Back to California Disability

Zoe Papanikolaou

Is there an issue if employer overpaid during SDI period?

So I've been on SDI for about six weeks now recovering from a back procedure and I just noticed something that's freaking me out a little. My employer apparently kept running payroll normally for the first two weeks of my leave even though my disability claim was already active. So I got my regular paychecks from work AND I assume SDI will pay me for those same weeks. I'm not sure if that counts as me being overpaid somehow or if the issue is with my employer or with EDD. Has anyone dealt with this situation? I don't want to end up owing EDD money or having my claim messed up because of a payroll error.

Reporting the wages you received from your employer to EDD is the right starting point here. EDD looks at whether you received wages for the same days you were claiming disability benefits. The question to put to them directly is what they count as wages against your SDI payments for those two weeks. Each claim gets evaluated on its own details, but transparency with EDD is always the safer path.

0 coins

So I should contact EDD before they figure it out on their own? I didn't even know I was supposed to report employer pay separately.

0 coins

Proactively reporting is better than waiting for a notice. Use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online to flag it, or phone the disability line at 1-800-480-3287.

0 coins

Same situation happened to a neighbor. She reported it and EDD sorted it out without it becoming a bigger problem.

0 coins

EDD's own disability FAQ addresses this kind of overlap. The rule as written is that SDI covers days you can't do your regular work and aren't being paid wages for those same days. If wages hit your account for weeks your claim covers, EDD will want to know. It's worth pulling up myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and checking whether your weekly certification showed any earnings reported.

0 coins

I don't think I reported any earnings because I didn't realize payroll had still run. Would not knowing count against me?

0 coins

Probably not in terms of intent, but the fix is to get ahead of it now rather than wait. If EDD finds the overlap first, it looks very different than if you flag it.

0 coins

This is scaring me because I'm about to start my own SDI claim and my HR department is super disorganized. How do I even know if my employer stopped payroll correctly?

0 coins

Receipt number on my own claim got tangled up for a while, which is a totally different headache, but I ended up talking to someone at EDD after trying Claimyr (claimyr.com). They had me pull up the receipt number I got when I filed in SDI Online and confirmed the doctor's office had matched the right one. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability if you need it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Anyway for the wages overlap thing I'd just get it on record with EDD fast.

0 coins

My claim's sitting at a weird status and I want to ask EDD about which weeks are actually pending. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific week dates you're asking about. That way the agent can pull it up fast.

0 coins

Tried that line about forty times over three mornings. Never got past the automated message. Might give that a shot.

0 coins

Employer paying you while you're on SDI isn't automatically your problem to fix on the EDD side, but it depends on what kind of pay it was. Some employers run what's called supplemental pay to top up SDI. Others just made a payroll mistake. Those two things get treated differently. Ask your HR whether it was intentional or an error, and get the answer in writing.

0 coins

HR said it was definitely a mistake on their end. They want to claw back the two weeks of pay. Does that change anything with EDD?

0 coins

If your employer is recouping the wages, tell EDD that too. The timeline of when they take it back and when your SDI weeks fall matters.

0 coins

My salon did something similar when I was on disability a few years back, just kept direct deposit running by accident. HR fixed it on their end and I reported it to EDD and nothing bad happened, it just took a few extra weeks to sort out.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD is going to call you to flag this, so the burden's on you to report it. That's just how this system works. If wages showed up in those SDI weeks and you didn't report them, an overpayment notice will show up eventually and then you're appealing instead of just explaining.

0 coins

Is an overpayment notice different from a Notice of Determination? I keep seeing both terms and can't tell which is which.

0 coins

A Notice of Determination, the DE 2517, is what EDD sends when your claim isn't payable. An overpayment notice is a separate thing that comes if EDD decides you were paid more than you should have been. Two different documents, two different situations.

0 coins

That clears it up. So theoretically the OP could get either one depending on how EDD reads the employer pay situation.

0 coins

Flagging the employer pay issue in SDI Online sooner rather than later genuinely does make a difference in how these things resolve. EDD moves slowly but they do track wage data, and if a discrepancy shows up during their review it's a lot harder to resolve after the fact.

0 coins

How long does EDD usually take to even notice a wage overlap? Weeks, months?

0 coins

It varies, but it can come up during your claim's review or even after a final payment is issued. There's no reliable timeline I've seen that holds across everyone's situation.

0 coins

months usually from what ive seen. but then the notice comes out of nowhere and stresses everyone out anyway.

0 coins

From a documentation standpoint, get a written statement from your payroll department showing the dates and amounts they paid in error and when they intend to recover it. If EDD ever asks for details about those weeks, having dates and figures from the employer in writing is a lot cleaner than trying to explain it verbally.

0 coins

Payment dates came up for me too, the posted date in my bank versus when EDD said they issued it were off by a few days and I wasn't sure which one counted. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and told me the actual issue date EDD had on file, which matched EDD's side not my bank's.

0 coins

My payment date question was almost the same thing. Used Claimyr as well and once the agent pulled up my claim they confirmed the issue date and I could see it aligned with my Notice of Computation timeline. At that point I stopped worrying about the bank delay. Someone at the line tried to reach a person for three weeks before that and never got through.

0 coins

Three weeks of mornings on that line and I got the automated recording every single time. Good to know there's another option.

0 coins

There's another angle here. If your employer paid you full wages for those weeks, EDD might consider that you weren't experiencing a wage loss for that period, which affects what SDI is designed to cover. It's not just about whether you owe EDD money, it's about whether the SDI payments for those exact weeks were appropriate at all.

0 coins

So does that mean I could have to pay back SDI for those two weeks even though I didn't do anything wrong?

0 coins

That's really a question for EDD to answer based on your specific situation. How they classify the employer pay matters a lot here, which is why getting it documented and reported is the move.

0 coins

Exactly right. EDD's disability benefits calculator and the rules on their site explain what wages factor into the benefit calculation, but the actual determination on a situation like this needs to come from EDD directly on this claim.

0 coins

Overpayment notices can be appealed within 30 days of the date on the notice, with the DE 1000A appeal form or a detailed letter if you've misplaced it. That's not a prediction that you'll get one, just useful to know before it surprises you.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice itself, not the date I receive it?

0 coins

Date on the notice. That's the one that counts.

0 coins

This is the part that always worries me about EDD mail. What if it arrives late and you've already lost days?

0 coins

The appeal form instructions say 30 days from the issue date on the notice. If you have a reason the appeal is late, an administrative law judge can review that too. But the fastest fix is to appeal as soon as the notice arrives.

0 coins

if your boss kept paying you that sounds like their mess not yours but yeah you still gotta let edd know or it comes back on you either way. edd doesnt care whos fault it was they just see the numbers

0 coins

Yeah that's basically what I'm realizing. The payroll person said they'd handle it internally but I think I still need to tell EDD separately.

0 coins

yeah 100% dont rely on hr to fix it with edd. two different things

0 coins

HR at most companies has no idea how SDI interacts with their own payroll, lol. The number of times I've heard someone say 'oh HR is handling it with EDD' and then three months later they get an overpayment notice is kind of wild.

0 coins

So true. EDD and an employer's HR don't really coordinate the way people assume they do. EDD gets wage data through tax records, not through a direct call with your payroll department.

0 coins

Report it yourself. Don't wait on HR to do anything EDD-related. Those are separate lanes.

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mailbox after my tenth automated payment and I had no idea what it was at first! Missed that it needed to come back within 20 days. Used Claimyr to reach an agent who checked my claim and told me my DE 2593 had been received and logged, and that my next payment cycle was still on track. Huge relief after a week of trying that line and getting nowhere.

0 coins

Three mornings in a row I called the disability line and never reached a person. What actually happened when you tried that?

0 coins

The line I'd been trying just played a recording and ended. With Claimyr I ended up actually talking with an EDD agent. The agent went through what was on my claim and told me the DE 2593 was received, so I knew where I stood.

0 coins

The DE 2593 deadline is the one that catches people off guard. Good you got confirmation. Twenty days goes fast when you're recovering and not watching the mailbox.

0 coins

Wait, I didn't know about the DE 2593. I've been on automatic payment for a while. Should I be watching for one of those?

0 coins

Automatic payments run for ten weeks and then EDD sends the DE 2593 to verify you're still unable to work. Return it within 20 days. If you're past week ten and haven't seen it, check your mailbox carefully and also look in SDI Online.

0 coins

I'm at week six so not there yet, but good to know this is coming. Does it get mailed or can I do it online?

0 coins

EDD mails it. Keep an eye out around week ten.

0 coins

Mine got lost once and EDD stopped my payments. Had to explain the situation. Not fun.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in on a claim I had a while back and I wanted to appeal but the EDD phone line was completely pointless for three weeks. Claimyr was what finally got me to an agent who looked at the notice date on my file and confirmed I still had days left in my appeal window. Filed the DE 1000A the same afternoon.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's disability line so your phone rings when an actual agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

My claim has a discrepancy in the base period quarter EDD used and I've been trying to reach someone about it for weeks. Might actually use it for that.

0 coins

The base period quarter question is a real one to get sorted. The weekly benefit amount flows directly from which quarter they pull.

0 coins

Just to loop back on the original question, the SDI rules are built around wage loss. The whole point is that you're not earning while you can't work. If wages were still hitting your account for those weeks, the system is designed to flag that eventually. Getting ahead of it is unambiguously the right move.

0 coins

Agreed, I already sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online this morning explaining what happened with the payroll. Waiting to hear back.

0 coins

That's the right step. Keep a note of the date you submitted it in case EDD's response references that timeline later.

0 coins

Ask EDD specifically whether the employer wages they're seeing in your record are categorized as supplemental wages or standard wages, because the distinction matters for how they evaluate your SDI weeks. Document whatever they tell you.

0 coins

Well explained. The nature of the payment from the employer is exactly the question EDD needs to resolve, not just the fact that it happened.

0 coins

Get it in writing from both sides. EDD's response in SDI Online counts, and the employer email or letter counts. Keep both.

0 coins

I'm also worried because my employer does some kind of supplemental plan on top of SDI. Does that count as being overpaid? I thought that was normal.

0 coins

Supplemental pay from an employer that tops up your SDI to something closer to your full salary is a different arrangement than payroll continuing by mistake. Ask EDD and your HR how that specific plan interacts with your SDI claim, because the details of those plans vary.

0 coins

Okay so I shouldn't just assume it's fine because it seems like a normal benefit. I'll ask HR to explain what their plan does exactly.

0 coins

EDD's site explains wages and SDI at a general level, but how your employer's specific supplemental plan counts is a question to put to EDD on your own claim.

0 coins

been dealing with edd for months and the fastest thing i ever did was just send a request through sdi online and not wait on the phone. the phone line is just a wall

0 coins

Yeah the Request Claim Update feature exists for a reason. Phone line is a last resort for me now.

0 coins

exactly. if you can get an answer in sdi online in a few days it beats three mornings of busy signals

0 coins

Employer payroll errors during an SDI claim are more common than people admit. The issue is that most workers don't know to report it because they assumed the two systems talk to each other. They don't.

0 coins

Yep. People think EDD and HR are synced up somehow. They're not. EDD pulls wage data on its own timeline and claimants are on the hook for reporting anything that could affect their benefit.

0 coins

That's exactly what happened to me. I just assumed HR would have flagged it. Lesson learned the hard way, but at least I caught it before an overpayment notice showed up.

0 coins

Flagging this in SDI Online was the right call and you did it early, which matters. If EDD needs more information they'll follow up through the system or by mail. Keep checking your SDI Online messages.

0 coins

Will do. I also asked my employer to send me a written confirmation of the payroll error and their plan to recover it, so I have that for my own records.

0 coins

Good. That paper trail is exactly what you'd want if EDD ever needs to see the employer's side of it.

0 coins

Hope it resolves cleanly. These payroll overlap situations usually do when the claimant gets ahead of them.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure