Back to California Disability

Mae Bennett

SDI denied because employer exempt, can I still collect unemployment after back injury?

So I hurt my back pretty bad at a non-work event, been out for going on three weeks now. Filed my SDI claim through SDI Online like two days after it happened and just got a denial notice saying my employer is exempt from SDI. I didn't even know employers could opt out of this. Apparently my company runs some kind of voluntary plan or something, so EDD says I don't qualify under state SDI. The notice has an appeal form but I'm honestly not sure appealing makes sense if the employer is legitimately exempt. Here's the thing though, my back is bad enough that I can't do my warehouse job right now, but the doctor says maybe in another 3-4 weeks I might be ready. So I'm sitting here with zero income wondering if unemployment is even an option while I can't actually work. I know unemployment usually requires you to be able and available to work, so I'm spinning my wheels on this. Anyone dealt with the employer-exempt SDI denial situation and figured out what to do next?

Waiting period question first, because it matters for your situation either way. When I filed my own DI claim last spring after shoulder surgery, I had to confirm with EDD exactly which seven days counted as the non-payable waiting period before my first payable day. Spent a solid week trying to reach someone on 1-800-480-3287 with no luck. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to an actual EDD agent without spending my entire morning on hold. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed my waiting period started on the first day I was unable to work, not the day I filed, and that my first payable day was the eighth day. For your situation, if there's any question about voluntary plan coverage, knowing exactly how those seven days are counted is worth pinning down.

0 coins

The base period question is what I need answered for my own claim and I'd try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready before I phone in?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the dates you stopped working. The agent can pull up exactly what's on file.

0 coins

My waiting period came out the same way, day one being out of work, not day one of filing. That detail tripped me up at first too.

0 coins

The unemployment question is the one to ask EDD directly, because the answer depends on whether your voluntary plan denial affects your base period wages in EDD's records. What EDD's site says plainly is that you can't receive unemployment and disability for the same days, and unemployment requires you to be able and available to work every week you claim. With a back injury keeping you from your warehouse job, that second requirement is the problem right now.

0 coins

Yeah that's what I figured. Can't exactly tell unemployment I'm ready to load pallets when my doctor has me on lifting restrictions.

0 coins

Exactly the right read. When your doctor clears you, that's the moment to file for unemployment, not before. EDD decides each claim, but being able and available to work is the weekly requirement.

0 coins

Does the voluntary plan denial count against you somehow when you go back and file unemployment later? Like does EDD flag your record?

0 coins

Employer-exempt thing is a real headache. Mine tried to tell me I was under their voluntary plan too and I had to dig through my onboarding paperwork to even figure out what coverage I had. The SDI denial notice should tell you exactly which plan applies, or at least give you a reason code. Read that thing closely before deciding to appeal or drop it.

0 coins

I looked at the notice again, it's the DE 2517, and it does say voluntary plan but doesn't give me a contact for the plan administrator.

0 coins

HR is your starting point. The plan administrator info has to come from them, not from EDD.

0 coins

HR stonewalled me on the same thing once. Put your request in writing so you have a record of asking.

0 coins

Appeal deadline is worth noting before anything else. The DE 2517 denial has a DE 1000A appeal form attached, and you have 30 days from the date on that notice. If you let that pass, a late appeal requires explaining the delay to an administrative law judge. So decide on the appeal question first, then figure out the voluntary plan coverage question separately.

0 coins

I'm at day nine since the notice date. So I've got time, but not a lot of it.

0 coins

Get the appeal in if there's any doubt. You can always withdraw later if the voluntary plan confirms full coverage. Missing the window is permanent.

0 coins

The 30-day clock thing bit a friend of mine. She thought she had more time and lost her shot. File the appeal first, sort it out after.

0 coins

Voluntary plan or state SDI, somebody has to cover you for a legit back injury if your employer opted into an approved plan. That plan has to meet at least what SDI provides. HR should hand you the plan administrator's number, and that's who actually processes your claim while state EDD is out of the picture.

0 coins

So the voluntary plan is supposed to pay at least as much as state SDI would? That's the first good news I've heard.

0 coins

That's EDD's requirement for approving a voluntary plan. Whether your employer's plan actually does that is between you and the plan administrator. EDD isn't the one paying you in that case.

0 coins

This is what I wish I'd known earlier. The voluntary plan route isn't a dead end, it's just a different door.

0 coins

cant believe employers can just opt out of sdi and nobody tells you at hiring, like that should be on your offer letter or something

0 coins

It is disclosed, usually buried in the benefits summary. Most people don't read it.

0 coins

fair enough but still

0 coins

Unemployment eligibility after a back injury is worth checking through Ask EDD on EDD's site if you don't want to stay on hold. You type your question in and they respond, slower than a phone call but it creates a written record of what they tell you.

0 coins

Does Ask EDD actually give you a real answer or just links to pages you've already read?

0 coins

Real answers in my experience, took about a week. For something like this where you just need a yes or no on eligibility timing, it worked fine.

0 coins

Might use that for the unemployment question. The SDI piece I think I need to sort through the voluntary plan first.

0 coins

My base period situation was confusing me. I wasn't sure which quarter of my wages EDD was actually looking at and whether my part-time months from earlier this year would drag my benefit amount down. I tried calling 1-800-480-3287 so many times, I lost count. Used Claimyr and ended up with an EDD agent on the line. She told me which quarter of my base period they were using and confirmed the actual wages on file matched what my W-2 showed.

0 coins

My base period quarter thing matched my own claim, same kind of uncertainty about earlier part-time work. I've used Claimyr too and once the agent confirmed which quarter was in use, I checked whether any missing wages would change my Notice of Computation amount. Turns out the amount was already final by then.

0 coins

been trying that line for two weeks, different times, never gets past the hold music before it cuts me off

0 coins

That's the same thing I dealt with for a while. The music stops and then nothing.

0 coins

Voluntary plan coverage not applying is one thing. No coverage at all is a different thing. Make sure your employer's plan actually enrolled you. Sometimes new hires get missed in the enrollment process. That's an HR problem, not an EDD problem.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about whether I was actually enrolled. I've been there two years but worth double-checking.

0 coins

Two years makes it less likely, but check anyway. Errors happen.

0 coins

While you're sorting out the voluntary plan vs. state SDI thing, go ahead and start gathering your pay stubs and your note from the doctor about the lifting restrictions. If you end up filing unemployment once you're cleared to work, you'll want that documentation ready anyway, and if the appeal goes somewhere, you'll need proof of your wages.

0 coins

Good point. I've got my last four pay stubs and the doctor's note says no lifting over 10 lbs for at least four weeks.

0 coins

Keep that note. The date range on the doctor's restrictions is exactly what you'd need to show why you couldn't meet unemployment's able-and-available requirement during those weeks.

0 coins

Is a doctor's note enough or does unemployment need something more official?

0 coins

EDD decides based on what you submit. What documentation they require beyond a standard written restriction note is a question to put to them directly.

0 coins

The DE 2500A form question came up for me separately from all the voluntary plan drama. I wasn't sure if I'd need to certify every two weeks or if automatic payments were set up. Got an EDD agent on the phone after trying Claimyr, and she said my claim was set to automatic payment for the first five payments. After that, the DE 2593 would be mailed to me and I'd have 20 days to return it or benefits would stop.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly, never heard of it before?

0 coins

It waits on EDD's line for you so your phone rings when an agent picks up, instead of you sitting there for hours. I found it when I'd given up on getting through myself.

0 coins

Alright, my question would be about which weeks they have on record as paid. I'll try it for that.

0 coins

The DE 2593 deadline is the one that catches people off guard. 20 days sounds like plenty until you're managing a recovery and suddenly the form got buried on the counter.

0 coins

For the back injury piece: make sure whoever is certifying your claim is on EDD's list of licensed health professionals. Your primary care doctor or an orthopedist are fine. A physical therapist cannot certify a DI claim, which surprises some people.

0 coins

Wait, a physical therapist can't do it? My PT has been the main person I've seen.

0 coins

PT is not on EDD's list. It needs to be a physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, or another provider EDD recognizes. Your PT can document your restrictions for HR, but the medical certification has to come from someone on that list.

0 coins

My orthopedist signed the certification so I think I'm okay on that one.

0 coins

The appeal form question is simpler than people make it sound. Mail the DE 1000A to the return address on your denial notice, include a written explanation of why you disagree, and that's it. They review it. No magic involved.

0 coins

Even if the denial is because of the employer-exempt status? Like is there even a basis to appeal that?

0 coins

The basis would be if you believe you should be covered under state SDI despite what the denial says. If your employer is legitimately in a voluntary plan, you're appealing to the wrong party. Your claim is with the plan, not EDD.

0 coins

That's the right distinction. The appeal is for disputing EDD's ruling on a state SDI claim. If the voluntary plan is the right vehicle, HR and the plan administrator are the path.

0 coins

The employer-exempt situation does get resolved. I know someone who went through the voluntary plan route for a knee surgery and got paid. Slower than state SDI would have been, but the plan paid. The key was filing directly with the plan administrator within whatever deadline the plan set, not waiting on EDD.

0 coins

Did they give you a sense of what the plan's deadline was? Mine didn't come with any paperwork on the voluntary plan at all.

0 coins

Ask HR in writing today, specifically for the plan administrator contact and any filing deadline. The plan has its own rules separate from EDD's.

0 coins

Payment method on my own claim took a while to sort out. Wasn't sure if I'd get the Money Network debit card or direct deposit, and nothing was confirming in SDI Online. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent and she confirmed the payment method on file matched what I'd selected when I filed.

0 coins

I'll be honest, I read that and my first reaction was doubt, because I've tried that disability line probably a dozen times in the last month and it's either busy or drops after the hold music. Never once got to a human.

0 coins

I get the skepticism. I had the same run of it, mornings, mid-afternoon, didn't matter. The agent I spoke with was a regular EDD employee, confirmed the payment method and said direct deposit would apply starting with the first issued payment.

0 coins

The payment method question is a real one. EDD says direct deposit is available for SDI Online claims, but which weeks were actually paid through it matters if something looks off on the deposit end.

0 coins

EDD's disability calculator on their site at edd.ca.gov is worth running even if the voluntary plan ends up being the right path. It gives you an estimate of what state SDI would have paid based on your wages, which gives you a floor to compare against whatever the voluntary plan offers. If the plan pays less than state SDI would, that's worth noting.

0 coins

Didn't know I could run the calculator even if I'm not on state SDI. That's useful for the comparison.

0 coins

The calculator is public, you don't need to be on an active state SDI claim. Use it to benchmark.

0 coins

the voluntary plan at my old job paid less and nobody pushed back on it because they didnt know what the benchmark was

0 coins

Can I ask about the unemployment timing question because I'm in a somewhat similar spot, different injury but same uncertainty. If my doctor clears me for light duty but not my full job, does unemployment treat that as able and available to work?

0 coins

Whether partial clearance counts as able and available for unemployment is a determination EDD makes case by case. The question to put to them is exactly what you wrote: cleared for light duty but not the full regular job. Ask EDD in writing so you have the response.

0 coins

Okay I'll put the question to them in writing through Ask EDD, that makes sense.

0 coins

The base period wage thing is worth understanding regardless of which path you're on. EDD looks at wages from roughly five to eighteen months before your claim started, picks the highest quarter, and that quarter drives your weekly benefit estimate. If you had lower earnings in some periods, the calculator on EDD's site will show you which quarter was highest.

0 coins

My pay has been pretty steady for two years so hopefully that's not a complicating factor.

0 coins

Steady pay for two years is about the cleanest situation for the base period calculation. Run the numbers on the calculator anyway so you know what to expect on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

The voluntary plan appeal vs. EDD appeal thing is the real fork in the road here. You can't do both at once and expect them to coordinate. Decide which claim is the right one, file that appeal or that plan claim, and pursue it. Trying to work both angles at the same time usually just slows everything down.

0 coins

So your read is pick one and go hard on it rather than hedging?

0 coins

If your employer is legitimately in a voluntary plan, the EDD appeal is probably a dead end. Put your energy into the plan administrator and get their filing deadline from HR today.

0 coins

The EDD appeal deadline is still worth preserving in writing, even if you end up not pursuing it. Mail the DE 1000A before day 30 just to keep the option open.

0 coins

The doctor's availability for certifying is worth confirming too. If your orthopedist submitted the medical certification to EDD as part of the state SDI filing, that cert is on file with EDD. The voluntary plan administrator may need their own form filled out separately. Two different certifications for two different claims.

0 coins

So I'd need my orthopedist to fill out the plan's own form separately? That's another thing to coordinate.

0 coins

Usually yes. Plan administrators often have their own paperwork. Call the office and give them a heads up so they're not surprised by two different forms coming in.

0 coins

can you even file for unemployment and have it pending while you wait to see if the voluntary plan pays? like just to have something in process

0 coins

EDD says you can't receive unemployment and disability for the same days. While you're unable to work due to the injury, you don't meet unemployment's requirement of being able and available to work, so filing unemployment during that period creates a conflict. When you're cleared to work, that's the right time to file.

0 coins

ok so its not like you can file early and just not collect until ready

0 coins

Exactly. Filing while you can't work doesn't put you in some kind of queue. Unemployment is week by week and each week you have to certify you're able to work.

0 coins

spent three weeks trying to get through to someone on the sdi line about my own claim. mornings mostly. never once got past the automated part

0 coins

Three weeks is about where I stopped counting. It becomes this background task you do every morning that never goes anywhere.

0 coins

yeah exactly. its just part of the morning routine now

0 coins

Two things worth repeating from this whole thread for anyone in the same spot: file the DE 1000A before day 30 of the denial notice date even if you end up not needing it, and get the voluntary plan administrator contact from HR in writing today. Those two steps keep all your options open while you figure out which path actually applies.

0 coins

Printed this out. Day 17 now, so I've got time on the appeal window. HR emailed me back this afternoon with the plan administrator's number. Starting there tomorrow.

0 coins

Good. The plan administrator is the right next call. Have the denial notice date and the DE 2517 handy when you reach them.

0 coins

Is the plan administrator going to know what the DE 2517 is, or is that an EDD form they won't recognize?

0 coins

The plan administrator deals with EDD denials regularly. The DE 2517 is familiar to them. Bring it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure