Back to California Disability

Isaiah Cross

SDI pregnancy weekly benefit amount too low wrong base period wages — what can I do?

Filed my pregnancy disability claim about three weeks ago and got my Notice of Computation in the mail yesterday. The weekly benefit amount on there is way lower than I expected, and when I looked more closely I think EDD pulled wages from the wrong time period. I was on unpaid leave for a few months about a year and a half ago and barely worked, so those low-earnings quarters dragged everything down. But the quarters right before I went out on disability I was working full time and making good money. I don't understand why they didn't use those more recent wages. Is there any way to dispute the base period they used? Has anyone else had their benefit amount come out wrong because of something like that?

The base period confusion tripped me up on my own claim too, before I figured out what EDD actually uses. It's not your most recent paychecks. EDD looks at a 12-month window that ends several months before your disability start date, specifically the highest-paid quarter inside that window. If you had low earnings during that stretch because of unpaid leave, that is what the calculation is based on. The calculator on EDD's site can show you what quarters were in play for your start date, so you can check whether the Notice of Computation matches what the calculator gives you.

0 coins

Thank you, I'll try the calculator. Is there anything I can do if the quarters really were the low ones, like can I ask them to use different wages?

0 coins

The base period is set by the claim start date, so EDD doesn't pick different quarters on request. If the amount on your Notice of Computation looks like a math error compared to what the calculator shows, that's worth contacting EDD about. If the math is right but the period just had low wages, the notice is correct.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is not an approval, just so you know. It shows the potential benefit amount. Eligibility is a separate determination, but the amount calculation is worth double-checking against the calculator before you do anything else.

0 coins

December 14th is when my own Notice of Computation came in, and I had the same reaction. The quarter EDD used was from when I'd dropped to part-time hours, not the quarter I was earning the most. I ran the numbers on the calculator and it matched what EDD had, so the formula was right, it just felt low because that one quarter was so much lighter. Worth running the calculator with your actual start date to see if the figures line up.

0 coins

That's discouraging but helpful. So even if I earned a lot more recently it might just not be in the base period at all?

0 coins

Exactly. If your higher-earning quarters fall outside the 12-month window EDD uses for your claim's start date, they don't count toward the calculation. The calculator on EDD's site will show which quarters it's pulling.

0 coins

I had the same frustration. My highest-earning stretch was just barely outside the window. Nothing wrong with the math, just bad timing on when I went out.

0 coins

Notice of Determination landed in my mailbox after my own pregnancy claim, and the benefit amount listed didn't match what I'd estimated at all. I tried the EDD phone line several mornings in a row and kept hitting the same wall. I ended up getting through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com), and they have a video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my notice and confirmed which quarter of the base period EDD used to calculate my amount, and explained that my wages in that quarter were lower than I'd realized because two of those months I'd been at reduced hours. The notice was accurate. If you think yours has an actual error, getting to an agent is the fastest way to have them read the specific figures on your claim.

0 coins

I want to ask about this because I've tried that disability line so many times and it just cuts off after the hold music, like it doesn't even queue you, it just ends the call. How does Claimyr actually do anything different when the line itself won't hold?

0 coins

The line did that to me too, three times in one morning. Claimyr stays on with EDD so you don't have to, and your phone rings once a real EDD person picks up. I ended up talking to an agent for about ten minutes, and she was definitely an EDD employee, she had my claim on her screen.

0 coins

I had a similar experience! The agent I reached told me my claim's start date was entered as a day later than my actual first day out, which was pushing everything off. Got that corrected and the payment lined up after that!

0 coins

Huh, okay. I'm still not sure what to make of it but I've got nothing to lose at this point. Thanks.

0 coins

EDD's phone line has been a full-time job for me this week. I've been out since a hip thing flared up and my Notice of Computation came in showing an amount that looked off. I've sent a message through SDI Online but nothing yet. Anyone know how long they usually take to respond through there?

0 coins

The SDI Online message route can take a few days. If you think there's a calculation error on your Notice of Computation, the message you sent is a reasonable start. Just make sure you're specific about which quarter or figure you think is wrong.

0 coins

I put the specific quarter in the message, so hopefully that helps. Just frustrating waiting.

0 coins

The wait is real. Mine took about a week to get a response through SDI Online. Not ideal but it did come.

0 coins

My pregnancy claim benefit amount came in lower than expected too and I nearly panicked. My sister told me it was definitely wrong and I should file an appeal right away, but I'm glad I checked the calculator first because it was actually right, just not the quarters I thought they'd use. The appeal form is for when EDD denies the claim or makes an error, not for when the formula works out to less than you hoped.

0 coins

That's a relief to hear, I didn't want to file an appeal if I didn't need to. How did you figure out which quarters they actually used?

0 coins

The disability benefits calculator on EDD's site, you just put in your claim start date and your quarterly wages and it shows you exactly which quarter they're using. It matched my notice exactly.

0 coins

I keep second-guessing whether I entered my wages right in the calculator. Like what counts as wages for SDI purposes, is it gross or net? Not sure if I'm doing it wrong.

0 coins

Use your gross wages, before any deductions. That's what SDI is calculated from. The calculator on EDD's site uses gross wages per quarter.

0 coins

Went through this same thing after a back injury last year. The base period looked backwards to me too. Took a minute to understand it's not your last paycheck, it's a window from months before you even filed. Once I ran the calculator I stopped arguing with myself about it.

0 coins

Same. I kept thinking they'd use my most recent wages but that's not how it works. The calculator straightened me out.

0 coins

Exactly. Run the calculator, check the quarters, see if the math matches the notice. If it does, the amount is probably right even if it stings.

0 coins

my claim was pending so long i thought they lost it. notice of computation finally showed up and the amount was lower than i expected but i ran the numbers and it was right. just felt low because i only worked part time for a few months in that window

0 coins

Part time wages pulling the amount down is exactly what I think happened to me too. Did you end up accepting the amount or try to do anything about it?

0 coins

accepted it, nothing to do when the math is right. it just is what it is

0 coins

Same situation here. Accepted mine too. The calculator confirmed it.

0 coins

Waiting on my own notice still and already stressed about what the amount will say. I took a few months off between jobs last year and I'm terrified that's going to drag the number down. Is there any way to know before the notice arrives?

0 coins

The disability benefits calculator on EDD's site will give you an estimate before the notice comes. You'll need your gross wages by quarter for the period it covers. It won't be exact but it'll give you a ballpark.

0 coins

Okay I'll try that. I just want to be prepared so it doesn't blindside me.

0 coins

Running it ahead of time really does help with the shock factor. And even if the number is lower than you hoped, you'll know what to expect before the notice lands.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim form didn't match what my doctor's office had, and payments were stalled for two weeks because of it. I tried the EDD line every day and kept getting cut off. Used Claimyr and got on the phone with an EDD agent directly. She looked up my claim and confirmed which receipt number was on file and what number my provider had submitted under. That mismatch was why everything was sitting there. Got it straightened out the same day.

0 coins

Wait, what is Claimyr exactly? I've never heard of it.

0 coins

It sits on the line with EDD while you do other things, and when a live person picks up it rings your phone. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh interesting. I have a question about my own base period wages I still need answered, I might try that for it.

0 coins

Receipt number mismatch is a real pain. Had the same thing. Took me forever to track down which number the provider actually used.

0 coins

An appeal is worth filing if EDD sent a Notice of Determination saying your claim is denied or your benefit amount was calculated incorrectly as an error, not simply because the amount is less than you hoped. The Appeal Form is included with the Notice of Determination, and you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file it. If you've lost the form, a detailed letter sent to the address on the notice works too.

0 coins

Mine was a Notice of Computation, not a Determination. So I haven't been denied, the amount is just less than I expected. Does that mean an appeal doesn't apply here?

0 coins

Correct. The Notice of Computation shows your potential weekly benefit amount, it's not a denial. An appeal is for a Notice of Determination. If you believe the computation has a math error, contacting EDD through SDI Online or by phone is the right move, not an appeal form.

0 coins

I didn't know there were two different notices. That would have confused me completely.

0 coins

Honestly this thread is clarifying something I had wrong for weeks. I thought my Notice of Computation was the approval and when it looked low I thought I'd been shortchanged. It's just an estimate of the amount, not a decision on the claim. The actual approval or denial is a separate thing.

0 coins

Yes same, I thought getting the notice meant everything was settled. Good to know it's not the final word.

0 coins

The two-notice thing trips a lot of people up. The computation notice just says what your weekly amount could be, the determination is where EDD says whether you're eligible.

0 coins

My notice showed up and the weekly amount was about what the calculator predicted, so at least that matched. But the first week listed as payable was later than I expected, which was confusing.

0 coins

The first seven days of a new disability claim are a waiting period that doesn't pay out. It's not processing time, it's just the structure of the program. The first day that can be paid is day eight.

0 coins

Oh, that explains it. I had no idea there was a mandatory waiting period built in. I thought it was a delay on EDD's end.

0 coins

Almost everyone assumes that. The seven-day waiting period is baked in from day one of the claim, not related to how fast EDD processes it.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim showed up two weeks late according to what I expected and I couldn't get through to EDD no matter what I tried. Tried the line early on a Monday, tried midweek, same result every time. Ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr and asked about the specific payment that hadn't landed. She told me EDD issued it on a certain date but it was going to a card I'd requested, and the card itself was still in transit from Money Network.

0 coins

I've been using Claimyr too and I'm really glad it worked out for you. When I got through, the agent confirmed my medical certification had been received and matched to my claim, which I'd been anxious about for days.

0 coins

Wait, the agent could actually see whether the medical certification was matched? I wasn't sure if EDD could look that up.

0 coins

Yes, she told me the date it came in and confirmed it was matched to my claim ID. Such a relief to hear that directly.

0 coins

payment in transit for a week because of the card situation is rough. glad you got it sorted

0 coins

The Money Network card thing is new to me. I keep seeing people mention a Bank of America EDD card and was confused when my paperwork said something different.

0 coins

EDD's payment card moved to Money Network. It's no longer Bank of America. If you're setting up payments now, the card that arrives will be a Money Network card. Direct deposit is also an option if you filed in SDI Online.

0 coins

Good to know. I was looking at old threads and they all said Bank of America so I thought mine was wrong.

0 coins

Same confusion here! All the old posts said BofA and I was totally lost when my card came in a Money Network envelope.

0 coins

Ran into a situation last year where my hours had been cut for about four months before my claim, and the base period landed right on those months. Amount was lower than expected, math was correct, nothing to appeal. Filed and took what it was.

0 coins

Did you at least get enough to cover your basics? I'm really worried about making ends meet on a reduced amount.

0 coins

Barely. It's not designed to replace your whole income. Worth checking whether your employer has any supplemental pay for disability leave.

0 coins

HR is worth asking about that, some employers top it up.

0 coins

My pregnancy claim came through and the base period actually worked in my favor because the year before I'd gotten a raise and worked a ton of overtime! So my highest-earning quarter was right in the window. Luck of timing I guess.

0 coins

That's so lucky. Timing really does seem to be everything with this.

0 coins

Overtime quarters are clutch for this if they fall in the right window. My highest quarter was holiday season overtime and it bumped my weekly amount up noticeably.

0 coins

does the base period ever change if you file later or earlier like if you delay filing do you get different quarters

0 coins

Your claim's start date sets the base period, not the date you file the paperwork. Delaying the filing doesn't shift the quarters EDD uses. The start date is when the disability actually began.

0 coins

ok so it doesnt matter if i file on day one or day thirty the quarters are based on when i actually stopped working

0 coins

Exactly right. File as soon as you can though, there's a 49-day window from the disability start date to file and to get the medical certification in.

0 coins

Pregnant workers sometimes get complication-based benefits a few weeks before the actual due date, which can shift the claim start date earlier. That can move which quarters are in the base period. Happened to a coworker of mine, her provider certified restrictions at 36 weeks so her claim started early, which changed what quarters were in play.

0 coins

I didn't realize that. My doctor did restrict my hours before my due date, so I wonder if I should have started my claim earlier and whether that would have changed my base period.

0 coins

Benefits can start before birth when a provider certifies that complications, work restrictions or reduced hours make it appropriate. If you had restrictions certified before you stopped working entirely, your start date and base period could potentially differ from what you've got now. Worth discussing with your doctor's office.

0 coins

This is something worth asking about proactively. The earlier start date due to work restrictions isn't automatic, the provider has to certify it.

0 coins

For anyone comparing their Notice of Computation to their own estimates, one thing that threw me off was using my net pay instead of gross when I ran the calculator. The SDI calculation is based on gross wages per quarter. When I reran with gross figures the calculator matched my notice exactly.

0 coins

This is probably what I did wrong too. I was using my take-home pay. Let me redo it with gross and see if that changes the picture.

0 coins

Run it with gross wages per quarter, and make sure you're pulling from the right quarters for your specific claim start date. The calculator on EDD's site will walk you through which ones to enter.

0 coins

Gross versus net is such an easy thing to get wrong and it makes the number look really different. Good catch.

0 coins

Filed two claims over five years, different base period both times, different amount both times. It just depends on when you stopped working and what your income looked like in that window. Nothing suspicious, just math.

0 coins

That actually helps me feel better. It's not personal, just timing.

0 coins

Exactly. Run the calculator, verify the quarters, and if the math checks out there's nothing wrong with the claim.

0 coins

Coming out of eight weeks of pregnancy disability now and the PFL bonding claim starts next. Just wanted to say for anyone newer to this, PFL is a totally separate claim from the disability one. Different filing, different rules. EDD handles both but you'll file a new claim for the bonding piece after disability ends.

0 coins

Good to know. I'd heard that PFL comes after but wasn't sure if it was automatic or something I had to do separately.

0 coins

Completely separate filing. When your disability period ends, you file a new PFL bonding claim. It is not automatic, and PFL has no waiting period the way disability does.

0 coins

PFL bonding was way smoother to file than the disability claim honestly. But yes, totally separate process.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure