Back to California Disability

Daniel White

SDI calculation — how does California EDD figure out what you'll get paid?

Went out on disability three weeks ago after a pretty rough back situation that my doctor says is going to keep me out of work for at least two months. I work in food service and my hours have been all over the place the last couple of years — busy season, slow season, picked up extra shifts here and there. So when I started trying to figure out what my SDI payment would be, I got completely lost. The Notice of Computation showed up and I honestly didn't know what most of it meant. It listed a weekly benefit amount that felt lower than I expected given what I earned last year. I know EDD looks at wages from some period before the claim, but I can't figure out which months they actually used or whether my busy season shifts even counted. Has anyone gone through the SDI calculation and figured out how to read the Notice of Computation? Specifically trying to understand why the amount might be different from what I thought I'd get.

Waiting period was the first thing that threw me off when my payment came in lower than the Notice of Computation suggested for the first couple weeks. I kept thinking EDD had miscalculated. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live EDD agent on the phone about it and she pulled up my claim and confirmed the first seven days are just not payable — that's the waiting period, not a processing glitch. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. She also confirmed my actual weekly rate matched the notice exactly once those first days were past.

0 coins

Seven days non-payable — does that mean seven calendar days or seven work days? I keep second-guessing that part.

0 coins

Calendar days, the agent was clear on that. So day eight is when the first payable day starts, not the eighth work day.

0 coins

Had the exact same confusion. Saw the weekly amount on my notice and then the first deposit was noticeably smaller and I thought something was wrong. Nope, just the waiting period eating into week one.

0 coins

The base period thing is what most people don't expect. EDD doesn't look at the 12 months right before you got hurt or sick — it goes back further than that. The way it was explained to me: they take a 12-month window made up of four quarters, and that window ends several months before your claim starts. So if you've had a slow stretch recently and your best earning season was before that window, the number on your notice can look confusing. The calculation itself uses the single highest-paid quarter inside that base period to figure the weekly amount, which they estimate as somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of what you made in that quarter.

0 coins

That explains a lot actually. My busiest stretch was about 18 months ago and my hours dropped off after that. So those big months might be outside whatever window they used.

0 coins

Wait, so they only use ONE quarter out of the whole year? Not the whole year averaged out?

0 coins

Yep, just the single highest quarter. Which sounds like it would help you, but if your best quarter happens to fall just outside the base period window, it doesn't count at all. That's why some people's amounts look off.

0 coins

The EDD site has a benefits calculator where you can punch in your quarterly wages and get an estimate. It helped me check whether the number on my notice made sense before I did anything else.

0 coins

My hours varied a lot too and I made the mistake of assuming EDD would use my W-2 total from last year. They don't. The base period is specifically defined and it's based on when you filed, not what year you think of as 'last year.' I didn't understand that until after I filed and then spent two weeks confused about why my notice showed a lower amount. The SDI calculation uses wages that were subject to SDI deductions — if any of your income wasn't getting that CASDI deduction taken out, it might not count toward the base period even if you earned it.

0 coins

The CASDI piece is something I hadn't thought about. I had a few months where I picked up work for a catering company and I honestly don't know if they were taking out SDI. I'll have to check those pay stubs.

0 coins

Tips are another weird one for food service workers — whether those show up correctly in the wage records depends on how your employer reported them. Worth verifying what EDD actually has on file for each quarter.

0 coins

Tips are tricky, yes. I'd check what each quarter shows separately rather than just looking at a total, because one quarter being off by a lot will mess up the whole calculation if it was going to be your highest quarter.

0 coins

Something I got completely wrong before my first claim — I thought the 'potential benefit amount' on the Notice of Computation was the total I'd receive for the whole disability. It's not. That's the weekly amount, and separately there's a maximum total the claim can pay. Reading it more carefully the second time I saw it listed both. The SDI calculation gives you a weekly rate and then a ceiling on the whole claim. If your disability lasts longer than a certain number of weeks at that weekly rate, you'd hit the ceiling.

0 coins

Ceiling meaning 52 weeks total? Or does it vary by what you earn?

0 coins

52 weeks is the max number of weeks for a DI claim. The dollar ceiling on your specific notice is based on your own benefit amount, so it's different for everyone. Your notice will show both.

0 coins

Didn't know there was a 52-week cap until I was about 10 months in and someone in my doctor's office mentioned it. Would've planned differently if I'd read the notice more carefully at the start.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question — is the weekly benefit amount on the Notice of Computation actually what lands in your bank account each week, or do they take anything out of it?

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits at the state level. Whether any federal tax applies depends on your situation and I'd check EDD's tax information page or ask a tax professional before assuming either way. EDD doesn't withhold anything automatically as far as I know, so the amount on the notice is generally what you'd see deposited.

0 coins

No withholding taken out automatically, right. What you see on the notice is what hits the card or account. The tax question for federal purposes is worth looking into separately before filing your taxes.

0 coins

Got it, so the notice amount is the actual amount. That part I can at least count on when I'm trying to figure out bills.

0 coins

The part that always gets people is that the base period isn't just 'the last year.' There's actually a gap between when the base period ends and when your claim starts. So wages you earned in the months right before you filed — like the most recent quarter — might not even be in the calculation at all. For gig workers and people with variable hours like food service, this can mean your most recent stretch of heavy work doesn't help you as much as you'd think.

0 coins

That's exactly what I think happened to me. The last four or five months before I went out I was working a ton of overtime to cover for someone who left. None of that is in the calculation?

0 coins

Probably not, depending on exactly when your claim starts and where those months fall. The base period is set when you file, and there's typically a lag. EDD's calculator can help you figure out which quarters they used.

0 coins

This is the most confusing part of the whole SDI calculation to explain to people. The gap between 'recent earnings' and 'base period earnings' trips everyone up the first time.

0 coins

My calculation came back lower than I expected and I sent a message through SDI Online asking EDD to explain which quarters they used. They responded and listed each quarter with the wage amount they had on file. Turned out one quarter was showing zero because my employer at the time hadn't filed their wage report on time. That's fixable — you can ask EDD about it — but I didn't know to look for it until I asked.

0 coins

Zero for a whole quarter because the employer was late filing? Can EDD adjust that after the fact?

0 coins

They can look into it. In my case it involved going back to the employer to get it corrected, and that took some time, but it was worth it because that quarter would've been my highest one.

0 coins

Employer wage reporting errors are more common than people realize in industries where turnover is high. Always worth checking each quarter individually on the notice rather than just accepting the total.

0 coins

Which quarter of the base period EDD actually picked was something I had to phone them about directly. SDI Online showed me the weekly amount but not the full breakdown of which quarter drove the number. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent on my own claim, and she read off each quarter's wage figure from the base period and confirmed which one they'd counted as the highest. Turned out the quarter I thought would be highest was actually edged out by a quarter I'd forgotten had a lot of hours in it.

0 coins

How specific did the agent get — did she actually name the quarter with the month range or just a dollar figure?

0 coins

She gave me both — the quarter dates and the wage amount EDD had on file for each one. That let me cross-check against my own pay stubs and confirm the numbers were right.

0 coins

Getting that level of detail over the phone is way more useful than just reading the notice. The notice shows you the result but not always the inputs.

0 coins

Had a whole back-and-forth with a coworker about whether SDI pays the same as unemployment. It doesn't work that way at all — the SDI calculation is based on a percentage of your wages in the base period, while unemployment uses a different formula entirely. And you can't get both at the same time for the same days anyway. My coworker had filed for unemployment while still unable to work and EDD flagged it.

0 coins

Wait, so if someone gets laid off while they're still on disability, they can't collect unemployment while they're still out?

0 coins

Unemployment requires you to be able to work and available to work. If you're still on disability and can't work, you don't meet that test. DI covers the days you can't work. When you're recovered and able to work again, that's when unemployment comes into the picture.

0 coins

My HR told me I could collect both and I almost filed for unemployment while still on SDI. Really glad I didn't. EDD would've caught it.

0 coins

The 70 to 90 percent range confused me because I didn't know where in that range I'd land. Lower earners get closer to 90 percent and higher earners get closer to 70, but the exact percentage is based on how your wages compare to the state average. You won't know your exact percentage until the Notice of Computation shows up — the calculator on EDD's site gives you an estimate but the notice is the real number.

0 coins

So the percentage isn't fixed and can be different for two people even if they earned the same amount in absolute terms?

0 coins

Correct. It's relative to average wages, so the percentage shifts based on where your earnings fall on that scale. The notice is the only place you'll see your actual rate.

0 coins

This is why comparing SDI amounts with coworkers doesn't tell you much — everyone's calculation is based on their own base period and their own percentage.

0 coins

Tried to figure out the SDI calculation myself using my pay stubs before the notice came and my estimate was off by a decent amount. Part of it was I was using gross wages instead of the wages subject to SDI contributions specifically. If you have any pre-tax deductions that affect what gets reported to EDD, the base they calculate from might be slightly different from your gross pay.

0 coins

I have a small 401k deduction — does that affect what EDD counts as wages for SDI purposes?

0 coins

Honestly not certain on the exact answer for every type of deduction — I'd check your pay stub to see what the CASDI deduction is actually calculated on versus your gross pay. That'll tell you the base EDD is using.

0 coins

The W-2 box for SDI wages is usually the clearest way to see what EDD has on record versus what you think you earned in a given year.

0 coins

Went back to work part time partway through my claim and was really unsure how that would affect the SDI calculation for my remaining weeks. EDD's the one who figures out how partial weeks get paid — there's no formula you can easily run yourself. You just report the work and wages and they calculate it on their end.

0 coins

What counts as 'going back part time' — does it have to be with the same employer, or any work at all?

0 coins

Any work for pay. Doesn't matter if it's your original employer or a different one. You report it, EDD handles the math on how much of that week's benefit you get.

0 coins

Good to know. My doctor mentioned the possibility of a phased return and I didn't know if I'd just lose SDI the moment I worked any hours.

0 coins

Pregnancy claims have their own version of this. My due date was coming up and I wanted to know what my payments would be, but my wages over the past year had been all over the place because I'd changed jobs mid-year. The notice came and I still wasn't totally sure if the base period captured the job change correctly. Worth double-checking each quarter on the notice if you've had any major changes to employers or hours in the two years before filing.

0 coins

Does changing jobs reset the base period or does EDD combine wages from both employers?

0 coins

EDD combines all wages subject to SDI contributions, regardless of how many employers. So both jobs should show up in the base period as long as the CASDI deduction was taken out. The notice should reflect all of them.

0 coins

Employer changes are one of the most common reasons the notice looks off. Each employer files their own wage report and sometimes they're not all in the system at the same time.

0 coins

Payment method was something I had to sort out after my claim was approved — my bank account I'd set up for direct deposit had been closed and I hadn't updated it in SDI Online. EDD's card is through Money Network now, not Bank of America like it used to be. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who confirmed the payment that had been issued and which account it had gone to, and she told me how to update the direct deposit in SDI Online before the next one processed.

0 coins

Money Network, not Bank of America — glad you said that, I keep seeing people say to expect a Bank of America card and get confused when it shows up with a different name.

0 coins

Yeah, the old EDD cards were Bank of America. The new ones are Money Network. Same kind of prepaid debit card, different provider.

0 coins

Had no idea they switched. I would've been confused too if a card showed up and it didn't say what I expected.

0 coins

Direct deposit is definitely something to get set up correctly before the first payment processes. Good heads up on double-checking whatever account you put in.

0 coins

Does the SDI calculation ever get redone if EDD gets updated wage information from an employer after the notice was already issued? Like if the employer filed their wage report late and then corrected it, does EDD automatically recalculate?

0 coins

In my experience, it's not automatic. You need to flag it to EDD and ask them to look at it. They won't necessarily know to recalculate unless you bring it to their attention.

0 coins

Contacting EDD through SDI Online with a Request Claim Update is probably the cleanest way to raise it. Write out what you think is different and what quarter is affected.

0 coins

Okay, so it's on me to initiate that. Good to know before I just wait around thinking they'll catch it on their own.

0 coins

Medical certification not showing as received in SDI Online had my entire claim stuck for over a week. Claimyr put me through to an EDD agent who looked up my claim right then and said the certification hadn't been matched to my claim yet — my doctor's office had submitted it but under a slightly different receipt number. The agent confirmed what EDD was waiting for so I could go back to the doctor's office with the exact information they needed to resubmit correctly.

0 coins

Receipt number mismatch — is that something that just happens sometimes or did the office make an error entering it?

0 coins

In my case the office had transposed two digits. Easy mistake but it meant EDD had no way to match it to my claim. Once they resubmitted with the right number it cleared up quickly.

0 coins

Does the doctor's office need to call EDD to fix that or can they just resubmit through SDI Online?

0 coins

My office resubmitted directly through SDI Online with the corrected number. They didn't need to involve EDD by phone, they just went back in and corrected their own submission.

0 coins

For anyone still confused on the base period — the reason EDD uses the period it does instead of your most recent wages is that it takes time for employers to file wage reports. The base period is set up so that the wage data EDD needs is already in the system when you file. Your most recent quarter before filing might not have been reported by your employer yet.

0 coins

So there's actually a reason for the lag, it's not just EDD being slow?

0 coins

Right, it's a data availability issue. The quarter that just ended may not have all the employer reports filed in time. The base period uses quarters where the data is reliably in.

0 coins

This is the clearest explanation I've seen of why the base period works the way it does. It's not arbitrary — it's timed around employer reporting cycles.

0 coins

If your Notice of Computation came and the amount genuinely seems wrong based on what you know you earned, the first step is to check each quarter listed on the notice individually against your pay stubs. If a quarter is missing wages or showing a lower number than your stubs show, that's worth raising with EDD. The notice isn't infallible and wage records do have errors.

0 coins

How far back do I need to keep pay stubs to cover the base period? I don't have everything going back two years.

0 coins

W-2s and your employer's pay records should cover it if you don't have all the stubs. If you can't get the stubs, your employer is required to have payroll records and can provide them.

0 coins

Tax transcripts from the IRS can also show what your employer reported to the federal government in wages, which usually tracks pretty closely with what should be in EDD's records.

0 coins

Does the SDI calculation change at all if you have a second job? I work full time at a restaurant and also pick up bartending shifts at a separate place on weekends. Both jobs take out CASDI.

0 coins

Both should count. EDD combines all wages subject to SDI contributions across employers when they build the base period. As long as both employers are taking out the CASDI deduction and filing wage reports, those wages should both show up in your base period quarters.

0 coins

Multiple jobs is actually a situation where the base period can work in your favor — if both jobs were active during your highest quarter, that combined wage number can push your weekly benefit amount up noticeably.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. I was worried the second job wages just wouldn't count at all.

0 coins

My first claim I didn't even know there was a calculator on EDD's site. I just waited for the notice and was completely unprepared for the number on it. Second time I used the calculator first and had a reasonable estimate before filing, which made budgeting a lot easier while I was waiting for the notice to arrive.

0 coins

Where exactly is the calculator — on edd.ca.gov directly or inside SDI Online?

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov — search for the disability benefits calculator and it comes up. You put in your quarterly wages and it spits out an estimate. It won't be exact but it's close enough to plan around.

0 coins

Used the same calculator before my second claim and it was within a few dollars of the actual notice. Really useful for anyone trying to figure out whether their bills are coverable before the claim processes.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure