Back to California Disability

Freya Collins

SDI denied wrong base period self-employed — how to correct it?

So I've been doing freelance graphic design for about three years, and I pay into SDI through my Schedule SE each year. Last spring I had to stop working completely for about six weeks because of a back injury that my doctor said kept me from sitting at a computer for any length of time. I filed my DI claim through SDI Online and thought everything was in order. Then I got a Notice of Determination saying my claim was denied because I didn't have enough wages in the base period they used. The thing is, I think they pulled the wrong quarter or the wrong twelve-month window entirely, because my earnings in the year before the injury were solid. My highest-earning quarter would more than cover the minimum. Has anyone dealt with EDD using the wrong base period, especially as a self-employed person who pays into SDI voluntarily? I filed the appeal form that came with the denial but I honestly don't know what documentation I need to pull together or whether the appeal is even the right path here. Any help would be really appreciated.

Waiting period confusion nearly cost me my claim, so I want to share what cleared it up for me. I assumed the seven-day waiting period was just processing time and that EDD would start counting my benefit days from when I filed. That is not how it works at all. Those first seven days of your disability are simply non-payable, no matter how fast EDD processes anything. For a self-employed person appealing a denial, that detail matters because if EDD recalculates your base period and approves you, day eight is still your first payable day. Anyway, I had a separate confusion about which quarter my own claim used, and after three mornings of the disability line ending the call before I even heard a hold message, I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up speaking with an actual EDD agent. The agent confirmed the waiting period start date on my claim matched my disability start date exactly. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability if anyone needs it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing the name but have no idea what it does.

0 coins

Glad you asked. Basically it stays on hold with EDD's disability line so your phone rings once a live agent picks up, and you take it from there.

0 coins

Got it, appreciate that. My claim has a date discrepancy I need cleared up, so I might give that a shot. For the original poster, the waiting period point is a good one to flag for the appeal too, because if EDD corrects the base period you want to make sure the start date is right as well.

0 coins

Appeals are absolutely the right path here. The Notice of Determination you got has an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, and you have 30 days from the date printed on that notice to get it in. Miss that window and you need to explain the delay to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

Thirty days from the date on the notice, not from when I received it?

0 coins

Correct. Date printed on the notice, not your mailbox date. Mail it to the return address on the notice itself, not any general EDD address.

0 coins

Does that mean I should photograph or scan the envelope with the postmark just in case? I'm waiting on a denial for something similar and I want a paper trail.

0 coins

Not a bad idea. I keep copies of everything I mail to EDD, envelope included.

0 coins

The base period for a DI claim covers four quarters, the highest-paid single quarter of that twelve-month window is what sets your weekly benefit amount. EDD's site has a calculator that lets you plug in your earnings by quarter so you can see which quarter they should have used versus which one they apparently did. Pull your Schedule SE filings and your SDI payment records, run the numbers, and attach the output to your appeal letter with a clear explanation of the discrepancy.

0 coins

That calculator is really useful, thank you. My Schedule SE for the year before the injury shows my highest quarter clearly so I'll attach that.

0 coins

Exactly right. The more specific you are about the quarter and the wage total, the cleaner your appeal argument is. A detailed letter works as well as the DE 1000A form if you've misplaced the form, as long as it's mailed to the address on the notice.

0 coins

I didn't know you could use a letter instead of the form if you lose it. Good to know!

0 coins

Self-employed thing confused me at first too. You pay CASDI voluntarily, same deduction line on a paystub but you're electing it. EDD still looks at your reported wages the same way, so the base period rules don't change just because you're freelance.

0 coins

Right, that part I understood. The issue is they seem to have grabbed the wrong twelve months entirely, not just the wrong quarter within the right window.

0 coins

Then your appeal needs to spell out exactly which twelve months they should have used and why. Keep it simple and factual.

0 coins

In my experience EDD doesn't always pull the most recent base period first. They go with the standard window and sometimes that works against you. Appeal clearly states the right window, attach your earnings proof, done.

0 coins

This is exactly what happened to a guy I know in construction. He appealed, attached two years of his Schedule SE returns, and EDD corrected the quarter. Took a few weeks but it worked.

0 coins

Yep. Clear documentation beats a phone argument every time.

0 coins

Two years of Schedule SE returns, noted. I'll pull both just to be thorough.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. I'm self-employed too and I thought you couldn't even get SDI if you were freelance. Is that only if you haven't elected into the program?

0 coins

If you haven't elected coverage and paid the CASDI contributions, then you're right, you're not covered. But if you have been paying into it voluntarily, you are covered and can file a DI claim just like any employee.

0 coins

Oh okay, that makes sense. I need to check whether my contributions have been going through correctly then before I ever need to file.

0 coins

Checking that now is much smarter than finding out during a denial. Your SDI payment records should show the contributions are current.

0 coins

Thirty days goes fast when you're recovering from an injury. File the appeal today if you haven't already.

0 coins

Filed it the day I got the notice. Still pulling together the supporting documents to send separately.

0 coins

Send everything together if you can. One packet is cleaner than staggered mailings.

0 coins

Quarter three of my base period is what EDD used for my claim, and I genuinely wasn't sure that was the right one. I'd been doing gig work alongside my regular job and my earnings were uneven across quarters. After about nine days of busy signals and dead ends on the disability line, I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr and asked which quarter they'd actually pulled for my base period. The agent looked it up and confirmed quarter three was correct given my claim start date, and walked me through which wages they'd counted. That settled it for me.

0 coins

Glad you got that resolved. Did the agent say anything about how to verify the quarter yourself in SDI Online, or was it only visible by calling?

0 coins

The agent said the Notice of Computation lists the quarter they used, so if you have that letter it should be on there. I'd already misplaced mine so calling was the only way I could get it at that point.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'll check my Notice of Computation first before making any calls then.

0 coins

I've been searching for my Notice of Computation for a week. Good reminder to actually file these things somewhere I can find them.

0 coins

my cousin did freelance video editing and had the exact same problem, wrong base period in the denial. he just wrote a really clear letter explaining the quarters and mailed his tax returns with it and they fixed it

0 coins

Good to hear it worked without a full hearing. Did he have to wait a long time for the correction?

0 coins

few weeks i think, wasnt super fast but it did get sorted

0 coins

Every case is different. Don't assume the same timeline.

0 coins

For the appeal letter, keep it straightforward. State the quarter you believe they should have used, state the wages in that quarter, attach your Schedule SE. Explain the discrepancy once, clearly, and stop there.

0 coins

Should I reference the Notice of Determination number in the letter?

0 coins

Yes. Include it at the top so they can match your letter to your file immediately.

0 coins

Does the appeal automatically put your claim on hold, or does EDD keep processing anything while you wait for the hearing?

0 coins

The denial stands while the appeal is pending. EDD doesn't pay benefits on a denied claim just because an appeal was filed.

0 coins

That's rough. So there's no income at all until the appeal is resolved?

0 coins

Not from EDD disability, no. If you're able to work again you could file for unemployment separately, but disability and unemployment can't be claimed for the same days.

0 coins

Wait, so if I go back to work while my DI appeal is pending, I lose the disability claim?

0 coins

Disability covers the days you genuinely can't do your regular work. If you're back to work, those days aren't disability days. The two programs can't cover the same period.

0 coins

Sending the appeal certified mail is worth it. At least you have proof it was received. EDD losing a document and then saying the appeal was late is a nightmare I've heard about from people, anyway.

0 coins

Certified mail, got it. I was just going to drop it in a mailbox.

0 coins

Definitely get the receipt. Small extra step and it matters a lot if there's ever a question about timing.

0 coins

Administrative law judge hearing sounds scary but it's really just your chance to present what you have! I went through an appeal on my own claim last year for a different reason and the process was actually pretty clear once I had my documents organized. The Notice of Determination explains the whole appeal process on the back.

0 coins

Good to know the back of the notice has the instructions. I read the front and kind of panicked.

0 coins

Flip it over! Everything you need is there. And bring every document you think might be relevant, better to have too much than too little.

0 coins

Useful reminder. I skipped the back of mine and had to call to ask what to do.

0 coins

Appeals that go to a hearing: you get to present your wage records, your tax filings, any correspondence from EDD. The administrative law judge is there to hear your side, not just rubber-stamp the denial. Bring organized copies of everything.

0 coins

Organized copies for each party present, or just one set?

0 coins

Bring extras. At minimum one for yourself, one to submit. Ask when you're notified of the hearing whether the judge wants additional copies in advance.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim kept showing a question mark in SDI Online and I had no idea if my direct deposit had even been set up. Tried the disability line for days. Eventually used Claimyr and an agent pulled up my account and confirmed direct deposit was linked and that the first payment had been scheduled. I'd been worried I'd have to deal with the debit card situation on top of everything else.

0 coins

Honestly this reads like a sponsored post or something. How is Claimyr actually useful if EDD's line is as backed up as everyone says?

0 coins

I had the same doubt at first, but then I tried it when my claim had an issue with which weeks had been marked paid. The agent I ended up talking to went through my claim week by week and confirmed which ones had issued and which were still showing open. That was real information I couldn't get any other way.

0 coins

Okay, if it's giving actual week-by-week info that's different from just being on hold forever. I might try it for my own claim.

0 coins

the appeal thing still makes me nervous for the original poster. base period disputes can take a while

0 coins

Yeah, I'm prepared for it to take some time. Just want to make sure I'm doing everything right on my end.

0 coins

you are. the documentation approach people are describing here is what works.

0 coins

Linking the Schedule SE to the specific quarter in dispute is the key move. I've seen people attach their whole tax return without pointing to the page and the reviewer has to hunt for it. Put a sticky note or a highlight on the exact line.

0 coins

Highlighting the specific line, that's a practical tip I wouldn't have thought of.

0 coins

Makes it easier for whoever is reading it to see exactly what you're pointing to without having to interpret anything.

0 coins

Agreed. Any document you attach should have the relevant section clearly marked.

0 coins

Medical certification on my injury claim came back as not received by EDD even though my doctor's office had submitted it online. I'd given them my receipt number and everything. After a week of trying the disability line and getting nowhere, I used Claimyr and an agent told me the certification had come in but was matched to a different claim ID, not mine. The agent flagged it so the right team could fix the match.

0 coins

How did they know it was matched to the wrong ID? Did they tell you what to do next?

0 coins

The agent could see the submission timestamp and my provider's license number in the system, and those matched what my doctor's office had submitted. The agent said to watch SDI Online for the status to update, and that if it didn't update within a few days I should contact them again through Ask EDD.

0 coins

Two weeks trying that line myself and I still haven't gotten through. Good to know there's another way.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the people I've known who appealed a base period issue and had solid documentation won. It just takes patience and really organized paperwork.

0 coins

That's encouraging. I've got three years of clean Schedule SE filings so I feel like the documentation side is solid.

0 coins

That's exactly what you need. Clear records make the whole thing less stressful.

0 coins

EDD gets the base period wrong more than people realize. It's not always obvious from the denial notice which window they used. Worth asking in your appeal letter that they specifically state which four quarters they calculated from.

0 coins

That's a smart thing to include. Asking them to identify the quarters they used so I can directly compare.

0 coins

Makes the error undeniable if it's spelled out.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation should have that information if you received one before the denial, but if not, explicitly requesting it in the appeal is the right move.

0 coins

wait can a physical therapist certify a disability claim? my pt said she could fill out the medical certification for me

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a DI claim. You need a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, chiropractor, optometrist, podiatrist, dentist, psychologist, or similar licensed provider. Ask your treating doctor or whoever prescribed your PT to do the certification instead.

0 coins

oh no i didnt know that. i havent filed yet so ill get my actual doctor to do it, thanks

0 coins

Better to find that out now than after submitting. Good catch.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure