Back to California Disability

Jackie Martinez

Should I appeal SDI denial wait for doctor form to be reviewed or do both?

Filed my claim about three weeks ago after being out with a back injury, and EDD just sent me a Notice of Determination saying it's not payable. Here's the thing though: my orthopedist's office told me they submitted the medical certification, but I'm not sure if EDD actually received and matched it to my claim before they made this decision. The notice came really fast, which makes me think maybe they just didn't have the doctor's part yet when they processed it. Now I'm looking at the DE 1000A appeal form that came with the notice and trying to figure out if I should file the appeal right away, wait to see if the doctor form gets reviewed and fixes things, or do both simultaneously. The deadline on the notice is 30 days from the date it was issued and I've already burned through about a week just figuring out what happened. Has anyone been in this situation where the denial might just be because the medical certification wasn't matched in time?

DE 2501 Part B from my own surgeon's office had the same matching problem on my shoulder claim, and SDI Online showed no certification received even after the office said they'd sent it in. Ended up talking to a live agent at EDD after trying Claimyr (claimyr.com), and the agent pulled up my claim and said the certification was sitting there but hadn't been matched to my receipt number yet. Video on reaching an EDD disability agent live if you're in the same boat: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Turned out my doctor's office had filed it without the receipt number I gave them at the portal, so there was nothing tying the two together. Agent told me to have the office resubmit with the correct receipt number and that the claim would be reviewed again once they did.

0 coins

My medical certification situation is basically the same thing and I've been going back and forth with my doctor's office for two weeks. Want to try Claimyr for it, what should I have ready before I call?

0 coins

Have your claim receipt number, the date you filed, and the date your doctor's office says they submitted. The agent will look up whether anything was received on EDD's end and what receipt number, if any, it got attached to.

0 coins

This is almost exactly what I think happened with mine. Did you still file the appeal while waiting for the resubmission, or did you hold off?

0 coins

Filed the appeal the same day. Didn't want to risk the 30 days running out while waiting on the office to fix the receipt number issue.

0 coins

Filing both at the same time, the appeal and the fix with the doctor's office, seems like the safest move. Can you do that without one canceling the other out?

0 coins

To answer the question being asked here directly: file the appeal before that 30-day window closes, and separately ask your doctor's office to resubmit with the correct receipt number. Those are two different tracks and neither one cancels the other. If EDD gets the certification matched and approves the claim, your appeal becomes moot. If the appeal is what fixes it, great. But letting the deadline pass while waiting on the office is a risk not worth taking.

0 coins

So even if the denial was just a timing error, they won't fix it on their own without an appeal?

0 coins

EDD acts on what they have. If the certification wasn't there when they processed it, the denial is what they issue. The appeal is how you say the full picture wasn't reviewed.

0 coins

Exactly. File the appeal, don't wait around.

0 coins

THREE weeks on hold trying to reach anyone at that disability line and I still can't get a person. Filed in October, doctor submitted the same week, notice came back denied before I could even blink. The phone line either rings out or dumps you into an automated loop that ends the call. At some point you just want to know what form they're waiting for.

0 coins

That line has been rough for months. Sending a Request Claim Update through SDI Online sometimes gets a response faster than the phone.

0 coins

Tried that too. Got a generic message back that said my claim was under review. No specifics.

0 coins

Ask EDD through the online form is worth trying if SDI Online messages aren't getting detail. At least it creates a record of what you asked.

0 coins

The appeal form is the DE 1000A and it comes attached to the Notice of Determination. EDD's site says you have 30 days from the date on the notice to submit it, and a late appeal requires you to explain why it was late, which an administrative law judge then looks at. Write a clear explanation in that appeal of what you believe happened: that the medical certification may not have been received or matched before EDD made its decision. Attach anything you have from the doctor's office confirming they submitted it.

0 coins

The doctor's office sent me a confirmation email when they submitted through SDI Online. That should be useful as an attachment to the appeal?

0 coins

Yes, keep it. A timestamped confirmation from the provider's side showing when they submitted is exactly the kind of thing worth including with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Date on the submission confirmation versus date on the Notice of Determination will matter a lot here. If they submitted before EDD issued the denial, that's the key detail.

0 coins

Waiting period question tripped me up on my own claim and I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr to sort it out. Agent looked at my claim and confirmed the seven-day waiting period starts on day one of the disability, not on the day EDD gets the paperwork. Had no idea those were different things. For whoever's also confused about when the payable days actually begin, that cleared it up for me.

0 coins

Waiting period being day one of the disability is what confused me too, used Claimyr as well on my claim. Once the agent confirmed my receipt number was matched to the right certification, I understood why my pending weeks looked the way they did. Had to just sit with the first seven days being unpaid regardless.

0 coins

How do either of you have time to stay on that line long enough to reach anyone? I've tried mornings, afternoons, nothing.

0 coins

Redial situation for me too, mornings over a week straight before I tried a different approach.

0 coins

that line is impossible honestly been on it twice this month for my own claim both times just ended the call on me

0 coins

Appeals go to the return address printed on the Notice of Determination, not to a general EDD address. Double-check the envelope you're sending it to before it goes out. The form asks for a detailed explanation, so be specific: what day the disability started, when you filed, when the doctor's office submitted, and what you believe was missing or unmatched at the time EDD issued the denial.

0 coins

Good point, I hadn't even thought to check the return address separately from the main EDD address I've been using.

0 coins

The notice itself will have it. Use that one, not the general mailing address.

0 coins

Mailing to the wrong address is an easy mistake that costs you time you don't have when there's a deadline.

0 coins

My doctor's office submitted my form and swore it went through, but EDD had no record of it on their end for almost two weeks. Turned out they'd filed it on paper and mailed it, but the online receipt number I gave them was what they needed to use in SDI Online instead. Once I figured that out I had them resubmit through the portal and it matched the same day. If your office submitted on paper after you filed online, that could be what's happening.

0 coins

Wait, so if you file online but the doctor submits on paper, does that cause the mismatch?

0 coins

In my case the receipt number is what ties them together, and that number only matters in SDI Online. Paper submissions go through a different process and I honestly don't know how EDD handles those, but mine caused a delay.

0 coins

The provider submitting through SDI Online and using the receipt number the claimant got at filing is the most reliable way to get them matched. Paper still works but the claimant should check with EDD if it doesn't show up after a reasonable time.

0 coins

seven days into my own claim and nothing's moved. denial notice showed up before my doctor even got the form in. filed the appeal on day two after getting it, wasn't waiting around.

0 coins

Filing it right away was the right call. 30 days sounds like a lot until it isn't.

0 coins

yeah and my employer's leave coordinator kept telling me to wait and see. glad i didn't

0 coins

Appeal and fix the certification issue at the same time. Those are independent steps and you need both moving. If the denial came before the medical certification was matched, your appeal letter should say exactly that: when you filed, when the provider submitted, and that you believe the certification was not associated with the claim when EDD issued the determination.

0 coins

Should I include a copy of the medical certification itself in the appeal packet, or just the submission confirmation from the doctor's office?

0 coins

The confirmation showing when it was submitted is what you control. The certification itself is your provider's document and EDD should have it already or be getting it from the resubmission. Focus your appeal on the timeline.

0 coins

Is there a specific form for the appeal or just a letter?

0 coins

The DE 1000A came with your Notice of Determination. Use that. If you've lost it, a detailed letter with your name, claim number, and explanation, mailed to the address on the notice, also works according to EDD's appeals process.

0 coins

Base period question was what I needed answered on my own claim, so I ended up getting through to an EDD agent and asked which quarter they were looking at. Used Claimyr for that one. Agent confirmed the quarter of the base period being used and what wages they had on record for it. Knowing the actual quarter let me check my own records and confirm everything matched.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying that disability line and nothing but a recording. Hard to believe anyone actually gets through.

0 coins

Got through once before on my own after a lot of mornings. This time I didn't want to spend another two weeks on it. Agent read off the quarter and the amount on file, that was it.

0 coins

Agent confirmed my Notice of Computation figures matched the quarter on file for my own claim too. Knowing the actual quarter is the fastest way to check whether your wages were captured right.

0 coins

Quarter question is on my list too, been meaning to verify mine since the amount on the notice looked lower than expected.

0 coins

Don't overthink it. File the appeal now, then deal with the doctor's office separately. Missing that 30-day window because you were waiting on a form fix would be a much worse situation.

0 coins

What happens if you miss the 30 days?

0 coins

You have to explain why you were late and an administrative law judge decides whether to let it go forward. Not guaranteed.

0 coins

Yeah filing it now makes more sense then, don't want that risk.

0 coins

Doctor's office told me the same thing twice already, that they submitted, but my SDI Online shows no certification received. Asked them to give me a copy of whatever confirmation they got and they said the system didn't generate one. Getting a little frustrated trying to figure out if it's on their end or EDD's.

0 coins

Ask them specifically what receipt number they filed it under. If they don't have one or used a different number, that's probably the issue right there.

0 coins

Oh I didn't even ask that. I'll call them today and find out.

0 coins

The claimant's receipt number from SDI Online at the time of filing is what the provider needs. If they don't have it, have it ready when you contact them.

0 coins

my situation was the same. denied before the form even showed up. filed the appeal on paper and had the doctors office redo the submission the same week. took a few more weeks but it got fixed eventually

0 coins

Did they ever tell you officially whether the original denial was because the certification wasn't there in time, or did it just get quietly resolved?

0 coins

never got a clear answer honestly. the payment just came through and i assumed it was sorted

0 coins

That tracks. EDD doesn't always spell out what changed, the payment is usually how you find out.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but I've been told by people at my job that if EDD denies you, you should just refile instead of appealing. That doesn't sound right to me but wanted to ask here before I did anything.

0 coins

Refiling is not the right move here. If the denial came on an active claim, the appeal is what addresses that specific decision. A new filing would start over and you'd lose the original dates, including the start of your disability period.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense, the dates matter a lot since my doctor has a specific disability start date on the form.

0 coins

The appeal is tied to the Notice of Determination that was issued. That's the document and the decision being reviewed. A new claim would be a separate thing entirely with a new timeline.

0 coins

Don't refile. Appeal.

0 coins

Sent my own appeal letter and had the certification resubmitted in the same week. Wrote down the date I sent each one and kept copies of everything. If this goes to a hearing at any point you want a paper trail of what you did and when.

0 coins

Good point, keeping dated records of every step. I'll do the same.

0 coins

Mailing anything to EDD, send it in a way you can track. Keeps the guesswork out of it.

0 coins

Receipt number is the thing that keeps coming up in this thread and it's really the core of a lot of these matching problems. When the office has the right number and uses it in SDI Online, the certification links right up. When they don't, it floats out there unattached.

0 coins

My office said they submitted through the portal but I never confirmed they had my specific receipt number. Going to verify that today.

0 coins

That's the first question. If they have it and used it, ask EDD what their system shows.

0 coins

Appeals take time. Even if the certification issue gets fixed before a hearing, don't expect this to wrap up in a week.

0 coins

Honestly I'm just trying to protect my options. Even if the certification fix resolves it, having the appeal filed means I'm not at a dead end if something else goes wrong.

0 coins

That's the right way to look at it.

0 coins

November 14th was the date on my own Notice of Determination and I had the DE 1000A postmarked by November 20th. Tracking showed it delivered to the address on the notice six days later. Keep dates like that documented throughout.

0 coins

Dated copies of everything sent and a delivery confirmation where possible. That's good practice for any EDD correspondence.

0 coins

Exactly. If a question ever comes up about whether something was filed on time, you want something you can point to.

0 coins

Doctor submitted my form but said she couldn't find my claim in SDI Online at first. Turned out she was searching by my name and not the receipt number. Once I texted her the number directly, she found it in about two minutes and submitted right away.

0 coins

That's such a simple fix but I would have never thought to give the receipt number directly like that. Mine is probably searching the same way.

0 coins

Yeah give them the number. The portal finds the claim by that, not by name from what my doctor said.

0 coins

Where do I find my receipt number if I didn't write it down when I filed?

0 coins

Log into SDI Online through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open your claim. The receipt number should be there in your claim details.

0 coins

Does the appeal automatically extend the deadline while EDD reviews the certification, or is the 30 days still the 30 days no matter what?

0 coins

The 30 days is from the date on the Notice of Determination and it doesn't pause or extend based on what EDD is doing separately on the certification. File before it runs out.

0 coins

Okay, filing this week then.

0 coins

Update from my end: verified with the doctor's office and they did have the receipt number but entered one digit wrong in SDI Online when they submitted. They're resubmitting today with the corrected number, and I'm mailing the DE 1000A this afternoon to cover the appeal deadline. Didn't want to wait and find out the fix alone wasn't going to be enough.

0 coins

Doing both at the same time was absolutely the right call here.

0 coins

One wrong digit on the receipt number is a surprisingly common issue. Good that you found it before the 30 days were up.

0 coins

Keep a copy of that appeal and note today's date. If you end up not needing the appeal because the resubmission clears things up, no harm done. If you do need it, you're protected.

0 coins

Good outcome. That receipt number thing catches a lot of people off guard.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure