Back to California Disability

Carmen Ruiz

SDI denied after independent medical exam how to appeal — what actually worked for me

Got my denial notice last week and I'm honestly not sure where to start. My claim had been pending forever and EDD sent me to one of their independent medical exams a few weeks back. The examiner barely spent 10 minutes with me and now the notice came back saying I don't meet the criteria to be unable to do my regular work. I'm still dealing with the same back issue that my own doctor certified me for, so it really stings. I think the notice said something about 30 days to appeal but I'm not sure if I need a special form or just write a letter or what. Has anyone actually gone through appealing after one of these exams? Not sure what to put in the appeal or what documentation to pull together.

The denial notice itself is what you need to look at first. It should have an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, attached right to it. If you can't find that form, a detailed letter explaining why you disagree works in its place, but you mail it to the return address printed on the notice itself, not to any general EDD address. The 30 days runs from the date printed on the notice, not the day you received it, so count carefully.

0 coins

Thank you, I do have the notice. The date on it is from last Thursday so I still have time. Does the letter need to say anything specific or just that I disagree?

0 coins

Your letter should explain the specific reasons you disagree, and attach anything that supports your position, like your own doctor's notes or records showing what your condition actually prevents you from doing. The more specific the better.

0 coins

Worth noting, EDD's appeals page spells out that a late appeal still gets reviewed if you explain why it was late, and an administrative law judge decides whether that reason holds. So even if someone is reading this past the 30 days, don't give up without trying.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my own claim had a figure that looked off, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an EDD disability agent. The video for anyone who wants to see how reaching a live person at EDD disability works: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up my base period and confirmed which quarter they used to calculate the weekly amount. Turned out the number was right, I'd just misread the form. Anyway, for an appeal after an independent medical exam, the agent told me the DE 1000A is what starts the process and that you mail it where the notice says.

0 coins

Practical question about your call: did the agent say anything about how to word the disagreement on the form, or is it basically just your own explanation?

0 coins

Just your own explanation of why you disagree and what evidence backs it up. The agent didn't give me a template or anything, just said to be specific about what your condition prevents you from doing.

0 coins

Been hitting that disability line most mornings for two weeks and either it rings out or I get the system message that ends the call. Good to know there's another way to get a person.

0 coins

Your own treating physician's documentation carries a lot of weight here. Pull together any office visit notes, imaging reports, or work restriction letters you have from your doctor. The independent examiner spent 10 minutes with you; your doctor has the full history. That contrast is worth spelling out in your appeal.

0 coins

My doctor said she'd write a letter specifically responding to the IME findings. Is that the kind of thing I should include?

0 coins

Yes, that's exactly what to include. Attach it to your appeal when you mail it.

0 coins

Does the appeal go to EDD directly or to some separate appeals board? I've seen both mentioned and I'm not sure which applies to SDI denials.

0 coins

For SDI claims the appeal form goes to the address on the notice, and from there it goes through EDD's process to an administrative law judge hearing. You don't send it somewhere separately on your own.

0 coins

My coworker went through almost the same thing last year, IME, denial, the whole thing. She said the biggest mistake people make is being too vague on the appeal. Like, don't just say 'I disagree,' actually describe what you physically can't do and for how long you've been dealing with it. Her appeal got scheduled for a hearing and she was able to present her doctor's notes there.

0 coins

That's really helpful to know there's an actual hearing. So I'd be able to present things in person?

0 coins

From what she told me, yes. You can explain your situation and have your documentation there. It's more formal than I expected honestly.

0 coins

Wait does everyone get a hearing automatically or only some appeals? I'm in a similar situation and I didn't know hearings were even part of this process.

0 coins

A claim that isn't payable results in a Notice of Determination and that notice includes an appeal form. The appeal goes to an administrative law judge, so a hearing is part of that process. It's not a separate request you have to make, it comes with the appeal itself.

0 coins

The 30 day clock matters more than anything else here. Miss it and you're starting from scratch. Date on the notice, count forward, don't miss it.

0 coins

Already have the date written down on my calendar. Not missing it.

0 coins

Good. Mail it with tracking so you have proof of when it went out too.

0 coins

my claim got denied too but not for an ime, just for some paperwork reason. does the same appeal form work for any kind of denial or is there different forms for different reasons

0 coins

The DE 1000A is the standard appeal form for SDI denials regardless of the reason for the denial. Same process either way, same deadline.

0 coins

ok good because my notice looked the same as what this person is describing

0 coins

Two things nobody mentioned yet: keep a copy of everything you send and write down the date you mailed it. Had to prove I sent my appeal on time last year and I was really glad I had that anyway.

0 coins

Good call, I'll make copies before I send anything.

0 coins

Certified mail works too if you want something with an official postmark, that's what I did anyway.

0 coins

Same. Certified saved me once.

0 coins

Which weeks were paid on my SDI claim got confusing fast after I went back to work part time, so I tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line. She went through each week in my claim and confirmed which ones had payments issued and which were still pending. For what it's worth on the appeal question, she mentioned the DE 1000A is the right form and that you should attach everything your doctor gave you that the IME didn't have access to.

0 coins

My extension request is what I need answered, specifically whether EDD received the DE 2525XX my doctor submitted. I'll try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I get through?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and your doctor's office name ready. The agent can look up exactly what EDD has on file for your claim.

0 coins

Glad the agent confirmed the form for you. I keep second-guessing whether the DE 1000A is enough or if there's something additional for IME denials specifically.

0 coins

The DE 1000A is what EDD lists for appealing a Notice of Determination, and an IME-based denial comes through a Notice of Determination. There isn't a separate IME-specific form.

0 coins

Honestly the independent medical exam process feels designed to trip people up lol. 10 minutes with a stranger vs months of records from your own doctor and somehow that 10 minutes wins. Put everything in writing for the appeal and don't assume they already have your full history.

0 coins

That's exactly how it felt. The examiner didn't even look at the imaging reports I brought.

0 coins

Mention that in your appeal. Literally write that the examiner did not review the imaging you brought. Specifics like that matter.

0 coins

Can you request that the administrative law judge consider records that weren't part of the original IME? Or is the appeal limited to what EDD already had?

0 coins

You can submit additional supporting documentation with your appeal. Your own doctor's records, specialist notes, anything relevant. The hearing is a fresh look, not just a review of what was already there.

0 coins

Sorry if this is a dumb question but can your doctor actually attend the hearing with you or just submit written stuff? My doctor offered to help however she could and I want to know what to tell her.

0 coins

For the purpose of what you should tell her right now, written documentation and a letter specifically addressing the basis for the denial is the most important thing. Whether a provider can appear is worth confirming directly with EDD when your hearing is scheduled.

0 coins

That makes sense. I'll ask her to write the most detailed letter she can about what I can't do at work right now.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for disability is brutal. Called at 8:01 three mornings in a row and all I got was the recording that says they can't take my call and then it disconnects. Meanwhile my appeal deadline is ticking.

0 coins

I've had the same thing happen. It's so frustrating when you just need a quick answer.

0 coins

If you can get the info from the notice and the EDD website, do that. Waiting on that phone line to cooperate could eat your whole 30 days.

0 coins

The appeal form itself doesn't require you to call first. You can mail the DE 1000A with your letter and documentation without ever getting through on the phone.

0 coins

Physical job myself, shoulder injury, got an IME denial two years back. Mailed the appeal with a letter from my orthopedic surgeon that laid out exactly why I couldn't lift over a certain amount. The key was being specific about the physical demands of the actual job, not just the diagnosis.

0 coins

That's exactly the angle I want to take. My job requires a lot of lifting and bending and my doctor has restricted both of those specifically.

0 coins

Tell your doctor to put those restrictions in writing using your job's actual physical requirements if she can. The more it lines up with what your job actually demands the clearer the case.

0 coins

This is the right approach. Generic letters don't cut it. Specific restrictions tied to specific job tasks.

0 coins

DE 2525XX status was what I needed to check, whether EDD had received the extension my doctor filed. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr after the hold line disconnected on me twice. Agent confirmed the form had been received and gave me the date it was logged. That was a relief because my doctor's office couldn't tell me whether it had gone through on their end.

0 coins

Extension timing is exactly where I got stuck on my own claim too. Used Claimyr after that and once the agent confirmed the DE 2525XX date on my file I knew I didn't need to chase my doctor's office anymore. Had been trying the disability line myself every couple of days for about three weeks before I got through that way.

0 coins

Three weeks of trying that line sounds exhausting. Glad you got the confirmation.

0 coins

Good to know the extension confirmation works like that. I haven't gotten to that stage yet but I'm filing everything away for later.

0 coins

The timeline on an SDI appeal tends to run longer than people expect. File the DE 1000A as soon as your documentation is ready, don't wait until day 29. Administrative law judge hearings are scheduled after EDD processes the appeal, and you want as much buffer as you can get.

0 coins

Is there any way to know roughly how long the wait for a hearing date usually is? I'm trying to plan financially.

0 coins

EDD doesn't publish a standard timeline for hearings and it can vary. For financial planning purposes, assume it may take a while and explore any other resources available to you in the meantime.

0 coins

Does filing the appeal do anything to stop the payments from staying off during that period or do they stay paused until the hearing decision?

0 coins

Benefits are not reinstated just by filing an appeal. The claim stays in the status it's in until a decision is made. If the appeal is decided in your favor, EDD addresses the payment from there based on the ruling.

0 coins

been dealing with edd for months and the independent medical exam felt like a formality to find a reason to deny. don't give up though, file that appeal.

0 coins

Thank you. That's kind of how it felt to me too, but I'm going to push back.

0 coins

good. your own doctor's records are what matters. keep going.

0 coins

Appeals take a while, just so you know. This isn't going to resolve in a week. Set your expectations accordingly and document everything in the meantime.

0 coins

Yeah I figured it wouldn't be quick. Just want to make sure I do it right and don't miss anything.

0 coins

Then file soon and attach everything you have. That's really it.

0 coins

Has anyone had any luck with submitting through SDI Online versus mailing the appeal? I always default to mailing things but wondering if there's a faster way.

0 coins

The appeal form and supporting documents should go where the notice directs, and the DE 1000A is typically a mailed form. SDI Online's Request Claim Update feature is for general questions about a pending claim, not for submitting a formal appeal.

0 coins

Good to know, I'll stick with mailing it then and keep the tracking number.

0 coins

EDD's guidance on appeals says to mail the DE 1000A to the return address on the notice. That's the safest path.

0 coins

Filing with certified mail and keeping a photocopy of every single page you send is genuinely the move here. If EDD ever says they didn't receive something you have proof ready to go.

0 coins

Doing this for sure. I've already started making a folder with every document related to this claim.

0 coins

Same system I use. The folder gets big fast but you'll be glad you have it.

0 coins

Does the independent medical exam report itself get included in what the administrative law judge sees or do you have to request a copy of it to include with your appeal?

0 coins

You can request a copy of the IME report from EDD, and reviewing it before your hearing lets you address its specific findings directly. Your appeal letter should respond to what that report actually says if you can get it.

0 coins

That makes a lot of sense. Responding to the specific conclusions rather than just saying it was wrong is way more effective.

0 coins

Can you request it through SDI Online or does that require calling or writing in?

0 coins

Use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online or submit through Ask EDD to make that request in writing. Either leaves a record of when you asked.

0 coins

Update: I mailed the appeal this morning with the DE 1000A, a detailed letter, my doctor's office visit notes going back six months, her new letter specifically responding to the IME findings, and my imaging reports. Sent it certified mail and kept copies of everything. Really grateful for all the input here.

0 coins

That's a thorough package. You did exactly what the process calls for.

0 coins

Good work. Now you wait, but you filed the right way.

0 coins

Fingers crossed for a good outcome. You put together a solid case.

0 coins

quick question do you have to keep certifying with your doctor while the appeal is pending or does that pause

0 coins

Keep certifying through your treating physician for the period you're claiming. If the appeal succeeds, you want the medical certification to cover the right dates. Don't let that lapse thinking the appeal puts everything on hold.

0 coins

ok got it wasnt sure if that was still required during the process

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the independent medical exam process in general: EDD can order one when there's a question about whether a claimant meets the medical criteria. The examiner's report becomes part of the file EDD uses to make its determination. If the determination goes against you, the appeal is your path to have an administrative law judge look at the full picture including your own treating physician's records.

0 coins

Is there anything you can do before the IME happens to make the exam go better? Like, is there a way to prepare?

0 coins

Bring all your documentation to the exam itself, every record, imaging report, and doctor's letter. If the examiner doesn't review it, note that down afterward because it becomes relevant in an appeal.

0 coins

Wish I'd known that going in. The examiner waved off the folder I brought. Definitely put that in my appeal letter.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure