Back to California Disability

Amara Eze

SDI claim flagged for fraud, mismatch pregnancy file by mail — what happens now?

So I'm about 32 weeks pregnant and I filed my disability claim by mail because I don't have reliable internet access at home. I sent in the DE 2501 and my midwife completed and mailed in Part B for me. That was about three weeks ago. Yesterday I got a letter from EDD saying there's a mismatch issue and my claim is flagged — I think it's related to the name or maybe the dates not lining up between my part and her part? The letter mentioned fraud review and I honestly don't know what that means or how serious it is. I've never filed SDI before. Does a mismatch flag mean my whole claim gets denied? Has anyone dealt with this when they filed on paper? I'm due in about 8 weeks and I really can't afford a gap in income right now.

Waiting period question tripped me up on my own pregnancy claim last year — I thought the first week of benefits was just slow processing but it's actually a non-payable period by design, those seven days don't count toward your payments no matter what. I ended up needing to phone EDD to confirm the exact days EDD had recorded as my waiting period start because the dates on my Notice of Computation didn't match what I expected. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an agent on the disability line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and read me the exact start date they had on file, which was off by two days from what I'd written. Worth knowing for a mail claim especially, since postmark and receipt date can differ.

0 coins

Payment date on mine was also off and I had the same confusion about the waiting period days. Used Claimyr too after a week of busy signals and dead air on the disability line, and once the agent picked up I asked when my first payment had actually been issued. She told me the date and explained it was the eighth day from their recorded start, which finally made the math make sense.

0 coins

How many mornings did you try that line before you went the Claimyr route? I've been dialing at 8:01 every day for two weeks and either get the busy tone or a recording that just ends the call.

0 coins

Tried at least ten or eleven mornings myself. After the agent confirmed my payment date I went into SDI Online and cross-checked the weeks, and everything lined up once I had the right start date.

0 coins

A mismatch flag on a paper claim often comes down to something small — a name spelled differently, a date written in a different format, or the receipt number your midwife used not matching yours. The fraud review language in the letter sounds alarming but EDD uses it broadly for any discrepancy that needs verification. The important thing is to respond to whatever EDD is asking for in that letter, and to do it promptly.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

The letter asks me to call a specific number and provide documentation. It doesn't say which documents exactly, just 'documentation supporting your claim identity.' Does that mean my ID, my medical records, something else?

0 coins

Bring your photo ID, your Social Security card if you have it, and anything from your midwife's office that shows your name and the due date consistently. The goal is to show EDD that the claimant on Part A and the patient on Part B are the same person.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Okay that makes sense. I'll pull all of that together before I call.

0 coins

Paper claims get mismatched more than online ones because there's no system auto-matching the receipt number. Your midwife probably mailed Part B without putting the receipt number you got when you filed on the envelope or the form itself. That's the most common cause I've seen people mention here.

0 coins

yeah this happened to my coworker, the doctors office forgot to write the receipt number and it sat in limbo for weeks

0 coins

Exactly. And the fix usually isn't complicated once EDD can verify it's the same claim, but you have to be the one to push it through.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused — does the fraud flag mean EDD thinks you personally did something wrong? Or is it automatic when anything doesn't match? I'm asking because I'm about to file by mail too and now I'm scared.

0 coins

Automatic, not an accusation. EDD's system flags discrepancies for review as a protective step. It doesn't mean anyone believes you committed fraud, it means a human needs to verify the information matches.

0 coins

Okay that's a relief, I think. Still going to try to file online if I can find wifi somewhere just to avoid the paper process.

0 coins

Filing online doesn't guarantee no mismatch, but it does auto-populate the receipt number on the provider side, which removes one variable.

0 coins

I went through almost this exact thing when I was pregnant and filed on paper because I was on bed rest without a laptop. The mismatch on mine turned out to be my provider used my nickname on Part B instead of my legal name. Once I sent in a copy of my ID showing both names the flag cleared within about two weeks. Hang in there.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

That's actually really helpful. My midwife does call me by a shortened version of my name, so that could genuinely be it.

0 coins

Pull up whatever your midwife's office has on file for you and compare it to exactly what you wrote on Part A. If there's a difference that's probably your answer.

0 coins

EDD's own disability FAQ says a licensed midwife, nurse-midwife or nurse practitioner can certify for pregnancy, childbirth or postpartum conditions. So your midwife completing Part B is fully valid. The mismatch issue is separate from whether she's authorized to certify.

0 coins

Good to know because I wasn't sure if a midwife counted. I thought only an OB could sign off.

0 coins

Nope, midwives are explicitly on EDD's list for pregnancy and postpartum claims. The certification itself shouldn't be the problem here.

0 coins

The EDD disability phone line is a nightmare. I've called 1-800-480-3287 at least fifteen times across three weeks for my own claim issue and I've spoken to exactly zero humans. Gets to the main menu, I pick the option, it plays hold music for four minutes and then disconnects. Every single time.

0 coins

same, i gave up after like a week and just submitted through request claim update in sdi online and got a written response eventually

0 coins

That's what I ended up doing too. The SDI Online message system is slower but at least it doesn't hang up on you.

0 coins

The request claim update option in myEDD has worked better for me than the phone lately.

0 coins

Base period question on my claim was bugging me — the quarter they used to calculate my benefit amount wasn't the one I expected, looked like they went back further than I thought. Phoned EDD through Claimyr and got an agent to pull up exactly which quarter they used and what wages were in it. She confirmed the calculation came from my highest-paid quarter in the base period, which apparently isn't always the most recent one, it's whichever four quarters had the highest wages in the right window.

0 coins

I've been trying that line forever and can never get through. How is it even possible you talked to an actual person? Every time I call it either tells me call volume is too high or it cuts me off before I can get to hold.

0 coins

I know. I'd tried for two weeks before that. Claimyr holds the line and your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

My agent told me which weeks were paid on my claim when I asked, I had thought one week got skipped but it turned out it was just held until the waiting period cleared. Good to know about the base period quarter thing though, I never thought to check that.

0 coins

For a paper claim with a fraud flag, the most effective thing you can do is respond in writing AND try to reach someone by phone. Don't just do one. Send EDD a written response with your documents and also call to make sure they received it!

0 coins

Agreed on both channels. When you send documents by mail, keep copies of everything you send and note the date you mailed them.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Should I send it certified mail so there's a record it arrived?

0 coins

Certified mail is a smart move here, yes. You'll have proof of delivery if EDD later says they didn't receive it.

0 coins

Eight weeks before your due date is tight. For typical uncomplicated pregnancies EDD usually starts benefits about four weeks before the due date, so if your mismatch flag takes two or three weeks to resolve that could eat into the period before the birth. Keep pushing on the response and document everything.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

That timeline is exactly what's stressing me out. Four weeks out is basically when I need payments to start and I've already lost three weeks to this.

0 coins

If the mismatch clears, benefits should run from the day your midwife certified you as unable to do your regular work. The flag delays processing but doesn't necessarily move your start date if EDD confirms the claim is valid.

0 coins

November 14th was when I sent in my DE 2501, and I have the certified mail receipt showing EDD received it November 19th. My provider mailed Part B the same week. EDD sent me a letter about two and a half weeks later asking for identity verification. I called, provided my documents, and the flag cleared in about 10 business days after that. So total timeline from mail-in to cleared was roughly six weeks for me.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Six weeks total — okay. So if I respond to their letter this week I might be looking at cleared by mid-next-month?

0 coins

Roughly, though I can't promise that. My case may have been simpler. The key was that I responded the same week I got the letter.

0 coins

Keeping the receipt numbers and dates like that is really the right move. Hard to push back on anything without them.

0 coins

The 49-day window to get the medical certification in is a hard deadline. If your midwife mailed Part B and EDD hasn't matched it to your claim because of the mismatch flag, you need to make sure the certification itself was received before that window closes, not just mailed.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

How do I know if EDD actually received Part B? Is there a way to check online if you filed on paper?

0 coins

No online status for paper claims. You'd need to phone EDD or submit a Request Claim Update through SDI Online if you have an account. Or ask your midwife's office if they have a delivery confirmation.

0 coins

The 49 days runs from the disability start date, not the filing date. Worth confirming exactly what date EDD has as your disability start given the mismatch situation.

0 coins

The mail claim process is slower even under normal circumstances. EDD has to manually enter the information from both parts, which is why mismatches happen more often. You're doing the right things by responding promptly.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Is it too late to switch to SDI Online at this point? Or am I stuck with the paper process now that I've already filed on paper?

0 coins

Once a paper claim is filed I don't think you switch mid-claim. You'd need to ask EDD directly whether anything can be transferred. What you can do is create a myEDD account and use SDI Online to send messages and check status even on a paper claim.

0 coins

the fraud flag wording is scary but it really does just mean a discrepancy check. happened to someone in my building, resolved in about two weeks after they sent in their license and birth certificate.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Birth certificate too? That seems like a lot but I have it so I can include it.

0 coins

she included it just to be thorough, EDD didn't specifically ask for it. sending more than asked probably didn't hurt though.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim was defaulting to the Money Network card and I hadn't set up direct deposit yet. Called EDD through Claimyr about it because I'd been trying the disability line for days and kept hitting dead air. Agent told me the card had already been mailed to my address on file and that I could switch to direct deposit in SDI Online for future payments.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? I've never heard of it, is that a third party thing or through EDD?

0 coins

Not EDD's own service. Basically it handles the hold time on EDD's line for you, and your phone rings once a real EDD agent picks up. That's the gist of it.

0 coins

Oh interesting. I need to ask EDD about my waiting period start date because the letter I got has a date that doesn't match when I stopped working. Might try that for it.

0 coins

Fraud flags on mismatch cases usually resolve without denial if the identity information checks out. The bigger risk is timing. Respond to EDD's letter this week if you haven't, include clear copies of your ID and anything that shows your name consistently across both parts of the claim.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Calling tomorrow morning first thing with everything pulled together. I really appreciate everyone's input here.

0 coins

Good. If the agent you reach can't resolve it on the call, ask them to note in your file that you responded and provided documentation. Get a name or ID number from them if they'll give it.

0 coins

wait can a midwife even certify for sdi? i thought you needed a doctor

0 coins

Licensed midwives and nurse-midwives are on EDD's authorized list specifically for pregnancy, childbirth and postpartum conditions. A doctor isn't required for a pregnancy claim.

0 coins

oh okay i had no idea, i always assumed it had to be an MD

0 coins

Medical certification question on my own pregnancy claim had me going in circles. Filed online but my OB's office submitted through a different version of their portal and it didn't attach to my claim for almost two weeks. Used Claimyr to reach an agent on the disability line, and she told me EDD had received the certification but it wasn't matched to my claim ID yet — she confirmed the receipt number my doctor's office had used and said it would update within a few business days.

0 coins

Used Claimyr once too. Agent found my DE 2593 in the system and confirmed it had been received on the right date, which explained why my payments hadn't stopped. Relieved to have that confirmed because I'd been unsure whether the form even arrived.

0 coins

How long after the agent told you that did the DE 2593 confirmation actually show up in SDI Online?

0 coins

About three days. The agent said it was received, and three days later my payment for that period came through.

0 coins

If your midwife used certified mail for Part B, ask her office for the delivery confirmation number so you can at least verify it was delivered to EDD. That gives you something concrete to reference when you talk to them.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Texted her office just now to ask for that number. Good thinking.

0 coins

If they don't have it, have them note in writing the date they mailed it. Any documentation is better than nothing.

0 coins

Something that helped me on a paper claim issue was writing out a timeline — every date, every form, every mailing — and keeping it next to me when I called EDD. Makes it a lot easier to answer whatever questions they ask without fumbling around.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Writing mine up tonight. I have the receipt from when I mailed the DE 2501, the postmark date, and my midwife's confirmation of when she mailed Part B.

0 coins

Perfect. If EDD has questions about timing, having those dates ready shows the claim was filed inside the window and the certification went in on time.

0 coins

A timeline like that also helps if you ever need to file an appeal. Dates are everything with EDD.

0 coins

To the original poster — the Notice of Computation will come once the claim clears and EDD confirms eligibility. That document shows your weekly amount and the total. It's not an approval but it means they've processed enough of the claim to calculate the benefit.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Haven't gotten that yet obviously. Hopefully once this flag resolves it comes quickly.

0 coins

Usually within about two weeks after the certification is matched and verified, in a normal timeline. With the mismatch adding time, just keep the lines of communication open with EDD.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure