Back to California Disability

Mateo Hernandez

Private disability employee tax — does California SDI work the same way?

Okay so my HR rep threw a lot of paperwork at me when I started this job and I honestly skimmed most of it. Now I'm about six weeks out from going on leave for a procedure and I'm trying to figure out what I actually paid into and whether I'm covered. My paystub has a CASDI line being deducted every period and I never really thought about what that was until now. HR said the company doesn't have a private plan and that I should file through California EDD, which sent me down a rabbit hole. The way I understand it now, the CASDI deduction that comes out of worker paychecks — not employer contributions — is what funds State Disability Insurance, so the SDI program is essentially a private disability employee tax in the sense that employees pay into it themselves. Is that right? And assuming I do have coverage because I've been paying that deduction, what does the actual claim process look like? I've never filed with California EDD before and don't know where to start.

Your read on the CASDI deduction is basically right — workers pay it, not employers, and it's what funds SDI. The main thing to verify before you count on it is that you have at least $300 in wages that had the SDI deduction taken out during your base period, which is roughly the 12 months ending about five months before your claim starts. If those wages are on your paystubs, you're almost certainly covered. For actually filing, you go through SDI Online, which you reach by logging into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ — you fill out your part first, then your doctor fills out theirs with a receipt number you give them after you submit.

0 coins

Pulling up my paystubs right now — yeah, every single one has the CASDI line. So the base period question should be fine. The receipt number thing is new to me though. Does the doctor need that before they submit anything, or can they look up the claim another way?

0 coins

They need that receipt number to find your claim in the system. SDI Online gives it to you as soon as you finish filing Part A, so screenshot it immediately and send it to whoever is handling the medical certification at your doctor's office. Without it they can't match the certification to your claim.

0 coins

Agreed — my doctor's office lost the receipt number the first time and the whole thing sat unmatched for almost two weeks. Email it and also write it on a sticky note to bring to any appointments before your leave starts.

0 coins

20 days is the number that got me when I first went through this. You have 49 days from when your disability starts to file, and your doctor also has 49 days to get the medical certification in — if either of you misses that window EDD can disqualify the claim. File as soon as you can after nine days into the disability, don't wait to feel better first.

0 coins

Wait, there's a waiting period before I can even file? I didn't know that.

0 coins

Not exactly — the nine days is the earliest you can file, not a waiting period for benefits. There's a separate seven-day waiting period at the start of every claim where the first week is just non-payable. So you can file on day nine, but that first week doesn't pay out regardless.

0 coins

The seven days confused me too, I kept thinking it was processing time and kept refreshing SDI Online expecting a payment.

0 coins

DE 2593 was sitting in my stack of EDD mail for three weeks before I realized what it was, and I almost lost benefits because of it. EDD sends it out around week ten of a claim — it's a continued eligibility questionnaire — and you have 20 days to send it back or your payments stop. I had no idea it was even coming. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD's disability line because I was panicking — it holds the line so you end up talking to a live agent. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2593 was what they were waiting on, and that my form had arrived the day before we spoke so I was okay. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Flagging this for myself — DE 2593, return within 20 days, comes around week ten. I had zero idea about that form.

0 coins

EDD sends it with basically no warning. Mine came on a Saturday so I didn't even open the envelope until Monday, then I scrambled to fill it out that afternoon.

0 coins

Is the DE 2593 just for people on automatic payment or does everyone get it?

0 coins

Automatic payment is who gets the DE 2593 around the ten-week mark. If you're not on automatic payment you get a DE 2500A every two weeks instead to certify for continued benefits.

0 coins

Filing side of things: once you submit Part A in SDI Online, EDD usually reaches out within about 14 days after the medical certification is in. The Notice of Computation — people call it the DE 429D — comes in the mail and shows you the weekly benefit amount they calculated. It's not an approval, just the dollar figure they're working with. Actual payments start after the seven-day waiting period from your disability start date, and EDD aims to get most payments out within two weeks of receiving a complete claim.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation isn't the same as an approval letter? I assumed once that showed up I was good to go.

0 coins

Exactly not the same thing. The notice just tells you the potential weekly amount based on your highest-paid quarter during the base period. If EDD has an issue with the claim — a question about eligibility, a mismatch on the medical certification — you'd get a Notice of Determination instead, which is a different form and comes with appeal instructions.

0 coins

Tripped on that distinction myself. Got the Notice of Computation, assumed I was approved, then a week later got the Notice of Determination saying there was a problem with my certification dates. Very different pieces of mail.

0 coins

How much does SDI actually pay? I've heard everything from half your wages to almost all of it and don't know what's accurate.

0 coins

Somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of wages from your highest-paid quarter during the base period, depending on where your income falls. The exact number shows up on your Notice of Computation — there's also an estimator tool on EDD's site if you want to get a rough idea before filing.

0 coins

Okay so the range depends on income level, got it. I'll use the estimator.

0 coins

Run the estimator with your actual highest quarterly wages for the most useful estimate. The base period goes back further than most people expect — roughly five to seventeen months before your claim start date.

0 coins

Is SDI taxable? I haven't gotten a straight answer from anyone and I need to know before I figure out whether to adjust my withholding now.

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits at the state level. Federal is a different question — it depends on your situation — and EDD's tax information page or a tax professional is the right place to get a solid answer on that side.

0 coins

Appreciate that — at least I know the state piece. I'll check EDD's tax info page and probably ask my accountant about the federal question.

0 coins

I thought SDI was taxable everywhere because I got confused between the CASDI deduction on my paystub and the benefits themselves. The deduction is what you pay in; the benefit is what comes out when you file. Different things, different tax treatment.

0 coins

Pregnancy claim person here — does the CASDI employee tax thing apply the same way if you're taking leave for childbirth? I'm six months along and trying to plan.

0 coins

DI covers pregnancy and childbirth as long as you've been paying into SDI through the CASDI deduction and meet the base-period wage requirement. Typically you apply about four weeks before the due date, and after birth EDD recognizes six weeks for a standard delivery or eight for a Caesarean. Your OB or midwife handles the medical certification for the pregnancy portion.

0 coins

Does the leave after bonding count as the same claim or do I file something else?

0 coins

Bonding after the disability period ends is Paid Family Leave, which is a separate program and a separate claim from SDI disability. You'd file PFL after your DI claim wraps up. EDD sends a notice when the final DI payment goes out.

0 coins

Good to know they're two separate filings. I was treating them like one continuous leave but they're really two different programs hitting at different times.

0 coins

Workers' comp question — my injury happened at work, and HR told me to file workers' comp but someone else told me to file SDI. Which one is right?

0 coins

Work injuries are workers' compensation, not SDI. EDD itself says it's not common to get both at the same time, and there are exceptions, but the starting point for a work injury is a workers' comp claim. SDI is for non-work-related illness, injury or pregnancy.

0 coins

Okay so I need to go through workers' comp first. I didn't realize SDI was specifically for non-work injuries — I thought it covered any disability regardless of how it happened.

0 coins

Had the exact same confusion. Called my HR rep after reading stuff like this and they confirmed workers' comp was the right path for my situation.

0 coins

Notice of Determination landed in my mailbox last week saying my claim was not payable, and I have no idea what I did wrong. Filed everything on time, doctor submitted the certification — I'm completely lost on what to appeal and how.

0 coins

30 days from the date printed on that notice is your appeal window. The notice comes with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) — fill it out with as much detail as you can about why you think the determination is wrong, and mail it to the return address on the notice. If you've misplaced the form, a detailed letter works too.

0 coins

DE 2525XX and a Notice of Determination arrived in the same week so I was really confused about which form to focus on first. Called EDD using Claimyr and got to an agent who looked up my claim — turns out the certification dates on the doctor's submission didn't align with my stated disability start date, which is why the determination came out the way it did. Appealing now with that information.

0 coins

Certification date mismatch is so common. My doctor's office accidentally put the date I called them, not the date I became disabled, and it caused a ten-day delay.

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days no matter what — even if you're still gathering documents. You can add information later but you can't undo a missed deadline.

0 coins

Can you get unemployment and SDI at the same time? I got laid off right before I was planning to file a disability claim.

0 coins

EDD's rule is you can't collect both for the same days. Unemployment requires being able and available to work every week you claim it — if you're medically unable to work, you're in DI territory, not unemployment. File the DI claim while you're out; when you're able to work again, you can file for unemployment at that point.

0 coins

So while I'm still physically unable to work, DI is the right one to file, and I can look at unemployment once I'm cleared by my doctor?

0 coins

That's the general framework yes. EDD decides each claim on its own facts, so file the DI claim now for the days you can't work and ask EDD directly about the unemployment piece when the time comes.

0 coins

My physical therapist said she could certify my claim. I listed her on the form. Is that going to be a problem?

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of who can certify a DI claim. The list includes physicians, osteopathic doctors, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and licensed midwives for pregnancy cases. You'll need to get certification from one of those providers or the claim won't go through.

0 coins

Filing my doctor's office first thing tomorrow then. I already told the PT she was handling it, so I need to fix this before the 49-day window runs out.

0 coins

Worth double-checking your receipt number is what you give the new provider, not the PT's reference number or anything else from that original conversation.

0 coins

What about the payment method — does EDD just mail a check or is there a card?

0 coins

Default is a Money Network prepaid debit card EDD sends in the mail. If you filed through SDI Online you can switch to direct deposit instead — that option isn't available for paper claims. No checks unless you specifically requested one.

0 coins

Someone at work told me it was still a Bank of America card. That's outdated?

0 coins

Outdated yes — EDD moved to Money Network. If anyone gets a Bank of America card in the mail for a new claim it's not for SDI benefits.

0 coins

Switched mine to direct deposit through SDI Online and it was straightforward, just took an extra few days to verify the bank account before the first deposit came through.

0 coins

Receipt number situation — gave my doctor the form receipt from myEDD but she says the SDI Online system isn't finding my claim. We've been going back and forth on this for days and my 49-day window is ticking.

0 coins

Confirm the number is the one SDI Online gave you at the end of filing Part A, not a confirmation email number or a myEDD login reference. They look similar but are different strings.

0 coins

SDI Online showed two different number sequences on the confirmation screen and I'd given the doctor the wrong one. Got on the phone with EDD through Claimyr — the agent pulled up my claim and read me the exact receipt number on file. Doctor had the right one within the hour and submitted that afternoon.

0 coins

Really glad you got that resolved — writing the receipt number down in two places the moment I file so I don't have to go through the same thing.

0 coins

Two numbers on one screen is genuinely confusing design. The agent confirming which one is tied to the claim is the fastest fix when you're in that situation.

0 coins

What if I need more time than EDD approved? I'm supposed to be out six weeks but my doctor is saying more like ten now.

0 coins

You don't file a new claim. Your doctor fills out the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate — the DE 2525XX — and submits it to extend the claim. EDD sends that form with the notice about your final payment so your doctor's office should watch for it. If they don't get it in time, ask EDD to resend or have your doctor ask about submitting it through SDI Online.

0 coins

Does the extension process restart the waiting period?

0 coins

No new waiting period for an extension of the same claim. The seven-day wait only applies at the start of a new claim.

0 coins

My doctor submitted the DE 2525XX before the final payment notice even arrived — she just had it ready because I told her the original end date in advance. Payments kept going without a gap.

0 coins

EDD phone line keeps disconnecting me after fifteen minutes on hold. I've tried three times this week and can't get through to ask about a discrepancy in my benefit amount.

0 coins

SDI Online has a Request Claim Update option — open the claim ID in myEDD, hit that button, pick the request type, and write out your question. I've had faster responses that way than on the phone some weeks.

0 coins

Tried that two days ago actually. No response yet. The discrepancy involves my base period quarter and I want to actually talk to someone who can read me the numbers on my claim.

0 coins

Ask EDD through EDD's online contact form is another option, though it also takes time. For something involving specific figures on the claim, talking to an agent is usually better anyway.

0 coins

Payment timing threw me completely — SDI Online showed a payment issued but nothing was showing up on my Money Network card for days after.

0 coins

Check the EDD disability automated line at 1-800-480-3287 — it has payment information and sometimes shows an issued date before the card reflects it.

0 coins

Automated line gave me a date but the card still wasn't matching. Phoned EDD's disability line through Claimyr and the agent gave me the exact date and amount for the payment in question on my claim — it had been issued to an old card number I hadn't updated when I switched accounts. Got the payment method corrected while I was on the call.

0 coins

Payment method updates take effect for the next payment, not retroactively — good you caught it when you did or you'd have been chasing that one for a while.

0 coins

Does taking SDI affect your job? Like can your employer fire you for being out?

0 coins

SDI is the wage replacement piece — it doesn't protect your job on its own. Job protection during leave in California comes from CFRA or other leave laws, which are separate from EDD's program. HR or the Civil Rights Department's CFRA page is the right place to look for that question, not EDD.

0 coins

So SDI handles the money and CFRA handles the job. I had those backwards in my head.

0 coins

Important distinction — a lot of people mix them up and assume filing SDI protects the job automatically.

0 coins

Came across this thread while trying to figure out whether I had to tell EDD I was doing a little bit of freelance work while out on leave. Anyone dealt with partial work while on a DI claim?

0 coins

Report any work and earnings to EDD — partial week situations are handled by EDD and how those weeks pay out is EDD's call based on what you report. Don't skip reporting it; an unreported partial week can turn into an overpayment notice later that's a lot harder to deal with than just reporting upfront.

0 coins

Sending a Request Claim Update through SDI Online today to ask how to report it — better to have it documented than guess.

0 coins

My claim had a partial week situation and EDD sent a letter asking about it. Much less stress when everything was already reported accurately.

0 coins

Had no idea reporting partial work was a thing but it completely makes sense. Bookmarking this for when I go back part time at the end of my leave.

0 coins

How long can a DI claim actually last? My condition is ongoing and I don't have a clear return-to-work date.

0 coins

52 weeks is the maximum for a single DI claim. Extensions within that window require your doctor to keep certifying with the DE 2525XX each time. Beyond 52 weeks it would be a new claim, subject to its own filing and base period requirements.

0 coins

52 weeks is longer than I thought honestly. I assumed it was more like 12 or 16.

0 coins

Same assumption here until I actually read the EDD page. Knowing the real number helps with planning.

0 coins

Does the DE 2593 keep coming every ten weeks throughout a long claim or just the first time?

0 coins

Only for people on automatic payment — it comes at the ten-week mark specifically. After that, if you're on automatic payment EDD handles renewals differently and you'd hear from them if something is needed.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure