Back to California Disability

Ava Thompson

SDI appeal hearing overpayment after collecting unemployment and disability at same time — what to bring

So this whole thing started because I had a gap between my injury and when workers comp kicked in, so I filed for SDI. Meanwhile my employer terminated me while I was out and I figured I could collect unemployment too since I was going to need income. I didn't realize you flat out cannot get both for the same days. EDD sent me an overpayment notice a few months later saying I owe back a chunk of what I got paid during those overlapping weeks. I appealed it and now I actually have a hearing scheduled. Has anyone gone through an SDI appeal hearing for an overpayment after collecting unemployment and disability at the same time? I have no idea what to bring, what the judge actually looks at, or whether explaining I genuinely didn't know the rules helps at all. I'm not trying to get out of something I owe if I truly owe it, I just want to make sure I present this right.

Gather everything before that hearing date. The overpayment notice itself, the Appeal Form or your appeal letter, any DE 2501 paperwork from your original disability claim, and your unemployment payment history for those same weeks. The administrative law judge will want to see exactly which days overlapped. Having it organized by week makes the comparison straightforward.

0 coins

Thank you, I didn't even think about organizing it week by week. I have both payment histories somewhere, I'll pull them side by side.

0 coins

Does the judge actually read all of that, or is it more like you just talk? I have something similar coming up and I'm panicking a little.

0 coins

The hearing is more conversational than a courtroom, but the judge does review documents you submit. Bring two copies of everything, one for the record and one to reference yourself.

0 coins

The 30-day window on the overpayment notice is worth double-checking. The Appeal Form, that's the DE 1000A, has to be postmarked within 30 days of the date printed on the notice, not the date you received it. If yours was late, you can still explain the reasons for the delay and the judge decides whether to allow it. EDD's appeals page lays this out clearly.

0 coins

Mine was filed on time, fortunately. But I didn't know about the postmark rule versus receipt date, that's a useful distinction.

0 coins

Wait so if someone missed the 30 days they can still appeal? I think I might be in that situation and I'm not sure what to do.

0 coins

You can submit a late appeal with a written explanation of why it was late. An administrative law judge reviews whether the reason is good enough. No promises, but you don't necessarily lose the right to be heard just because the deadline passed.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim was what I needed clarity on, and the phone line was eating up my mornings for two weeks straight. Tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got a live EDD agent on the line. The agent pulled up my record and told me the exact date my most recent payment was issued and confirmed which week it covered, which cleared up why my bank deposit timing looked off. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Payment timing on my claim had me confused too so I tried Claimyr for the same reason. Once the agent picked up I asked which weeks had actually been paid out versus which were still processing, and she read them off one by one. Cleared up the overlap question I had been stressing about for days.

0 coins

How many mornings did you burn before that? Because I have dialed that number before 8 and after 8 and gotten the same dead-end recording every single time.

0 coins

Honestly four or five tries over about a week and a half. After the third time I stopped expecting it to work the regular way.

0 coins

Recording just hangs up on me every time I try. Glad something actually worked for you two.

0 coins

The overlap rule is simple: same days, can't have both. If your unemployment weeks and your SDI weeks crossed over even partially, that's what they flagged. Bring a calendar with both payment periods marked out. Judge can see it at a glance.

0 coins

That calendar idea is exactly what I needed to hear. I've been trying to explain it in words but a visual is way clearer.

0 coins

Yep. Numbers and dates on paper beat talking every time in those hearings.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be dumb, but does saying you didn't know count for anything? Like does the judge care if it was an honest mistake or is it just the math?

0 coins

It doesn't eliminate the overpayment amount itself, but it can be part of your explanation at the hearing. The judge is not there to penalize intent, just to determine what was owed. Present the facts, explain the situation clearly, and let the record speak.

0 coins

That's what I'm hoping. I genuinely had no idea the two programs were mutually exclusive for the same days.

0 coins

There's no waiver guarantee, but presenting good-faith context is still worth doing. The judge can note it in the record and it may affect how EDD proceeds from there. What's written in your original appeal letter matters too, so make sure your explanation is in there already.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is legitimately broken. I spent three weeks calling every morning trying to sort out my own claim issue and got through exactly zero times. The system just tells you the volume is too high and ends the call. You're supposed to appeal something with a 30-day window and you can't even confirm receipt.

0 coins

30 days goes fast when you can't get anyone on the line. I mailed mine certified just to have proof.

0 coins

Certified mail is smart. I did the same with my appeal letter so I had a tracking confirmation.

0 coins

Mailing certified is the move. Phone line is a waste of time, always has been.

0 coins

DE 2593 came up on my claim after I went back to work part time, and I wasn't sure if returning it late would restart my waiting period or just pause things. Tried the line a few times with no luck, so I went through Claimyr and got an agent to look at my file. She said the form had been received and logged on the date I mailed it, so the 20-day clock was fine. I'd been panicking for nothing.

0 coins

I've tried that line more mornings than I can count and I've never reached anyone. Something about Claimyr having a person pick up just doesn't track with what I know about how backed up EDD is.

0 coins

I didn't think it would work either. But the agent was an actual EDD employee, answered questions about my file, not some third party reading a script.

0 coins

same thing happened with my base period quarter, agent confirmed which one they used and it matched what i expected. saved me from filing something wrong

0 coins

Okay, that's more convincing than I expected. I might give it a shot for my own situation.

0 coins

Worth knowing that unemployment requires you to certify you're able and available to work every week you claim it. If you were actually unable to work because of your injury during those same weeks, that's another issue the judge may surface, separate from the SDI overpayment itself. You'd want to be ready to address that too.

0 coins

I didn't think about that angle at all. During those weeks I was genuinely unable to work, so certifying for unemployment at the same time was probably wrong on two levels.

0 coins

Exactly right. The SDI program is specifically for days when you can't do your regular work. Unemployment is for days you're able and looking. They're designed for different situations, which is why EDD flags the overlap.

0 coins

So if someone collected unemployment while still unable to work, could they owe on both sides? Like an overpayment from EDD on the unemployment side too?

0 coins

That's possible depending on what EDD determines about those specific weeks. The SDI hearing addresses the SDI overpayment. The unemployment side, if there's a separate issue there, would be its own determination. Best to keep track of both.

0 coins

I went through an overpayment appeal a couple years back, different reason but same type of hearing. Bring everything printed, don't count on pulling things up on your phone in the room, judge wants paper. Have your dates in order. Anyway the main thing is just be straightforward, they've heard every version of this.

0 coins

Printing everything out is on my list. I was going to bring my laptop but maybe paper is smarter.

0 coins

Paper. Always paper. Judge doesn't want to wait for you to find a file.

0 coins

Unemployment and SDI at the same time is one of those things nobody tells you upfront and then EDD catches it months later and you're blindsided. I know like three people this has happened to, lol. Good luck at the hearing.

0 coins

Exactly, nothing in the unemployment filing process said anything about SDI being incompatible. I found out the hard way.

0 coins

The two programs really do seem designed to confuse people who are already stressed and dealing with a health thing. Hope the hearing goes okay for you.

0 coins

Bring documentation of your injury and when you were actually unable to work. If your SDI medical certification has specific dates, match those against your unemployment claim weeks. That's the core of what the judge will look at.

0 coins

My surgeon's office should have records of when I was restricted from working. I'll request a summary to bring along.

0 coins

A written statement from the treating provider about work restrictions during those weeks is useful, yes. Keep it factual and date-specific.

0 coins

my cousin did the whole hearing thing and the judge just asked him to walk through each week. had his calendar out and it went fine. dont overthink the format

0 coins

That's reassuring, I keep imagining it's more formal than it probably is.

0 coins

They're not courtrooms exactly. More like a structured conversation with someone who's going to look at the numbers anyway.

0 coins

Notice of Determination on my own overpayment was what pushed me to finally get through to EDD, and I ended up using Claimyr to reach someone. The agent confirmed the notice had been issued, gave me the exact date it was mailed, and told me my appeal window ran from that date, so I knew exactly how much time I had left. I went straight to the DE 1000A that afternoon.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr? I've seen it mentioned and I don't know what it is.

0 coins

You hand it your EDD disability number and it stays on the line until an agent picks up, then you're the one talking. That's basically the whole thing.

0 coins

Got it. I've got a question about which weeks on my claim are still pending, so I might try that.

0 coins

The appeal letter you already submitted sets the frame. The hearing gives you a chance to explain and add documentation, but the judge will start from what you wrote. If your letter was vague, be ready to fill in specifics verbally.

0 coins

My letter was pretty general because I was panicking when I wrote it. I'll prep more detailed notes for the hearing.

0 coins

Notes are fine to reference during the hearing. Judges expect people to come prepared. Just don't read from a script word for word, it comes across better as a conversation.

0 coins

Does the hearing decide whether you owe or how much you owe, or both? Because I keep thinking maybe the amount they calculated is wrong and I don't know if I can dispute that part.

0 coins

The hearing can address both. If you think the overlap weeks they calculated are wrong, say so with documentation. The judge can review the specific amounts and dates, not just whether an overpayment existed at all.

0 coins

Bring your own calculation of the overlapping weeks if you believe the number is off. Lay it out week by week with the payment amounts from each program. That's the kind of concrete evidence that actually moves things.

0 coins

Okay that helps a lot. I was afraid it was just a yes or no on whether I owed anything.

0 coins

The administrative law judge process is so much less scary than it sounds! Mine was under 30 minutes and the judge was completely reasonable. Just have your paperwork and tell the truth about what happened.

0 coins

Under 30 minutes is way less than I was expecting. That does make me feel better.

0 coins

Mine is coming up and I've been dreading it. Knowing it can be quick helps.

0 coins

You cannot receive both for the same days, that's EDD's rule and it doesn't bend. The appeal is about whether the calculation is right, not whether the rule applies to you. Go in knowing that and you won't be caught off guard.

0 coins

Fair point. I'm not going in expecting the rule to change, just want to make sure the weeks they counted are accurate.

0 coins

Right approach. Dispute the math if the math is wrong. Don't argue the policy.

0 coins

late to this but i went through the same situation last year. brought all my payment records both programs, went week by week with the judge. ended up with a smaller adjusted amount than what the original notice said because two of the weeks they flagged didn't actually overlap when we looked at the exact dates.

0 coins

This is the most useful thing I've read. So the calculated amount can actually change at the hearing if the dates don't line up right.

0 coins

yeah they went off the payment issue dates and i had my bank deposit dates which were different. the judge used the actual week periods not the deposit dates so a couple weeks dropped off.

0 coins

The issue date versus deposit date distinction is real and worth checking carefully. EDD's records will show the week the payment was for, not when it hit your account.

0 coins

Unemployment agencies flag these overlaps through their own systems eventually, sometimes months after the fact. So even people who thought they were in the clear get notices later. If anyone reading this is currently collecting both, the time to sort it out is now before a notice arrives.

0 coins

Genuinely did not know EDD could come back that many months later with an overpayment. Good heads up for anyone in that spot.

0 coins

Months later is an understatement. Heard of people getting notices well over a year after the overlap. The system is slow but it does catch up.

0 coins

Update for anyone finding this later. Had my hearing. Brought everything printed and organized by week like this thread suggested. Turned out two of the weeks EDD had flagged, the payment on record was issued for a different period than what I'd actually received unemployment for those days. The judge adjusted the total. Still owe something, but less than the original notice said. Definitely worth showing up with documentation instead of just accepting the first number.

0 coins

Exactly the right outcome when someone comes prepared. The hearing process exists for situations like this.

0 coins

So glad it worked out better than expected! And good on you for organizing everything by week.

0 coins

Knowing the difference between what was paid and what period it covered made the difference. Glad the documentation held up.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure