Back to California Disability

Fatima Al-Sayed

What happens at SDI appeal hearing after doctor said return to work

So my doctor cleared me to go back to work at my regular job starting last Monday, but I had already filed an appeal on a denial I got a few weeks before that. The denial was for the last stretch of my claim, and now I don't even know if the hearing still matters or if I should just drop it. My supervisor expects me back and I don't want to miss my first week but I also feel like EDD owes me those weeks from before the doctor cleared me. The Notice of Determination came about six weeks ago and I filed the appeal form right away. Has anyone actually gone through an SDI appeal hearing after their doctor already gave them a return-to-work date? I have no idea what to actually expect at the hearing itself, what I'm supposed to bring, or whether going back to work before the hearing date hurts my case somehow. Really nervous about this whole thing.

Base period question tripped me up early in my appeal process, so I ended up phoning EDD's disability line to sort it out. Getting a live person on that line had been impossible for me for two solid weeks, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which quarter they used as my highest-paid quarter in the base period, which explained why my weekly amount looked lower than I expected. Knowing that before the hearing let me put together a clearer picture of the period in dispute.

0 coins

Claimyr reads like something a marketing team put together. I've seen too many of these posted around forums. What actually happened when you called, and did the person who answered identify themselves as an EDD employee?

0 coins

Thought the same thing when I first saw it. Went ahead and tried anyway because I'd been trying the 1-800-480-3287 line every morning for nine days straight. Agent I spoke with confirmed EDD had received my DE 2593 and told me the 20-day return window. That was an EDD employee, answered questions about my claim directly.

0 coins

Alright, that's enough for me to give it a shot. Got a base period question of my own to sort out before my hearing.

0 coins

Returning to work before the hearing date does not automatically end your appeal. The appeal covers the weeks EDD denied before the return-to-work date, so those days are still in dispute regardless of what you do now. Keep your first day back documented clearly, pay stub, any email from your supervisor, that kind of thing, because the hearing officer will want to see the boundary between the period you're claiming and the day you returned.

0 coins

That's really helpful, I wasn't sure if showing up at work would somehow cancel the whole thing. So the hearing is really just about the denied weeks before Monday?

0 coins

Exactly right. The administrative law judge looks at whether you were unable to do your regular work during the denied period. What your doctor says now about being cleared is a separate matter from what the medical certification said about those earlier weeks.

0 coins

Wait, so the judge only looks at the weeks on the denial notice, not at anything after? I think I assumed the whole claim got reopened somehow. Not sure if that's how it works.

0 coins

The Notice of Determination on EDD's site covers this. The appeal is for the specific period named in that notice. The administrative law judge reviews whether EDD's decision for those weeks was correct, not the entire claim history.

0 coins

Two hearings in on separate claims now and both times the judge asked me to walk through my work duties first, then compared them to what my doctor certified I couldn't do. Bring the actual denial notice, your medical records if you have them, and anything from your employer about your job requirements. The judge runs it pretty informally, you can explain things in plain language.

0 coins

What about if the job changed while you were out? My duties shifted and I'm not sure which version the medical cert was written against.

0 coins

Tell the judge exactly that. The job description that existed when your disability started is what matters. If it changed after, say so and explain when.

0 coins

Mine is warehouse receiving, pretty physical. My doctor's notes from during the claim period are very specific about lifting restrictions. I'm guessing that's the kind of documentation I want ready.

0 coins

That's the core of it. If the cert says no lifting over a certain amount and your job requires it, that's your argument right there.

0 coins

My appeal hearing went forward about three weeks after I went back to work and it was fine. The judge focused entirely on whether I had a qualifying disability during the denied weeks. I brought the denial letter, my doctor's notes from those weeks, and a written statement from my doctor about what I couldn't do at the time. The hearing itself took maybe 30 minutes over the phone.

0 coins

Phone hearing, not in person? I didn't realize that was an option. Did you request that or was it automatic?

0 coins

It was scheduled that way by default. I think most of them are phone hearings now. You can ask to change it if you have a reason, but I found the phone format pretty manageable.

0 coins

Mine was phone too. Went faster than I expected.

0 coins

Appeal form asks for a detailed explanation of why you disagree, did you write much on yours or just say you disagree? I sent mine in kind of quick because of the 30-day deadline and I'm worried I didn't put enough there anyway.

0 coins

You can still submit additional documentation before the hearing date. The judge reads whatever you send in advance. Write out your explanation now, include any medical records from that period, and mail it to the return address on the notice so it gets into the file.

0 coins

ok good, I've got my doctor's notes from the whole stretch and some texts from my employer about why I couldn't modify my duties. I'll put together a letter and send it in this week.

0 coins

The appeal form is the DE 1000A. If you no longer have it, a detailed letter works as long as it's mailed to the address on the denial notice and arrives before the hearing.

0 coins

Don't overthink the hearing. I went in thinking it would be like court and it wasn't. The judge asked questions, I answered, it was done. If you have your medical cert and the denial letter you're in decent shape.

0 coins

Did you have a lawyer or did you just go by yourself? I keep seeing mentions of legal representation and I don't have money for that right now.

0 coins

Went alone. Most people do. You know your own situation better than any lawyer would anyway.

0 coins

Representation helps in complicated cases but it's definitely not required. The administrative law judge is used to claimants explaining things themselves.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim had been wrong since I filed and I finally reached someone by using Claimyr to get to EDD's disability line after too many failed attempts on my own. The agent confirmed my payment was set to the debit card and walked me through switching to direct deposit in SDI Online while we were on the phone. Sorted out in one call what I'd been trying to fix for weeks.

0 coins

Did you have to do anything in SDI Online before the call or did the agent handle the whole thing?

0 coins

Agent confirmed what was on file and told me where to find the payment method option in SDI Online. I made the actual change myself while we were talking, pretty straightforward once I knew where to look.

0 coins

ive been hitting that line since tuesday morning, same recording every time, cuts off after a minute. how many days did it take you before you tried that

0 coins

Return to work date and appeal hearing date being close together isn't unusual. The hearing decides what EDD owed you for the denied weeks. Those weeks don't disappear because you're back now.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes me feel a lot better. I've been thinking the whole thing was moot now that I'm back.

0 coins

Not moot. You're asking for money owed for time you were out. The hearing settles that.

0 coins

Are the denied weeks ones where EDD already issued a Notice of Determination, or is there a part of the claim that's still just showing pending? The two situations go through different processes and it matters for what you bring to the hearing.

0 coins

The denial is from the Notice of Determination I got. Specific date range named in it. The earlier weeks of my claim were paid, it was just this last stretch they denied.

0 coins

Then your hearing file should already have EDD's reason for the denial. Ask the administrative law judge's office if you can review the file before your hearing date so you know exactly what argument you're responding to.

0 coins

That's a good practical step. Knowing EDD's stated reason ahead of time lets you bring documentation that speaks directly to it rather than guessing.

0 coins

my claim got denied for the last two weeks too and i have no idea how to appeal. is the form the same one thats on the denial letter

0 coins

The DE 1000A is attached to the Notice of Determination. If you've misplaced yours, write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the return address printed on the denial notice. The 30-day window runs from the date on that notice.

0 coins

ok 30 days from the date on the letter not from when i got it, got it

0 coins

Correct, the date printed on the notice is the date the clock starts, not the date it arrived in your mailbox.

0 coins

I'm worried about my case a little differently. My doctor cleared me to return to work in a modified capacity and EDD denied the last four weeks saying I wasn't totally restricted. The cert said light duty only. I'm not sure if light duty counts as unable to work for SDI purposes.

0 coins

Your regular or customary job duties are the standard EDD uses. If your normal job requires tasks your doctor said you couldn't do, even a light-duty restriction can support the claim. Bring the original job description and the specific restrictions your doctor listed at the time.

0 coins

My job is retail stocking, definitely involves lifting. The cert from that period lists a ten-pound limit. That's pretty directly in conflict with what I normally do.

0 coins

Then put that side by side at the hearing. The cert's restriction against your actual job duties is exactly what the judge will evaluate.

0 coins

That kind of clear mismatch between the restriction and the job requirements is usually the strongest type of appeal case. Put it in writing before the hearing date.

0 coins

Medical certification had been sitting unmatched for over two weeks on my own claim and I finally reached an EDD agent through Claimyr after getting nowhere on the disability line for days. Agent told me my doctor had submitted the cert but used a slightly different version of my first name and it wasn't matching to my claim. EDD flagged it and my doctor's office sent a corrected submission the same week.

0 coins

The notice I got shows a different benefit start date than I expected and I want to ask EDD directly which weeks they applied the waiting period to. I'll try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready before that call?

0 coins

Have your claim ID from SDI Online and the Notice of Computation ready. The agent will pull the claim and go through the specific dates with you.

0 coins

Waiting period confusion is real. Mine ran from the first seven days of the disability and I kept thinking it was processing time until someone here corrected me.

0 coins

The hearing officer isn't there to catch you out. In my experience they want a clear timeline, when the disability started, what the doctor certified, and what your job actually requires. Keep it factual and don't get into arguing what EDD should have done differently.

0 coins

That's the right approach. Stick to what happened, not how annoyed you are at EDD.

0 coins

Noted. I do have some frustration built up but I'll leave that at the door.

0 coins

My appeal took almost eight weeks from filing the form to the actual hearing date, so try not to panic if the scheduling feels slow. The wait is normal and the hearing itself is usually pretty short!

0 coins

Eight weeks is what I keep hearing from people. Filed mine three weeks ago so sounds like I've got more waiting ahead.

0 coins

Use the time to get your documentation together. Having everything organized before the date makes the hearing itself much calmer!

0 coins

Going back to work before the hearing is actually pretty common and the judges know it. People can't put their lives on hold waiting for a hearing date. Just be clear about the exact date you returned and have something from your employer that confirms it.

0 coins

My first shift back was last Monday. I saved the schedule and I'll print the email my supervisor sent. Is that enough?

0 coins

That should cover it. The return-to-work date just needs to be clear, what you bring sounds fine.

0 coins

Saved my first post-claim pay stub too, just to have another date reference.

0 coins

the waiting period thing got me on my first claim. thought it was seven days of processing time. its seven days they just dont pay, its not about how long edd takes to review anything

0 coins

I made the same mistake. The first seven days of a new claim are non-payable. Processing is a separate thing on top of that.

0 coins

yeah two separate things, made my payment come out different than i thought it would

0 coins

Bring the medical certification from the denied period, the denial notice, and something that shows your job duties during those weeks. The judge needs to see what your work actually required. Clear documentation of the gap between what your doctor said you couldn't do and what your job demands is the strongest thing you can walk in with.

0 coins

Can the doctor send anything directly to the administrative law judge or does everything have to come through the claimant?

0 coins

Your doctor can submit a written statement or letter for the record. Contact the hearing office to find out how they accept it, usually mail to the address on the scheduling notice.

0 coins

Mine said they'd provide a letter if I needed one. Good to know I can actually use it.

0 coins

EDD's appeals information is on edd.ca.gov and it lays out what documents the administrative law judge reviews. Worth reading before the hearing so you're not surprised by the format. The DE 1000A is the standard appeal form but a letter with the same information works if the form got lost.

0 coins

is there a way to check the status of the appeal online through sdi online or is it all by mail

0 coins

Status updates on appeals generally come by mail. SDI Online shows claim information but the appeal process runs through the Appeals Board, so mail is the main channel for hearing notices and decisions.

0 coins

Got my hearing date notice by mail about five weeks after I filed the form. Nothing showed up online for it.

0 coins

Claimant preparation matters more than people expect going into these hearings. The judge reads EDD's file in advance, so they already know EDD's reason for the denial when you walk in. If your documentation directly contradicts that reason, your case is in a much better position than if you're just saying EDD got it wrong without specifics.

0 coins

This is the part most people skip. They show up expecting to explain and don't bring anything to back it up. Documents do more work than words at that table.

0 coins

I've been making a folder all week. Denial notice, doctor's notes by date, job description, and the schedule from my employer showing what I normally lift. Feels more organized now than when I first posted.

0 coins

That's a solid set of materials. Having it organized by date helps the judge follow the timeline without asking you to dig around.

0 coins

One thing I didn't expect at my hearing was the judge asking me to describe a typical workday in detail, not just my job title. Think through that before you go in so you can answer clearly without fumbling.

0 coins

Good call. I do receiving so I'll think through the full shift, unloading, scanning, shelving, all of it.

0 coins

Physical specifics matter. Pounds, heights, how often. The more precise you are the more it lines up with what your cert actually says.

0 coins

Something worth checking before the hearing: the Notice of Computation should be in your SDI Online file and shows the weekly benefit for the disputed period. If the denied weeks fall inside the same claim, the amount the judge can award should match that figure. Worth knowing before you go in so there are no surprises.

0 coins

Mine is in SDI Online and I checked it yesterday. The weekly amount lines up with what I calculated based on my pay from that quarter, which I guess is a good sign.

0 coins

If it matches what you expected then no issue there. The Notice of Computation is what it is, the hearing is about whether you were owed those weeks, not about adjusting the amount.

0 coins

Late appeal because you missed the 30-day window is a different situation. Need to explain the delay and an administrative law judge decides whether to let it in. If yours was filed within 30 days of the notice date you don't have to worry about that part.

0 coins

Filed mine the week I got the notice, so I'm well within 30 days.

0 coins

Then that's not your problem. Focus on the substance.

0 coins

What counts as a good reason for a late appeal if someone missed the window? Not sure if there's a list anywhere.

0 coins

There's no fixed list. The administrative law judge reviews whatever explanation you give for the delay and decides whether to allow it. The appeal form has a section for it, or you can explain in a letter.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure