Back to California Disability

Amaya Watson

SDI payments too low wrong wages showing from old job

So I finally got my Notice of Computation after filing my SDI claim for my back surgery and the weekly benefit amount is way off. Like embarrassingly low compared to what I actually earn. I went through my pay stubs and I think EDD pulled wages from when I was at my previous employer, not my current job where I've been making significantly more. I switched jobs about 14 months ago and my wages at the new place are almost double what they were before. Has anyone dealt with this? I don't even know if I'm looking at this right or if maybe the base period just doesn't include my recent paychecks? I'm scared I'm going to be stuck on this lower amount for my whole claim and I can't cover my bills on that. Do I just have to accept whatever the Notice of Computation says?

Part A went in and my doctor's office submitted the certification within a week, but SDI Online was still showing pending on day 15. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD disability agent rather than keep hitting that busy signal. The agent pulled up my file and confirmed the medical certification had come in but was matched to the wrong receipt number, so it was just sitting there unlinked. They corrected it on the spot. For reaching someone on that line: Claimyr's video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Anyway, separately, the wages question you're describing is really common with job changes. The base period looks at a specific 12-month window from several months back, so your most recent paychecks might not be in it yet even at your current job.

0 coins

Hold on, you actually got a live person at EDD disability? I've called that number at least eight or nine mornings in a row and it either rings forever or the recording cuts me off. What made this work, I genuinely don't understand how you got through.

0 coins

Claimyr just waits on that line for you until there's a real person, then your phone rings. That's the whole thing. The agent I spoke to was definitely EDD, she had my claim right in front of her.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself when my receipt number situation got tangled. Agent confirmed the number on file didn't match what my provider submitted, and we sorted out which one to have the office resubmit under. Got that cleared up in one call.

0 coins

Okay that is wild, I've been suffering through redial after redial. Might actually try this for my own certification question.

0 coins

The base period calculation is what's tripping you up here. EDD looks at wages from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date, divided into four calendar quarters. The highest single quarter in that window is what determines your weekly benefit. If your job change was 14 months ago, it depends on exactly when you switched and when your claim started, because some of those earlier lower-wage quarters might be the ones landing in your base period. The Notice of Computation should show which quarters they used. Check the dates on it carefully.

0 coins

Thank you, so the quarters on the notice, do those show the actual dollar amounts they used for each one? I want to compare them to my W-2s.

0 coins

Yes, the Notice of Computation lists the wages by quarter. Match those to your pay records. If a quarter is showing wages from your old employer and you expected your new employer's wages to be in that window, that's the discrepancy you'd want to flag with EDD.

0 coins

Worth adding: EDD bases it on wages subject to the SDI deduction. If your old job somehow had different withholding, that could affect what shows up. But for most W-2 jobs it's straightforward, the CASDI line on your pay stub is what gets reported.

0 coins

Got hit with this same issue two years back after switching companies. Thought EDD had my numbers wrong. Turned out the base period just hadn't caught up to my new salary yet. Nothing was actually wrong, it was just bad timing on when I filed.

0 coins

Did you end up appealing it or just accepting the lower amount?

0 coins

Accepted it. My old wages were still in the system correctly, just lower. Wasn't worth fighting something that was technically right.

0 coins

That timing issue is brutal when it happens. Some people file right after starting a new job and the whole base period is basically their old salary. No error, just bad luck with the calendar.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. I've tried calling before 8, right at 8, midmorning, nothing. You either get a busy signal, a recording that tells you to try again, or dead air. If your wages are showing wrong you need to actually talk to someone and there's basically no way to do that through normal channels.

0 coins

True. The online message thing through SDI Online exists but I've never gotten a real answer from it.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update option in SDI Online is worth trying for a written record, but for something like a wage discrepancy where you need to know which quarter they pulled, a phone call is faster. The number for the disability line is 1-800-480-3287 if you haven't tried.

0 coins

Yeah I know the number. I've dialed it about forty times. That's my point.

0 coins

Waiting period thing got me confused on my claim too. My first payment was lower than I expected and I panicked, thought EDD had my wages wrong. Turned out it was just the first seven days being unpaid, so that first check only covered part of a week. Ended up phoning EDD through Claimyr to ask an agent to walk me through it. Agent confirmed the waiting period applied to days one through seven and that my payment was actually calculated on the right wages, just for fewer days than I thought. Anyway I had also changed jobs so I was nervous.

0 coins

What is Claimyr, I keep seeing it mentioned and I don't know what that is?

0 coins

So basically you tell Claimyr what number to dial and it stays on the line with EDD while you do other stuff. When a live person picks up, your phone rings so you can take over the call. That's it.

0 coins

Oh okay. I've been scared to call because I don't know what to say. My question is about whether my part-time hours before I went out count toward my wages or not. Maybe I'd try that for my own claim.

0 coins

The wages that count are the ones that had the CASDI deduction taken out. Part-time hours at a regular employer should count if SDI tax was withheld.

0 coins

If the quarters on that Notice of Computation show your old employer's wages and you think your new employer's wages should be in that window instead, ask EDD to verify what wage records they have on file for you. Sometimes wages just haven't been reported yet by a newer employer.

0 coins

Wait, the new employer might not have reported my wages yet? How would I know that?

0 coins

You wouldn't know from SDI Online. That's why you have to call EDD and ask which wages they have on record for the specific quarters on your notice.

0 coins

Yep happened to someone I know, employer hadn't submitted their quarterly payroll report yet so EDD literally couldn't see those wages. It sorted itself out but took a bit.

0 coins

my first notice looked totally off too, old job wages, freaked out. turns out the timing just landed that way and i couldnt do anything about it. was annoying but it was right

0 coins

Same. Stressful to look at but not actually an error.

0 coins

Okay that's making me feel slightly better but also worse because I still need to cover my rent lol.

0 coins

The rule EDD uses: your base period covers four specific calendar quarters, ending about five months before your disability began. So if your claim started in, say, September 2026, your base period would be April 2025 through March 2026. Wages earned outside that window don't count. A job change 14 months before filing could easily land your old wages squarely in that period depending on when each quarter falls.

0 coins

This is really helpful. So my new job's wages from the last few months before I went out are just not in the base period at all?

0 coins

Exactly. The most recent quarter before you filed is usually excluded. That's why people with recent raises or job changes feel like the number is behind. It's not an error, it's just how the window is set.

0 coins

EDD's site has a calculator that lets you plug in your quarterly wages and see the estimate. Worth running your numbers through it to confirm the base period math before deciding whether to dispute anything.

0 coins

Not sure if this helps but I read somewhere that if your base period wages don't meet the minimum you can request an alternate base period? I think? Not sure if thats a real thing or if I made that up honestly.

0 coins

There is no alternate base period under California's SDI program. What EDD uses is the standard base period, the four quarters ending five to seventeen months before the claim start. If you don't meet the minimum earnings in that window, the claim may be denied. Worth double-checking, but I haven't seen EDD offer an alternate calculation.

0 coins

To add to that, the minimum is at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period. So if someone worked very little in that window, that's the threshold to clear, not an alternate period.

0 coins

Okay yeah I definitely mixed something up. Thanks for the correction.

0 coins

My benefit amount came out lower than I expected too and I genuinely thought I'd done the math right. Took me a few days to realize the highest quarter thing matters a lot. If you had one really good quarter in there you'd get a decent amount, but if your best earnings are outside the base period you're just stuck.

0 coins

Yeah my highest quarters are definitely the recent ones that apparently aren't counted. Really frustrating.

0 coins

It's a rough situation and not uncommon. The notice is at least good for seeing exactly which quarters they used so you know what you're working with.

0 coins

called that disability line three times last week. got through once, was on hold for a while, then it dropped. twice i just got a recording. still haven't gotten an answer about my wages.

0 coins

That line is brutal. Keep trying, mornings tend to be your best shot but honestly even then it's a crapshoot.

0 coins

Mornings, afternoons, doesn't matter. It drops or it doesn't answer. I tried for two weeks straight before I found another way in.

0 coins

Which quarter of my base period they pulled was my whole question. Used Claimyr to get through on that disability line since I'd had no luck on my own. Agent found the quarter they used was Q4 of the year before I filed, which was my lower-earnings period. The higher quarter I expected them to use was outside the base period window by one quarter. Nothing to dispute, just unfortunate timing.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for my own claim and glad I did. Agent confirmed the Notice of Computation had already been generated and mailed, and told me the weekly amount on it. That saved me waiting to see if it arrived.

0 coins

About that call, did the agent say anything about whether you could do anything once you knew the quarter, or was it just informational?

0 coins

Just informational in my case. She said the base period is set and the notice shows what it shows. Told me to appeal within 30 days of the notice date if I disagreed with how EDD applied the rules.

0 coins

That's basically what I'm dealing with. One bad quarter landing in the wrong spot.

0 coins

For documentation purposes: pull every pay stub from the 18 months before your claim start and add up the quarterly totals. Then compare to the quarters on your Notice of Computation. If the amounts match your old employer's records, EDD has the right wages, it's just the base period timing. If the amounts don't match anything in your records, then there may be an actual reporting error worth flagging.

0 coins

This is a great approach, doing this tonight. At least I'll know if it's a real error or just timing.

0 coins

Exactly. The two problems look the same from the outside but the fix is different. Timing issue, nothing to do. Reporting error, call EDD and ask them to verify what wage records they have.

0 coins

lol I went through this whole panic when I saw my notice and thought EDD had me pegged as making way less than I do. spent like an hour going through papers. turns out it was right, just the base period was from when I was working less. anticlimactic but also kind of relieved.

0 coins

same exact thing happened to me. all that stress for nothing

0 coins

Hoping mine lands the same way, the stress of not knowing is the worst part.

0 coins

If after checking your records you do find an actual discrepancy, the right path is to contact EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update or by phone and ask them to verify the wage records on file. If they confirm an error, they can look into it. If the wages are correct but just from the base period window, there's no dispute mechanism for that, the base period is what it is.

0 coins

So there's no way to substitute more recent wages even if the base period ones are low because of the job change?

0 coins

Not in California's DI program. The base period is fixed. What you can do is make sure the wages they do have on file are accurate, but you can't swap in a different time window.

0 coins

That's correct. EDD's rules set the base period by statute. The Notice of Computation reflects whatever wages were reported to them in those quarters. If those wages are from your old employer because that's when the base period falls, that's the number.

0 coins

My partner went through something similar after a promotion. Great new salary, went out a few months later, the notice looked like old money. It stings but once you understand the window it at least makes sense.

0 coins

Makes sense but still hurts when your bills are current.

0 coins

Absolutely. The gap between what you need and what SDI pays is real. Hope the back recovery goes okay too, that's the main thing.

0 coins

One thing worth checking: if your previous employer paid into SDI and your new one does too, EDD should have records for both. The issue is only which quarters those wages fall in. Make sure both employers were actually deducting CASDI, some smaller employers mess that up and then those wages don't get reported to SDI.

0 coins

Both are regular companies so I think the deductions are right. I can see CASDI on stubs from both.

0 coins

Then it's almost certainly just the timing of the base period window. That's the most likely explanation given your job change timeline.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later: the formula EDD uses is based on the highest single quarter in your base period, not the average and not your most recent wages. So even if three quarters are low, one really strong quarter can lift the weekly benefit amount. The calculator on EDD's site is the best way to run your own numbers before expecting a certain amount.

0 coins

Didn't realize it was the single highest quarter, I assumed they averaged all four. That actually changes my math.

0 coins

Yes, highest quarter only. That's why the timing of when your best-paid quarter lands in the base period matters so much.

0 coins

And 70 to 90 percent of that quarterly amount annualized, depending on your income level. The percentage varies, the notice will show your specific rate.

0 coins

Appealing the amount is an option if you think EDD made an actual error. The appeal deadline is 30 days from the date on the notice. After 30 days you're stuck with whatever they computed.

0 coins

Good to know about the 30 days. I need to figure out first if it's even an error or just bad timing.

0 coins

The Notice of Determination is the form that comes with an appeal form attached. If your situation is just the base period falling on lower-wage quarters, you wouldn't have grounds for an appeal because EDD applied the rules correctly. Appeals are for when EDD got a rule wrong or used incorrect wage data.

0 coins

ran through my numbers on EDD's calculator last week. matched my notice almost exactly. at least i knew nothing was wrong before i stressed myself out more.

0 coins

Using that calculator tonight. At least I'll have a clear answer either way.

0 coins

it helped me a lot. way better than guessing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure