Back to California Disability

Giovanni Marino

How to file SDI claim when patient changed doctors during treatment

So I'm in a bit of a complicated spot and I really hope someone here has dealt with this before. I had a back injury at the end of October and started seeing a spine specialist who put me out of work. I filed my SDI claim in SDI Online and gave her the receipt number so she could submit the medical certification. She got it in and I was getting payments fine for about six weeks. But then my insurance changed and I had to switch to a completely different doctor in a different practice. My new doctor is saying he's not sure how to certify the continuation of my claim since he wasn't the one who originally certified it. He said something about maybe needing to start a whole new claim? That doesn't sound right to me because I never went back to work. My condition is the same, I just have a different provider now. I don't want to lose my payments or have a gap. Has anyone switched doctors in the middle of an SDI disability claim and figured out what actually needs to happen with the medical certification side of things? Do I need to do anything on my end or is it all on the doctor?

Base period calculations tripped me up on my own claim earlier this year so I spent a lot of time trying to reach EDD about it. Couldn't get anyone to pick up for days, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. She pulled up my claim and told me my highest-paid quarter was from about 14 months before my start date, which I never would have figured out on my own just reading the Notice of Computation. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability if you haven't tried it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ On your actual question, the new doctor absolutely can certify the extension on the same claim. He doesn't start a new one. He'd submit the DE 2525XX, the supplementary certificate, to continue your existing claim. That form is what any provider uses to extend disability beyond the initial period, and it doesn't have to be the same doctor who filed the original certification.

0 coins

I used Claimyr on my own claim too and I'm glad I did! The agent told me the DE 2593 had already been mailed to my address on file and that I had 20 days from the date on it to send it back or my payments would stop. I had no idea that form was even coming.

0 coins

The 20-day return window on the DE 2593 is worth knowing. Did the agent say anything about what happens if someone is on automatic payment versus the two-week certification?

0 coins

She said I was on automatic payment, which is why the DE 2593 came after my fifth payment rather than the two-week form. That cleared up a lot of confusion for me. I went into SDI Online after the call and updated my mailing address just to be sure.

0 coins

Good to know the new doctor can use the DE 2525XX. That was my worry reading this too.

0 coins

Your new doctor's concern is understandable but the situation is more straightforward than he may think. A licensed physician can certify continuation of a disability claim even if he was not the original treating provider, as long as he can attest to your current condition and inability to work. The form your original doctor used covered the initial period. What your new doctor would submit is the DE 2525XX, which extends the same claim forward. No new claim is needed as long as there was no return to work between providers.

0 coins

So he would need to get the DE 2525XX specifically, not just some general form from EDD?

0 coins

Exactly right. The DE 2525XX is the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate. EDD typically sends it with the final payment notice, the DE 2500E, but your doctor's office may also be able to access it through SDI Online directly.

0 coins

Does the new doctor need the original claim receipt number to find it in SDI Online? I'm asking because I'm not sure if that number stays the same when a different provider looks it up.

0 coins

The claim ID stays the same throughout the life of the claim. Your new doctor would look up the claim in SDI Online using the receipt number you got when you first filed your Part A. Give him that number and it should come up.

0 coins

New doctor just needs to pick up where the old one left off. Same claim, same receipt number. I switched providers mid-claim two years ago after my original surgeon moved out of state and it went fine. Just make sure your new doc is actually on the list of providers EDD accepts for certification.

0 coins

What do you mean by EDD's accepted list? Is there a specific license type required?

0 coins

Not every type of provider can certify. It's got to be someone like a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, that kind of thing. A physical therapist can't do it, for example, even if they're treating you. Worth double checking if your new doc is in that category.

0 coins

That's actually a really useful point. I'd assumed any treating provider could certify but apparently not.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke. I called 14 times over three days trying to ask something way simpler than a doctor switch and never got through. How is anyone supposed to manage this stuff when you can't even talk to a person?

0 coins

ive been redlining for almost two weeks on that number lol doesnt matter what time i call

0 coins

Mornings are slightly less impossible. Slightly.

0 coins

I tried 8am sharp on two different days. Same result both times.

0 coins

Tell your new doctor he is not starting anything new. He is picking up an existing claim. The key thing is that there's no gap where you went back to work. If you stayed out the whole time, it's one continuous disability period and the certification just continues.

0 coins

There was no gap at all. I went straight from one doctor to the other without going back to work even a single day.

0 coins

Then you're in good shape. Continuous disability, same claim. Your new doctor does the DE 2525XX and the payments should keep moving.

0 coins

This is exactly the kind of answer I needed to find for my own situation, switching providers next month anyway.

0 coins

Worth pointing out where this is documented: EDD's SDI Online system lets any licensed provider submit a certification or extension for a claim, not just the original one. The DE 2525XX is the form for extensions and continuations. It's listed on EDD's site under the certify or extend claims section. Your new doctor's office may not have dealt with an SDI continuation before but it's a standard form in the system.

0 coins

Does the new doctor need to review the original certification before he can file the DE 2525XX, or can he go straight to submitting based on his own current exam?

0 coins

He certifies based on his own examination and his own assessment of your current condition. He doesn't need the original certification in front of him. He just needs to be able to attest that you're still unable to perform your regular work.

0 coins

That actually makes me feel a lot better. I was worried he'd refuse because he didn't know my baseline from before.

0 coins

Payment method was the thing I had to get sorted on my claim. I'd set up direct deposit when I filed but then changed bank accounts and had no idea if the payments would bounce. Called EDD through Claimyr and talked to a rep who confirmed my old account was still on file and walked me through how to update it in SDI Online before the next payment processed. Saved me a real headache.

0 coins

Something about this reads like a sponsored post. A service that gets you through to EDD when the line is impossible to reach sounds like marketing copy to me.

0 coins

I thought the same thing honestly when I first saw it mentioned somewhere. But I was stuck trying to ask about my DE 2525XX because my doctor submitted it and nothing updated in SDI Online for over a week. Got on with an agent who confirmed EDD had received the form and that the extension was processing. So it checked out for me, real EDD agent and everything.

0 coins

Fair enough. I've been leaving messages through Ask EDD for a week with no response so maybe I'll try it on the payment method question I've got.

0 coins

The rep I spoke with confirmed the update went through same day, so definitely worth it if you have something specific to sort out.

0 coins

your new doc just needs to certify you're still unable to work. thats it. same claim.

0 coins

Is that all he has to submit, just that he confirms inability to work, or does he need to give a whole new diagnosis history?

0 coins

he fills out what hes asked on the form. he cant do it without examining you himself but it doesnt require your whole history from the other doctor.

0 coins

Agree with this. The form asks about the current period of disability, not the whole story from day one.

0 coins

my coworker had this happen and his new doc just submitted the form and it was fine. no new claim or anything. they were back on payments within like two weeks

0 coins

Two weeks sounds about right if everything goes in clean.

0 coins

yeah his was pretty smooth. the only thing he said was make sure the new doc actually knows how to use SDI Online because apparently some offices dont

0 coins

Action items for your end: get your receipt number to the new doctor, confirm he can access SDI Online, and ask his office to submit the DE 2525XX promptly. EDD typically contacts you within 14 days of receiving a completed certification. If payments stop before that, file a Request Claim Update through SDI Online so there's a record.

0 coins

Where do I find the Request Claim Update option? Is it inside the same SDI Online dashboard where I check payment status?

0 coins

In myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/, open SDI Online, find your claim ID, then look for the Request Claim Update option. Choose the category that fits your question and write in the details.

0 coins

Bookmarking this for my own switch situation coming up anyway.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update is underused. A lot of people just keep calling and never send anything in writing.

0 coins

Medical certification matching is what had me stuck for almost three weeks on my claim. Filed everything on time, gave my doctor the receipt number, and SDI Online still showed nothing updated. I ended up getting through to EDD using Claimyr and the agent checked my claim and said the certification had come in but was showing under the wrong claim ID because my doctor had used an old receipt number from a previous claim. I didn't even know I had a previous claim receipt still in their system.

0 coins

When the agent found the mismatch, did she fix it on the spot or did she have to send it somewhere else to get corrected?

0 coins

She said she couldn't update it herself but she flagged it and told me EDD would mail a notice, and to read it and appeal within 30 days if I disagreed with anything on it. She confirmed the certification was actually there though, which at least told me the problem wasn't on my doctor's end.

0 coins

I've tried that line probably thirty times over two months and never once got a person. good to know there's a way to actually reach someone.

0 coins

Doctor switch mid-claim is more common than people realize. In-network changes with insurance are constantly forcing this. The claim itself doesn't care who certified it originally as long as the new provider is licensed and can certify your current condition.

0 coins

Mine was exactly an insurance network change. It happened overnight basically and I had no warning.

0 coins

Yeah that's rough timing. As long as you haven't gone back to work at all, the continuity argument is solid. New doc, same claim, same period of disability.

0 coins

The provider switch won't affect the claim if there's no return-to-work gap. Your new physician just certifies the current period. He examines you, confirms you can't do your regular duties, and submits the DE 2525XX. That's standard practice.

0 coins

Is there a deadline for when the new doctor has to submit after taking over the case?

0 coins

EDD needs it within 49 days of your disability start date for the initial certification, but for an extension mid-claim the timing tracks to when the prior certification period ends. Best not to let it sit.

0 coins

My original certification covered through mid-December so I should still be within the period. I'll push my new doctor's office to file this week.

0 coins

My sister changed doctors in her sixth week of maternity leave and the payments never stopped. New OB submitted the extension form and it picked right up. Caesarean recovery so she had the extra time and the new doctor certified that too.

0 coins

Eight weeks for a C-section recovery, that lines up with what I'd heard.

0 coins

Exactly, her original OB had certified the standard 8 weeks but she had a complication and the new doctor extended it past that with the supplementary certificate.

0 coins

Knowing an actual case where it worked without a break in payments is really helpful. Thank you.

0 coins

EDD doesn't care which doctor certifies as long as the provider is licensed. It's your claim, not your doctor's.

0 coins

Short and accurate. That's the whole answer right there.

0 coins

Worth double-checking that your new doctor isn't a provider type EDD excludes. Physical therapists, for example, can't certify SDI claims even if they're your primary treating person right now. Has to be a physician, nurse practitioner, PA, that category.

0 coins

He's an MD so I think I'm fine there. Spine and orthopedic specialist.

0 coins

MD is squarely in the right category. No issue there.

0 coins

Physical therapist one trips people up. I've heard of offices that thought the PT could sign off and then the certification came back invalid.

0 coins

From an administrative standpoint, the cleanest thing is to have your new doctor's office contact your old one to get the clinical notes before submitting anything to EDD. That way the DE 2525XX reflects a continuous and consistent treatment picture. EDD isn't auditing the clinical consistency but it helps if questions come up later.

0 coins

Practical advice. The claim documentation being internally consistent is good protection if EDD ever requests more information.

0 coins

EDD's certification forms don't ask for prior treatment history in detail, but the new provider should be able to speak to the current inability to work based on his own exam. The records handoff is just good clinical practice.

0 coins

Don't let your new doctor's office stall on this. Some practices take forever to handle anything insurance or SDI related because nobody wants to deal with the paperwork. Push them to do it this week if the certification period is ending soon anyway.

0 coins

Their front desk already pushed it to next week. I'm going to call them again today actually.

0 coins

Good call. The squeaky wheel definitely matters with medical office admin stuff.

0 coins

New doctor, same claim. That's the short answer. The form is the DE 2525XX.

0 coins

yeah exactly this. dont let the doc talk you into filing all over again

0 coins

Restarting a claim from scratch would mean a new waiting period too. That's another seven days you wouldn't get paid for. No reason to do it.

0 coins

One thing worth flagging: if your new doctor ends up being uncertain about submitting through SDI Online, his office can call EDD's disability line for provider guidance. The number is 1-800-480-3287. Provider staff can also navigate the SDI Online side once they have the claim receipt number and their own provider credentials.

0 coins

Provider-side access in SDI Online is separate from the claimant side. His office would log in with their own credentials, not yours.

0 coins

I didn't realize the doctor's office had their own login for SDI Online. That makes sense now that I think about it.

0 coins

Exactly, and it also means you don't need to give them anything beyond the receipt number. Everything they need to submit the DE 2525XX comes up on their end once they locate your claim.

0 coins

The whole thing about waiting periods confused me at first. I thought switching doctors would restart mine. But the waiting period is just the first seven days of the initial claim, it only applies once at the beginning. It has nothing to do with switching providers later.

0 coins

I actually did think it might restart the waiting period! So that's definitely not the case?

0 coins

Correct, the seven-day waiting period only applies once, at the very start of the claim. No provider switch or extension resets it. You already served it in your first week out.

0 coins

Yeah I panicked for nothing about that one. Once you've done your first seven days, that's done.

0 coins

How things ultimately shook out is what I'm curious about. Did your new doctor's office agree to file the DE 2525XX this week?

0 coins

Update: I called them this morning and the office manager said they'd done SDI certifications before and would submit the DE 2525XX by Thursday. She also confirmed they're registered in SDI Online already. Feeling much better about this.

0 coins

Thursday gives EDD time to process before your current certification period closes. That's the right sequence.

0 coins

Good news. That office actually knowing what they're doing is half the battle.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure