Back to California Disability

Gabrielle Dubois

PFL overpayment appeal ignored while collections sends notices — what do I do now?

Filed my appeal on a Paid Family Leave overpayment back in September using the DE 1000A and mailed it to the return address on the notice. It's been about six weeks and I haven't heard a single thing back about the appeal, but last week a collections notice showed up saying I owe the full amount. My whole situation is confusing because I thought PFL and SDI were the same thing when I filed, and I ended up getting some weeks I apparently shouldn't have, though I genuinely don't understand how. I've sent messages through Ask EDD twice and nothing. Does EDD even acknowledge that the appeal was received? And does collections keep running even while the appeal is supposed to be open? I'm kind of panicking because I don't have the money they're claiming I owe and I don't want this to go further.

Mailing the DE 1000A to the address on the overpayment notice is exactly right, so you did that part correctly. The appeal form starts the process, but EDD doesn't send a confirmation letter just to say they got it. The 30-day window runs from the date printed on the notice, so as long as you mailed it within that window you should be within your rights to have it reviewed. Keep the envelope or any proof of mailing if you have it.

0 coins

I didn't send it certified, which I'm now regretting. Is there any way to show I sent it on time without that?

0 coins

A dated copy of the form, a bank statement showing you bought stamps around that date, anything helps. Going forward, certified mail for anything time-sensitive like this.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way myself. Certified mail from now on, every time.

0 coins

Collections and appeals running at the same time happens. EDD's collections side doesn't automatically pause just because you filed an appeal. Keep copies of everything and don't ignore the collections notices, but your appeal is the main thing to focus on right now.

0 coins

So I could get a decision demanding payment while the appeal is still technically open? That seems backwards.

0 coins

It can feel that way, yeah. The appeals unit and the collections unit don't always talk to each other fast. Document every date and every notice you get.

0 coins

Went through something similar and keeping a folder with every date written on each piece of mail made a big difference when I finally did get someone on the phone.

0 coins

Payment dates on my own DI claim were a mess earlier this year and I could not figure out what weeks had actually been paid versus what was still pending. After days of the line just cutting out before I even got to hold, I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an agent. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which payment dates had issued and which weeks were still showing open, so I finally knew what I was actually dealing with instead of guessing from the SDI Online screen.

0 coins

Reads like a marketing comment to me honestly. How is some third-party thing getting you through to EDD when the rest of us sit on that line for an hour and nothing?

0 coins

Totally get the skepticism. I thought the same thing before I tried it. The agent I spoke with was an EDD employee, answered questions about my specific claim, same as any other call, just without me hitting redial a hundred times first.

0 coins

Used it when I had the same doubt, figured it couldn't hurt. The agent told me the two weeks I thought were unpaid had actually issued on specific dates I hadn't noticed. Ended up being a timing issue with how my payment method was set up. Decided to try contacting EDD the regular way after that since I had the info I needed.

0 coins

Okay that's more useful context. Might give it a shot if the regular line keeps doing what it's been doing to me.

0 coins

PFL and SDI are two separate programs even though they both come out of the same SDI deduction on your check. PFL is for bonding or caregiving, DI is when you yourself can't work. If you filed for one when you should have been on the other, that's how an overpayment can happen. The appeal is your chance to explain what you thought you were filing for.

0 coins

Nobody explained the difference to me when I filed. I was out after having my baby and just filed for whatever the hospital paperwork said. Is that a valid thing to bring up in the appeal?

0 coins

Bring it up. Write out exactly what you understood at the time and what information you were given. An administrative law judge looks at the whole picture.

0 coins

The confusion between PFL and DI is genuinely common for new parents. The pregnancy disability part is DI, then bonding is PFL after that. Easy to mix them up when you're just handed forms at discharge.

0 coins

EDD's appeals page says the administrative law judge reviews a late appeal if you include reasons for the delay, so even if yours is somehow considered late, you can explain why. The 30-day clock starts from the date on the notice itself, not the date you received it, which is a detail that trips people up.

0 coins

The date on my notice and the date I got it in the mail were five days apart. So my 30 days started from the printed date, not when it arrived?

0 coins

That's correct per EDD. The notice date is what counts, which is why mailing early matters so much with these things.

0 coins

That five-day gap is terrifying to me honestly. I always assumed the clock started when the envelope hit my mailbox, not some date I never even saw until I opened it.

0 coins

Filing as soon as you get the notice is the safest move for exactly that reason.

0 coins

Ask EDD messages sit for a while before anyone looks at them. If you need an answer faster, the phone line is 1-800-480-3287. Expect a wait but keep trying.

0 coins

I've tried calling three times and the line disconnects me every time before I even get to hold. Is that normal?

0 coins

Yeah it's brutal. Keep calling, different times if you can.

0 coins

been at it for two weeks on that number. sometime around 8am it rings longer before the disconnect but still nothing solid.

0 coins

DE 2593 got sent to me while I was still dealing with an appeal on a different issue and I almost missed the 20-day window to return it. Kept everything stacked and lost track. Used Claimyr to get through on that one, agent confirmed EDD had received the form and that my claim was still active. Asked the agent about which weeks were still showing in the pending column too, and they read them off to me one by one.

0 coins

What did you actually have ready when you got on with the agent? I want to make sure I have everything if I call.

0 coins

Social security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the letter I was asking about. Had it all open on my laptop. Agent asked for the claim ID right away anyway.

0 coins

been trying that line most mornings this week. not sure ill ever get through the normal way at this point.

0 coins

The overpayment appeal and the collections process are handled by different parts of EDD, which is why you can get a collections notice even when an appeal is open. It's frustrating but it's not necessarily a sign the appeal failed. Document every piece of mail with the date you received it.

0 coins

Should I respond to the collections notice separately or just let the appeal run?

0 coins

Worth responding to the collections notice in writing to note that an appeal is pending. Keep a copy of whatever you send.

0 coins

Responding in writing to both channels is the right call. Creates a paper trail on both sides.

0 coins

Went through a PFL overpayment situation last spring and the thing nobody tells you is how long everything takes. My appeal sat for months before an administrative law judge was assigned. Meanwhile notices kept arriving. Eventually got resolved but it was a slow process.

0 coins

Months. Okay. I did not realize it would take that long. How did you stay on top of everything during that time?

0 coins

Kept a simple log, date received, date responded, what I sent. Made everything easier when I finally had to explain the timeline.

0 coins

A log like that also helps if the judge asks why something was done on a certain date.

0 coins

wait so pfl and sdi arent the same thing? i filed for pfl when i hurt my back and nobody told me that was wrong until i got a notice months later

0 coins

PFL is for bonding with a new baby or caring for a sick family member. Back injury while you couldn't work is DI. Two different claims with different rules.

0 coins

so i probably have an overpayment too. great. what do i even do now

0 coins

Check the notice you received for the appeal deadline and file the DE 1000A before that date, with a written explanation of what you understood when you filed.

0 coins

Appeals and collections running in parallel is a known issue. If you have proof the appeal was filed within 30 days, hold onto it. If the appeal is ultimately decided in your favor the overpayment gets reduced or cleared. If not, you'd receive a Notice of Determination and could then look at next steps.

0 coins

And if I lose the appeal I can still do something after that?

0 coins

There is a further review process. The Notice of Determination explains it and includes deadlines.

0 coins

The notice after the decision is key. Read every word and note the date it was issued, same 30-day window applies to any further appeal.

0 coins

my coworker had a pfl overpayment waived completely because she showed she spent the money already and couldnt pay it back, is that something edd actually does lol

0 coins

An appeal and a waiver are different things. The appeal contests whether the overpayment was correct. A waiver request is separate and EDD decides whether to grant it based on their own criteria. Never count on a waiver being approved.

0 coins

oh i didnt know those were different processes. good to know

0 coins

Don't count on a waiver. Appeal first if you think the overpayment amount is wrong.

0 coins

Notice of Determination on my claim last year said I owed an amount I didn't agree with. Tried the phone line for most of a week, got the busy signal or the disconnect every single morning. Ended up getting through to an EDD agent using Claimyr. Agent read off what the notice said and confirmed EDD had no record of my earlier response letter, which explained why nothing was moving. Filed the DE 1000A the same day.

0 coins

My claim has a Notice of Determination I haven't been able to reach anyone about. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I bring to the call?

0 coins

Have the notice itself, your claim ID, and the date the notice was issued. Agent will ask for the claim ID first.

0 coins

Knowing my response letter wasn't on file would have changed everything for me. That kind of confirmation is exactly what I needed.

0 coins

Not sure if this helps but when I was worried about an overpayment on my own DI claim I sent a message through SDI Online using the Request Claim Update option. It's slow but at least there's a record of you asking.

0 coins

I've been using Ask EDD but maybe SDI Online's Request Claim Update leaves a better trail. I'll try that too.

0 coins

At minimum it ties the message to your specific claim ID, which Ask EDD doesn't always do as clearly.

0 coins

That's a solid point. Anything that attaches your question directly to the claim number is better documentation.

0 coins

November 3rd my appeal letter went out, November 28th the first collections notice arrived. Filed the DE 1000A at the same time as a written explanation of the error. Still waiting on the appeal decision but at least both sides of EDD have something in writing from me now.

0 coins

The written explanation alongside the DE 1000A, is that standard or did someone advise you to do it?

0 coins

The form has a section for explanation but it's small. I attached a full separate letter with the timeline, the dates, and why I thought I was filing correctly. Seemed smarter than trying to squeeze it in a box.

0 coins

Attaching a detailed letter is a good practice. The more specific the timeline the better.

0 coins

Appeals sometimes feel like they go into a void. Keeping your own record of every date, every mailing, every notice is the main thing you can control right now.

0 coins

Doing that now. Made a folder yesterday with everything dated.

0 coins

Putting the date you received each piece on the envelope before you file it away is an easy habit.

0 coins

If your letter really wasn't received by EDD, the appeals unit has no idea you filed. Worth trying to confirm it got there somehow, even if it means calling.

0 coins

This is what worries me most. How do I even confirm it was received if nobody answers the phone?

0 coins

SDI Online message or Ask EDD asking specifically whether an appeal is on file for your claim number. Put the claim ID in the subject line.

0 coins

Phrasing it as a yes or no question sometimes gets a faster response. 'Is appeal DE 1000A on file for claim number X' is clearer than a long explanation.

0 coins

the collections notices stopped for me once the appeal decision came through. took a while but they did stop.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring to hear. Did you have to do anything specific to make them stop or did it just happen?

0 coins

Just happened once the decision posted. Didn't have to call anyone.

0 coins

Keep all your documents, mail the DE 1000A certified if you haven't already, and don't miss any deadlines on the collections notices either. Those are two separate tracks and both need attention.

0 coins

Should I hire anyone to help or is this something I can manage on my own?

0 coins

Many people handle it on their own. If the amount is large or the situation is complicated, a legal aid organization can review the case at no cost.

0 coins

Legal aid is a good option to look into. Some counties have workers' rights clinics that handle EDD appeal questions.

0 coins

For what it's worth, once I had actual dates from the agent on my payment history I could match them against the overpayment notice and see where the discrepancy actually came from. Made writing the appeal explanation a lot clearer.

0 coins

Having concrete dates to reference in the written explanation sounds way more useful than trying to describe a general timeline from memory.

0 coins

Matching your own records against what the agent reads off the claim is exactly the kind of detail that makes an appeal letter specific instead of vague.

0 coins

does filing the appeal stop the interest from building on the overpayment amount or does that keep going too

0 coins

EDD's overpayment notices and the appeals process details are what govern that. The best answer is to call EDD or ask through SDI Online specifically about whether interest or penalties apply to your claim while an appeal is pending, because that can vary.

0 coins

ok ill ask through the site then. dont want that number getting bigger while i wait

0 coins

Ask in writing through SDI Online so you have a record of the question and whatever they respond with.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure