Back to California Disability

Dmitry Smirnov

Is CASDI mandatory for California workers? What it means for your SDI claim

So I got my first paycheck at a new job and noticed this CASDI deduction coming out automatically. Nobody at HR explained it and I didn't sign anything for it. I work in a warehouse doing overnight shifts and they just started taking it out without asking me. I looked it up a little and it seems connected to disability insurance somehow but I'm not sure if this is something I opted into or if my employer just decided to do it. Is CASDI mandatory for everyone in California or can you opt out? And if they're taking it out does that mean I automatically have SDI coverage if something happens to me?

The CASDI line on your paystub is California's State Disability Insurance withholding, and yes, for most employees in California it's mandatory. Your employer doesn't ask permission and you don't sign up for it. The state requires covered workers to contribute, and that's what funds the DI program. So as long as your wages are subject to that deduction, you're building coverage. If you ever get hurt outside of work or sick or need time off for surgery or something, you can file a disability claim through SDI Online and that CASDI you've been paying is what backs it.

0 coins

Thanks, that clears it up. So does it matter how long I've been at the job before I can file? Like is there a minimum time you have to have the deduction coming out first?

0 coins

The requirement isn't time at the job, it's wages. EDD looks back at a base period of wages you earned before your disability starts, and you need at least $300 in wages that had the SDI deduction on them during that base period. So if you just started and something happened right away, it might depend on what you earned before this job too during that window.

0 coins

Warehouse work overnight is rough, I did that for three years and ended up with a back thing that put me out for weeks. File as soon as you're eligible, don't wait around thinking it'll get better on its own.

0 coins

To add onto what was said above about it being mandatory, there are some workers it doesn't apply to. Certain self-employed people aren't automatically covered, and some employers have their own voluntary plan instead of the state one. If your employer has a Voluntary Plan, the deduction might look slightly different on your stub. But for a standard warehouse job with a regular employer, you're almost certainly under the state SDI program and yes it's mandatory.

0 coins

Good point about the voluntary plan thing, didn't know that was even a thing. Mine just says CASDI so I'm guessing I'm under the state one.

0 coins

CASDI specifically is the state deduction label, so you're right, that's the California SDI program. A voluntary plan employer would have their own deduction label typically.

0 coins

My employer has a VP and I honestly had no idea until I tried to file through SDI Online and ran into confusion. Worth knowing the difference before you ever need to use it.

0 coins

Receipt number situation came up for me when I actually had to use my SDI coverage after hurting my shoulder at the gym. I filed Part A through SDI Online and got a form receipt number, then told my doctor's office to look for the claim using that number so they could submit the medical certification. The office kept saying they couldn't find it, and I couldn't get anyone at EDD on the phone for days. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an actual EDD agent, and I found out the receipt number I'd given the office had a digit transposed. Once I gave them the corrected one the certification went through the same week. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Oh that's a good heads up about the receipt number, I never would have thought a one-digit difference would hold the whole thing up.

0 coins

The doctor's office can't find your claim at all without the exact number matching. I went back to the office in person with a screenshot of the right one and that fixed it.

0 coins

Same thing happened to my partner's claim, the office had an old number from a previous claim and submitted the cert against the wrong one. Took two extra weeks to sort out.

0 coins

To answer the question about opting out more directly: you can't opt out if you're a covered employee. The deduction is set by the state and your employer is required to withhold it. It's not like a 401k where you decide the percentage or whether to participate at all. The rate on your stub is what it is, and it comes out every paycheck on wages subject to SDI.

0 coins

Makes sense. I wasn't trying to get out of it, just wanted to understand what it was since HR never explained it.

0 coins

Totally understandable, most people don't know what it is until they actually need to use it or see it on their stub and wonder. At least now you know it's there working for you.

0 coins

HR at a lot of warehouses is basically nonexistent for stuff like this. I found out about SDI from a coworker who had used it, never from anyone official at my job.

0 coins

CASDI mandatory question is one I had too when I first started working in California after moving from out of state. Where I came from there was nothing like this on my check. It felt weird at first but after I had to use it for a knee surgery last spring I was really glad it was there. My weekly benefit amount was on the Notice of Computation EDD sent after my claim was approved, and it covered a decent chunk of my income while I was out six weeks.

0 coins

How long after you filed did the Notice of Computation come? That's the one that tells you the amount right?

0 coins

The notice showed up maybe ten days after my doctor submitted the medical certification. It tells you the potential weekly amount and the maximum for the claim. It doesn't mean you're approved, just what you'd get if you are. Actual first payment came about a week after that.

0 coins

The notice is not an approval letter, that's a thing people get confused about. I thought mine meant I was good to go but EDD still needed to process the medical cert before anything was payable.

0 coins

Something worth knowing for your situation: the CASDI deduction funds both Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave under SDI. So if you ever have a baby and want to take time to bond, or need to care for a sick family member, that same deduction also covers PFL claims. Different program, different form, no waiting period for PFL unlike DI, but same withholding on your check.

0 coins

Wait so the same deduction covers PFL too? I thought those were totally separate programs you'd pay into separately.

0 coins

Same withholding, separate programs. You file them differently and EDD handles them separately, but the CASDI line funds both. You can't get both at the same time though, they're for different situations.

0 coins

I got confused about this when I had my daughter. I was on disability for the pregnancy and then had to file a separate PFL claim for bonding after. Completely different claim ID and process even though the same CASDI was what funded both.

0 coins

Since you mentioned you just started at a warehouse job, worth flagging that a work injury is a different thing. CASDI and SDI disability covers non-work injuries and illnesses. If you got hurt on the job, that's workers' comp territory, not SDI. EDD itself says it's not common to get both at the same time. So if something happened at work, talk to your employer about their workers' comp carrier, not EDD.

0 coins

Good to know. The overnight shift has some equipment around so I'll keep that in mind. What about if I got sick, like a serious illness that wasn't work related at all?

0 coins

A non-work illness that makes you unable to do your regular job for at least eight days is exactly what SDI disability is designed for. You'd file through SDI Online, get your doctor to submit the medical certification, and go through the normal claim process. The seven-day waiting period at the start is unpaid, then you'd start getting payments if everything checks out.

0 coins

The eight-day thing tripped me up. I thought I had to be out exactly eight days but the first seven are just the unpaid waiting period, the eighth day is when you become eligible for payment. You have to be unable to work your regular job for at least eight consecutive days to even qualify to file.

0 coins

Payment date was what I had to actually call EDD about on my own claim, which I'll get to in a second. But first, confirming what people said: CASDI on your stub is mandatory, it's not optional and your employer is following state law by withholding it. The amount on your stub might look small week to week but it's there every check and it's what makes you eligible when you need it. On my own claim I used Claimyr to get through to EDD's disability line because SDI Online was showing a payment as pending for longer than I expected. The agent pulled up my account and told me the specific payment had issued two days earlier and that I should see it on my Money Network card within a few business days.

0 coins

Appreciate you sharing that. Glad you got an answer. EDD's phone line seems impossible to get through on so knowing options exist helps.

0 coins

The agent was clear about the date it issued and I was able to confirm it landed on the card right on schedule after that. Just needed someone to look at the actual claim.

0 coins

The Money Network card thing is new to me, I had been expecting some kind of Bank of America card from stuff I read online. EDD's debit card is Money Network now, not BofA, so if you're waiting on a card that's the one to look for.

0 coins

To bring it back to your original question since there's been a lot of good info here: CASDI mandatory status means every covered California employee pays in, no exceptions for the individual worker. You can't negotiate it, skip it or reduce it. The good news is that means you're covered from day one of contributing wages, and the SDI program is there if you ever need to file. The process is all online through SDI Online which you get to through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and your doctor handles the medical certification on their end once you file Part A.

0 coins

Really helpful, thank you. So if something happened tomorrow I'd go to myEDD and file Part A, then give my doctor the receipt number to do their part?

0 coins

Exactly that. File your Claimant's Statement in SDI Online, save the receipt number, give it to your doctor or their office, and they go into SDI Online on the provider side and submit the medical certification using that number to match it to your claim. EDD then contacts you about the status, usually within about 14 days after they have both parts.

0 coins

Worth noting you have to wait nine days after the disability starts to file, and you have to do it within 49 days of when it started or you can get disqualified. I nearly missed that window when I was out sick and nobody told me.

0 coins

My coworker thought the CASDI on her check was for unemployment insurance and was confused when she tried to file unemployment and they said she hadn't contributed to that separately. For the record: CASDI is for SDI disability and PFL, not unemployment. Unemployment has its own separate situation with the employer. They're funded differently.

0 coins

I made the same mistake when I first got laid off. Spent like an hour trying to figure out why my SDI wasn't covering my unemployment period.

0 coins

You can't get unemployment and disability for the same days either. If you're still unable to work, you're on disability. When you're recovered and able and available for work again, then you can file for unemployment. EDD handles both but they're separate.

0 coins

And unemployment requires being able and available to work every week you claim it, so if you're genuinely still out with an illness or recovery you wouldn't qualify for unemployment anyway during that time.

0 coins

Coming from someone who had to deal with a Notice of Determination after my first claim got denied: make sure your doctor submits the medical certification within 49 days of when your disability starts. Mine submitted it on day 51 and EDD issued a denial. I appealed using the DE 1000A form that came with the notice, within the 30 days on the notice. While I was waiting to hear on the appeal I needed to know what EDD had on file for my claim dates, and I used Claimyr to get in touch with an EDD disability agent. The agent told me exactly what date EDD had as my disability start and what date the cert had come in, which helped me understand what the appeal needed to address.

0 coins

How did the appeal go if you can share?

0 coins

Still pending but the agent's information helped me write a much better explanation for the appeal than I would have had otherwise. The notice says 30 days from the date on it, not 30 days from when you receive it, so read it carefully.

0 coins

The 30 days running from the notice date not the receipt date is something a lot of people miss. If the notice sat in your mail for a week before you opened it, your window is already shorter than it looks.

0 coins

DE 2593 caught me completely off guard about five months into my claim. EDD sent it after what I found out were my fifth automatic payments, ten weeks into the claim, asking if I was still unable to work. The form said I had 20 days to return it. I didn't see it right away because my mail piles up when I'm not feeling well. I called EDD to ask if my benefits would stop and ended up getting through to an agent through Claimyr because I'd had no luck on my own. The agent confirmed the DE 2593 was in my file and told me what deadline date was on it, which turned out I still had four days left to return it.

0 coins

That's really close. What happened after you returned it in time?

0 coins

Payments continued without interruption. If I hadn't gotten through to find out the actual deadline I probably would have just assumed I was out of time and panicked.

0 coins

The DE 2593 is easy to miss if you're unwell and not checking mail carefully. EDD sends it and if it doesn't get returned in time the payments stop. Setting a reminder to check mail more often once you're past the two-month mark of a claim is worth doing.

0 coins

There's also the DE 2500A for people not on automatic payment, that one comes every two weeks. The DE 2593 is specifically for the automatic payment track after ten weeks. Different forms, different schedules, worth knowing which one applies to your claim.

0 coins

Automatic deduction, no choice, no opt-out, that pretty much sums up CASDI for California employees. I'd add that because it's taken automatically your employer is also required to report your wages to EDD, which is part of how EDD calculates your base period when you file. You don't have to prove your earnings yourself in most cases because that's already in EDD's system from the reporting.

0 coins

Oh that's good to know. So I don't have to submit my own pay stubs or anything?

0 coins

Typically the wage data is already there from employer reporting. Sometimes EDD asks for verification but it's not the standard first step. Your Notice of Computation will show which quarter they used and the amount for the base period.

0 coins

If the amount on the notice looks wrong compared to what you actually earned, that's the time to contact EDD. Errors in employer reporting do happen and it affects your benefit amount, so check the notice carefully when it arrives.

0 coins

Eight months into a job is when I finally needed mine and I was grateful I hadn't tried to opt out even if I'd had the option. Filed for a surgery I'd been putting off, got the Notice of Computation within about two weeks, first payment not long after. The whole thing was smoother than I expected. The only wrinkle was my surgeon's office being slow about the medical certification but EDD followed up and they got it in.

0 coins

How slow did the office take? Mine is known for being backed up and I'm planning a procedure soon.

0 coins

About nine days after I filed my Part A before they submitted it. The key was I gave them the receipt number right away and followed up with them directly when I hadn't heard anything from EDD. The office just needed a nudge.

0 coins

Doctor's offices often don't know that the claimant's receipt number is how the system matches the two parts of the claim. Telling them specifically to use that number when they file the cert on the provider side of SDI Online is worth saying out loud to whoever you talk to there.

0 coins

Quick note on something I see people get confused about: the seven-day waiting period is not EDD processing time. It's an actual unpaid waiting period that's part of every new DI claim. You don't get paid for those first seven days, period. The eighth day is the first day you can be paid for. Processing time on top of that is a separate thing. I see a lot of people think they're waiting on payment when actually they're still in the waiting period.

0 coins

So the seven days runs from when disability starts, not from when I file or when the cert comes in?

0 coins

From when the disability starts. EDD bases it on the disability start date on your claim, not on when you filed or when the certification came in.

0 coins

This is actually the thing that confused me most on my first claim. I thought I was two weeks in and EDD was slow, but I was actually still in the waiting period for half of that time. The math makes more sense once you understand what the seven days is actually counting.

0 coins

Since you're new to California payroll, also note that SDI does not cover you if you're injured on the job. Warehouse work has that risk. Workers' comp is what covers on-the-job injuries and your employer is required to carry it. SDI is for everything else: illness, off-work injury, pregnancy, surgery for a non-work condition. The two programs exist in parallel and EDD itself says it's unusual for both to apply at once.

0 coins

Makes sense to know the difference. I'll ask HR about the workers' comp carrier too just to have that info on hand.

0 coins

Smart move to ask before you need it. HR might not volunteer it but they're required to have that information available.

0 coins

Extending a claim is something that's also worth knowing about since you're learning the system. If your disability lasts longer than your doctor originally certified, you don't start a new claim. Your doctor submits a Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate, the DE 2525XX. EDD typically sends that form out with the notice for your final payment so your doctor knows to look for it if more time is needed.

0 coins

Good to know. So the extension comes from the doctor's end, not from me filing again?

0 coins

Exactly, you don't do anything new on your end except maybe remind your doctor's office to look for the DE 2525XX form or submit it through SDI Online. The connection to your existing claim stays the same.

0 coins

I got confused about this when my recovery ran long and I went to myEDD thinking I had to start over. The existing claim just gets extended through the doctor's submission. No new claim ID, no new waiting period either.

0 coins

Final thing worth mentioning since your original question was about whether CASDI was mandatory at all: yes, and there's no employer workaround either. If an employer is trying to avoid withholding it for covered employees, that's on them and not something you need to worry about from your side. Your wages subject to SDI are covered regardless. If you ever filed a claim and EDD somehow didn't have your wages on file because an employer wasn't reporting properly, that's between you and EDD to sort out, but it's the employer's error, not yours.

0 coins

Okay so I'm protected either way basically, that's reassuring.

0 coins

In terms of your entitlement to file, yes. EDD will work off whatever wage data they have. If there's a discrepancy you'd find out through the Notice of Computation and could raise it then.

0 coins

Employer payroll errors affecting base period wages are rare but they do happen. The notice showing your base period wages is the place to catch it.

0 coins

To wrap this thread up with a direct answer since it got long: CASDI mandatory, yes, full stop, all covered California employees pay it, your employer deducts it automatically, you're covered. File through SDI Online when you need it, give your doctor the receipt number for the medical certification, and EDD takes it from there. The seven-day wait applies, the Notice of Computation tells you your potential amount, and payments usually start within two weeks of EDD having a completed claim.

0 coins

Really appreciate all this. Went from having no idea what that line on my paycheck was to actually understanding how the whole thing works if I need it.

0 coins

That's honestly the best outcome from a thread like this. Most people only look it up when they're already in a panic needing to file, so knowing the basics beforehand puts you in a much better position.

0 coins

Bookmarking this for my own reference because even having used SDI I didn't know all the details about the DE 2593 and extensions. Good thread.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure