Back to California Disability

Miguel Harvey

How to tell if SDI claim was denied from notice — what to look for

So I finally got something in the mail from EDD after weeks of waiting and I genuinely don't know if it's good news or bad news. It's a couple of pages and there's a lot of text. I filed my SDI claim about three weeks ago after my doctor took me off work for a back issue, and the medical certification went in maybe five days after I filed. I thought no news was good news but then this envelope showed up and now I'm kind of panicking. Is there a specific form number I should be looking for? Does a denial come as a separate letter or is it on the same notice as the payment info? I don't even know what an approval looks like so I have no idea how to compare. Any help would be really appreciated.

Check the top right corner of the pages for a form number. If what you received is the Notice of Computation, that's the DE 429D, and it shows your potential weekly benefit amount. It doesn't mean you're approved yet, but it isn't a denial either. A denial comes on a different form called the Notice of Determination, and that one is the DE 2517. It will say specifically that your claim is not payable and it comes with an appeal form attached.

0 coins

The form number in the corner says DE 429D. So that's the computation notice? Does that mean I'm still waiting to hear if I'm actually getting paid?

0 coins

Exactly right. The DE 429D just tells you what your weekly amount would be if the claim is approved. Keep an eye on SDI Online and your mail for any DE 2517. If you don't get one and payments start, you're good.

0 coins

Got the same notice last month and was confused too. Payments started the next week without any other letter coming.

0 coins

DE 2517 is the denial. Plain and simple. It says not payable right on it and there's a form stuck to the bottom you use to appeal. Don't ignore it if you get one, there's a deadline on there.

0 coins

How fast do you have to appeal if you get the DE 2517?

0 coins

30 days from the date printed on the notice. Not 30 days from when you got it. Date on the notice is what counts.

0 coins

Wait so if the mail was slow and I got it late that could already cut into my time? That's kind of terrifying honestly.

0 coins

If the delay ate into your window, you can still file the appeal and explain why it was late. An administrative law judge looks at the reason. File it anyway and attach a note about when you actually received it.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my stack at the five-payment mark and I almost missed the 20-day window because I didn't know what it was. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to figure out where my claim stood. The agent confirmed the form had been received and that my automatic payments were still running. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The five-payment detail is exactly what I needed to see. Had the same situation and used Claimyr too. Once the agent confirmed my DE 2525XX extension was in the system, I went back to SDI Online and the pending weeks cleared out within a few days.

0 coins

How many mornings did you spend trying that line before you got through? I've hit the busy signal before 8 and gotten the disconnect recording after noon. There's no winning.

0 coins

Tried for eight straight mornings and got nowhere, which is why I went a different route. Still had the same complaint as you but at least got my answer.

0 coins

that 20 day window for the de 2593 is brutal if you dont check your mail every day

0 coins

Worth clarifying something about the DE 2517 and what actually triggers one. EDD issues it when they determine the claim isn't payable, which can happen for a few different reasons, not just a missing medical certification. Could be a base period earnings issue, could be that the certifying provider wasn't on EDD's approved list, or something else entirely. The notice itself will say the reason, so read that part carefully before deciding how to frame your appeal.

0 coins

What counts as an approved provider? My doctor is an MD so I figured that was fine.

0 coins

An MD is fine. The list includes licensed physicians, osteopaths, chiropractors, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, licensed midwives and certain government facility medical officers. Where people run into trouble is if someone like a physical therapist tries to certify, because they're not on EDD's list.

0 coins

Didn't know physical therapists weren't on the list. My PT mentioned she could fill out the forms and I almost let her, glad I didn't anyway.

0 coins

The appeal form that comes attached to the DE 2517 is called the DE 1000A. If you've already lost the form somehow, you can still write a detailed letter and mail it to the return address on the notice. The letter just needs to explain clearly why you disagree. Either way, 30 days from the notice date is your window.

0 coins

And the appeal goes to whatever address is on the back of the DE 2517, not to some general EDD address?

0 coins

Right, the return address printed on that specific notice. EDD's general address isn't where claim forms and appeals go.

0 coins

Mailed mine to the wrong address once. Had to refile and lost a week of my window. Use the address on the notice.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD picks up anyway so half the time you don't even know what's pending, what's denied, what's just sitting there. I've called at 8:01 three mornings in a row and get a recording telling me call volume is too high.

0 coins

Same. I stopped trying before 9 and started trying at random afternoon times. Didn't help much.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is its own puzzle. No solution, just persistence.

0 coins

been trying for two weeks. nothing.

0 coins

For anyone confused about the payment side, the Notice of Computation isn't a guarantee of payment but it does tell you the weekly amount EDD calculated from your highest-earning base period quarter. If that number looks wrong, that's worth flagging before the claim goes further, not after payments start.

0 coins

Mine showed an amount that seemed lower than I expected. Is there a way to check whether the right quarter was used?

0 coins

EDD's disability benefits calculator is on their site and you can run your own wages through it. If your Notice of Computation doesn't match what the calculator shows, that's a reason to contact EDD and ask which quarter they used.

0 coins

The base period covers the 12 months ending about five months before your claim starts. If you recently had a big raise or a high-earning quarter, it might have fallen outside the window EDD used.

0 coins

I think I'm confusing the waiting period with EDD just not having made a decision yet. Is the first week always unpaid no matter what, even if everything is approved?

0 coins

Yes, the first seven days of any new DI claim are always unpaid. That's not a processing delay or anything being reviewed, it's just how the program works. The first day you can actually receive benefits is day eight.

0 coins

So even if my doctor certified right away and EDD approves everything quickly, that first week I'll never see money for?

0 coins

Correct. Every new claim has that seven-day period that's simply not payable. It isn't something you can waive or appeal.

0 coins

yeah that one stings when youre already stressed about money

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD issue a denial but then approve on appeal? I got a DE 2517 last month and filed my appeal right away but I have no idea what the odds are or how long it takes.

0 coins

Appeals go to an administrative law judge. What you'll want to bring is whatever documentation supports why the denial reason was wrong. Pay stubs, the medical certification, any correspondence with your provider's office. The strength of the appeal depends on what the denial reason actually was.

0 coins

The reason on mine had to do with the medical certification, something about the provider not matching the claim. My doctor's office said they submitted it.

0 coins

Ask your doctor's office which receipt number they used when they filed in SDI Online. It has to match the one you got when you submitted your part of the claim. A mismatch can cause exactly that kind of problem.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came through on my injury claim and I genuinely could not parse the denial reason from the letter alone. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD disability agent and she walked me through exactly what the DE 2517 said about my claim status.

0 coins

An actual live person picked up? I've been trying that line for three weeks and every morning it kicks me after the first menu. I honestly have a hard time believing that's even possible anymore, the line is so bad.

0 coins

Spent two weeks the same way before I tried a different approach. The agent I talked to was definitely EDD, she had my claim pulled up and read back the specific denial code.

0 coins

Had a similar experience on my own claim. Once the agent answered, I asked whether the payment method on file was set to direct deposit. She confirmed it was and told me to expect a notice once a decision came through.

0 coins

Good to know the agent could actually explain the DE 2517 language. That letter reads like a form letter for a reason nobody told you.

0 coins

30 days sounds like plenty of time until you realize you spent two weeks assuming the notice was junk mail.

0 coins

This. It sat on my counter for 10 days before I actually opened it. Kids everywhere, anyway.

0 coins

opened mine the same day but still waited a week to do anything about it. wish i hadnt.

0 coins

Open EDD mail the day it arrives. That's the one rule that actually matters.

0 coins

If the claim isn't payable but you haven't gotten a DE 2517, it's also possible the claim is still pending rather than denied. Pending just means EDD hasn't made a decision. A denial is a formal determination, and EDD has to send you that notice before it's official.

0 coins

Mine still says pending in SDI Online. So no news isn't the same as a denial?

0 coins

Pending means they haven't decided. Denied means they decided and sent the DE 2517. Two different things.

0 coins

Pending drove me crazy for two weeks and then payments just showed up. Hang in there.

0 coins

My claim kept showing pending for almost three weeks and I had no idea if the medical certification had even matched to my claim properly. I went through Claimyr to reach someone on the disability line and the agent looked up my receipt number and told me the certification was sitting unmatched because the number my provider used had a digit off.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, and when an actual EDD person picks up it rings your phone. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

Interesting. My situation is an open question about which quarter of the base period EDD used for my benefit calculation. That's worth a call.

0 coins

receipt number digit off is such a small thing to cause that much headache

0 coins

Appeal deadline question. If the notice date is a Sunday, does the 30 days start that day or the next business day? Filing mine now just in case but want to know.

0 coins

File it right now regardless. Don't try to calculate the edge of the window. The earlier the better, and a detailed explanation of your disagreement with the denial reason matters more than the exact day.

0 coins

Already dropped it in the mail this morning anyway.

0 coins

Right call.

0 coins

wait so the de 2517 is always a denial and the de 429d is always the computation notice? i thought they were different versions of the same thing

0 coins

They're two completely separate notices. The DE 429D is about your potential weekly benefit amount and comes before any determination. The DE 2517 is a formal decision that the claim isn't payable. Very different documents with different purposes.

0 coins

ok that makes way more sense. i got the 429d and thought it was bad news when it wasnt

0 coins

Confused me too the first time.

0 coins

Filing the appeal and including your medical records or a letter from your provider is a good move if the denial was related to the medical certification or your condition. Keep it factual and specific to the reason on the DE 2517.

0 coins

Should I contact my doctor before mailing the appeal or just send what I have?

0 coins

Contact the provider first. If the denial was about the certification, you want them to confirm what they submitted and when. That information strengthens the appeal.

0 coins

Ask the office to give you a copy of exactly what they filed in SDI Online. Having that in hand before you write the appeal helps.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim showed in SDI Online but the amount never landed in my account on that date. Spent three mornings trying the EDD line and each time got cut off mid-menu. Tried Claimyr and got an agent. She pulled up the claim and told me the payment had been issued on the 14th and to allow a few business days for the Money Network card to reflect it.

0 coins

Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr on my own claim and I'm honestly grateful. The agent checked my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file was one day off from what I had on my form, which explained why my first week wasn't calculating right.

0 coins

One day off made that big of a difference?

0 coins

Apparently yes, it shifted the whole waiting period window. The agent said to watch for a corrected notice in the mail.

0 coins

the money network card threw me off too. thought my payment was lost.

0 coins

Update from me. Checked the mail again today and there's no DE 2517 anywhere. SDI Online still shows pending but I think based on everything here I'm just waiting on a decision rather than having been denied without knowing it.

0 coins

Pending with the DE 429D already in hand is pretty normal. The computation notice comes first and the payments follow once EDD finishes processing the full claim.

0 coins

Keep checking SDI Online every few days. When the status changes you'll see it there before mail arrives.

0 coins

If it tips past 14 days since the medical certification went in, that's when I'd push harder to get an answer.

0 coins

Just to put a bow on the original question. The way to tell a denial from other EDD mail: look for the DE 2517 form number, look for language that says the claim or specific weeks are not payable, and look for the DE 1000A appeal form attached at the bottom. If none of those are present, what you have is not a denial.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary I've seen in this whole thread. Thank you.

0 coins

DE 2517, not payable language, DE 1000A attached. Three things to check.

0 coins

Shorter version: if it doesn't say not payable, it isn't a denial.

0 coins

Does the DE 2517 always come by mail or can it show in SDI Online too?

0 coins

EDD mails official notices including the DE 2517. Check your mail and also your SDI Online account for any updates on the claim status.

0 coins

You can also send EDD a message through SDI Online using the Request Claim Update option if you want to ask directly about a specific notice.

0 coins

Didn't know about the Request Claim Update option. Going to try that this week.

0 coins

been sitting here for 20 days with nothing but the de 429d and no de 2517 either. is that just normal waiting or should i be worried at this point

0 coins

20 days since the medical certification was submitted, or since you filed? If 20 days have passed since the certification went in, reaching out to EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update or by phone makes sense.

0 coins

since the certification went in. guess ill try the phone line again tomorrow morning.

0 coins

The line before 8 is a wall and after noon it drops you. Tried every time slot there is on a two-week stretch and got exactly one person.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure