Back to California Disability

Yara Elias

Should I choose unemployment SDI after surgery which pays more in California?

So I had a pretty major back surgery last month and my doc says I'm looking at 10-12 weeks before I can even think about returning to work. My employer technically let me go right before the procedure, layoff situation, so now I'm sitting here trying to figure out what makes sense. Should I choose unemployment SDI after surgery which pays more? I filed for SDI already but someone at my old job said unemployment might be a better deal. I honestly have no idea how these two even interact. Anyone been in this situation?

The layoff timing here is what changes everything. While you cannot work because of your recovery, unemployment is not an option for you. Unemployment requires that you be able to work and available every single week you claim it. If your surgeon has you restricted from your regular duties, you do not meet that test. SDI is exactly what it is there for in your situation.

0 coins

So basically I can't collect both at the same time no matter what? Even if I wanted to?

0 coins

Correct. EDD is clear that you cannot receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same days. When you are able and available to work again after recovery, you can file for unemployment then.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps a lot. Didn't realize it was that cut and dry.

0 coins

The 'which pays more' question is kind of moot when one of them you don't qualify for yet. Your weekly SDI amount is based on your highest-earning quarter in a base period from about 5 to 18 months back. EDD's site has a calculator that'll give you an estimate. Check that before assuming anything about what you'd get.

0 coins

Does the calculator give you a pretty accurate number or is it just a rough estimate?

0 coins

It's an estimate. Your actual weekly amount is on the Notice of Computation that EDD mails once the claim is processed. That's the real number.

0 coins

Got it, so the calculator is just for ballpark planning and the notice is what actually matters.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim didn't match what my provider had on file, and my claim just sat there. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number my surgeon's office used was off by one digit, which was why the medical certification hadn't attached. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once my provider resubmitted with the right number it moved within a few days.

0 coins

I used Claimyr too after my own claim just sat pending for two weeks with nothing moving. The agent I reached checked my Notice of Computation and read me the weekly amount on file, which was actually higher than the calculator had shown me. I was pretty relieved to know what to actually expect each week.

0 coins

Wait, the Notice of Computation the agent read you, did it already show on SDI Online or did you only find out from the call?

0 coins

Honestly it hadn't appeared in SDI Online yet when I called. The agent could see it on their end. It showed up in my account a couple days later.

0 coins

So the receipt number thing is real, my surgeon's office just said they submitted but I never confirmed which number they used.

0 coins

Ask your surgeon's office specifically which receipt number they entered when they filed. Don't assume they used the right one. Learned that one the hard way.

0 coins

Is there a way to look up what number they'd need to use or does the claimant have to give it to them?

0 coins

You got it when you filed on SDI Online, it's on that confirmation screen. Give it to the office directly, don't leave it to them to find it.

0 coins

Makes sense, I'll pull mine up and send it to my doctor's office today.

0 coins

The SDI versus unemployment question tripped me up at first too. I kept thinking since I lost my job, unemployment was my thing. But my physical therapist said to file SDI, which I did, and then someone at EDD corrected me anyway because I was still not cleared to work. The timing of when you can go back is everything here.

0 coins

Just to push back a little, a physical therapist can't certify an SDI claim, right? That's not on EDD's list of who can sign off on the medical part.

0 coins

You're right about that. EDD's list of who can certify covers physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, and a few others but a physical therapist is not among them. The medical certification has to come from someone on that list.

0 coins

Oh I did not know that. My doctor did the actual certification, the PT just gave me the advice to file. So I think it was fine in the end.

0 coins

Ten to twelve weeks out from back surgery, you're squarely in SDI territory. File, get your doctor to do the certification, wait out the seven-day waiting period, and payments usually start moving within two weeks after EDD has everything. Unemployment is for when you're on your feet again.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period, is that seven days after I filed or seven days from when surgery happened?

0 coins

Seven days from when your disability started, which in your case is probably around your surgery date. That whole first week is non-payable no matter what.

0 coins

Okay so it's not like a processing delay, it's just a straight up unpaid week built into the claim.

0 coins

Exactly. It's not EDD dragging its feet. It's just how the program works.

0 coins

cant get unemployment when youre literally not able to work lol that would be wild. edd would just deny it anyway

0 coins

yeah they check that pretty fast apparently

0 coins

my buddy tried to do both at the same time once and edd caught it immediately

0 coins

Payment on week three of my own surgery claim didn't post when I expected. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the line and they pulled up which weeks had been paid and which were still pending. Agent said week three had issued that morning and to check my account in a day or two, which I did and it was there.

0 coins

The whole thing sounds like a marketing pitch to me honestly. You really just ended up talking to an actual EDD person?

0 coins

I had the same doubt when I first saw it mentioned somewhere. Tried it anyway when my own waiting period question wasn't getting answered through SDI Online messages. The agent confirmed the exact start date of my claim and walked me through how the seven days counted from my first restricted day, not from when I filed. It was a real EDD person.

0 coins

Okay that's more convincing. I might just try it, been sitting on a question about my own payments for a week now.

0 coins

Sorry if this is a dumb question but when you switch from SDI to unemployment after recovery, do you have to do anything special or just file for unemployment at that point?

0 coins

Filing for unemployment when you're ready to return is a separate process from your SDI claim. You'd file a new unemployment claim at that time. The two programs don't automatically hand off to each other, you initiate it.

0 coins

And SDI would just end when my doctor clears me? Or do I have to close it out somehow?

0 coins

You report when you go back to work. If you go back part time, you report that too. EDD handles how a partial week pays out.

0 coins

My clients ask me this constantly at the salon. The short answer I always give them: if you physically can't work right now, it's SDI. When you're cleared and looking for a job, then you think about unemployment. The two don't overlap.

0 coins

That's a pretty clean way to explain it honestly. I work in retail and had the same confusion when I had my own surgery last year.

0 coins

It really is that simple in practice. The confusing part is when someone loses their job AND has a medical thing going on at the same time, like this person, because you feel like you should be on something for the job loss too.

0 coins

Yeah the layoff part makes it feel like unemployment should apply right away. But recovery comes first.

0 coins

The base period wage question is worth looking at closely. Your SDI weekly amount comes from your highest-earning quarter in roughly the year before your claim, not what you were earning right before the layoff. If your earnings were higher a year ago than recently, that could actually help your SDI amount.

0 coins

Huh I hadn't thought about that. My earnings were actually stronger earlier in the year before things slowed down at my company.

0 coins

Worth running through EDD's calculator with those earlier earnings plugged in. You might be surprised. And the Notice of Computation will show you exactly which quarter they used.

0 coins

The quarter they use is the highest-paid one in the base period, so plugging in a few different scenarios in the calculator helps you understand what to expect before the notice arrives.

0 coins

The waiting period thing confused me so much when I filed! I kept thinking EDD had lost my claim for the first week. Nope, just the unpaid waiting period doing its thing. Once I understood that it's baked into every new claim, I relaxed a lot.

0 coins

I made the same mistake. I called my doctor's office in a panic thinking the certification hadn't gone through. It had, it was just the waiting period.

0 coins

Right! And then payments started on the eighth day and I was like okay this actually works. Good luck to everyone here!

0 coins

One thing about the unemployment side that's worth flagging: even if EDD pays you unemployment while you're still recovering, they can come back later with an overpayment notice asking for the money back. I've seen that happen to someone in my building. Not worth the risk.

0 coins

To be clear on the rule there: you simply cannot receive both for the same days. It's not a gray area. If EDD paid both and later found out, an overpayment notice would follow and you'd have to pay back what you weren't entitled to.

0 coins

Yeah exactly. And appealing an overpayment is a whole thing. Just don't do both.

0 coins

The appeal window on an overpayment notice is 30 days from the date on it. If you miss that you're in a worse spot.

0 coins

From a clinical standpoint, your surgeon's restrictions are what matter to EDD, not how you feel day to day. If you're restricted from your regular duties, you're on disability. Document everything your provider says about work limitations.

0 coins

My surgeon has me on full restriction until my next follow-up. So that covers me for now I guess.

0 coins

That's what EDD needs. Your provider's certification of those restrictions is the medical part of your claim.

0 coins

DE 2593 came to me around week 11 and I almost missed the 20-day return window. If you go on automatic payments, that form shows up after about 10 weeks and you need to respond or your benefits stop. Worth setting a reminder the day your claim starts.

0 coins

Nobody told me about that form. What is it exactly?

0 coins

It's EDD checking whether you're still unable to work. Answer it within 20 days or benefits stop. It's called the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire.

0 coins

Setting a reminder right now. Thank you.

0 coins

DE 2593 situation on my own claim: EDD sent it, I returned it, but my payments paused anyway. Used Claimyr to reach an agent and they confirmed EDD had received the form but my response hadn't been processed yet. Agent said it was in and to watch for benefits to resume in a few days, which they did.

0 coins

When you talked to the agent, did they say whether you needed to do anything else on your end or just wait?

0 coins

Just wait. The agent said the form was received and nothing more was needed from me. That was the whole answer, which was actually a relief.

0 coins

been trying that disability line for three weeks straight and can never get through. good to know something actually worked for someone

0 coins

Worth knowing too that SDI can run up to 52 weeks. For a 10-12 week recovery you're nowhere near that limit, so you have room if your doctor ends up extending you.

0 coins

Okay 52 weeks is a lot longer than I thought. I assumed it was capped at something shorter.

0 coins

Nope, 52 weeks is the max for DI. Extensions go through your doctor who submits a supplementary certificate, you don't file a new claim.

0 coins

Wait the extension is on the doctor's side, not the claimant's? I thought the claimant had to request it somehow.

0 coins

The physician submits a form called the DE 2525XX for any extension. EDD typically sends it with your final payment notice. You don't start a new claim, your provider just certifies the additional time.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in on a claim I had a couple years back and I had no idea what it meant. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent and they explained that my claim wasn't payable and walked me through what the determination said, that I had 30 days from the notice date to appeal if I disagreed. Ended up filing the appeal form from the notice itself.

0 coins

My delivery app took a hit and I've been trying to reach EDD about whether my gig income even counted for the base period calculation. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I try it?

0 coins

Have your claim ID and Social Security number right in front of you. Also pull up SDI Online before the call so you can see your claim status while you're talking to the agent.

0 coins

Got it, will do. Been leaving messages in SDI Online for days with nothing.

0 coins

The layoff right before surgery is tough timing but it doesn't disqualify you from SDI. What matters is whether you paid into SDI through your CASDI deductions while you were working. If those are on your pay stubs, you contributed and you're eligible to claim.

0 coins

They were definitely deducted every paycheck. I used to look at them and wonder what they were even for.

0 coins

Now you know what they were for.

0 coins

That's the whole deal. Workers pay in, workers draw from it when they need it.

0 coins

The first time I filed I was convinced I had to choose between SDI and unemployment and that picking wrong would mess up everything. EDD's site actually lays it out pretty clearly once you find the right section. You can't do both at the same time, and while recovering from surgery the choice kind of makes itself.

0 coins

I spent days overthinking this exact question before my own claim. The 'able and available to work' test for unemployment is what settled it for me. I clearly wasn't either.

0 coins

Exactly. If your doctor has you restricted, that test answers it for you without any math involved.

0 coins

after my injury last year i was so stressed about this same thing. filed sdi and it worked out fine. dont overthink it just file and let the process go

0 coins

Did you have any issues with the medical certification side of it?

0 coins

my doctor was slow about it and i had to remind them like twice. once they got it in everything moved though

0 coins

After recovery, when your surgeon clears you, file for unemployment at that point if you're still without a job. EDD treats each claim separately. SDI for the medical period, unemployment when you're able and looking. That's the right sequence.

0 coins

That actually makes total sense now. I was trying to figure out if I should file both right now and I was worried about doing something wrong.

0 coins

You're not missing a window by waiting. You can't legally claim unemployment while you're unable to work anyway, so when you're cleared is the right moment to file.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure