< Back to California Disability

Need to restart SDI after brief return to work - reopen claim or file new one?

Hi everyone! I thought I was ready to return to work after dealing with severe nerve pain for almost 4 months (October through mid-February 2025). My doctor reluctantly cleared me, but after just two weeks back at my warehouse job, the pain is unbearable again. My doctor agrees that I returned too soon and needs to put me back on disability. I'm confused about the process for going back on SDI so quickly after returning to work. Do I need to file a completely new claim, or is there a way to reopen my previous one since it's the same medical condition? Will my weekly benefit amount stay the same ($1,580) as my previous claim? We handled everything through SDI Online last time and plan to do the same now. Are there any special forms or documentation I need since this is essentially a continuation of the same issue? Any advice would be super appreciated!

Brooklyn Foley

•

if its been less than 60 days you can reopen the old claim. login to SDI online and look for the option to reopen. my cousin did this last year

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

Thanks! Do you know if your cousin had to get their doctor to submit anything new? Or was it just filling out the reopening form?

0 coins

Jay Lincoln

•

What you're experiencing is what's called a 'recurrence claim' in EDD SDI terminology. The specific process depends on timing: - If it's been less than 14 days since you returned to work, you may be able to simply continue your existing claim without additional paperwork. - If it's been 15-60 days, you'll need to file a 'recurrence claim' through SDI Online. You'll see this option when you log in. Your doctor will need to submit a new medical certification confirming it's the same condition. - If it's been more than 60 days, you'll need to file a completely new claim. Your weekly benefit amount should remain the same as long as it's within the same benefit year (which runs for 12 months from your original claim date). Just make sure both you and your doctor specify it's a recurrence of the same condition.

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

Thank you so much for the detailed explanation! It's been exactly 16 days since I went back, so looks like I need the recurrence claim option. I'll let my doctor know she needs to submit a new certification.

0 coins

Jessica Suarez

•

I went through EXACTLY THIS with my back injury!! Went back to work too soon and omg big mistake. I had to do what they call a recurrence claim and my benefit stayed the same. Just make sure your doctor fills out their part ASAP because mine took forever and I almost didn't get paid for those weeks!!!

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

I'm sorry you went through this too but glad to hear from someone with a similar experience! Did they back-pay you for the weeks when you weren't at work but waiting for your doctor?

0 coins

Marcus Williams

•

when this happened to me my doc was super slow with the paperwork and i almost lost my mind waiting!!! call your doctor's office EVERY DAY until they confirm its been submitted! the edd website is useless for checking if they received it

0 coins

Lily Young

•

Same, I waited 3 weeks because my doctor's assistant kept saying "we sent it" but EDD never got it. Nightmare. Follow up with both sides!

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

This is really stressful to hear. I'll definitely stay on top of my doctor about this!

0 coins

Be aware that even though this is a recurrence claim, you may still face a waiting period. EDD's rules on this can be confusing. If it's been more than 14 days since you returned to work, you might need to serve another 7-day waiting period before benefits resume. Also, make sure your doctor clearly documents that this is the same condition that simply worsened after returning to work. If it's coded differently, EDD might treat it as a new claim which could affect your benefit calculation and create delays. You might want to submit a DE 2501 Recurrence Certification through your doctor rather than a completely new claim form to avoid confusion. Good luck!

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

Thank you for the heads up about another waiting period! That's frustrating but I guess it makes sense. I'll make sure my doctor knows to document this as the same condition.

0 coins

Wesley Hallow

•

When I tried to do this EXACT thing the EDD KEPT DENYING my recurrence claim even though it was the SAME EXACT problem!!! They said I didn't provide enough medical evidence that it was related to my first claim. I had to appeal THREE TIMES and wait 4+ months to get paid. The system is BROKEN!!!! 😡

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

Oh no, that sounds awful! Did you eventually get approved? Was there anything specific that finally worked?

0 coins

Wesley Hallow

•

I finally got approved after my doctor wrote a VERY detailed letter explaining exactly how it was the same condition. But I still had to call them like 50 times and no one would answer!!!

0 coins

Justin Chang

•

After struggling with getting through to EDD about my recurrence claim last month, I found this service called Claimyr that connected me with an EDD agent in about 20 minutes instead of endless busy signals. Saved my sanity! You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ?si=1hcSq3KFtCr4oAmd or just go to claimyr.com if you need to actually talk to someone about your case. Made a huge difference for me when I had questions about my recurrence paperwork.

0 coins

Brooklyn Foley

•

does this actually work? i tried calling edd last week like 30 times and kept getting hung up on

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

Thanks for sharing this! I'll definitely check it out if I run into trouble. The last time I tried calling EDD I spent 3 hours on hold only to get disconnected!

0 coins

Jay Lincoln

•

Just to add some clarity to what others have said - for a recurrence claim you'll need: 1. Your doctor to complete a "Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate" (DE 2525XX) form 2. You to complete a "Notice of Recurrence of Disability" (DE 2551A) Both can be done through SDI Online. Since you've passed the 14-day mark but it's under 60 days, your claim should be processed as a recurrence rather than a new claim. Your benefit calculation should remain the same. Regarding the waiting period - if it's the same or related condition and within 60 days, you shouldn't have to serve another 7-day waiting period, but there are exceptions. When you file, EDD will determine if another waiting period applies.

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

Thank you for listing the exact forms! This is incredibly helpful. I'll make sure both my doctor and I complete the right paperwork.

0 coins

Marcus Williams

•

update us what happens!! im about to go back to work after 3 months on disability and im worried the same thing will happen to me

0 coins

Elijah Knight

•

I will definitely update! Just submitted my part of the recurrence claim today and my doctor promised to do her part tomorrow. Fingers crossed it goes smoothly! Hope your return to work goes better than mine did.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
7,115 users helped today