How to appeal SDI denial for motion picture industry worker — what I'm dealing with
Got my denial notice last week and I'm honestly still kind of in shock. I've been doing hair and makeup on set for about twelve years, and the work is project-based so my hours jump around a lot depending on what's shooting. I had a procedure done earlier this year that kept me off set for almost two months, filed my DI claim through SDI Online, got my doctor's certification in on time, and then got a Notice of Determination saying I wasn't eligible. The reason on the notice was vague and I don't fully understand what disqualified me. I know there's an appeal process but I have NO idea where to start. Has anyone in the entertainment industry or similar gig-type work gone through this? The irregular pay quarters make my situation feel really different from someone with a steady paycheck every week. What do I actually need to pull together to fight this?
84 comments

Miguel Diaz
30 days from the date printed on that Notice of Determination is your deadline to get the appeal in. The notice comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. If you've misplaced it, you can write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the return address on the notice. Put everything you disagree with in that letter, specifically.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorI still have the notice so I have the form. Does the letter need to be certified mail or is regular mail fine?
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
EDD doesn't require certified mail, but a lot of people send it that way just to have proof of the date it went out. Either way, hold onto your copy of whatever you send.
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
Wait, can you appeal if you already missed the 30 days? Asking for a situation that might be past that window.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
A late appeal is possible but you'd need to explain the reason for the delay. An administrative law judge looks at whether the reason is valid. Don't sit on it any longer if you're close to or past that mark.
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
Irregular hours are common in construction too so I know how that base period math can get confusing. EDD looks at your four highest quarters in a set window going back from when your disability started. If your highest-earning quarter doesn't fall where you think it does, the weekly amount comes out lower than expected and sometimes the eligibility math doesn't work out at all.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorThat's exactly what I'm worried about. Some of my biggest paychecks were on a project that wrapped right before the base period window, so they might not even count.
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
Yeah that's the kind of thing worth spelling out in the appeal. Pull your W-2s or pay stubs for the two years before you filed and map out which quarters had what wages. If you can show your highest quarter was in the base period they used, that helps your case.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
You also need at least 300 bucks in SDI-taxed wages in that base period or nothing qualifies. Worth checking your stubs to confirm that SDI deduction was actually taken out every check.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
DE 2593 came in the mail during my claim and I wasn't sure how urgent it was at first, so I held off responding. Sent it back past the 20-day window and my payments stopped. I tried calling the EDD disability line for two weeks straight and kept hitting recordings. I ended up trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and an EDD agent pulled up my claim and confirmed they hadn't received the DE 2593 yet. She said I needed to return it to get benefits reinstated. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
DE 2593 caught me too, same thing. Used Claimyr on my end, got an agent, asked about submitting the DE 2525XX for more time off set. She confirmed they'd received the extension request from my doctor and that my claim was updated. The EDD line before that had been useless for me.
0 coins
Paolo Longo
How many mornings did you spend trying before you found that? I've been at it since Tuesday.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
About nine or ten days of trying, mostly around 8am. Never got a person until that call.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorSo the DE 2593 is different from the appeal form, right? The DE 2593 is for staying on benefits during an active claim and the DE 1000A is for the appeal after a denial?
0 coins
Yara Khoury
Yes exactly. The DE 2593 keeps an active claim going after about ten weeks. The DE 1000A is what you use if EDD said you're not eligible at all.
0 coins
Amina Bah
For the base period question: EDD uses a 12-month window made up of four quarters. It runs from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date, so the most recent quarter or two before you got sick often aren't counted. If your motion picture project wages were earned close to when you filed, those might have landed in what EDD calls the disability benefit base period but it depends on the exact dates.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorOkay so if my procedure was in, say, mid-year, the quarters that count would be from more than a year before that? That explains so much about why the numbers looked off to me.
0 coins
Amina Bah
Roughly, yes. The calculator on EDD's site can estimate your weekly benefit from the wage quarters you plug in. If you run your numbers there before the appeal hearing, you'll know what EDD should have used versus what they actually computed.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
That calculator is genuinely useful. I ran mine before my claim even processed and it matched what ended up on my Notice of Computation almost exactly.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
The EDD disability line is a wall. I called something like 40 times across three weeks trying to ask one simple question about my denial. Got through once, was on hold for over an hour, and then the call dropped. The whole situation is set up to wear you down.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
40 times is brutal. I gave up after about two weeks and just used Ask EDD on the website. Got a written answer in a few days, which was actually better since I had something to show at the appeal.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
Ask EDD worked for you? I've had it sit with no response for a month. Maybe I should give it another shot.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
Appeals go to an administrative law judge, not the same EDD staff answering phones anyway. The hearing is where the real argument happens.
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
I'm in a similar spot but with pregnancy. I work on-and-off in catering for film productions and my income is all over the place. If I get denied am I basically guaranteed to lose the appeal or does the appeals judge actually look at the whole picture?
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
The administrative law judge reviews the case fresh. You can bring wage records, your pay stubs, anything that shows your earnings during the base period. It's not a rubber stamp of the denial.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
For pregnancy specifically, the typical disability period is around six weeks for a natural birth and eight for a cesarean, though your doctor can certify additional time if complications come up. Make sure your doctor's certification covers the full period you were off.
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
Mine was a c-section and my doctor only put six weeks on the form. Can she update that or is it too late?
0 coins
Javier Cruz
She can submit an extension through the DE 2525XX form. EDD sends that form with the final payment notice, but the doctor can also complete and submit it through SDI Online. Talk to her office as soon as you can.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
my situation was kinda like this, got denied because they said i didnt have enough sdi taxable wages but i def had the deduction on every single check. ended up being a wage reporting mismatch between what my employer submitted and what edd had on file
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorThat's scary. How did you sort it out?
0 coins
Emma Thompson
had to get my employer to resubmit the wage data to edd. took forever but once they had the right numbers on file the appeal went fine
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
That happens more than people think in project-based industries. The employer files wage reports and if one project's wages didn't get tied to your SSN correctly you're the one who has to push to fix it.
0 coins
Malik Jackson
Appeals can honestly go better than people expect when you show up with documentation. I appealed a denial a couple years back, brought a full year of pay stubs and my W-2s, and the judge asked questions and actually listened. Took a few months to get a decision but it went in my favor.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorA few months feels long when you're out of work and the bills aren't stopping. Did you have any income at all during that stretch?
0 coins
Malik Jackson
Nothing from EDD during the appeal wait. I was doing odd jobs where I could. It's rough and I'm not going to sugarcoat that part.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Is there any interim payment while an appeal is pending or does everything just stop?
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
Payments from EDD stop after a denial. If the appeal is successful, back pay for the denied period can be issued. No interim payments while the appeal is in process.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
For the appeal letter itself, be specific. Name the weeks or dates EDD says you weren't eligible, state what wages you earned in each quarter of the base period, and explain why you think their computation was wrong. Vague appeals are harder to win than ones where you've laid out exactly which fact you're disputing.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorShould I attach all my pay stubs right to the appeal form or wait and bring them to the hearing?
0 coins
Javier Cruz
Bring them to the hearing and also send copies with the appeal form. You want EDD and the judge to see the full record as early as possible.
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
What if I don't have all my pay stubs because some were from a production that only paid digitally and I deleted the emails?
0 coins
Javier Cruz
Contact that production's payroll company. Most keep wage records for several years and can reissue them. Your bank statements showing the deposits can also help establish what you were paid and when.
0 coins
Malik Jackson
Notice of Determination I got last spring was confusing about which quarter they flagged, so I ended up phoning EDD through Claimyr to get a real person. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the specific determination code and which weeks were listed as denied. That let me write a much more targeted appeal.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
The EDD disability line has beaten me every time I've tried it. I called eight mornings in a row and never got past the automated menu. How is talking to an agent through Claimyr even possible if the line itself is that crowded?
0 coins
Malik Jackson
Honestly I didn't know what to expect either. The service waits the line out for you and your phone rings when an EDD agent picks up. The agent I spoke to was just a regular EDD rep, it wasn't anything special on their end.
0 coins
StarSurfer
I tried that too after my own Notice of Determination came in and an agent confirmed they'd switched my payment to a Money Network card since I hadn't set up direct deposit. Good to know before I was hunting for a check that wasn't coming!
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
Okay, that actually makes sense as a workaround for a line that hangs up on you. I'd want to ask them about which quarter of the base period they used in my computation.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
Worth knowing that the appeal hearing isn't a courtroom thing. It's usually a phone hearing with an administrative law judge. You explain your situation, the judge may ask questions, and you can walk through your wage records out loud.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorDoes the judge already have my claim file or do I need to send everything to them directly?
0 coins
AstroAlpha
The judge gets the claim file from EDD. But you still want your own copies of everything so you can reference them during the hearing.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
I didn't know it was a phone hearing, I was picturing something like a courtroom. That's a lot less scary.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
The SDI taxable wages requirement is real. If any of your motion picture gigs were on the production company's loan-out arrangement or some kind of day-player structure where the CASDI deduction wasn't taken out, those wages may not count toward your base period even if you have W-2s showing the income.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorI have had a few projects where the paycheck looked different. How do I know which ones had the deduction?
0 coins
Oliver Becker
Check your pay stubs line by line for 'CASDI' or 'SDI' in the deductions. If it's not there, those wages don't count for DI eligibility. Your W-2 box 14 sometimes shows it too, though the label varies.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
yeah this tripped me up too. some of my short-gig checks didnt have sdi on them and edd basically couldnt count those weeks
0 coins
Javier Cruz
Receipt number from my original SDI Online filing was something I lost track of and later needed to match the medical certification to my claim. I'd been trying the EDD disability line for days with nothing, so I tried Claimyr to get to an agent. She looked up my claim by my SSN and confirmed the receipt number on file matched what my doctor's office had used to submit the certification, so the claim wasn't the problem I thought it was.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
What even is Claimyr? I've been trying that disability line since Monday and I'm not getting anywhere.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
It's a service that handles the hold time with EDD for you. When an agent at EDD picks up, your phone rings and you're the one who speaks with them. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
Got it. I'd want to ask EDD why my wages from the last production I worked didn't show up in my base period. That's been sitting unanswered for two weeks.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Appeal paperwork can pile up fast with kids in the house, trust me. I kept a folder just for the EDD stuff, one for the original claim, one for the denial notice and the DE 1000A, one for wage records. Kept me from losing anything important.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorPhysical folder or digital? I've been trying to keep it all in an email folder but stuff keeps getting buried.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Both honestly. I scanned everything and kept a folder on my laptop too, just in case. The hearing scheduler sent stuff by mail and by SDI Online message so I needed both anyway.
0 coins
Ravi Malhotra
been dealing with a denial appeal for weeks now, honestly so tired. just wanted someone to know its not just them going through this.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorYou're definitely not alone. This thread has helped me more than anything else I found.
0 coins
Paolo Longo
hope yours resolves soon.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
One thing I got wrong when I first saw my denial was thinking I could just call EDD and ask them to reconsider over the phone. That's not a thing. The appeal form or a detailed written letter to the return address on the notice is the actual path, lol. Learned that the hard way.
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
I was going to try to call and explain my situation. So that literally does nothing?
0 coins
Freya Christensen
You can call and ask questions, but reversals don't happen by phone. Everything that matters goes through the written appeal and then the hearing.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
Calling to get information about what specifically caused the denial can still be useful before you write the appeal letter though. Know what you're arguing before you argue it.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Payment date on one of my approved weeks came up wrong in SDI Online, showed as issued but the amount didn't land. I ended up getting through to EDD using Claimyr and an agent confirmed the payment had been issued on a specific date and that the deposit was on its way to my direct deposit account.
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
Used Claimyr myself when my claim start date showed something different than what I'd filed. The agent confirmed the date they had on the system and told me it was based on when my doctor submitted the medical certification, not when I filed my part. Cleared up a lot of confusion for me.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Did the agent say anything about whether you could change that start date after the fact?
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
She said the start date on the claim is what it is and I'd need to look at my Notice of Determination if I wanted to dispute it. So I pulled that notice out and checked.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorThis thread has given me so much to work with. I had no idea there were so many moving pieces in an appeal.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Before the hearing, write out a one-page summary of your argument. What EDD said in the denial, what wages you have documented, why the base period they used doesn't reflect your actual eligible earnings. The judge will appreciate that you've organized it.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorDoes that summary get sent in advance or just used during the call?
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Bring it to reference during the hearing. You can also submit additional documents to the appeals board before the hearing date, the notice scheduling your hearing will explain how.
0 coins
StarSurfer
In motion picture and entertainment the production structure can make SDI look weird on paper because you technically work for a new employer every project. All those individual employers should still have been withholding SDI from your pay though!
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorEvery project was with a different signatory company under my union contract and they all took out the deduction. I can see it on every paystub. That's what makes the denial confusing.
0 coins
StarSurfer
That's actually a strong starting point for your appeal then. You have documented SDI withholding across multiple employers in the base period and that's exactly what EDD should be counting.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
Union payroll in entertainment typically goes through one of the larger payroll processing companies and those wage records are usually clean and consistent. That could work in your favor when the judge looks at the documentation.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
Denials get reversed more often than people think when the claimant actually shows up with their records. Most people either miss the deadline or submit the appeal form with no documentation. If you've got the pay stubs and you've got the SDI deduction, go fight it.
0 coins
Ava Rodriguez
AuthorThat's what I needed to hear. I've got everything, I just didn't know if the process was worth the effort.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
Worth it. File the DE 1000A before that 30-day clock runs out, attach what you have, and prep the rest for the hearing.
0 coins