Is SDI pay based on gross or net wages? Trying to figure out what I'll actually get
So I'm going out on disability next week, back surgery, and I'm trying to figure out what my payments will actually look like. I keep reading stuff online about the wage calculation but none of it says clearly whether the amount they use is what I make before taxes get pulled out or after. Like is SDI pay based on gross or net wages? Makes a pretty big difference for how I'm planning my budget for the next couple months. I've got the kids and all the bills so I'm trying to do the math before I actually file. Already logged into myEDD to start looking at SDI Online but haven't filed yet.
94 comments

Freya Collins
Base period wages they look at are your gross, before anything gets taken out. The quarter with the highest gross earnings in that 12-month window is what they use to figure your rate. I had the same question when I filed last spring, shoulder injury kept me out eight weeks. Couldn't get a straight answer on the phone for three weeks, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got talking to an EDD agent the same morning. Video they put out on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up my claim and told me right away which quarter they'd used, it was Q2 from my base period, and that matched my highest-earning stretch doing overtime. Put my mind at ease knowing the number was set.
0 coins
LongPeri
Q2 of your base period being the one they flagged, did the agent say anything about how that quarter was identified on the Notice of Computation, or was it just something they could see on their end?
0 coins
Freya Collins
Showed up on the agent's end, they read it to me. My Notice of Computation had the weekly amount on it but not the quarter label, at least not labeled obviously. The agent just confirmed which one it came from.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
been dialing that disability line since monday, 8am sharp, nothing but a recording that cuts me off. four days now. good to know there's another way.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
To add a bit of precision here: EDD looks at wages subject to SDI withholding, which are your gross wages before income taxes, retirement contributions or anything else is deducted. The actual formula takes your highest-earning quarter in the base period and calculates a percentage of those wages. The percentage ranges from 70 to 90 percent depending on where your income falls. Run the estimator on EDD's site to see your own number before the Notice of Computation arrives.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorSo my gross wages, not my take-home. That actually makes the math easier since I know what I earned each quarter. Going to try the calculator tonight.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
Wait, so the SDI deduction they take out of my paycheck every week, the CASDI line, that doesn't factor into the benefit calculation at all? It just determines whether I'm covered?
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
Exactly right. The CASDI deduction is what funds the program and establishes your eligibility. It's not a savings account that fills up and pays you back dollar for dollar. The benefit comes from your wage history in the base period, and the Notice of Computation will show the exact amount.
0 coins
Liv Park
CASDI line on a stub is how small it looks compared to what comes out of a full check. People always expect more.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
okay so I was totally confused about this for the longest time too. I thought SDI would pay based on my direct deposit amount, like what I actually see in my bank account after my salon takes out the state taxes and everything. Nope. It's the full gross amount per quarter they're working from. My first claim two years ago the Notice of Computation came and I was honestly surprised it was higher than I expected because I forgot how much I actually gross before all the deductions.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
The surprise going the right direction is a good surprise. Most people assume the worst and then the notice shows a higher figure than they budgeted for.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
I'm kind of scared to assume anything. Not sure if tips count as wages for my situation, I work at a coffee shop and tips are part of my income but I don't know if SDI is based on gross or net wages when tips are involved. Should I just ask EDD directly?
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Tips that are reported and have CASDI withheld from them count. The key is whether SDI tax was actually deducted from those earnings. If your employer withholds CASDI on tips, those wages are in the base period calculation. If you're unsure what your employer reported, your W-2 or pay stubs would show the CASDI withheld amount.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
Okay that makes sense. My stubs do show CASDI on tips so I think I'm good. Still going to triple-check before I file.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
gross wages 100% not net. found this out the hard way when i thought my benefit would be way lower. notice of computation came in and it was based on what i made before anything got pulled, way better than i expected tbh
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorThat's actually encouraging to hear. My gross is decent, it's just the take-home that feels small after everything's removed.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
same thing here. assumed the worst and then the notice showed something better. still not full pay but better than i thought.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
From a bookkeeping standpoint: EDD pulls from the base period, which is four quarters ending roughly five to eighteen months before your disability start date. Highest of those four quarters in gross SDI-covered wages sets the weekly amount, estimated at 70 to 90 percent of that quarter's weekly average. The Notice of Computation locks in the exact figure. Worth running the calculator on EDD's site with your actual gross quarterly numbers before you file so you have a ballpark.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorFive to eighteen months back, so not my current quarter. Got it. That means last winter's overtime I did would be in there, which helps.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
Correct. That lag in the base period is why someone who just got a big raise might see a benefit that looks lower relative to their current check. EDD is working from wages that are several months old.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Raise timing and injury timing rarely cooperate.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
I'm filing for the first time and I genuinely didn't know any of this. I had my husband add up my net paychecks and we were panicking that it would barely cover the mortgage. If gross is what they use that changes our whole calculation. Where exactly do I find my gross quarterly wages, is that on my W-2 or do I need pay stubs?
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
Pay stubs work well because they break down each pay period and you can add by quarter. W-2 gives you annual gross, which you'd need to split out manually. If your employer uses a payroll service, an annual earnings statement by quarter is usually available through the employee portal.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
We've been adding up net this whole time and totally underestimated. I'll get the stubs out tonight.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Sounds like you're going to end up in a better spot than you thought. The calculator on EDD's site is pretty straightforward once you have the quarterly gross numbers in front of you.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Payment method question was the thing I needed answered and the disability line just never picked up. Tried seven mornings in a row. Ended up using Claimyr to reach someone at EDD and talked to an agent about whether my payments would go to a card or if I could switch to direct deposit. Agent told me direct deposit is an option on SDI Online claims and walked me through where in the account to set it up.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
My claim's been approved and I want to know if I picked the wrong payment method when I filed, lol. Going to try that for my own call. What do I need to have ready when I use it?
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Have your Social Security number and claim ID from SDI Online handy. Agent asked me for both right away.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Seven mornings is nothing, I hit two weeks of that before I finally got through on my own. Mornings, afternoons, tried everything.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
What nobody explains clearly is that your benefit is NOT going to match your paycheck even calculated from gross. The 70 to 90 percent isn't of your whole paycheck, it's a percentage of what you earned in your highest quarter. So someone who made a lot of overtime in one quarter and not much the others might see a number that feels off. The estimate calculator on EDD's site at least lets you plug in your own quarters and see.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorYeah I figured it wouldn't be a full replacement. Just trying not to be blindsided by the actual number.
0 coins
LongPeri
The range between 70 and 90 percent seems wide. Is there a way to know in advance which percentage applies to your income level before the Notice of Computation arrives?
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
EDD's calculator gives you an estimate based on your quarterly wages, that's the closest you'll get before the official notice. The actual percentage lands somewhere in that range depending on where your income falls, the lower your wages the higher the percentage generally.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
That's accurate. EDD designed it so lower earners replace a higher share of their wages. The Notice of Computation is the definitive answer, the calculator is the preview.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
My sister kept telling me SDI would only pay based on what I took home and I was so stressed! Found out from this thread and from EDD's site that it's gross wages and honestly the difference on my calculation was about two months of breathing room. Filed last week, waiting on the medical certification from my doctor's office now.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Two months of breathing room is huge. Hope your certification gets in fast, waiting on the doctor's office is its own kind of stressful.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
My doctor's office said they'd submit through SDI Online within a few days. Fingers crossed it matches up with my claim quickly!
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
Make sure your doctor uses the receipt number from your SDI Online filing. That's how their certification gets linked to your claim.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
Patients ask me this all the time. Gross wages, before any deductions, is what EDD pulls from. The CASDI line on your stub is what makes you eligible, the gross is what determines the amount. Use the calculator on EDD's site, it's faster than doing it by hand.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorShort and direct, exactly what I needed. Calculator it is.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Agree. The calculator gave me a close enough number that my actual Notice of Computation wasn't a surprise.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Went through this last fall, pulled a muscle in my back at work, found out pretty fast it matters a lot which quarter you're pulling from. I had one really strong quarter from picking up extra shifts and that ended up being the one EDD used. Gross from that quarter made my benefit amount way more livable than if they'd averaged it out or used a weaker quarter.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorExtra shifts counting toward that highest quarter is exactly what I'm hoping for. I had a solid spring of overtime.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Spring overtime would be Q2, should land right in the base period window depending on your start date. Definitely plug it into EDD's calculator to confirm.
0 coins
Liv Park
Makes sense they'd take the highest quarter but I could see why people expect it to be an average. Never is though.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
Not sure if this is obvious but I had to ask: does the base period change if you file on a different date? Like if I wait another month to file, does that shift which quarters EDD looks at and potentially help or hurt my benefit amount?
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
Timing your start date can shift which quarters fall in the base period, yes. EDD looks at a 12-month window ending 5 to 18 months before the disability start date. If you're on the edge of a quarter, a few weeks difference in your start date could bring in a stronger or weaker quarter. The calculator on EDD's site lets you try different start dates to see the effect.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
I didn't realize the start date I pick could actually change the benefit amount. That's worth running through the calculator a few times before I file.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
The disability start date has to reflect when you actually became unable to work, not a date chosen purely for a better benefit calculation. File as close to your actual disability start as EDD's rules allow.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Right, EDD's rule is to file within 49 days of the disability start date and no earlier than nine days after. The start date is the day the disability began, not a date of convenience.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Medical certification from my doctor was the thing holding up my whole claim. SDI Online showed pending for two weeks and I couldnt get anyone at EDD on the line. Tried Claimyr and got an agent. Agent checked and said the certification hadnt come in yet, still waiting on the providers end. Gave me the receipt number to bring back to my doctors office so they could locate the claim in SDI Online and submit it right.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Receipt number being the missing link at the doctor's office, that happened to mine too. I actually used Claimyr on my own claim when I needed to ask about the DE 2593, the continued eligibility form EDD sent me around week ten. Got on with an agent and confirmed the form had been received and that my automatic payments would keep running. Had been stressing for days whether the form got there in time.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
DE 2593, is that something that comes automatically or do I have to request it? I haven't heard of that form yet.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
EDD mails it to you around the ten-week mark if you're on automatic payment. You just fill it out and send it back within 20 days. The agent told me mine came in on the right date so I didn't have to worry.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
been trying that disability line every other day for a week and a half. mornings cut me off, afternoons same thing. starting to think it's not possible to reach a person.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Waiting period is seven days, not payable. Comes right off the top of every new claim. Payable on day eight.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorSeven days I won't see any money for. Got it. Building that into the budget now.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
Is that seven calendar days or seven business days? I've been assuming calendar.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Calendar days.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Seven calendar days, confirmed. It's always a little longer than people expect but at least it's predictable.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
The timeline on most claims: file your part in SDI Online, your doctor submits the certification, EDD usually issues payment within two weeks of receiving both. That's the target, not a guarantee. If your claim is straightforward and both parts are in cleanly, that two-week window holds up more often than not.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorTwo weeks after both parts are in. So my planning should really start from when my doctor submits, not when I file.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
Exactly. The clock on payment timing really starts when EDD has both the claimant's statement and the medical certification. Filing your part first and then waiting on the doctor adds to the total wait.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
My doctor's office mentioned submitting within three to five days. So two weeks after that would be my earliest realistic payment date to plan around.
0 coins
LongPeri
Someone upthread mentioned the base period ends 5 to 18 months before the claim start date. That means if I file in December, my most recent quarter probably isn't in the base period at all, right? So my current paycheck amount doesn't directly determine my SDI benefit.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
Correct. The lag is intentional. EDD needs a completed and reported quarter to base the calculation on. Your most recent few months are almost always outside the base period window, which is why a raise you just got won't show up in this claim's benefit.
0 coins
LongPeri
That explains why my coworker got less than expected even though she'd been earning more lately. Her recent quarters weren't in the window.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
An alternative base period exists in some cases, but the standard base period covers the scenario most claimants deal with. If the standard window leaves someone with insufficient wages, EDD can look at an alternate set of quarters.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
my paycheck stub literally says gross wages at the top and then all the deductions come after. edd uses that top number, the one before anything is subtracted. pretty simple once you know to look there
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorThat's a good way to put it. The top number before anything is touched. Makes it easy to find on the stub.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
yeah just grab 3 months of stubs per quarter and add up that top line. thats your quarterly gross. then plug it into edds calculator
0 coins
Ryder Greene
The confusion between gross and net is probably the most common question I see on these threads. Net makes you panic, gross gives you a realistic picture. Once you run the EDD calculator with actual gross quarterly numbers most people feel better about their disability claim budget.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
Running it tonight with my actual stubs. Hoping for a better number than my net-based panic calculation.
0 coins
Liv Park
Reality check either way is better than guessing.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Worth noting: EDD's benefit page specifies that the wages used must be subject to SDI deductions. If you had any income during the base period that didn't have CASDI withheld, it won't count toward the calculation. For most W-2 employees this isn't an issue, but independent contractors or someone with mixed income types might see a difference.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
Gig income without CASDI withheld is a whole separate thing. As a driver I have to handle SDI contributions differently and not everybody knows that.
0 coins
LongPeri
Does self-employed or gig workers electing into SDI coverage actually change the benefit calculation method, or is the gross wage logic the same?
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
The gross wage principle is the same. What changes is how the wages were reported and whether CASDI was paid. The base period still applies the same way. If you're unsure whether your earnings are covered, the SDI Online filing process or EDD directly can confirm what's on record for your account.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
filed two days ago and already refreshing sdi online every few hours which i know doesnt help. doctor said theyd get the certification in by end of week. anyone know if sdi online updates in real time when the doctors submission comes in or is there a lag
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
There's usually a short lag between when a provider submits and when SDI Online reflects it. Checking daily is plenty. Constant refreshing won't speed anything up.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
figured. still going to check twice a day at minimum.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
The 14-day window EDD mentions is from when they have both parts, so once your doctor's certification lands you're in the queue. The wait after that is the hard part.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
For someone like you going out next week: file as soon as your disability starts, make sure your surgeon has your receipt number from SDI Online. That gets the certification matched to your claim faster. Don't wait to see if the payment comes before you chase that receipt number.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorFiling the day I go out and handing the receipt number to my surgeon's office at the same appointment. Good call.
0 coins
Freya Collins
What she said. My biggest delay was my doctor's office not having the receipt number to find my claim. Cost me four extra days.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorFour days matters when you're counting every dollar. Noted.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Does the gross calculation change at all for people who get paid hourly versus salary? Like does EDD treat a steady salary differently than someone whose hours vary week to week?
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
EDD looks at the total gross wages reported for the quarter regardless of how they were structured. Hourly or salary doesn't change the formula. What matters is the total SDI-covered gross for each quarter in the base period, whichever quarter is highest drives the benefit calculation.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
That makes it cleaner for hourly workers then since you can just add up paystub totals without converting anything.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
Exactly right. Add the gross from each pay stub in a quarter, that's your quarterly gross for EDD's purposes. No conversion needed.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
UPDATE: Filed this morning through SDI Online, took maybe 20 minutes. My surgeon's office already had an appointment tomorrow so I'll bring the receipt number in person and make sure they have it to submit the certification. Ran the calculator on EDD's site with my actual gross quarterly numbers and the estimate came in a lot better than what I had panicked about using my net figures. Thanks everyone.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
20 minutes to file and a better number than you feared, good start. Hope the surgery and recovery go smoothly.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
Bring the receipt number on paper, don't just mention it verbally. Surgeon's office is busy and you want them to have it in front of them.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
AuthorPrinted it out already. And writing it on two sticky notes just in case.
0 coins