Independent medical evaluation Orinda — does it affect my California EDD SDI claim?
So I'm dealing with something kind of layered and trying to figure out how it all fits with my California EDD disability claim. I work at an architecture firm in the East Bay and I've been out since mid-October after a pretty serious back issue that required surgery. Filed my SDI claim through SDI Online and everything went through fine — my surgeon's office submitted the medical certification, I got my Notice of Computation, payments started. But now my employer's insurance carrier is scheduling an independent medical evaluation through a clinic in Orinda, and I'm spiraling a little trying to understand whether that changes anything on the EDD side. The SDI claim is for my own disability, not anything work-related, so I'm not sure if the independent medical evaluation is even relevant to EDD or just to whatever the employer's insurance is doing separately. Has anyone been through something like this where you had an IME scheduled while you were also collecting California EDD disability? Did EDD ever ask about it or did the two just run on totally separate tracks?
84 comments

Kiara Fisherman
Waiting period confusion nearly cost me on my own claim, so I'll share what I found out when I phoned EDD directly. The seven days at the start of a DI claim are a non-payable waiting period — not processing time, not a delay, just seven days that never get paid no matter what. I was counting those days as part of the hold-up and kept thinking something was wrong. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an agent after the hold music cut me off twice at the 1-800-480-3287 line, and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed exactly which week the waiting period covered and when my first payable day was. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. On the IME question — EDD's disability side and an employer's insurance carrier are separate tracks. EDD pays DI because your own doctor certified you can't do your regular work; an independent medical evaluation arranged by another carrier doesn't feed into that certification or override it at EDD.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorThis distinction between the two tracks is exactly what I needed. I was afraid the IME report would somehow get sent to EDD and trigger a review or something.
0 coins
Liam Cortez
Payable day eight was a surprise to me too when my claim started. My office manager had told me I'd see a payment after a week and then I was confused why nothing showed for the first several days.
0 coins
Savannah Vin
Employer carrier IMEs and EDD are completely separate. EDD doesn't receive reports from a private carrier and doesn't ask about them on the claim forms.
0 coins
Mason Stone
49 days is the number that matters for the medical certification deadline and I almost missed it stressing about other things. The form receipt number you get after filing Part A is what your doctor's office uses to find the claim in SDI Online. Without that number they can't match the certification to your claim. Did you give that number to your surgeon's office before they submitted?
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorYes, I passed the receipt number to the office when I filed. They confirmed it went in through SDI Online. My Notice of Computation showed up a few days after that.
0 coins
Makayla Shoemaker
Receipt number matching is the thing that hung up my claim for two weeks. The front desk submitted under a slightly different spelling and EDD couldn't match it.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
49 days sounds like a long time until you're recovering from surgery and suddenly it's day 44 and you haven't heard anything.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
Workers' comp and SDI get confused a lot and it's worth being precise here. If the surgery and the back issue are from a work injury, that's workers' comp territory, not DI. EDD says it's not common to get both workers' comp and state disability at the same time. If this is a non-work-related condition, DI is the right program. The fact that an employer's insurance carrier is scheduling an IME makes me wonder which situation this is — but only you and your doctor know the answer to that.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorDefinitely non-work-related. The back issue started well before this job and is unrelated to anything at the firm. The carrier running the IME is a separate long-term disability policy through the firm's benefits, not workers' comp.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
Long-term disability through an employer plan is a whole separate thing from SDI. They often run alongside each other, but EDD doesn't coordinate with a private LTD carrier as far as the certification process goes.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
Good clarification. A lot of people assume SDI and an employer's LTD plan are the same program and then get surprised when they have to interact with both separately.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
Has your claim been showing anything unusual in SDI Online since the IME was scheduled? Like did anything change on the status screen or were any new forms issued?
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorNothing has changed on SDI Online. Still shows the same active status it had before. No new forms, no letters from EDD. That's partly what made me think EDD might not even know about the IME at all.
0 coins
Anita George
EDD wouldn't know about it unless you told them. The IME is arranged by the other carrier, not by EDD, so it doesn't create any event in your SDI claim.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
Active status with no new forms sounds like things are running normally on the EDD side. The IME is just your employer's carrier doing their own review.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
My claim at the architecture firm I used to work at — wait no, different industry — but anyway, I had an IME scheduled by a private insurer while I was out and I just showed up, did it, and kept certifying through SDI the whole time. EDD never asked about it and my payments continued without interruption. The two processes just ran in parallel.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorParallel tracks — that's reassuring. Did you do anything to document that the IME was for the private carrier and not for EDD, just in case?
0 coins
Logan Chiang
Honestly no, I didn't document anything special. The IME report went to the private carrier and nothing was ever forwarded to EDD that I know of.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
There's no paperwork you send to EDD about an IME arranged by another party. EDD's claim stands on the certification from your own licensed health professional.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
What kind of doctor performs the independent medical evaluation in a case like this — does it have to be someone in a specific specialty, and does EDD care who it is?
0 coins
Mason Stone
EDD doesn't care who performs the IME at all because EDD isn't the one ordering it. For EDD's purposes, the only certification that matters is the one submitted by your own treating provider — your surgeon in this case.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
The list of who can certify a DI claim for EDD is specific — physicians, osteopathic doctors, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors and a few others within their scope. The IME doctor arranged by the private carrier is irrelevant to that list since they're certifying for a different purpose.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
Makes sense. So for EDD the certification is entirely between the claimant and their own treating provider, not whoever the carrier picks.
0 coins
Micah Franklin
DE 2593 showed up in my mailbox while I was dealing with my own claim after surgery and I nearly missed the 20-day window to return it. It's the continued eligibility questionnaire EDD sends after the first ten weeks on automatic payment. If you're on automatic payment, watch for it — not returning it on time can interrupt your benefits even if your medical certification is fully in order.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorMine started in October so I'm probably not at ten weeks yet, but flagging this for when I get there. Is there a way to submit it electronically?
0 coins
Micah Franklin
EDD sends the DE 2593 by mail and you return it the same way. It asks whether you're still unable to work, so keep an eye on the mailbox around that ten-week mark.
0 coins
Ella Harper
The DE 2593 caught me right when I was juggling a PT schedule and I almost forgot about it entirely. Setting a calendar alert around week eight so it's not a surprise is worth doing.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Base period question that took me a while to figure out — the weekly benefit amount on the Notice of Computation is estimated from wages in a 12-month base period that ends a few quarters before the claim starts, not the most recent pay. I was looking at my current salary and wondering why the number on the notice looked different. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the line about which specific quarter of my base period EDD had used, because the SDI Online message tool wasn't giving me a straight answer. The agent told me which quarter had the highest wages and confirmed that matched what was on my Notice of Computation. If the amount on your notice seems off, the benefit calculator on EDD's site can help you estimate it before you call.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorSalary changed between the base period and now, which probably explains part of what I'm seeing on my Notice of Computation. Good to know there's a calculator on EDD's site to cross-check it.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
The base period timing surprises almost everyone on their first claim. Using a quarter from roughly five to eighteen months before the start date means a recent raise or a slow quarter earlier in the year can both shift the number.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
EDD's calculator on their site gives a pretty close estimate. It won't match to the cent but it's close enough to know if something looks wrong.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
Something I want to flag about extensions — if your surgeon determines you need more time off after your current certification period ends, EDD sends a notification with the final payment that includes the form for your physician to submit the extension. It's the DE 2525XX. You don't file a new claim. The physician submits the supplementary certificate, and EDD picks up from there.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorGood to know about the DE 2525XX. My surgeon mentioned there might be additional recovery time depending on how rehab goes, so this is useful.
0 coins
Liam Cortez
My extension went smoothly once the office submitted the DE 2525XX. The key is making sure the physician's office knows to submit it through SDI Online promptly after the final payment notification.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
DE 2525XX timing matters — the physician needs to submit it before or right around the time benefits end, not weeks later, to avoid a gap.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
Has anyone had an employer's insurance carrier try to coordinate with EDD directly? Like, could the Orinda clinic send their IME report to EDD without the claimant knowing?
0 coins
Savannah Vin
EDD doesn't accept IME reports from private carriers or employer insurance companies. The SDI claim is based solely on the medical certification submitted through SDI Online by the treating provider.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
Private carriers have no mechanism to submit anything into SDI Online. It's a closed system for the claimant and their licensed health professional, not for third-party insurers.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
That's clarifying. I'd assumed there might be some coordination channel between private carriers and EDD, but it sounds like there genuinely isn't.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
Went through surgery recovery and an employer LTD review simultaneously last year. The LTD carrier sent me to their own evaluating physician, I complied with their process, and kept my EDD SDI claim going in parallel with my own surgeon's certifications. The two programs asked for completely different things and nobody from EDD ever called or wrote about the LTD carrier's process.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorKnowing someone ran both simultaneously without EDD stepping in is exactly what I needed to hear. What did you do when the LTD carrier's conclusion was different from your surgeon's?
0 coins
Sophie Duck
The LTD carrier reduced my private benefit for a period based on their evaluation, but EDD's payments continued based on my surgeon's certification. The two ran on separate rules.
0 coins
Makayla Shoemaker
That's how it works — different programs, different standards, different processes. What one carrier decides has no bearing on what EDD does with the SDI claim.
0 coins
Anita George
Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me talking to an EDD agent when I had a question about how my payment method was set up after my direct deposit didn't go through the second week. The agent confirmed the payment had been issued and walked me through switching to direct deposit properly through SDI Online so the next one landed in the right account.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorPayment method is something I've been meaning to double-check too. I set up direct deposit when I filed but never confirmed it took on the EDD side.
0 coins
Anita George
SDI Online shows the payment method on the claim. It's worth looking there first — if it shows direct deposit with the right account information, you're set.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
Direct deposit through SDI Online works well once it's confirmed active. If EDD shows the account as verified, the payment should land within a couple of business days of issuance.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
Medical certification timing on my own claim had me nervous for the full first week. Waiting for the agent via Claimyr to get the detail I needed — the agent confirmed the certification from my provider had been received by EDD and was matched to my claim, so the pending status I was seeing was just normal processing. Knowing that specific thing was matched helped me stop checking SDI Online every hour.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorMine was confirmed matched early on, so I'm not worried on that front. It's really just the IME question that had me uncertain about the EDD side.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
Pending after the certification is matched just means EDD is reviewing the claim. It doesn't mean anything is wrong, and it typically resolves within two weeks of a completed submission.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
Two weeks from a fully completed submission is the general window. If it goes past that, the SDI Online message tool or the disability line is the right next step.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
Timing question — when did EDD actually contact you after the medical certification came in? The 'usually within 14 days' on the EDD site is vague, and my own experience was that the Notice of Computation showed up before I even got a letter acknowledging the certification.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorFor me the Notice of Computation appeared in SDI Online first, before anything came by mail. By the time the paper copy arrived I'd already reviewed it online.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
The Notice of Computation isn't an approval — it sets out the potential weekly and maximum benefit amount based on the base period wages. Some people read it as an approval letter, but it isn't.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
Right, I learned that the hard way when I told my landlord the claim was 'approved' based on the Notice of Computation and then had to explain a few days later that it was still pending.
0 coins
Liam Cortez
Pregnancy leave SDI question that might be off-topic but is related — does an IME arranged by an employer affect a pregnancy-related SDI claim the same way? Like, can a carrier-ordered evaluation somehow challenge a midwife's certification for a pregnancy claim?
0 coins
Mason Stone
EDD's pregnancy DI claims work the same way structurally. The certification comes from the licensed provider — a midwife, nurse practitioner, or physician depending on the situation — and a private carrier's evaluation has no standing in that SDI process.
0 coins
Liam Cortez
Makes sense that the structure is the same. I was wondering if pregnancy claims had a different review path at EDD but it sounds like the certification process is consistent.
0 coins
Savannah Vin
Bonding after the pregnancy disability ends is Paid Family Leave, which is a separate claim entirely. Worth filing for that separately at the right time, since PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way DI does.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
Appeal rights are worth knowing about even when things are going well. If EDD ever issues a Notice of Determination on the claim — which would happen if something became not payable — there's an appeal form included and the deadline is 30 days from the date on the notice. Keeping that date in mind matters because a late appeal needs extra justification for the delay.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorNo Notice of Determination so far, just the Notice of Computation and regular payment activity. But knowing the 30-day appeal window in case something changes is useful.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
30 days goes faster than you'd think when you're recovering from surgery and trying to manage everything else at the same time. Reading any notice EDD sends the day it arrives is good practice.
0 coins
Ruby Blake
The appeal form is the DE 1000A and it comes with the Notice of Determination. If the form is lost, a detailed letter sent to the return address on the notice works as an appeal too.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
Unemployment and SDI sometimes get confused in these situations — specifically, can someone collect unemployment while their DI claim is active if the employer ends the job during the leave?
0 coins
Emma Olsen
The two programs can't cover the same days. DI is for days when someone can't work because of their own disability. Unemployment requires being able to work and available for work every week claimed. While still unable to work, DI is the right program. When ready to work again, filing for unemployment at that point is an option.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
So the sequence matters — not simultaneously, but potentially one after the other depending on what happens with the job. EDD decides each claim separately.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
There's a lot of uncertainty in that situation and I'd say asking EDD directly how the specifics of a given case work out is smarter than relying on what people online assume.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
SDI Online message tool — has anyone actually gotten a useful answer through it on a pending claim? Every time I've tried I get a form response that says the claim is under review.
0 coins
Anita George
The message tool is inconsistent. For anything where you need an actual answer tied to your specific claim, calling 1-800-480-3287 and reaching a person is more reliable.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
I've had decent luck with the message tool for simple factual questions, like confirming the payment method on the claim. For anything nuanced it doesn't really help.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Figures. The hold times on the phone line are brutal but it sounds like the phone is still the most reliable path for getting a real answer.
0 coins
Makayla Shoemaker
Quick note on who can certify — a physical therapist cannot certify a DI claim for EDD. I made that mistake early on when my PT offered to fill something out. EDD's list is specific: licensed physicians, osteopathic doctors, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, midwives, nurse-midwives, and authorized medical officers at US government facilities, each within their scope. For a back surgery situation, your orthopedic surgeon is exactly the right certifier.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
AuthorMy surgeon handled the certification so I'm good there. I had no idea a PT couldn't certify — that's the kind of thing that would cause a claim to stall badly.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
The PT limitation surprised me too. I had assumed anyone clinical could certify but the EDD list is narrower than that.
0 coins
Liam Cortez
For anyone reading this whose PT already submitted something — go to your treating physician to do the certification through SDI Online. The PT submission won't count.
0 coins
Savannah Vin
How long is the DI claim for a back surgery situation typically — is there a standard number of weeks EDD expects before questioning the ongoing disability?
0 coins
Ruby Blake
EDD doesn't set a standard number of weeks for a given condition. The physician certifies what they determine and EDD goes from there. The maximum on a single DI claim is 52 weeks. What matters is what the treating provider puts in the certification.
0 coins
Mason Stone
For ongoing disability beyond the initial certification period, the DE 2525XX extension is what keeps the claim active. The physician determines the extended period and submits through SDI Online.
0 coins
Savannah Vin
52 weeks is a longer window than I expected. I'd assumed EDD would have condition-specific limits built in somewhere.
0 coins
Owen Devar
Does attending the independent medical evaluation in Orinda count as being able to work? Like, would going to that appointment affect EDD's determination of ongoing disability?
0 coins
Emma Olsen
Attending a medical evaluation arranged by an insurance carrier is not the same as being able to do your regular or customary work. EDD's disability determination is based on whether you can perform your usual job duties, not on whether you can attend a medical appointment.
0 coins
Owen Devar
That framing helps — the standard is about regular job duties, not about mobility generally. So driving to an appointment wouldn't be read as evidence of being able to return to the architecture firm.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
Your surgeon's ongoing certification is what EDD relies on. If the surgeon is still certifying you as unable to work your regular job, attending an IME doesn't create a conflict on the EDD side.
0 coins