Back to California Disability

Isabella Costa

SDI eligibility if employer withheld taxes for another state — does California still cover you?

So my situation is kind of unusual and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I worked remotely for a company based out of state and when I looked at my paystubs, they were withholding taxes for a different state the whole time, not California. No CASDI deduction showing anywhere. I got hurt a few months ago and had to stop working, and now I'm trying to figure out if I can even file a California SDI claim. My doctor is ready to certify but I don't want to go through the whole process if I'm going to get denied because of how my employer handled the taxes. Has anyone dealt with this? Did you end up being eligible or did EDD say you weren't covered?

The CASDI deduction on your paystubs is really the key thing here. If your employer was withholding for another state and no California SDI contributions were taken out, EDD may determine you weren't covered under the California SDI program during that period. That said, the other state may have its own disability program that covered you. The only way to know for certain is to ask EDD directly, because they look at your actual wage records, not just what your paystubs say.

0 coins

I've been going back through every stub I have and there is definitely no CASDI line. I'm worried this means I'm just out of luck.

0 coins

Check if the other state has a disability program too. Some do, some don't. Worth finding out before you assume you're stuck.

0 coins

Exactly. Filing with EDD costs nothing, and they'll look at your base period wages on file. If nothing is there, they'll send a notice explaining why.

0 coins

The SDI program requires SDI contributions, which show up as that CASDI deduction. EDD's site explains that you need at least $300 in wages subject to SDI during your base period to establish eligibility. If your employer never paid into California SDI on your behalf, those wages likely won't count toward that threshold, and EDD would issue a denial notice rather than approving the claim.

0 coins

Does that mean an employer withholding for the wrong state is essentially an employer error that the worker ends up paying for? That seems like a significant problem.

0 coins

It can be, yes. There are situations where an employer misclassified which state's taxes applied, and in those cases the worker may have recourse with the employer or the state labor board. But EDD itself decides eligibility based on what's in your wage record.

0 coins

So the worker gets stuck in the middle while the employer made the call. Great system.

0 coins

A Notice of Determination came on my claim after I filed and I genuinely didn't understand why I'd been denied. Turned out there was a whole question about which wages EDD had on record for my base period. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the line at EDD's disability number, and the agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly what the notice meant and that I had 30 days from the issue date to appeal if I disagreed. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Filed the appeal with the DE 1000A and a detailed letter right after that call.

0 coins

Claimyr, what's that exactly? I keep striking out on that phone line and I have a question about my own wages in the base period I really need answered.

0 coins

It's a service that keeps trying EDD's line so you don't have to, and your phone rings once a real EDD person picks up. That's really it.

0 coins

Oh that's actually pretty useful. I want to ask EDD which quarter they used to calculate my benefit amount, so that might be exactly what I need.

0 coins

I've called that disability line so many mornings I've lost count. Mondays are the worst but honestly every day is bad. No matter when I try I either get a busy tone or it cuts off.

0 coins

Wait, I might be misunderstanding something. I thought as long as you paid any state taxes you'd be covered for disability? Like I assumed SDI was just part of regular state tax withholding. Is that not right?

0 coins

SDI is separate from regular state income tax. It's its own deduction, the CASDI line. You can have California income tax taken out and still have zero SDI contributions if the employer set it up wrong.

0 coins

Okay so I could be in the same boat as the person who posted this. I work remote and I honestly don't know what state my employer withholds for. I should probably check that now.

0 coins

Seriously check those stubs. I found out my employer had something weird going on with my withholding last year and had to get HR involved lol.

0 coins

Filed a claim once where the base period wages came back lower than expected. EDD had a different number than what I earned. Sometimes employer records and EDD records don't match, and you don't find out until after you file.

0 coins

How do you even fix that if the numbers don't match?

0 coins

You contact EDD and they tell you what's on file. If it's wrong, you go to your employer. EDD goes by what they have.

0 coins

This is making me realize I should find out what EDD actually has on record for me before I assume anything.

0 coins

My doctor submitted the medical certification and I had no idea what receipt number to give the office. Had completely lost track of it after I filed. Eventually got it sorted but it took longer than it needed to.

0 coins

Did you have to refile or could you recover the number somehow?

0 coins

You can find the receipt number in SDI Online once you log into your claim. I should have looked there first instead of panicking.

0 coins

Good to know. I haven't even filed yet because of this eligibility question but I'll keep that in mind when I do.

0 coins

my employer set up my taxes wrong when i first started and i only noticed like 6 months in. hr fixed it going forward but those first months were just gone. so annoying

0 coins

Six months is a long time for them to get it wrong. Did they fix the records or just going forward?

0 coins

just going forward. the past quarters stayed wrong i think. i never pushed it further but probably should have

0 coins

The base period for a DI claim covers wages from about 5 to 18 months before the claim start date, and EDD takes the highest-paid quarter of a 12-month stretch within that range. If your employer wasn't contributing to California SDI during that time, those wages simply won't appear in EDD's SDI wage records, even if you earned them.

0 coins

So even if I had a good income during that period, it doesn't count if the contributions weren't made to California SDI. That's a rough situation to be in.

0 coins

Correct. The dollar amount matters less than whether those wages were subject to California SDI. EDD's disability calculator on their site can help estimate what a benefit might look like if you do have qualifying wages, just to give you a sense of the range.

0 coins

Is there any situation where a worker could be credited for wages their employer should have reported but didn't?

0 coins

That's a situation where talking to EDD directly is the right move. I wouldn't want to guess at what they'd do in a specific case like that.

0 coins

The receipt number question on my claim took me forever to figure out. SDI Online was showing one thing and the doctor's office had something slightly different. I tried the disability line for days and kept hitting that recording. Eventually I gave Claimyr (claimyr.com) a shot and spoke with an EDD agent who confirmed the exact receipt number on file for my claim and told me the medical certification hadn't been matched yet but was in their system.

0 coins

I've used Claimyr too, glad it worked for the receipt number situation. I called to ask EDD about the start date on my own claim, something hadn't looked right in SDI Online, and the agent confirmed the actual date they had recorded, which turned out to be two days off from what I expected.

0 coins

Two days off from what you expected, did that affect anything? Like which base period they used or the benefit amount?

0 coins

The agent told me the start date as recorded and said to review my Notice of Computation for the quarterly breakdown. She didn't tell me whether the difference changed anything, just pointed me there.

0 coins

the line just rings and rings for me. three weeks of trying most mornings before i gave up and sent a message through SDI Online instead

0 coins

Honestly the clearest answer to whether you're eligible is just to file and see what EDD says. They'll either approve it or send a denial notice. The notice tells you what they found and you can appeal within 30 days. Waiting around guessing doesn't help.

0 coins

You're right that waiting doesn't help. I think I've been afraid of getting a denial but at least then I'd know for sure.

0 coins

Exactly. And if they deny it you have the appeal form, DE 1000A, and a window to respond.

0 coins

This was my approach too. Filed not knowing if I'd qualify, got the Notice of Computation pretty quickly, and figured out from there where I stood. Anyway.

0 coins

One thing to keep in mind with the appeal process: if you do get a denial and the notice date has passed the 30-day mark before you even see it, you can still file a late appeal. You'd need to explain why it was late and an administrative law judge reviews the reason. Worth trying rather than assuming it's over.

0 coins

That's correct. The appeal form is the DE 1000A and you mail it to the return address on the notice itself. A detailed letter works too if you don't have the form.

0 coins

I didn't know a late appeal was even possible. That takes some of the pressure off.

0 coins

Just don't sit on it longer than you have to. The sooner you file it the better your explanation looks.

0 coins

I went through something similar last year where my employer had some kind of mix-up with withholding and I ended up with less SDI credit than I expected. It was a mess to sort out. Ended up getting a lower benefit amount than I would have otherwise.

0 coins

Did EDD still approve your claim even with the lower wages on record?

0 coins

They did, because there was enough in the base period to meet the minimum. But the weekly amount reflected only what they had on file.

0 coins

That's good to know. So partial coverage is possible if at least some wages are there.

0 coins

EDD's phone line has been a brick wall for me since I filed. I keep trying around 8 in the morning when they open and it's either busy immediately or I sit there and then it just disconnects. It's like they designed it to wear you down.

0 coins

Same thing every time I've tried. You'd think after all these years they'd have a better setup.

0 coins

i got through once after about two weeks of trying. once. and the person was helpful so i dont know why it has to be that hard

0 coins

One actual helpful person if you can get to them, but getting there is the whole problem.

0 coins

Something worth clarifying about the waiting period since I got confused by this myself early on. I assumed the seven-day waiting period was EDD processing my paperwork. It's not. It's a non-payable period built into every new claim, the first seven days you're disabled. The first day EDD will actually pay for is day eight. Processing the claim is a separate thing on top of that.

0 coins

I made that exact same mistake. Kept thinking my claim was taking two weeks plus seven days to process instead of understanding those were two different things.

0 coins

Yeah the waiting period threw me off too. I thought something was wrong with my claim for the first week.

0 coins

EDD explains it on their site, but it's easy to miss. The seven days are just not payable, full stop, not a delay.

0 coins

A payment date I expected hadn't shown up in SDI Online and I'd been checking every day for a week. I tried calling the disability line and never got past the hold music before it cut off. I ended up trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got an EDD agent on the line who told me the specific week in question had been processed and what date the payment was issued.

0 coins

That sounds helpful but I'm a little skeptical, service like that appearing right when people are frustrated with EDD seems like it's designed around a vulnerable moment to market something.

0 coins

I had the same thought when I first saw it mentioned. Then I tried the disability line for ten straight mornings and nothing. Used it and spoke to someone at EDD who confirmed the medical certification on my claim had been received. So from my own experience it's just what it says it is.

0 coins

Fair enough. I've got a question about my DE 2593 that I need to sort out before the 20-day window closes, so I might just try it.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the form in front of you. That's what I had ready when the agent answered.

0 coins

Filing even with uncertainty about eligibility is the right call. EDD reviews what's in the wage records and issues either a Notice of Computation or a denial notice. Either one tells you where you stand.

0 coins

This is basically the consensus I'm getting here and I think it's right. I'll file and go from there.

0 coins

Let the process do what it's supposed to do. That's all you can do.

0 coins

My HR department got the state wrong on my withholding for almost a year before anyone caught it. When I eventually asked about it they were apologetic but couldn't undo the past quarters. I never ended up needing to file disability during that stretch but I always wondered what would have happened if I had.

0 coins

thats kind of scary. like youre just trusting them to do it right and they dont and you have no idea

0 coins

Exactly lol. I check my stubs every month now. Learned that lesson.

0 coins

Filed in SDI Online through myEDD, got the receipt number right away, gave it to my doctor's office that same day. The office submitted the medical certification within a few days and then I just waited. Notice of Computation showed up about 10 days after that. Anyway the whole thing went pretty smooth once I had the right info to give the doctor.

0 coins

This gives me hope that the actual filing process isn't as complicated as I'm imagining it.

0 coins

It's not bad once you're just doing it. The confusing part for me was more what all the terms meant beforehand. Anyway just do it.

0 coins

The myEDD portal makes it pretty straightforward. Keep the receipt number saved somewhere you can find it easily.

0 coins

If your employer did withhold for the wrong state, that's on them, not you. Document everything, your paystubs, any communication with HR about it. If you end up denied and appealing, that paper trail could matter.

0 coins

I actually have all my stubs saved as PDFs so the documentation is there. I'll keep those organized just in case.

0 coins

Good instinct. Having the stubs shows what was and wasn't deducted and can support an appeal if you need to make the case.

0 coins

Exactly. Don't throw anything away.

0 coins

For the medical certification, make sure the provider submitting it is on EDD's list of who can certify. It's not just any licensed professional. It includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and a few others. Someone asked me once if a physical therapist could certify and the answer is no, they're not on the list.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a specific list. I just assumed any doctor could do it.

0 coins

Most people assume that. It's the licensed health care providers EDD specifies. Your regular physician is almost always fine.

0 coins

EDD's site lists them under the claim filing section. Worth a quick check if your situation involves a specialist.

0 coins

been dealing with this same question about out-of-state employer withholding for months and nobody at EDD could tell me anything because i couldnt get through. eventually sent a message through SDI Online using the Request Claim Update option and got a response a few days later that at least pointed me in the right direction.

0 coins

I didn't know you could send a message through SDI Online like that. That's really helpful to know.

0 coins

yeah go into your claim in SDI Online and there's a request claim update option. pick the type that fits and write your question. not instant but it works.

0 coins

Slower than a phone call but at least you get an answer in writing. Sometimes that's better anyway.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure