Back to California Disability

Abigail Spencer

Should I switch from unemployment to SDI after having a baby — California EDD question

So I had my baby three weeks ago and I was on unemployment when I went into labor because my job had laid me off about a month before my due date. I kept certifying for unemployment through the birth because honestly I had no idea what else to do. Now someone in my mom group mentioned that I should have switched to SDI when I stopped being able to work before the birth, and I'm kind of panicking that I've been doing this whole thing wrong. Can you even do that now that the baby is here? I'm still not back on my feet, definitely not ready to go back to any job. Do I need to file a new SDI claim or is it too late? I don't even know if unemployment was the wrong call the whole time or if it's fine since I didn't have a job to go back to anyway. Any help would be like genuinely so appreciated right now.

Waiting period question tripped me up on my own claim, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent about it. I tried that line for days and got nowhere, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to someone. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed my waiting period was days one through seven of the claim, the first payable day was day eight, and that it's not the same thing as processing time. Video on reaching someone on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Knowing that cleared up why my first payment looked short.

0 coins

I want to ask EDD whether the waiting period on my claim got counted right, because my first payment seemed off. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the dates of your disability period ready. The agent can pull up exactly which days they applied the waiting period to.

0 coins

Wait so the waiting period is literally just the first seven days of the claim and doesn't mean you're waiting for EDD to process things? That's news to me, I thought it was both.

0 coins

Yes, that's correct. The waiting period is specifically the first seven calendar days of a new claim, and they are simply not payable. It has nothing to do with how long EDD takes to review the paperwork.

0 coins

Unemployment and disability at the same time, is that actually allowed? I thought you could collect both while you're out?

0 coins

EDD's own language on this is pretty direct: you can't receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same days. Unemployment requires you to be able to work and looking for work every week you claim it, so once you couldn't work before the birth, unemployment wasn't really the right fit anymore.

0 coins

Oh that's what I was afraid of. So if she was certifying for unemployment while she physically couldn't work, those weeks could be a problem?

0 coins

Possibly, yes. EDD can find an overpayment if you certified for unemployment during weeks you were unable to work. The right move is to contact EDD and sort out which weeks are which before they catch it on their own.

0 coins

You can still file an SDI claim. The window is 49 days from when the disability started. Count back from the day you couldn't do your normal work, whether that was before or at the birth, and see where you land.

0 coins

My disability honestly started maybe a week or two before I delivered because I was having complications. Does that change when the 49 days starts?

0 coins

If your provider certifies that you couldn't work starting at that earlier date, then the clock runs from there. Get with your doctor's office fast and find out what date they'd put on the medical certification.

0 coins

The 49-day rule is real and firm. After that window you risk disqualification. If you're close to the edge, file your part in SDI Online today and let the doctor submit the medical certification right after.

0 coins

wait so she was on unemployment through her whole pregnancy and nobody told her about sdi? that seems like a gap

0 coins

EDD doesn't exactly hold your hand through these transitions. You're supposed to know the rules and sort it out yourself, which is a lot to ask when you just had a baby and lost your job in the same month.

0 coins

yeah thats rough, like how is anyone supposed to figure that out

0 coins

Forums like this end up being where people actually find out. Official EDD materials aren't always easy to connect to real situations.

0 coins

To answer the core question directly: unemployment and SDI cover different situations. Unemployment is for when you are able and available to work but don't have a job. SDI covers the period when a medical condition, including pregnancy and recovery from childbirth, prevents you from doing your regular work. If your condition kept you from working, those weeks belong to SDI, not unemployment. File your claim in SDI Online through myEDD as soon as possible and have your provider submit the medical certification right away.

0 coins

So for the weeks right after delivery when I literally could not go back to work, those are the SDI weeks?

0 coins

Typically six weeks after a standard birth, eight after a Caesarean. Your provider can certify a longer period if there were complications. Those weeks are what SDI is designed to cover.

0 coins

I'm not sure if this applies here, but I think she said she was laid off before the birth. Does not having a job change whether SDI pays out?

0 coins

Being laid off doesn't automatically disqualify a person from SDI. What matters is whether there were enough wages subject to SDI in the base period before the claim. The Notice of Computation will show the weekly amount once the claim is in.

0 coins

The overlap between unemployment and SDI around a pregnancy is genuinely confusing and EDD's phone line is useless for getting a quick answer. I tried calling early morning three days in a row during my own claim and got the same recording every time.

0 coins

Same problem here. Line just dumps you after a few minutes. No actual person.

0 coins

And this is exactly the kind of situation where you need a real answer, not a web page. The specific dates matter, the specific weeks matter.

0 coins

It's exhausting. Mine took two weeks to even get through once.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared about the overpayment angle. If she certified for unemployment during weeks she couldn't work, does that mean she for sure owes money back?

0 coins

Not automatically, but it's a real risk. EDD can issue an overpayment notice if they determine she wasn't eligible for unemployment those weeks. If that happens, there is an appeal process, 30 days from the date on the notice to file.

0 coins

Okay that's slightly less terrifying. So she should file the SDI claim now and then wait to see if EDD sends anything about the unemployment weeks?

0 coins

Filing the SDI claim now is the right first step. Keep records of every date and every form submitted. If a Notice of Determination or overpayment notice comes, the dates on file will matter for any appeal.

0 coins

The base period question is what I ended up having to call EDD about on my own maternity claim! SDI Online showed my potential benefit amount but I had no idea which quarter of my earnings they actually used to get there. I tried the phone line four mornings in a row, nothing. Eventually I got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com). The agent told me which specific quarter of my wages they pulled and confirmed it was my highest-paid quarter from the base period. That explained why my weekly amount was what it was instead of what I guessed from a different quarter.

0 coins

My weekly amount on the Notice of Computation also didn't match what I expected, and I had used Claimyr too on a different question. Once the agent confirmed my payment date for the first issued payment, I went into SDI Online to verify the deposit and everything lined up. The base period calculation really does explain most surprises on that notice.

0 coins

Days of trying that line and nothing, so hearing people actually got through is wild. How many mornings did it take before you got someone?

0 coins

For me it was after a week of not getting anywhere on my own. Once I had the agent on the line I just asked about that one quarter and she read off the exact dates and wage amount they used.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation isn't an approval, it just shows what the amount could be? I keep seeing people say that.

0 coins

Correct. The Notice of Computation shows the potential weekly and maximum benefit. It doesn't mean the claim is approved, just that EDD has calculated what it would pay if everything checks out.

0 coins

Don't overthink the PFL part yet. Finish the SDI part first. SDI is the disability and recovery weeks. PFL bonding after that is a separate claim you file when SDI ends. One thing at a time.

0 coins

That is actually so helpful. I keep seeing PFL mentioned and I didn't know if I needed to file for both at once.

0 coins

No. SDI first for your recovery, then PFL for bonding after. They're separate.

0 coins

Is the PFL waiting period the same as SDI's seven days?

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period. That seven-day non-payable period applies to SDI claims only.

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online through myEDD, is that the only way, or can you do it on paper? Asking for someone who isn't great with computers.

0 coins

Paper is still an option. The form is the DE 2501, Claim for Disability Insurance Benefits. The claimant fills out Part A and the provider completes Part B and mails it in within 49 days of the disability start date. SDI Online is faster but not the only path.

0 coins

Good to know. The 49-day deadline applies either way though, right?

0 coins

Yes, same deadline regardless of paper or online. And with paper, the receipt number process works differently: the provider gets the form directly from the claimant rather than looking it up in SDI Online.

0 coins

to be fair she was laid off a month before the birth, so unemployment made sense at the start. the problem is staying on it once she physically couldnt work anymore

0 coins

That's the exact moment the switch should happen. The day you can no longer do your regular work because of the pregnancy or complications, that's when SDI starts, not unemployment.

0 coins

yeah and nobody tells you that in real time. you just figure it out after.

0 coins

filing the claim now even if the dates are messy seems better than waiting and missing the window entirely

0 coins

That's the right call. File first, sort the details out as the claim processes. Missing the 49-day window is the one thing you can't fix later.

0 coins

Yeah waiting only makes it worse.

0 coins

Does the doctor have to certify the whole period going back to before the birth, or just the current recovery period?

0 coins

The provider certifies the full period of disability they can attest to. If complications before the birth are part of it, the start date would reflect that. The provider needs to be specific about when the disability began and when they expect it to end or be reassessed.

0 coins

So I should tell my provider to include the pre-birth weeks if those weeks were actually when I stopped being able to work?

0 coins

Bring the full timeline to your provider's appointment and let them document what they can confirm. They certify based on what they can verify clinically, so give them the full picture.

0 coins

This is a good reminder that the doctor's side of this is so important. I've been focused on what I do in SDI Online and not enough on making sure the medical certification has everything.

0 coins

Payment method ended up being the thing I had to sort out by phone on my own claim. I had filed online and assumed direct deposit was set up, but I hadn't actually selected it, so payments were going to a card instead. Got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com) after spending three mornings hitting the same dead end on the disability line. The agent confirmed no direct deposit was on file and told me I could update it in SDI Online under my payment preferences. Switched it over the same day.

0 coins

Spending three mornings on that line and getting nothing is exactly what I'd expect. I tried eight or nine times across two weeks on my last claim and got through once, then got cut off. Hard to believe people are reaching actual agents.

0 coins

The line really is that bad, I'm not exaggerating. The agent I spoke with was an EDD employee, answered my specific question about the deposit, nothing fancy. I just finally had a way to get there.

0 coins

My direct deposit for my current claim never showed up either. The agent I spoke with told me which weeks had been paid out. Sorted it out from there.

0 coins

Wait, I think I may have done the same thing. Filed online and assumed direct deposit was automatic. I need to check my payment settings.

0 coins

check it today honestly, don't wait to see if the card shows up

0 coins

Two questions from me: does she need to tell EDD about the unemployment weeks before they figure it out themselves, and is there any form specifically for that? Trying to understand the sequence here anyway.

0 coins

EDD will likely reconcile records on their own eventually. That said, proactively filing the correct claim now establishes the right dates on record. There's no specific form for self-reporting the overlap, but the SDI claim's dates will create a paper trail.

0 coins

So the SDI claim itself kind of fixes the record by putting the right start date out there?

0 coins

It establishes when the disability began, yes. EDD then has both the unemployment certifications and the SDI start date on file and can determine how to handle any overlap. If they find an issue, you'll get a written notice with appeal rights.

0 coins

my coworker had a baby and got both unemployment and sdi at the same time and nobody said anything to her about it

0 coins

That's not how the rules are written. EDD says you can't receive both for the same days. It's possible EDD didn't catch it, or the weeks didn't actually overlap, but it's not something they allow when found.

0 coins

ok yeah i shouldnt have said she definitely got both, maybe i misunderstood what she told me

0 coins

EDD catches these things on the backend sometimes, not right away. Getting a notice a year later is a thing.

0 coins

The medical certification was my sticking point. Provider submitted through SDI Online but the claim just sat pending and nobody could tell me what was wrong. Tried the EDD line for two weeks, different times of day, couldn't get a person. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and reached an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and said the medical certification was there but the receipt number my provider used didn't match the one on my claim. That was the whole problem.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? I've never heard of it, how does it work?

0 coins

It handles the hold time on EDD's line so you end up talking to a live agent yourself. That's about all there is to it.

0 coins

Ah okay. My extension request is sitting out there with no update and I've been wanting to ask EDD whether they even received the DE 2525XX from my provider. Might use it for that.

0 coins

The receipt number mismatch is actually something I saw warned about in a different thread. The provider needs the specific number from your claim, not just a general form ID.

0 coins

If the SDI claim gets approved for the recovery period, does that automatically affect the unemployment claim for the overlapping weeks?

0 coins

EDD will see the SDI claim dates and the unemployment certifications. Any determination about an overpayment on the unemployment side would come through a separate notice with its own appeal window.

0 coins

Okay. So two separate processes, not one decision that handles both.

0 coins

Exactly right. Each program's claim is reviewed on its own. If EDD finds the unemployment weeks were improper, that notice will come separately from the SDI determination.

0 coins

For anyone unsure whether complications before birth count toward the disability start date, the answer is yes if your provider can certify them. You don't have to wait until the actual birth to start the SDI period.

0 coins

This is the part I wish I had known. I had real complications in the last couple weeks and I just thought SDI only started after delivery.

0 coins

Lots of people assume that. If your provider documented the complications and you couldn't work because of them, those weeks can be part of the claim.

0 coins

Does that mean the waiting period would start from the complication date, not the birth date?

0 coins

If the provider certifies a disability start date before the birth, then yes, the seven-day waiting period would run from that earlier date, and the first payable day would be the eighth day from there.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the myEDD portal at least shows you where your claim stands once it's in the system. It's not perfect but checking it after filing gives you a sense of whether the medical certification showed up.

0 coins

I just want to know what I should actually do first tomorrow morning. File the SDI claim in SDI Online, call the OB to tell them I'm filing, give them the receipt number after I file, and then wait?

0 coins

That sequence is right. File your part first to get the receipt number, give that number to your provider right away so they can find the claim and submit the medical certification, then watch SDI Online for updates. EDD typically reaches out within 14 days of receiving a completed claim.

0 coins

And save every confirmation screen and email. The receipt number especially.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure