How to appeal SDI denial for receiving full pay from your employer
Got my denial notice last week and I'm kind of panicking. I'm still out recovering from a back procedure and EDD sent me a Notice of Determination saying I was disqualified because I received my full salary the whole time I was out. My HR said the company just continues pay as normal during medical leave, so I had no idea that would be an issue with the SDI claim. The notice has an Appeal Form on it. I'm not sure if I should even bother because maybe full pay really does disqualify you? Or is there a way to argue it? The notice is dated about a week ago and I know there's some kind of deadline. Any experience with this would really help.
71 comments

Justin Chang
The 30-day clock on that appeal runs from the date printed on the notice itself, not the day you received it, so check that date carefully. Filing the DE 1000A that came attached to your notice is the right first step. Write a detailed explanation of your situation, attach anything that shows what your employer paid and why, and mail everything to the return address printed on the notice. EDD will schedule a hearing before an administrative law judge.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorThank you, that helps. Do I need to send anything from my employer explaining their pay continuation policy, or is my own statement enough?
0 coins
Justin Chang
Your own explanation matters, but a letter from HR describing the pay continuation policy would strengthen your position considerably. Bring whatever documentation you have about how that pay was structured.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorGot it, I'll ask HR to put something in writing about the policy before I mail the appeal.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Thirty days goes fast. Mail it certified so you have proof of the date.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
This. Don't just drop it in a mailbox and hope.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Certified mail saved me once, definitely worth it.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
Payment date showed as issued on my Notice of Computation but my bank hadn't received anything yet, which is what made me phone EDD. I tried the disability line mornings for four days straight and got the recording every single time. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the payment had been issued on the 14th and to allow a few more business days for it to post to my Money Network card. That cleared up the confusion for me.
0 coins
Justin Chang
Claimyr worked the same way for my claim. The agent went through which weeks had actually been paid versus which were still pending, and that told me exactly where the gap was. It matched what SDI Online showed once I knew what to look for.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
Wait, which weeks question, what did you ask them exactly?
0 coins
Justin Chang
Asked which benefit weeks had payment issued and which hadn't posted yet. The agent went through each week individually, so I could see it wasn't just one lump payment.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
The Money Network card timing tripped me up too, good to know there's a way to actually reach someone about it.
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
Full pay from your employer is exactly what EDD flags. Their reasoning is that you weren't actually losing wages if you got your whole salary. But that doesn't mean the appeal automatically fails. The hearing is your chance to explain the specifics, so definitely file it.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorThat framing actually makes sense to me now. So the argument would be about how EDD is supposed to count employer-continued pay?
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
Pretty much. How it's classified matters. That's what the judge looks at, not just the fact that you got paid.
0 coins
Kylo Ren
Is this different from using PTO or sick time? I'm trying to understand if those would cause the same denial.
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
PTO and sick time are a separate situation, that's worth asking EDD directly because how they treat it can depend on the specifics of your claim.
0 coins
Nina Fitzgerald
Don't skip the deadline because you're unsure whether you'll win. File first, figure out the details after. A late appeal needs a whole separate explanation just to get heard.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Exactly. File it and sort the rest out.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorYeah, filing it regardless is the plan. Didn't want to miss the window second-guessing myself.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
My coworker went through something similar when she was out after a procedure and her company kept paying her. She said the appeal paperwork itself wasn't that complicated, just took her some time to write out the full explanation clearly. The hearing was a lot less intimidating than she expected.
0 coins
Kylo Ren
That's reassuring honestly. I keep imagining it like a courtroom.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
Ha, it's really not. She did it over the phone and said the judge was straightforward about what they needed.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
Phone hearings are pretty common now, easier than driving somewhere for sure.
0 coins
Kiara Fisherman
DE 2593 came in the mail after my tenth week on automatic payments and I almost missed the 20-day return window because I was still home recovering. That deadline caught me off guard. After returning it I wanted to confirm EDD received it, so I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr about it. The agent confirmed the form had been received and told me my next payment cycle would continue.
0 coins
Nina Fitzgerald
That whole thing sounds like marketing to me. How would some third-party service get you to an EDD agent any faster than calling yourself?
0 coins
Liam Cortez
Honestly I thought the same thing the first time I saw it mentioned. Tried it anyway after a week of dead ends on that line. The agent pulled up my base period and told me which quarter EDD had used for my benefit calculation. Cleared up a question I'd had since my Notice of Computation arrived.
0 coins
Nina Fitzgerald
Alright, I'll give it a shot. Nothing else has worked.
0 coins
Savannah Vin
The DE 2593 deadline is real, 20 days is not a lot of buffer.
0 coins
Mason Stone
full pay denial is rough, appeal it though. my friend got denied for something dumb and the judge actually overturned it. worth trying
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorGood to hear, gives me a little hope.
0 coins
Mason Stone
yeah dont give up before you even file lol
0 coins
Makayla Shoemaker
The appeal form asks for a detailed explanation. Write out the timeline, when your leave started, what your employer's pay policy is, and why you filed for SDI despite receiving that pay. Judges want the full picture, not just a brief objection.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorTimeline idea is helpful. Should I include the dates from my medical certification too?
0 coins
Makayla Shoemaker
Yes, include those. The certification dates establish your disability period, which is central to what the judge is evaluating.
0 coins
Kylo Ren
Wait, if the 30 days is from the notice date and I've already used up maybe 10 of those days just reading this thread, should I be filing today?
0 coins
Justin Chang
File as soon as you can. Don't wait for everything to be perfect. You can submit a detailed explanation with the form and add more documentation later if the judge allows it.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Today is better than tomorrow on this one.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
The appeal process is actually more accessible than it seems! I appealed an overpayment notice a while back and the administrative law judge was really clear about what evidence they needed. Bring your paperwork and explain your situation plainly.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Good to hear the judge is reasonable.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
Mine was very thorough and gave me a real chance to explain things.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
Four days before my deadline I realized I hadn't attached anything to the appeal form, just mailed the form itself. Had to scramble to get a follow-up letter in. Add your documentation the first time, don't be me anyway.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Classic. At least you caught it.
0 coins
Emma Olsen
Barely, it was a stressful week with the kids home and all.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
Notice of Determination on my claim listed a disqualification reason I didn't fully understand, so I needed to talk through it with someone at EDD. After a few days of getting nowhere on the phone line, I ended up getting through to an agent using Claimyr. The agent read me exactly what the determination said and confirmed which form EDD had flagged as incomplete on my end.
0 coins
Makayla Shoemaker
What did you have ready when the agent picked up, did you need anything specific?
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
Claim ID and the date on the notice, mostly. The agent found everything from there.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
been trying that line since tuesday, five or six mornings now and nothing. might have to look into this.
0 coins
Savannah Vin
Employer pay continuation and SDI interact in a specific way and EDD does look at how it's characterized. Filing the appeal doesn't cost you anything. Worst outcome is the judge agrees with EDD, and you're no worse off than you are now.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorThat's a pretty clear way to think about it. Zero to lose by filing.
0 coins
Savannah Vin
Exactly.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
Missed the appeal deadline on a different kind of notice once and had to submit a whole written explanation for why I was late. The judge reviewed it but it added weeks to the process. Filing on time is so much simpler.
0 coins
Kylo Ren
What counts as a good enough reason for a late appeal?
0 coins
Jason Brewer
An administrative law judge decides that, there's no guaranteed list. Illness, not receiving the notice, something serious that kept you from responding. The stronger and more specific you are, the better your shot.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorDefinitely filing before the deadline, this thread convinced me not to wait.
0 coins
Liam Cortez
HR letters do carry weight at these hearings. Asked a friend who'd been through one and she said her employer's written explanation of the pay policy was what the judge focused on most.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
That tracks. The judge needs something concrete from the employer side, not just the claimant's word.
0 coins
Makayla Shoemaker
Get it on company letterhead if you can.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
File the appeal, attach the HR documentation, and keep your copy of everything you send. That's the whole checklist.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Short and right.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Keeping copies is something people always forget until they need them.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
Talked to HR today and they're writing a letter explaining that the pay continuation is a standard company benefit, not wages in exchange for work. I'm mailing the DE 1000A with that letter and my own written timeline tomorrow, certified. Really glad I didn't just accept the denial.
0 coins
Justin Chang
That framing in the HR letter, benefit rather than wages, is exactly the kind of detail that matters at a hearing. Good documentation.
0 coins
Jason Brewer
Filing with solid paperwork puts you in the best position you can be in. Hope it goes your way.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
Updates welcome if you're comfortable sharing after the hearing!
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
EDD's phone line is genuinely one of the worst I've dealt with. If you need to reach them before the hearing to ask anything about your claim status, budget multiple mornings for it.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Not wrong. Spent three weeks trying to get through on a different issue.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
the line just drops sometimes too, not even a hold, just gone.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
One thing that sometimes gets missed: the appeal address is on the notice itself, not EDD's general mailing address. Sending it to the wrong place can cost you time you don't have.
0 coins
Kiara Fisherman
Important detail. I nearly sent mine to a general EDD address before I read the notice more carefully.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
AuthorChecked the notice again after seeing this, yes, different address. Good catch.
0 coins