Back to California Disability

Joshua Wood

SDI claim denied because employer continued to pay during pregnancy leave — what now?

So I finally got a determination letter from EDD and I honestly don't even know where to start. I filed my SDI claim about five weeks into my pregnancy leave, everything seemed fine, my midwife submitted the medical certification, and then I get this denial notice. The reason they gave is that my employer kept paying me my full salary the whole time I was out. I had no idea that could be a problem. My HR department told me the company just does that for pregnancy leave, they continue your pay, and I thought that was a good thing? Now I'm reading the denial and I'm panicking a little because I don't know if I can appeal or if I even have a case. Has anyone had their SDI claim denied because employer continued to pay during pregnancy leave and gotten through it? The notice came with an appeal form and it says I have 30 days. I don't want to miss that window but I also don't understand what I'm even appealing.

Thirty days from the date printed on that notice is your appeal deadline, not 30 days from when you got it in the mail, so check the date on the letter itself right away. The form that came with it is the DE 1000A. If you've misplaced it, a detailed letter explaining why you disagree works too, mailed to the return address on the denial. Keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

The date on the notice is from about two weeks ago so I still have time, that's a relief. I still have the DE 1000A. Should I explain the salary situation in the letter or just fill in the form?

0 coins

Fill out the DE 1000A and attach a written explanation of your employer's salary continuation policy. Any documentation from HR about how that pay was structured would help your case at the administrative law judge level.

0 coins

HR gave me something in writing when I started leave so I'll include that. I didn't realize a written policy from them would actually matter here.

0 coins

EDD's position when an employer continues full wages during leave is that there may be no wage loss to replace, which is what DI is designed to cover. That said, the way your employer structured those payments matters a lot. Whether it was classified as salary continuation, vacation pay, sick pay or something else can affect how EDD looks at it. The appeal is exactly the right move while you sort this out.

0 coins

This is the part that trips people up. The label your employer puts on those payments isn't always what EDD goes by when they evaluate the claim.

0 coins

My HR said it's their standard 'salary continuation' policy for pregnancy leave, not PTO or sick time. Would that distinction matter in an appeal?

0 coins

It likely does matter, and the administrative law judge would be the one to weigh it. Document exactly what HR told you about how the pay category is coded and bring that to the appeal.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim didn't match what my OB's office used when they filed the medical certification, so the whole thing sat in limbo. Tried that EDD disability line, 1-800-480-3287, for three days and got nowhere. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got someone on the phone. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt numbers were mismatched, told me my provider needed to refile with the correct one. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The mismatched receipt number detail you mentioned is exactly what happened with my own claim. Had the same issue with my provider using a different number, used Claimyr too and got through to an agent who confirmed which receipt number was on file and what my Notice of Computation showed for my weekly amount. Knowing the actual number from my notice helped me figure out next steps.

0 coins

How many mornings did you spend trying that line before you gave up? I've had four days in a row where I dial at 8:01 and the recording cuts me off before I even get to hold.

0 coins

Four mornings for me before I tried a different route. The line either rang endlessly or dropped before I got anywhere.

0 coins

Appeals for pregnancy SDI denials do get reversed. The 30-day window is firm though, so get the DE 1000A in the mail before you spend too much time researching. You can keep gathering documentation while the appeal is pending.

0 coins

Mailing it this week. I'm going to include the HR letter and a timeline of my leave. Is there anything else that tends to help?

0 coins

Pay stubs from the leave period showing what your employer actually paid and how they labeled it would be useful. The more concrete the paper trail, the better.

0 coins

Don't wait on that appeal form. I've seen guys at my place miss the deadline by a few days and lose their shot entirely. Mail it certified so you have proof of the date.

0 coins

Certified mail is smart, then you have the postmark if anything gets disputed later. Same thing my wife did when her extension paperwork was questioned.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD goes by the postmark so it matters.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If your employer paid you the whole time, does that mean you weren't technically on unpaid leave? Because I thought SDI only covers you if you have actual wage loss. Not sure if I'm reading that right or if there's an exception for pregnancy.

0 coins

That's roughly right. DI is designed to replace wages you actually lost because you couldn't work. If your employer fully continued your salary, EDD's view is that there wasn't a wage loss during those weeks, so there's nothing to replace.

0 coins

So does the appeal even have a chance then? I'd be scared to appeal if EDD is just going to deny it again.

0 coins

Whether it has a chance depends on how the employer's payments were classified and documented. That's why the administrative law judge process exists, to look at the specifics. Filing the appeal doesn't cost anything and preserves the right to be heard.

0 coins

my cousin had the same thing happen and it took forever but she won her appeal. the judge looked at how the employer coded the pay and it made a difference

0 coins

How the pay was coded is really the crux of it. It's not just about whether money came in, it's about what category EDD considers it under for DI purposes.

0 coins

yeah she had HR write a letter explaining exactly what it was and that helped a lot

0 coins

Payment date on mine was way off from what SDI Online showed, pregnancy claim, back a few months. After a week of that phone line dropping me every single time I tried before 9am, I went through Claimyr and talked to an EDD agent. She checked the actual payment issue date on my claim and told me the deposit had already been processed on their end.

0 coins

Every morning I've tried that line, it either rings forever or hangs up on me after the menu. I find it hard to believe you just got someone on the phone that easily.

0 coins

It wasn't instant, I waited a while, but I did end up talking to a real EDD agent. The person I spoke to had my claim pulled up and confirmed the date.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period threw off the payment timing for my own claim too. EDD's agent confirmed the first payable day was day eight and that's what matched the deposit date on my notice. The waiting period catches a lot of people off guard.

0 coins

For the base period question, when you're calculating what the weekly benefit amount would have been, EDD uses the highest-paid quarter from the 12-month base period tied to your claim start date. If your employer was paying you fully during leave, there's also a question of whether those employer payments were classified in a way that overlaps with what SDI would pay. The Notice of Computation shows what EDD calculated as your potential weekly amount.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is worth reading carefully even during an appeal. It tells you the weekly amount they'd have paid if the claim were approved, which at least shows whether the base period calculation is in the right ballpark.

0 coins

Mine did come. The weekly amount on it looks right based on what I was earning before leave. The denial came later, so the computation part seemed fine but then the wage-loss issue killed it.

0 coins

That sequence makes sense. The Notice of Computation isn't an approval, it's just showing the potential amount. The determination on eligibility, which is what got denied, is separate.

0 coins

30 days goes faster than you think when you're dealing with a newborn on top of this. Get the form in the mail this week and sort the documentation out after.

0 coins

Sending it Thursday. Baby is four weeks old and I'm running on no sleep, so the reminder to just get it done and not overthink it helps.

0 coins

Thursday is good. Don't let perfect be the enemy of done here.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for disability is a nightmare. I've tried it on and off for two weeks on a separate workers' comp crossover question and the best I've gotten is 40 minutes of hold music before it cuts out. At least for appeals you can mail things in and not depend on reaching anyone.

0 coins

Workers' comp and SDI are two different things. If your injury was on the job, that's workers' comp territory. EDD itself says it's not common to get both at the same time.

0 coins

Yeah I know they're different, that's why I was trying to get EDD on the phone to understand where my situation landed. The line just never cooperates.

0 coins

Mailing the appeal is the move anyway. Phone calls don't create a record. Paper does.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mailbox while I was still figuring out an extension on my pregnancy claim, complete surprise. I'd been on automatic payment and didn't even know that form was coming. Ended up reaching EDD through Claimyr after the phone line ate up three of my mornings, and the agent confirmed the form had been mailed on a specific date and told me I had 20 days from that date to return it or benefits would stop.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it before.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's really all it is.

0 coins

Interesting. I've been trying to get someone on the phone about my base period quarter, that might be worth looking into.

0 coins

Does the pregnancy timing matter for the SDI denial? Like does it make a difference whether you filed before or after the birth?

0 coins

The disability period can start before the birth, usually around four weeks before the due date, or earlier if your provider certifies complications or work restrictions. After delivery it's typically six weeks for a vaginal birth and eight for a Caesarean, with the provider able to extend if there are complications. The denial here wasn't about timing, it was about the wage-loss question.

0 coins

Got it, so the timing rules are separate from the employer-pay issue. That makes more sense now.

0 coins

Mine started about three weeks before my due date because of some restrictions my midwife certified. The timing wasn't flagged, it was purely the salary continuation that caused the denial.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in on a workers' comp overlap question I had on a different claim. Tried the EDD disability line Tuesday and Wednesday mornings, nothing. Went through Claimyr on Thursday and had an agent on the line. She told me EDD had issued a Notice of Determination on my claim and said to read it and appeal within 30 days if I disagreed with it.

0 coins

That's almost exactly my situation right now. Used Claimyr too on my own pregnancy claim after two full weeks of that line going nowhere, and I finally got through. The agent checked which weeks had been marked paid and which were still showing as pending, so I at least knew where things stood.

0 coins

Which weeks were actually paid vs. pending, did the agent break that down for you?

0 coins

Yes, she went through it week by week on the claim. Told me the first seven days were the waiting period and the first paid week started after that, and confirmed two specific weeks after that were still pending on their end.

0 coins

The appeal form asks for a written explanation. Keep it factual: when your leave started, what your employer paid and how they labeled it, and why you believe you had a qualifying wage loss or that the payments shouldn't count the way EDD counted them. Don't editorialize, just lay out the facts.

0 coins

This is the most useful framing I've seen. Facts, not emotion. I've been drafting something pretty scattered so I'm going to rework it.

0 coins

Attach anything from HR that describes the payment type in writing. A policy document or even an email from HR works. Concrete documentation is what the administrative law judge will be looking at.

0 coins

Bonding leave after the pregnancy disability period ends would be Paid Family Leave, which is a completely separate SDI program with its own claim. If your pregnancy disability claim gets sorted out in the appeal, you'd file a separate PFL claim for bonding time after that. Just flagging it since people sometimes think it's all one thing.

0 coins

Someone at my company mentioned bonding leave and I honestly wasn't sure if it was part of the same claim. So PFL is filed separately after the disability period closes?

0 coins

Exactly. Pregnancy disability is DI, bonding is PFL. Two separate claims, filed at different times.

0 coins

PFL also has no waiting period, unlike the DI claim which has a seven-day non-payable waiting period at the start. Worth knowing for when you get to that stage.

0 coins

Hang in there. The appeal process is slower but it exists for exactly this kind of situation where the facts aren't straightforward.

0 coins

Thank you. I really thought this was going to be simpler. Learning a lot from this thread.

0 coins

The determination letter feels very final but it isn't. The appeal is a real process with an actual judge who reviews the specifics.

0 coins

the 30 day clock is real, seen people miss it by one day and lose the right to appeal entirely. get it postmarked before you do anything else

0 coins

Certified mail, keep the receipt. That's it.

0 coins

Sending it Thursday certified, receipt number and all. I'll keep this thread updated on how the appeal goes.

0 coins

HR documentation is going to be the backbone of your appeal, anyway. Get whatever they can put in writing about how the pay was categorized and get it in before the 30 days. Everything else you can sort out after.

0 coins

Pay stubs labeled clearly from that period are worth including too. The more official documentation the better.

0 coins

Right, anything with a pay period date and a category label on it. Official letterhead from HR goes a long way anyway.

0 coins

EDD's disability calculator on their site can at least confirm whether the base period calculation on your Notice of Computation looks right, even if the denial was about something else. Useful to verify that piece is correct before the appeal hearing.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation and the denial are addressing two different things. The computation is the potential amount, the determination is the eligibility question. Good to have both right.

0 coins

Exactly. If the computation looks correct and only the wage-loss determination is being appealed, that's actually a cleaner appeal to make.

0 coins

if you log into myedd and go into sdi online you can send a request update message on the claim too. not as fast as a phone call but at least its in writing and you get a record

0 coins

That's the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online. You pick the claim ID, choose the request type and write your question. It does create a written record, which can be useful alongside the appeal.

0 coins

yeah exactly. its good to have everything in writing when youre dealing with a denial anyway

0 coins

Should she mention the PFL bonding claim in the appeal, or keep the two totally separate?

0 coins

Keep them completely separate. The appeal is only about the DI denial. The PFL bonding claim is a different program filed at a different time and has nothing to do with the salary continuation question.

0 coins

Mixing the two in an appeal letter could actually muddy the argument. Stick entirely to the DI denial and the wage-loss question.

0 coins

Good to know. I was going to mention it since I'm planning to file PFL after, but I'll leave it out of the appeal letter entirely.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure