Back to California Disability

Andre Moreau

Is SDI deductible on federal return? Trying to figure out my taxes

Trying to sort out my taxes before the end of the year and I cannot figure out what to do with my SDI payments from this past claim. I was out for about ten weeks starting in September after a back procedure, and EDD paid me through mid-November. Now I'm looking at my return and I have no idea whether the SDI benefits I got count as income I need to report federally, or if they're deductible somewhere, or what. California I think doesn't tax them but federal is a whole other question that I can't get a straight answer on anywhere. My Notice of Computation showed my weekly amount and I just multiplied that out to get a rough total of what I received, but I genuinely don't know what bucket that goes into on my federal return. Has anyone dealt with this? Did you get a form from EDD at the end of the year, like a 1099-G or something? And does what your employer paid into SDI on your behalf change anything versus the CASDI deduction that comes out of your own paycheck?

DE 2525XX came back denied on my extension request and I needed to know if EDD had actually received it from my doctor's office before I could appeal anything. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live person on EDD's disability line after the hold music cut out on me twice. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the DE 2525XX had come in but was dated three days after my last paid week, which is why EDD couldn't pay the extension period without a new certification covering those dates. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. My doctor resubmitted with the right dates and it went through after that. On your tax question specifically, California does not tax SDI benefits, that part is right. Federal is murkier and genuinely depends on your situation, so I'd point you to EDD's tax information page and a tax professional rather than take my word for it here.

0 coins

The extension part is helpful context. When your doctor resubmitted, did EDD treat the gap days between the original end date and the new certification as just unpaid, or did those days get picked up once the new dates were on file?

0 coins

The agent said those gap days stayed unpaid because the certification didn't cover them. I didn't push to appeal that part since the rest of the extension came through fine.

0 coins

CASDI on your pay stub is what you as the worker put in, and it comes out of wages you already paid income tax on, so the SDI benefit coming back to you isn't taxed by California either. Federal is the part nobody can give you a clean universal answer on and that's genuinely frustrating when you're just trying to file.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact situation last filing season after a knee surgery claim. The CASDI deduction that comes out of your paycheck every period is paid entirely by you, the employee, not your employer, and that matters for how the federal side gets treated. Because you paid the premium yourself with after-tax dollars, the general guidance most tax professionals give is that the benefits aren't federally taxable, but I want to be clear that's not me giving you a tax ruling, it's just what I heard from my own CPA. EDD's site has a tax information section that lays out what they say about it, and that plus a tax professional is really the right path here.

0 coins

Did your CPA say anything about whether EDD sends a 1099-G for SDI specifically, or is that only for unemployment?

0 coins

Mine said to check my myEDD account and EDD's tax page for what documents they issue, because it apparently isn't the same for every situation. She wouldn't give me a definitive answer without seeing the actual forms.

0 coins

EDD mails tax documents to your address on file so make sure that's current in myEDD if you moved during the claim period. I got burned on that one with a delayed form two years ago.

0 coins

The CASDI line on your W-2 from your employer, that box that shows what was withheld for state disability, that's the amount you paid in. I've seen people confuse that with an employer contribution but California employers don't pay into SDI, it's all deducted from your wages. So when it comes to figuring out the federal picture, the fact that you funded the premium matters a lot according to every tax person I've talked to, but they all stop short of giving a blanket answer.

0 coins

Which box on the W-2 does the CASDI withholding usually show up in?

0 coins

Box 14, usually labeled CASDI or SDI, though your employer controls the label so it might read slightly differently. Your paycheck stubs from before you went out should show the deduction each pay period too.

0 coins

Box 14 is correct. It's considered a state tax for W-2 purposes even though it funds a benefit program, which is part of why the federal deductibility question gets complicated.

0 coins

Wait I thought SDI was just not taxable at all, like period. My coworker told me it's completely tax free. Am I wrong about that?

0 coins

California doesn't tax it, that part is right. The federal question is the one that isn't a flat yes or no for everyone, it depends on factors specific to your situation and EDD's tax page plus a tax pro are the right places to get that sorted out.

0 coins

Oh okay so my coworker was probably talking about the state side and I just assumed it meant everything. Good to know I should actually check before I file.

0 coins

Filed my taxes after a pregnancy disability claim two years ago and completely panicked about this same question in February. My situation was that my employer had a supplemental plan that topped up the SDI payments and I had no idea how those pieces fit together federally. My tax person said the SDI portion and the employer supplement are treated differently, but she wouldn't give me a universal rule, just what applied to my own W-2 and 1099 situation. The lesson I took is that if there's any employer top-up involved you really do need someone to look at your specific documents.

0 coins

Mine was straightforward SDI only, no employer supplement, so hopefully that simplifies things at least a little.

0 coins

If it's purely the EDD payment with no employer plan on top, you're dealing with fewer moving parts at least. EDD's tax information page is worth reading first before you pay someone to answer a question EDD might just answer directly.

0 coins

The employer top-up piece trips so many people up. I work in payroll and the number of questions I get in January every year about this exact issue is ridiculous.

0 coins

My claim start date had been entered wrong in SDI Online, it showed a date two weeks later than when my doctor actually certified my disability beginning. I had to phone EDD to get it sorted and ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr after the regular line kept dropping me at the hold point. The agent confirmed the start date in their system didn't match what was on my medical certification and flagged it for correction. That error had also shifted which weeks EDD counted as my waiting period, so it wasn't just a paperwork thing. On the tax question here, I'll just add that your SDI Online account under your claim should show total benefits paid, which is a useful number to have in hand when you sit down with a tax professional or EDD's tax guidance.

0 coins

How long did it take for the corrected start date to show up in SDI Online after the agent flagged it?

0 coins

About a week before I saw the claim reflect the right date. EDD mailed a corrected notice after that which I kept for my records.

0 coins

The start date and waiting period connection is something I didn't understand until I had my own claim. Those seven days at the beginning aren't processing time, they're a non-payable period built into every new claim, so if the start date is wrong it really does change which days get paid.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up was thinking the waiting period meant EDD was just processing the claim slowly. No, it's literally the first seven days of the claim that are never paid, by design, every single time. Has nothing to do with how fast EDD is moving on your paperwork. I found this out after calling to ask why my first payment didn't cover my first week, and the agent explained it in about thirty seconds.

0 coins

Does that seven day waiting period apply to pregnancy disability claims too, or is it different for those?

0 coins

Same rule applies, the first seven days of a pregnancy disability claim are also the non-payable waiting period. The only program that doesn't have one is Paid Family Leave, which is the separate bonding claim after the disability period ends.

0 coins

PFL not having a waiting period always catches people off guard because they assume the same rules carry over from their disability claim. They're genuinely two different programs even though they can run back to back for a pregnancy.

0 coins

My sister kept asking me if she could deduct the CASDI withholding on her federal return as a state tax paid, the way you can sometimes deduct state income tax. I didn't know the answer and told her to ask a tax professional. If anyone here actually knows whether CASDI qualifies as a deductible state tax on Schedule A, I'd be curious, but I also wouldn't trust a forum for a definitive tax ruling on it.

0 coins

EDD's tax page is the right starting point and a CPA or enrolled agent can confirm whether it applies to your specific filing situation. The forum answer to any tax question should come with a giant asterisk.

0 coins

Completely agree. I told her the same thing, just wanted to flag it here because it seems like a question related to what the original post is asking about.

0 coins

The deductibility of state taxes paid is its own separate question from whether the SDI benefit itself is taxable, so it's worth making sure a tax professional addresses both angles if they're both relevant to your situation.

0 coins

Nobody in my office could tell me anything useful about the tax side of SDI when I was out last year. HR literally said 'talk to a tax professional' and that was the whole answer. Which is correct I guess but not super helpful in the moment. The EDD tax information section at edd.ca.gov is at least a starting point that gives you EDD's own framing of the issue.

0 coins

HR is usually trained to send that question to payroll or a tax professional and not answer it themselves because the wrong answer creates liability. Frustrating but at least they didn't make something up.

0 coins

Fair point, I'd rather they say they don't know than give me a confident wrong answer.

0 coins

Notice of Computation had an amount on it that didn't match what I thought my benefit should be based on my wages, so I phoned EDD to ask which quarter they'd used for the calculation. Getting through took a few tries before I used Claimyr and had an EDD agent on the line, who told me which of my base period quarters had the highest wages and confirmed that was the one they'd used. The amount on my Notice was right, I'd just been looking at the wrong pay periods when I estimated it myself. Bringing this up because your Notice of Computation total is also the clearest record of your SDI benefit amount for tax purposes, whatever the federal treatment ends up being.

0 coins

Which quarter ended up being the highest one for you, like roughly how far back did EDD go to find it?

0 coins

The agent explained it was from the base period, which looks at wages from about five to eighteen months before the claim started. For me it was a quarter from about a year before I went out, which I hadn't thought to include when I was estimating.

0 coins

The base period math is confusing until you actually see your Notice of Computation and trace back which wages they used. EDD's benefit calculator on their site can give you an estimate before you file if you want a ballpark.

0 coins

Clearing up something I've seen get muddled in a few comments here: the CASDI deduction on your pay stub funds your SDI benefit, and it comes out of your wages as an employee contribution only. California employers do not contribute to SDI on behalf of workers. That's different from other payroll taxes where there's an employer match. It matters for the federal tax question because who paid the premium affects how the benefit is treated, which is why the answer isn't the same for every worker in every situation.

0 coins

This distinction also comes up if someone has a Voluntary Plan through their employer instead of the state SDI plan. That's a different setup and probably has its own tax treatment. Someone with a Voluntary Plan should definitely ask a tax professional specifically about that.

0 coins

Voluntary Plans are worth flagging because they operate differently from state SDI even though they serve the same general purpose. EDD's site describes them but the tax angle there is definitely a question for a professional.

0 coins

Mine is straight state SDI, deduction on the pay stub and all, so at least I don't have that extra layer to untangle.

0 coins

My first SDI claim I didn't even realize EDD had my old apartment address still in the system. Any year-end tax documents EDD sends go to the address in myEDD, so if you moved during or after the claim period make sure that's updated before January rolls around.

0 coins

Had the exact same address problem after relocating for a new job mid-claim. Updating in myEDD is quick but you have to remember to do it.

0 coins

The myEDD account is at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and the address update is in the account settings. Worth doing before the end of the year.

0 coins

Went through a really long disability claim after a complicated surgery last year and the tax question at the end of the year genuinely stressed me out more than I expected. The practical thing I did was log into SDI Online, pull up my claim, and write down the total benefits paid. That number became the starting point for every conversation I had with my tax person. Having it exact rather than estimating from my weekly amount times the number of weeks made the conversation a lot faster.

0 coins

Can you get to that total benefits paid figure from the main claim screen or do you have to dig into individual payment records?

0 coins

On my claim it was visible in the payment history section in SDI Online. Each payment period was listed separately so I added them up, which also let me double-check the total matched what I expected from my Notice of Computation weekly amount.

0 coins

Keeping screenshots of your payment history in SDI Online throughout the claim is a good habit because payment records are easier to access while the claim is current than after it closes.

0 coins

Every single January I watch people realize they have no idea what to do with their SDI benefits on their taxes and scramble to figure it out before the filing deadline. If you got SDI benefits this year, check your myEDD account and EDD's tax information section now rather than in April.

0 coins

The scramble is real. I did it both years I had a claim and I should have checked EDD's guidance months earlier both times.

0 coins

The myEDD account keeps your documents, your payment history is in SDI Online inside it, and EDD's tax page lays out the California tax treatment clearly. Those two things together get you most of the way to knowing what questions to bring to a CPA.

0 coins

EDD's tax information is on their main site and covers the California side clearly. The federal side is the one where even the IRS guidance gets into conditionals. I'd look at the IRS publication on sick pay and disability benefits and then bring questions to a tax professional if anything is unclear after reading it. That's genuinely the most honest answer.

0 coins

Is that IRS publication something you'd find through the regular IRS site search, or is there a specific form number for it?

0 coins

You can search the IRS site for 'disability benefits' or 'sick pay' and find their guidance. It's not a form, more of a publication. Your tax person will know exactly where to point you once you tell them the SDI payments came from California's state program funded by your own CASDI withholding.

0 coins

One more layer to the confusion: if you were also receiving unemployment insurance at any point this year, that's definitely taxable federally and you'd get a 1099-G for it. SDI and unemployment are completely different programs with different tax rules. You can't receive both for the same days anyway since EDD requires you to be able and available for work to claim unemployment, and if you're out on disability you clearly can't meet that test.

0 coins

Does that mean if someone finishes their disability claim and then gets laid off, they'd file for unemployment starting from when they're able to work again?

0 coins

Exactly. DI is for the days you're unable to work, and once you're able to work again and are available, that's when unemployment becomes the relevant program, assuming your job situation has changed. They're sequential, not overlapping, for the same days.

0 coins

The 1099-G distinction is worth flagging because someone who had both programs in the same year might receive forms for one and not the other, which can make the tax picture look confusing until you sort out which amounts came from which program.

0 coins

My biggest regret from my claim last year was not writing down the dates EDD processed each payment when they hit my account. I was on the Money Network card and I could see the deposit dates in the card's app, but I didn't screenshot anything and had to piece it back together later when my tax professional asked for the year's total.

0 coins

Money Network card's transaction history in the app only goes back a certain number of months, so relying on it for year-end records is risky. SDI Online payment history is a more reliable archive.

0 coins

Didn't realize SDI Online kept that history, I would have used it from the start if I'd known. Good to know for anyone still on a current claim.

0 coins

Came back to update my own situation from the original question. I ended up booking a session with a CPA who works with a lot of people on disability claims and she clarified the whole picture for me. For my situation, straight CASDI-funded SDI benefits with no employer supplement, she said the federal treatment was straightforward, but she also said she couldn't give me a one-size answer to share publicly because it really does hinge on individual circumstances. What she did say I can pass along: get the total paid amount from SDI Online, have your W-2 handy to show the CASDI withholding in box 14, and EDD's tax page is accurate for the California side. Federal is the question only your own tax professional can resolve for your specific return.

0 coins

Box 14 on your W-2 showing the CASDI amount is exactly what a tax professional needs to see the whole picture. Glad you got a clear answer for your own situation even if it can't be shared as a universal rule.

0 coins

The W-2 plus the SDI Online payment history is a solid package to bring to any tax appointment. This thread has been a good primer on knowing what to gather.

0 coins

Workers' compensation is a whole different thing from SDI and I've seen people on this forum mix those up when asking about taxes too. If you were injured at work, workers' comp handles it, not SDI, and the tax treatment for workers' comp benefits is its own topic. EDD is pretty clear that it's not common to get both at the same time.

0 coins

The workers' comp versus SDI distinction trips people up especially when an injury could have been work-related or not, because the determination of which program applies has to happen before you even know which tax rules are relevant.

0 coins

Exactly, and EDD's own guidance on that is to contact them and your workers' comp insurer if there's any overlap question. It's not something you sort out yourself.

0 coins

Came into this thread confused about whether my injury counted as workers' comp or SDI territory and this is the first place I've seen it explained that clearly. My situation was definitely non-work-related so I'm on the right track with the SDI tax question.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure