Back to California Disability

StellarSurfer

How much will I get on SDI based on quarterly earnings?

So I've been reading everything I can find and I still can't figure this out. My hours got cut to almost nothing about two months ago and now I'm going out on disability next week for a procedure I've been putting off. I work in retail so my pay fluctuates a lot by quarter, some quarters I did pretty well and some were slow. What I can't figure out is how much will I get on SDI based on quarterly earnings specifically, like does it average all four quarters or just the best one? I asked my HR person and she said she thought it averaged everything but I'm not sure she actually knows. I want to have some idea of what I'm dealing with before the first payment comes in because I need to know if I can cover rent.

The highest quarter of wages in your base period is what EDD looks at, not an average of all four. The base period is a specific 12-month window made up of four quarters, and EDD takes your single best-paid quarter from that window to calculate your weekly benefit amount. The Notice of Computation they send shows what they found and what your weekly amount works out to.

0 coins

Wait so if one quarter was really high because of holiday hours that one counts the most? That would actually help me.

0 coins

The best-quarter rule is spelled out on EDD's benefit calculator page. The calculator on EDD's site will let you put in your quarterly wages and get an estimate before your Notice of Computation arrives, which is worth doing so you're not completely in the dark.

0 coins

Thank you, pulling up the calculator now.

0 coins

To add one number that matters: the base period runs from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date, covering four calendar quarters in that window. So if your high quarter was holiday season and that falls inside the base period, yes it counts. If it was more recent it might be outside the base period entirely, which trips people up.

0 coins

Mine was last November so I need to check whether that falls inside the window. How do I figure out exactly which quarters EDD uses?

0 coins

EDD's calculator asks for your claim start date and then tells you exactly which four quarters it's looking at. Plug in next week's date as your start and it will show the window.

0 coins

I got confused about this too. I thought they used the most recent three months and was totally off on my estimate.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim sat unmatched for almost two weeks and I had no idea what was holding things up. Ended up reaching an EDD disability agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after getting nowhere with the phone line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and said the receipt number my doctor's office used didn't match the one SDI Online generated when I filed, so the medical certification was just sitting there unattached.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

You phone EDD, but it handles the hold time for you, and when an actual EDD person picks up you're on the line. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. My claim shows pending and I want to ask EDD which quarter they're using for my base period. Might give that a try.

0 coins

The phone line is a joke. I've redialed before 8 a.m. every morning this week and either get the too-busy recording or it drops after the first menu. Nobody should have to do this just to ask about their own money.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. Three mornings, zero agents.

0 coins

Tuesday was my best morning this month. Still took four tries.

0 coins

I tried Tuesday too. Got the recording twice and then nothing.

0 coins

One thing that catches people off guard: the benefit percentage isn't flat. EDD pays somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of your highest-quarter wages depending on where your income falls, so two people with the same highest quarter but different income levels can get different weekly amounts. The calculator handles this automatically, but it's worth knowing why your estimate might not be exactly 70 percent.

0 coins

I had no idea the percentage varied. I was just assuming 70 for everyone. So someone with lower wages might actually get a higher percentage of their quarter?

0 coins

That's the idea, yes. Lower earners get a higher replacement rate. EDD's calculator applies the right percentage based on what you enter.

0 coins

This is the part that actually surprised me when I filed. I expected a simple flat rate and the Notice of Computation showed something different from what I'd calculated.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question here, does the quarterly earnings thing count tips? I do hair and my reported wages look lower than what I actually took home because of how tips get handled.

0 coins

Only wages that had the CASDI deduction taken out count toward SDI. How tips are reported and whether the deduction was taken depends on your employer's payroll setup, so checking your pay stubs to see if CASDI was withheld on tip income is the place to start.

0 coins

My stubs show CASDI on the base wage but not on the tip line. So my effective base period wages are going to be lower than I thought.

0 coins

That's a pretty common situation in the service industry. The calculator will only work with what had the deduction on it, so using your W-2 taxable wages minus any tips that weren't withheld is how to get a realistic estimate.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim dropped before the Notice of Computation even showed up in SDI Online, which threw me off. Used Claimyr to get an agent on my disability claim because I'd tried the line maybe six mornings running and never reached a person. The agent told me the payment had been issued on a specific date and that the notice was mailed the same day, so they were just arriving in a different order than I expected.

0 coins

Claimyr worked well for me too, honestly relieved I found it. The agent I reached confirmed which quarter of my base period EDD had on file and what the weekly amount was going to be from my Notice of Computation, right there on the call.

0 coins

When the agent told you which quarter they used, was it the one you expected based on the calculator?

0 coins

Pretty close. I was off by about one pay period worth of wages because I'd used the wrong quarter cutoff dates in my own math. The agent read me the exact quarter boundaries they had.

0 coins

Payment arriving before the notice is exactly what happened to me too. I panicked thinking something was wrong anyway.

0 coins

wait does the base period change if you barely worked some quarters like can they skip a bad quarter

0 coins

EDD uses the highest single quarter regardless, so a quarter with low wages doesn't drag the amount down the way an average would. But the base period window itself is set by the claim start date and doesn't get adjusted to skip a slow stretch.

0 coins

ok so as long as one quarter was decent im not completely wrecked got it

0 coins

I wondered the same thing. Good to know the low quarters don't average in.

0 coins

You need at least 300 dollars in wages with the SDI deduction on them during the base period or EDD won't pay anything. That's the floor. Everything else about the quarterly math doesn't matter if you don't clear that.

0 coins

Even with cut hours I should clear that. Good to know that's the minimum though.

0 coins

Yeah most people are fine. Just putting it out there for anyone who had a really slow year.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is worth reading carefully when it arrives. It shows the weekly benefit amount and the maximum total you can receive, and it spells out which base period quarters EDD used. If the quarter listed isn't the one you thought was highest, that's your signal to look at the actual wage amounts and not just what you remember earning.

0 coins

Is there a way to dispute it if EDD used the wrong quarter or the wrong amount for your wages?

0 coins

The notice itself says what to do if you disagree. You'd appeal within 30 days of the date on the notice.

0 coins

Exactly right. The Appeal Form is DE 1000A and the notice has the return address on it.

0 coins

Waiting period trips up a lot of people when they're trying to figure out what their first payment will cover. The first seven days of a new claim are non-payable no matter what. That's not EDD processing time, it's a built-in unpaid week before benefits start. So your first actual payment covers day eight onward.

0 coins

So I'll lose one week of benefits no matter what? That part I didn't know.

0 coins

Every new claim, yes. It's not a delay or a problem with your claim, it's just how the program works.

0 coins

I called EDD about this thinking something was wrong. It's just the waiting period.

0 coins

Not sure if I'm reading EDD's site right but it says something about a 12-month base period with four quarters. Does that mean they look at exactly the last 12 months before you file?

0 coins

The window runs from about 5 to 18 months back from your claim start date, not the most recent 12 months. The gap exists so that wages are already in EDD's system from employer reports. The calculator will show you the exact dates once you enter your start date.

0 coins

That's the part I totally missed. I kept thinking they meant the last four quarters and was confused why my recent wages didn't seem to count.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site is the clearest way to see this. Enter your start date and the four quarters populate automatically.

0 coins

been trying that phone number for days. its not even busy it just ends the call. no hold music nothing.

0 coins

The line doesn't even do you the courtesy of a hold. It just kicks you.

0 coins

four mornings in a row now. same thing every time.

0 coins

Try right at 8 on the dot. Doesn't always work but it's better than mid-morning in my experience.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mailbox and I almost threw it out thinking it was junk mail. Called EDD disability through Claimyr to ask what it was and what would happen if I'd already missed it. The agent said it's the form EDD sends after about ten weeks of automatic payments to check that you're still unable to work, and that I had 20 days from the date on it to return it.

0 coins

That screams marketing to me. A service that just gets you through to a government phone line?

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first heard about it. But I ended up trying it when my waiting period question wasn't getting answered any other way, and the agent I spoke to worked for EDD, went through my claim dates and confirmed day one of my claim and when the seven-day window ended. It was just a regular EDD agent.

0 coins

Alright. I'll think about it.

0 coins

I didn't even know the DE 2593 existed. What happens if someone doesn't send it back in time?

0 coins

EDD can stop benefits if that form isn't returned within 20 days of the date on it. If you're on automatic payment and suddenly payments stop, that form is the first thing to check.

0 coins

My HR person told me the same averaging thing yours did and she was also wrong. The highest quarter is the only one that determines your weekly amount. The others are basically irrelevant unless none of them meet the minimum threshold.

0 coins

HR person probably handles so many different programs that the SDI rules get mixed up with other things. Glad I asked here.

0 coins

Yeah she was confusing it with how some short-term disability plans through employers calculate things. EDD's formula is just the one best quarter.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came through on my claim and it denied me. Got on with an EDD agent through Claimyr after the line had eaten my mornings for a solid week. Agent confirmed the notice date and said I had 30 days from that date to appeal using the DE 1000A form, and that the form was included with the notice.

0 coins

Did you have to explain your whole situation to the agent or did they just look it up?

0 coins

Just gave them my claim ID. They pulled it up and read me what was on it. Straightforward.

0 coins

been at that phone line myself for a week straight. glad to know actually reaching someone is possible at all.

0 coins

PFL is different from SDI right? My coworker said she got PFL for her back surgery and I thought PFL was for taking care of family.

0 coins

Your instinct is right. Paid Family Leave is for caring for a seriously ill family member or bonding with a new baby, not for your own illness or surgery. A back surgery would be covered under Disability Insurance, the DI side of SDI, not PFL. Your coworker might be using the terms interchangeably.

0 coins

That's what I thought. I'll make sure she files the right one if she needs to refile.

0 coins

This mix-up is so common. The two programs come from the same SDI system so people assume they're the same thing, but the qualifying reasons are completely different.

0 coins

Two people asked about whether recent wages count and I want to pile on with one more case: if you just switched jobs or had a gap in employment, your most recent paycheck might actually fall outside the base period window. The calculator on EDD's site will tell you immediately whether your best quarter is even in the window they're looking at.

0 coins

This is my situation basically. Hours got cut two months ago so my recent quarters are weaker. If my better quarter falls inside the window it still counts even if it wasn't the most recent one?

0 coins

Exactly. Being older inside the window doesn't disqualify it. Highest wages in that four-quarter stretch is all EDD cares about.

0 coins

Filed twice now. First time I overthought the quarterly math for a week and then the Notice of Computation showed a number within a few dollars of what the calculator said. Use the calculator.

0 coins

Genuinely the most useful thing in this thread. I've been spiraling on the math and should just enter my numbers.

0 coins

Yep. Plug it in, write down the number, move on.

0 coins

HR was wrong for me too by the way, told me SDI pays 60 percent flat. Notice came in and it was higher than that because of how the income bracket works. Anyway the calculator had it right the whole time.

0 coins

60 percent flat sounds like it's from an older version of the rules or from a different program. The tiered rate EDD uses now gives lower earners a better percentage.

0 coins

She might have been thinking of my employer's short-term disability supplement honestly. Anyway the actual number was better than I expected so no complaints.

0 coins

My HR said the same 60 percent thing. I should run the calculator again.

0 coins

does anyone know if the quarterly wages they look at include overtime or just your base pay

0 coins

Overtime is included as long as CASDI was withheld on those earnings. If you're hourly and your overtime shows up on your pay stub with the SDI deduction, those wages count toward your quarterly total.

0 coins

ok good because half my better quarters were overtime heavy

0 coins

gonna use the calculator tonight with the overtime included and see what i get

0 coins

Okay I ran the calculator and I actually feel a lot better. My holiday quarter is inside the base period window and it's by far my highest. The estimate came out to around 80 percent of that quarter spread over the week which I didn't expect. Thank you everyone, this thread helped me more than the EDD site alone did.

0 coins

80 percent replacement means you landed in the lower-income bracket for the formula. That's exactly how it's supposed to work for folks in that range.

0 coins

Glad the holiday quarter came through for you. Keep an eye on the mailbox for your Notice of Computation, it should arrive within a couple weeks of your medical certification going in.

0 coins

Now file the claim and don't overthink it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure