SDI claim denied S corp owner employee self employment form — what happened to mine
Got a denial notice last week and I'm still trying to figure out what went wrong. I'm the sole shareholder and also an employee of my own S corp, been paying into SDI through payroll for three years, CASDI comes out of every paycheck. Filed the claim after my back surgery kept me out of work for six weeks. Doctor submitted the medical certification, everything looked fine. Then the Notice of Determination showed up saying I'm not eligible. The form they flagged had something to do with self-employment but I'm not an independent contractor, I'm a W-2 employee of my own corporation. Has anyone dealt with this as an S corp owner? Did you appeal it? I don't even know where to start.
71 comments

Sean Kelly
Medical certification came back unmatched on mine the first time, which held everything up before we even got to the eligibility question. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at EDD's disability line, and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed they had the certification but it was filed under the wrong receipt number. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability if you want it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once my doctor's office resubmitted with the right number, things moved. Your situation sounds different since you got to the determination stage, but calling in and asking exactly which form or document triggered the denial would be a good first step before you write your appeal.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Did the agent tell you anything about how to get the receipt number corrected on the provider's end, or did your doctor's office just figure it out themselves?
0 coins
Sean Kelly
Agent just confirmed the mismatch and said my doctor's office needed to resubmit with the correct receipt number from my original filing. I passed that to the office and they handled it from there.
0 coins
Luca Greco
Three weeks of hitting that line before I got anyone. Mornings, afternoons, didn't matter, just the recording every time.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
The denial you received almost certainly has an Appeal Form DE 1000A attached to it. You have 30 days from the date printed on the Notice of Determination to file that appeal, so look at that date right now. Write a detailed explanation of why you disagree, attach any documentation that shows your W-2 wages and the CASDI deductions from your paychecks, and mail it to the address on the notice.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorI checked and the notice is dated 11 days ago so I still have time. The DE 1000A is in the envelope, good to know that's what I need.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Does the detailed explanation have to be on the form itself or can you attach extra pages? I want to make sure I get everything in and I'm worried the form won't have enough space.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Attach as many pages as you need. The form just needs your name, claim number and signature. The explanation can be a separate letter stapled behind it.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
EDD's own eligibility rules say you need wages subject to SDI deductions during the base period to qualify. Your CASDI deductions are the key evidence here. Pull your pay stubs or W-2 showing those deductions and make them central to your appeal packet. The issue EDD is likely raising is whether your wages were truly from employment subject to SDI rather than owner draws or distributions, which are not wages.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorEvery dollar I paid myself went through payroll, W-2, CASDI withheld every period. No distributions counted as wages. I've got all the stubs.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
The distinction between S corp salary and distributions matters a lot here. EDD cares about the W-2 wages specifically because that's what SDI is deducted from. Distributions bypass payroll and wouldn't have CASDI on them, so if EDD thinks you were taking distributions instead of salary, that's what they'd flag.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
Exactly. Show them every stub with CASDI on the line. That's the whole argument.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
Bring the last four quarters of pay stubs, your W-2, and the articles of incorporation or whatever shows you're the employee of the corp, not just the owner. Appeal board needs to see the structure clearly.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorI've got the W-2 and stubs. Didn't think about bringing incorporation docs. That's a good point, shows the employer-employee relationship on paper.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
Same thing almost happened to a guy on my crew, turned out his payroll company hadn't been remitting the CASDI on time, anyway the stubs saved him.
0 coins
Andre Lefebvre
Waiting period tripped me up when I first filed my own claim, I thought any day I didn't work counted but EDD's first seven days are just not payable no matter what. Called EDD about it and I'd been trying that number for days. Ended up getting through using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and the agent explained that the seven days run from my disability start date and nothing gets paid for them, that's just how the claim works. For your situation, make sure your appeal letter spells out your actual employment status loud and clear.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
Waiting period question is exactly what I need to get straight on my own claim. I went back to work part time in week three and I'm not sure how those days interact with the waiting period. Going to try Claimyr for that.
0 coins
Andre Lefebvre
Have your claim ID and your start date handy when you call. The agent will pull up your specific weeks and can tell you which days are in the waiting period and which are payable.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
EDD sees S corp owner-employees and assumes the worst. It's their standard move. Appeal it, the stubs and W-2 usually win.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorThat's what I figured. Just needed to hear it from someone who's seen it.
0 coins
Jamal Anderson
lol yeah EDD's default on anything that looks unusual is just deny first. appeals process exists for a reason tho
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I'm in almost the same boat and I'm panicking a little. My S corp only pays me quarterly through payroll, does that affect the base period calculation? I've been off work for two weeks already and I haven't even filed yet, am I going to miss the deadline?
0 coins
Nia Thompson
File right away, today if you can. You have up to 49 days from the day your disability began before the late filing could disqualify you. The quarterly payroll should still show SDI wages in the base period as long as CASDI was withheld.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
Base period for a DI claim covers four quarters going back roughly 5 to 18 months before the claim start date. Even quarterly payroll should land in those quarters. File now and let EDD calculate it from there.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Filing tonight. Thank you both.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
my boss tried to tell me i wasnt eligible because i do some gig work on the side but edd only looked at the w2 wages with casdi on them, the gig stuff didnt matter at all
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
That tracks. SDI eligibility runs on wages that had CASDI withheld. If your side work was 1099 with no SDI deduction, EDD wouldn't count it, but it also wouldn't disqualify you as long as your W-2 wages meet the base period requirement.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
yeah exactly, only the w2 side got counted and i still qualified no problem
0 coins
Liam McGuire
Quarter used in the base period was something I had no idea about until my claim came through lower than I expected. Not sure which quarter EDD picked or whether it was the right one. I tried that disability line for four days straight and either got a busy signal or the recording cut me off. Ended up getting through with Claimyr, and the agent told me which of my quarters they used and confirmed it was my highest-earning one, which answered the question I had. If your denial has anything to do with the base period, that might be worth asking when you call in.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
Quarter question is exactly where I am too. I've used Claimyr on a different claim before and once I had the agent on the line I asked about my receipt number showing up wrong in the system. Agent confirmed the number and said to give it to my provider so they could match the certification to the right filing. Sorted it out from there.
0 coins
Amara Eze
Been hitting that line since Tuesday. Five tries, nothing but the recording.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
Yeah it was the same for me every morning. The line just doesn't get through on its own most days.
0 coins
Giovanni Ricci
Attach a cover sheet to your appeal that lists every document you're including: W-2, pay stubs with CASDI line visible, corporate formation document, and your written explanation. Number the pages. Administrative law judges see a lot of these and a clean packet stands out.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorCover sheet and numbered pages, writing that down. This is exactly the kind of thing I wouldn't have thought to do.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Agreed entirely. A well-organized packet also makes it easier for the judge to find the CASDI deductions quickly, which is the central fact in your favor.
0 coins
Luca Greco
EDD's phone situation is genuinely broken. I tried every day for a week before my extension question got answered, mornings starting at 8, afternoons, didn't matter. Eventually sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online and got a response that way, took longer but it worked.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorDidn't know you could send a message through SDI Online directly. I'll try that too while I'm putting the appeal together.
0 coins
Luca Greco
In myEDD, open SDI Online, pick your claim, then Request Claim Update. Pick the type and write out your question. It's not instant but it doesn't leave you on hold forever either.
0 coins
NeonNomad
used that last month. took about a week but they answered.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
Two appeals I've seen go through in my circle, both came down to showing the payroll records clearly. One guy had a payroll service and had them print a certified ledger showing CASDI line by line, the judge liked that a lot, anyway.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
Certified payroll ledger is a good idea. Shows the deductions aren't just on stubs you printed yourself.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorMy payroll is through a service so I can request that. Good to know it carries weight.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
EDD's base period calculator is on their site if you want to estimate which quarters they're looking at before you get the Notice of Computation. Plug in your disability start date and it'll show you the window.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I didn't know there was a calculator on there. Looking at it now.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
The calculator gives you the base period window and a benefit estimate. The actual amount is on your Notice of Computation once EDD processes the claim, but the calculator is useful for figuring out which pay periods matter.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Has anyone had EDD reverse a denial like this outright without going to a full hearing, or does it always end up in front of an administrative law judge?
0 coins
Nia Thompson
An appeal goes to an administrative law judge. EDD doesn't typically reverse a determination on their own once it's been issued. The appeal is a separate proceeding and you present your case there.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
Judge. That's how it works. File the appeal, show up, bring your documents.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Got it. Good to know what to actually expect from the process.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashemi
S corp owner-employee denials usually come down to the classification question. Your appeal needs to show wages paid through payroll with CASDI withheld, not owner distributions. W-2 and pay stubs make that case. File the DE 1000A before the 30-day window closes.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
Author30-day clock is running. Filing this week.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
Short and right. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
Jamal Anderson
Worth knowing that even if you lose the first appeal you can appeal further, but honestly bringing the stubs and W-2 to the first hearing should do it if the CASDI deductions are there in black and white.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
There is an error in what was said above. EDD's process is one appeal to an administrative law judge, and if you disagree with that decision, you can go to the CUIAB Appeals Board, then to court. But the first appeal is the main event and most people don't need to go further than that.
0 coins
Jamal Anderson
fair correction, i oversimplified. the first ALJ hearing is what matters most.
0 coins
Amara Eze
Waiting period confused me too. I thought the seven days were processing days, not actual calendar days I just don't get paid for.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashemi
Calendar days from the disability start date. Not processing time, not business days. Just the first seven days of the claim are non-payable, then the eighth day forward is when benefits can start.
0 coins
Amara Eze
That clears it up. I lost a week thinking something was wrong with my claim.
0 coins
NeonNomad
filed my claim last month, still pending. doctor submitted everything. just waiting.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
After the medical certification is in, EDD typically contacts you within about 14 days on the claim status. If it's been longer than that, the Request Claim Update in SDI Online is a good way to ask without fighting the phone line.
0 coins
NeonNomad
been 16 days. sending that update now.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Quick question for the room: if the appeal takes a while, do you keep certifying with your doctor in the meantime, or does everything pause?
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Keep your doctor in the loop and make sure any extension or continued certification is submitted on time. The appeal and the certification process run on separate tracks. You don't want to lose benefits for missed certifications while waiting on the appeal outcome.
0 coins
Giovanni Ricci
If your doctor needs to extend your claim past the original approved period, they submit the DE 2525XX. That's separate from the appeal and should be done on the normal schedule regardless of where the appeal stands.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Okay so keep certifying as normal and also pursue the appeal. Got it, thank you.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
One thing I'd add: keep a copy of everything you mail. Date it, write down when you sent it. If the appeal notice later says they didn't receive something, you've got proof.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorSending certified mail so I have a tracking record. Covering myself there.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
Certified mail is the move every time with EDD, anyway.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
For the original poster: the Notice of Determination should spell out exactly which eligibility condition EDD says you don't meet. Reading that specific language closely before writing your appeal explanation will help you respond to the right issue, not a general one.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
AuthorRead it again last night. The language is about employment status and whether my wages were subject to SDI contributions. That confirms it's the owner-employee classification issue, so the W-2 and stubs are exactly what I need to address it.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
That's the right read. Address that exact language in your appeal. Quote it back and then point to your documentation line by line.
0 coins