SDI Online, so I set that up right after the call.

0 coins

Alright that's actually useful context. Maybe I'll try it, I need to ask about why my last payment hasn't posted.

0 coins

EDD asking for an independent medical examination while your payments are still going is not unusual, it happens when they have a question about the duration or nature of a condition. What you want to avoid is skipping it. Skipped exam equals stopped payments, and then you're fighting to get them restarted.

0 coins

The letter didn't say what happens if I miss it. Good to know that's the consequence.

0 coins

Usually there's a warning in there somewhere in the fine print. Read the whole letter again, every paragraph.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but do you know if the exam is with a doctor in your specialty or just a general physician? I'd want to know that going in.

0 coins

Bring any imaging, test results, or records from your treating provider to the exam. The independent examiner is working from whatever they receive, so the more documentation of your actual condition you bring, the better picture they have.

0 coins

My treating doctor's office has records but I didn't think to request them before. Can I still get them before the exam date?

0 coins

Yes, call the office and request them. Ask specifically for the records related to this condition. Most offices can get you copies within a few days if you explain you have an upcoming appointment.

0 coins

My chiropractor got records to me in two days when I explained it was for EDD. They were really quick about it.

0 coins

Went through one of these on a back injury claim years ago. The examiner asked me to do some basic range of motion stuff and asked questions about what my job requires physically. Came prepared with a letter from my doctor laying out the restrictions. Payments kept going after.

0 coins

Did EDD tell you beforehand what kind of doctor was doing the exam or just gave you an address?

0 coins

Just an address and a time. I called the number on the letter and they told me it was an orthopedic specialist. Worth calling if you can reach anyone.

0 coins

That's helpful, I'll try calling the number on the letter to get more details before I go.

0 coins

The claim's start date on my SDI Online was showing wrong, off by two weeks from when I actually stopped working. I used Claimyr to get on the phone with EDD and the agent looked at the claim and confirmed the date that had been recorded and told me which form I needed to send to request a correction. On the independent exam itself, do not exaggerate or downplay your condition. Just describe what you actually can and cannot do.

0 coins

Wait, what's Claimyr? I've never heard of it.

0 coins

You phone EDD disability through it and it stays on the line until an agent picks up, then you're the one talking to them. That's basically the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh interesting. I've been needing to ask about my own claim start date too, mine looks like it might be off. I'll check that out.

0 coins

The start date thing is worth fixing early. If EDD has the wrong date it can affect which weeks you get paid for.

0 coins

I'm dealing with something similar and it's freaking me out a little. My disability claim is for a pregnancy complication and I got certified by my OB, and now I'm worried they might send me for an independent exam too. Does this happen on pregnancy claims as well?

0 coins

It can happen on any type of DI claim, but pregnancy claims with an OB's certification where the medical facts are straightforward tend to have fewer complications. If you get one, the process is the same as described here.

0 coins

Okay, I'll try not to spiral about it unless it actually happens. Thank you.

0 coins

I had a pregnancy claim and never got one of those letters. Hopefully yours goes fine.

0 coins

EDD's appeals information on edd.ca.gov is worth reading before the exam, not because you expect to lose, but so you know the timeline. If the independent examiner's report leads EDD to issue a Notice of Determination that reduces or ends your benefits, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file an appeal using the DE 1000A form that comes with it.

0 coins

I didn't know the appeal form comes with the determination notice. Good to know so I don't go looking for it separately.

0 coins

It's attached to the notice. And if you miss the 30 days, a late appeal requires you to explain the reason for the delay to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it. Those can differ by several days if mail is slow.

0 coins

Payments continue during the exam process until EDD issues a new determination. So keep certifying normally and don't assume anything has changed until you get a notice saying it has.

0 coins

That's actually the most useful thing I've read in this whole thread. I didn't know payments keep going in the meantime.

0 coins

Until the notice says otherwise, nothing's changed.

0 coins

my cousin had one of these for a knee thing and they just asked him to walk across the room and bend it. he was fine after. kept getting paid. dont panic too early

0 coins

Appreciate the data point even if every situation is different.

0 coins

yeah for real everyones different just saying the exam wasnt like some scary thing for him

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim looked way off when it first showed up, the weekly amount didn't match what I expected at all. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and the agent walked me through which quarter of my earnings they used for the base period calculation and confirmed the amount. Turned out my highest-paid quarter was from before I switched jobs so the number was lower than recent wages would suggest. Anyway, independent exams, go, bring records, done.

0 coins

I used Claimyr too and I'm really glad I did, couldn't get through any other way. The agent I spoke with told me there was a Notice of Determination in my file from before my current claim that I had no idea about, and she told me I still had time to appeal it. I sent the DE 1000A that week.

0 coins

What did you have ready when you talked to EDD? Like did they ask for your receipt number or Social Security number to pull up the claim?

0 coins

They asked for my Social Security number and the last four of my EDD customer account number. Had both right there and it was fine.

0 coins

The independent medical examiner doesn't work for you and doesn't work for your doctor. They give EDD an independent opinion, which EDD uses to make their own call. That's the whole arrangement. No one is on your side in that room except the information you bring in.

0 coins

That's a pretty sobering way to put it but probably accurate.

0 coins

Just want you going in without illusions about what it is.

0 coins

Blunt but fair. Take your records. Be honest. That's the best position you can be in.

0 coins

been on disability since my surgery and nobody told me these exams were even a thing. glad i found this thread before i got one of those letters

0 coins

Not everyone gets one. It depends on the specifics of the claim. But knowing the process ahead of time definitely helps.

0 coins

yeah makes sense. good to know what to do if it shows up

0 coins

My client had one of these for a shoulder thing and she said the examiner spent maybe 15 minutes with her total. She walked in, answered questions, did a few movements, walked out. EDD kept paying her. So it doesn't have to be this huge ordeal.

0 coins

Fifteen minutes? That's shorter than I expected honestly.

0 coins

That was just her experience, everyone's different, but it wasn't the nightmare she built it up to be in her head.

0 coins

For documentation purposes: bring a printed copy of your original medical certification dates, any records of your treatment appointments during the claim period, and anything that shows the progression of your condition. The examiner is essentially checking whether the picture your treating doctor painted matches what they observe.

0 coins

Should I ask my doctor to write a summary letter or just bring the records directly?

0 coins

Both if you can manage it. A brief letter from your treating physician summarizing your restrictions as of now, plus the underlying records, is a solid combination.

0 coins

That's good advice. The treating physician's letter helps contextualize the records for someone who hasn't followed your case.

0 coins

Does EDD give you any way to reschedule the exam if the date they set conflicts with something? Or is it set in stone?

0 coins

Contact the number on the letter as soon as you know there's a conflict. EDD typically needs advance notice. Don't just not show up and assume it'll be rescheduled automatically.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'd want to handle that early.

0 coins

Don't sit on it. Call the same day you notice the conflict.

0 coins

What worries me about the whole thing is what happens if the independent examiner says you can work but your own doctor still says you can't. Can you use your doctor's continued certification to fight it?

0 coins

Your doctor's certification stays in your file and is part of the record if you appeal. The appeal goes before an administrative law judge who reviews all the medical evidence, not just the independent exam.

0 coins

The DE 1000A starts the appeal, and you can submit additional supporting documentation from your treating physician as part of that process.

0 coins

Okay that's what I needed to know. So the independent exam isn't automatically the final word.

0 coins

Went through the independent exam process last year for a back issue. My treating doctor and the independent examiner actually agreed on most of the restrictions, so EDD kept paying without any issue. The key thing was I brought documentation that matched what I'd been telling EDD in my certifications all along.

0 coins

Consistency between what you've reported and what your records show seems to be the main thing.

0 coins

Exactly. I hadn't overstated anything, so there was nothing for anyone to flag.

0 coins

The EDD disability phone line is a wall. I've dialed that number on 12 separate mornings and either get a recording that the line is too busy or it drops me after 20 minutes of hold. If you need to actually ask someone about your independent exam status or what your claim shows, good luck getting through the normal way.

0 coins

I've had the same experience just trying to ask basic questions. The line is brutal.

0 coins

Two weeks of mornings I tried for my own claim. Some of us have jobs we're trying to get back to eventually.

0 coins

The hold situation is genuinely demoralizing. Hope you got your question answered eventually.

0 coins

For anyone anxious about the exam, write down a simple list of what you cannot do before you go. What daily activities are affected, what your job required that you can't do right now. That way you're not trying to explain everything on the spot from memory and you don't accidentally leave something important out.

0 coins

That's a really practical idea. I always blank when I'm put on the spot.

0 coins

Exactly! Prepare it the night before so it's just there in your hand if you need to reference it.

0 coins

Doing this for sure even if I don't end up with an exam. Just useful to have.

0 coins

After the exam the independent physician sends their report to EDD. EDD reviews it alongside your claim file. If they determine you no longer meet the disability definition, they'll mail a Notice of Determination with an Appeal Form. If they agree with your continued disability, your payments keep going without you needing to do anything extra.

0 coins

Does EDD give you a copy of the independent examiner's report or just the determination based on it?

0 coins

The determination notice is what EDD sends you. For the actual report, you'd want to ask EDD directly about how to request it, that's outside what's on their public site.

0 coins

Get the determination notice date right when it arrives. That 30-day clock starts from the date printed on it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure