Paid family leave zero benefits employer not withholding SDI — what does that actually mean for my claim?
So I filed for PFL about three weeks ago to bond with my new baby and I just got a notice saying zero benefits, and when I called HR they said my employer never withheld SDI from my paychecks. I had no idea that was even something that could happen. I checked my old stubs and sure enough there's no CASDI line anywhere on them. Now I'm just completely lost because I thought PFL was something all California workers could get? Does this mean I'm just out of luck entirely? Has anyone dealt with an employer not withholding SDI and then getting denied benefits?
77 comments

Gemma Andrews
Your pay stubs are really the key thing to look at here. If there is no CASDI deduction showing on any of them, it usually means your employer was either exempt from SDI or was running a Voluntary Plan instead of contributing to the state plan. Workers covered under a Voluntary Plan may still be eligible for comparable benefits, but through the employer's plan rather than through EDD. The notice you received should indicate a reason code or explanation. Reading that carefully will tell you which situation applies to your case.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorThe notice just says 'employer not covered' basically. I didn't even know there was such a thing as a Voluntary Plan. So I should be asking my HR department whether we have one of those?
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
Exactly right. Ask HR specifically whether the company has a Voluntary Plan for SDI and PFL. If they do, your claim goes through that plan's administrator, not EDD directly.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
Wait so some employers just don't have to participate in SDI at all? I'm kind of freaking out because I've been at my job for two years and I don't think I've ever seen CASDI on my stubs either.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
Start date on my own PFL claim got messed up and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date they had on file was off by nine days from what I'd actually put in the form, which would have knocked out my waiting period calculation entirely. Had to get that corrected before anything else could move.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
Used Claimyr on my own claim too, for the medical certification. My provider had submitted it but EDD's agent told me the receipt number on the certification didn't match what was on my original filing, so it was just sitting there unmatched. Got that receipt number corrected through the provider's office and the claim moved within a few days.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Can I ask, did you have to do anything after the agent told you that, or did they fix it on their end?
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
The fix had to come from the provider's office, not EDD. I just told them the correct receipt number and they resubmitted. EDD couldn't change it themselves.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorThe receipt number thing is interesting because I'm not sure my provider used the right one either. That's something I should check I guess.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
There's an important distinction worth flagging here. PFL and SDI are both funded by the CASDI payroll deduction, so if your employer never withheld CASDI, that affects both programs. EDD's site says employees must have paid into SDI during their base period to be eligible. No withholding means no base period wages subject to SDI, which is exactly why you're seeing zero benefits.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
This is basically the whole story. No CASDI deduction means no SDI contributions, which means EDD has nothing to draw from for either DI or PFL. It's not EDD's error, it's the employer's.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
So the employer is the one who messed this up, not the employee? Can you do anything to recover those contributions?
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
That question goes beyond what EDD handles. The Labor Commissioner's office and potentially an employment attorney are where I'd point someone in that situation.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Your employer should have been deducting CASDI the whole time. That's on them, not you. I'd put something in writing to HR and keep a copy.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorYeah I'm definitely going to do that. I just want to make sure I know all my options before I go back to them.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
Document everything. Every conversation with HR, every stub, every notice from EDD. You'll want that paper trail.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
I went through something similar with a coworker situation and the whole voluntary plan thing is confusing. Some employers opt into their own plan that mirrors SDI but it's run by a private insurer. If your employer has one, you'd file your PFL or disability claim with whoever administers that plan, not EDD. Worth pushing HR to give you the actual plan documents.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorHR told me this morning they're checking with their benefits administrator. So fingers crossed they actually have something in place.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Good, make them put the answer in an email so you have it.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
Honestly HR at a lot of companies has no idea about this stuff lol. Push until you get an answer from someone who actually knows.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
To add some context, all California employers with employees are generally required to withhold SDI unless they have an approved Voluntary Plan or fall into a narrow exemption category. So if neither of those applies to your employer, they may have been out of compliance. The Employment Development Department isn't the right place to report that though, it would be a different agency.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Labor board or labor commissioner is who handles that side of it.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
Right, that would be the place to look into if the employer wasn't running any kind of approved plan and still wasn't withholding.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
wait so pfl and sdi come from the same deduction on your check? i always thought they were totally separate things
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
Same deduction, yes. The CASDI line on your pay stub covers both Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave. They're separate programs but funded together.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
ok that actually makes sense now. so if theres no casdi line youre cut off from both
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
The situation you're describing is really frustrating and I'm sorry you're dealing with it right after having a baby. For what it's worth, the zero benefit notice does include an appeal form. If you believe the denial is incorrect or if there's a Voluntary Plan that should cover you, you can appeal within 30 days of the notice date. Don't let that deadline slip.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
Author30 days from the date on the notice itself, right? Not from when I received it?
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
The 30 days runs from the date printed on the notice, yes. If the notice date is several days ago, don't wait.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorOkay. The date on mine is from last week so I still have time but I'm going to move on this quickly.
0 coins
Honorah King
Notice of Computation on my own DI claim had an amount that looked way too low, so I ended up reaching EDD through Claimyr to get it explained. The agent walked me through which quarter of wages they'd pulled and confirmed the base period they used. Turned out one quarter of my earnings hadn't posted yet when the claim was processed, which is why the weekly benefit amount was lower than I expected.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Honestly the first time I saw someone mention Claimyr on a forum I figured it was just an ad dropped in a thread.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
Tried it myself when my receipt number situation dragged on. The agent I reached confirmed the receipt number on file and told me the certification was sitting there but hadn't been matched yet. That part surprised me, that it was there but just unlinked.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Huh. Okay, that's more convincing than I expected. I think I'll give it a shot for my own extension question.
0 coins
Honorah King
Have your claim ID and the Notice of Computation in front of you when you go in. Made the conversation faster.
0 coins
Mary Bates
Just to be precise about the base period piece: EDD looks at wages earned and subject to SDI during a specific 12-month base period before your claim start date. If no wages in that period had CASDI withheld, the system will show zero because there's nothing qualifying in the base period. That's the mechanical reason behind the notice you got.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorThat's actually really helpful to understand the why of it. It's not some arbitrary decision, it's literally that there's nothing to calculate from.
0 coins
Mary Bates
Exactly. The system isn't penalizing you, it's just working with what's there, and what's there is zero SDI-covered wages.
0 coins
Clay blendedgen
HR's response will tell you everything you need to know. If they say Voluntary Plan, ask for the carrier name and your claim number with them. If they say no plan, you're in different territory.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
This. Two questions, carrier name and your claim number. That's the whole conversation with HR.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorHR got back to me and apparently there IS a voluntary plan. They're sending me the contact info for the administrator today.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
That's actually really good news about the voluntary plan! If the employer has an approved Voluntary Plan covering PFL, the benefits should be at least equal to what EDD would have paid. The plan administrator would handle the claim from here, so you'd file or update your claim with them directly instead of through EDD.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorSo my EDD claim is basically done then and I start over with the plan administrator?
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Pretty much, yes. The EDD denial was because there were no wages subject to state SDI. With the Voluntary Plan, your employer's plan is what covers you, and their administrator is your contact from here.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
Glad you got some clarity on this. Good luck with the plan administrator.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
EDD's phone line has been a nightmare for three weeks solid for me. I finally got through on my DI claim through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the DE 2525XX extension my doctor submitted had been received and was attached to the right claim. I'd been staring at the same screen in SDI Online for two weeks not knowing if the extension even made it.
0 coins
Mary Bates
The payment method on my own claim is what I need to sort out and I'm going to try Claimyr for it. What's useful to have ready before that call?
0 coins
Reina Salazar
Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the notice or form number you're asking about. The agent was faster when I had the DE 2525XX number ready.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
been trying that line since tuesday. mornings, afternoons, same result every time
0 coins
Oliver Brown
For the appeal itself, if you do end up needing to file one with EDD: the notice includes an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. If you've misplaced it, a letter with a detailed explanation of why you're appealing works too, sent to the return address on the notice. The 30-day window runs from the date on the notice.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorI may not need to appeal EDD at all now that the voluntary plan thing is sorted out. But it's good to know the process in case the plan administrator denies me too.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
If the plan administrator denies you, the appeal process runs through them, not EDD. Ask for their grievance procedure in writing.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
Can I jump in with a related question? My employer also doesn't seem to have CASDI on my stubs but I'm about to go out on disability for a surgery. Should I call EDD first or go straight to HR?
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
HR first. Find out whether there's a Voluntary Plan before you file anywhere. If there is one, you'd file with the plan administrator. If there isn't one, then you'd contact EDD and also ask about whether the employer should have been withholding.
0 coins
Pedro Sawyer
Okay that order makes sense. HR first, then figure out where to file based on what they tell me.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
And get whatever HR tells you in writing, not just a verbal answer in the break room.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
The whole voluntary plan thing is weirdly under-explained. I've been at three different jobs in California and never knew some employers ran their own SDI-equivalent plan until I had to file last year.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Nobody tells you this stuff when you get hired. It's just buried in the benefits packet that most people never read.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
Exactly and the benefits packet is like 40 pages of stuff you don't understand until you actually need it.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
Glad you got the voluntary plan answer from HR. Keep the documentation from EDD too even though your claim goes elsewhere now. That denial notice shows the reason and your timeline in case you need it later.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
AuthorGood point. I'm keeping everything in a folder at this point, the EDD notice, the HR emails, everything.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
That's the right move. You don't know what the plan administrator is going to ask for.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Weeks 3 through 7 on my own DI claim were a mess to track down because I wasn't sure which had actually been paid out. Used Claimyr and the agent went through each week with me and told me exactly which had been issued and which were still pending. Helped me figure out that one week had been held because the DE 2593 hadn't come back to EDD yet.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
Can I ask, did the agent tell you anything about when the held week would release once you returned the DE 2593?
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
The agent said to return the DE 2593 within 20 days of when EDD sent it, and that the pending week would process after that was received. Didn't give me a specific date beyond that.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
been sitting on a pending week myself for a while now. good to know the DE 2593 might be the reason
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
wait can someone clarify, is pfl just for bonding or can you use it for your own surgery too
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
PFL is for bonding with a new child or caring for a seriously ill family member. For your own surgery or illness, that's Disability Insurance, not PFL. Two different programs even though they come from the same paycheck deduction.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
ok got it so pfl wouldnt help for a personal surgery
0 coins
Oliver Brown
Right. PFL doesn't cover your own medical condition. DI is what you'd file for a surgery or anything that stops you from doing your regular work.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Following this thread because a friend is in an almost identical spot, employer never deducted CASDI and she just had a baby. The voluntary plan angle is something I hadn't even thought to suggest to her. She's going to ask HR on Monday.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Tell her to ask specifically for the plan administrator's contact info, not just whether a plan exists. HR sometimes knows one but not the other.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Good call, I'll pass that along.
0 coins
Lena Schultz
Update for anyone following: the plan administrator reached out and said I do have coverage under the employer's Voluntary Plan. They're sending me a claim form for the PFL bonding leave. The EDD denial was correct from their side because I had no state SDI wages, but the voluntary plan is what should have been covering me all along. So if you're in this situation, check with HR about a voluntary plan before assuming you're out of options entirely.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
That's the best outcome you could have hoped for given the situation. Good follow-through on your part.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
So glad it worked out! And honestly this whole thread is a good reminder that the CASDI line on your pay stub is worth checking before you ever need to file.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Good outcome. Make sure the plan administrator's claim form is in before any deadlines they set.
0 coins