Back to California Disability

AaliyahAli

How long before sends SDI claimant to their own doctor exam — California EDD disability explained

So I've been on SDI since my back surgery about six weeks ago and my claim got approved pretty quickly which I was surprised about honestly. But my neighbor who works in HR mentioned something about EDD sending people to their own doctor for some kind of independent exam, and now I can't stop thinking about it. I had no idea that was even a thing. My surgeon certified everything and I've been doing what I'm supposed to, certifying on time, staying off work like I'm supposed to. Is this something EDD actually does? How long before sends SDI claimant to their own doctor exam? Is it triggered by how long you've been out or by something specific in your file? I really don't want to get blindsided by something like that especially since I'm still genuinely recovering and not ready to go back. Any experience with this would be really helpful.

Base period question nearly derailed my claim from the start. SDI Online showed a weekly amount that felt way lower than it should've been and I spent two weeks hitting redials on 1-800-480-3287 before anything happened. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got someone on the line. The agent pulled up which quarter they'd used as my highest-paid quarter and walked me through why it landed where it did in the base period window. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Tried that line myself about forty times over three days. Never got past the busy signal. Hard to believe any service actually gets you through it.

0 coins

I get the doubt. I felt the same way my first morning trying. What I can tell you is I ended up talking to an actual EDD agent, not a recording, and she knew my file. That was enough for me.

0 coins

DE 2593 came up for me when I tried that number. The agent confirmed it had been received on their end, which was a relief because I'd mailed it right at the edge of the 20-day window and had no way to verify otherwise.

0 coins

Alright. Still skeptical but I'll give it a go. My extension paperwork is sitting in limbo and I need a real answer.

0 coins

The independent medical exam you're describing is not a standard part of how California EDD runs a disability claim. The SDI program works from your own doctor's certification, and nothing in EDD's published process describes routinely sending claimants to a separate physician. Where that idea likely comes from is workers' compensation, which does use independent exams fairly often. SDI is not workers' comp.

0 coins

Oh that actually makes a lot of sense. My neighbor must've been thinking about workers' comp stuff, he deals with both at work. So EDD just takes what my surgeon submits?

0 coins

Correct. Your surgeon's certification is what EDD works from. The key is that your provider needs to be on EDD's list of who can certify, and a surgeon qualifies.

0 coins

Wait, so any doctor can certify? I was going to ask my physical therapist to do mine and now I'm not sure if that's okay.

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. You need a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant or one of the other types EDD names. Your PT can support your care but can't submit the certification itself.

0 coins

Okay glad I asked before I did that. I'll go back to my actual doctor.

0 coins

Workers' comp does the independent exam thing. SDI doesn't. Your neighbor got the wires crossed.

0 coins

Yeah I think that's what happened. I feel better about it now.

0 coins

Same confusion cost me two days of worry when I first filed. They're completely different programs.

0 coins

My client in the chair this week literally asked me the same question, she just started a leave after a procedure and was scared EDD was going to send her somewhere. I told her what I knew but I wasn't totally sure so I'm glad I found this thread. Sounds like her regular doctor's certification is all she needs.

0 coins

Her doctor handles the whole certification side through SDI Online. As long as the provider submits it within 49 days of when the disability started, that's the piece EDD needs from the medical side.

0 coins

49 days, writing that down for her right now.

0 coins

Okay so I've been reading and I need to make sure I understand this right. The seven day waiting period at the start of a claim, that's not processing time, right? Because my claim has been pending for nine days and I'm worried I'm not going to get paid for any of it and I don't even know when my first payment will come.

0 coins

The first seven days are genuinely non-payable, that's written into how the program works. Day eight is the first day that can be paid. The pending status you're seeing is separate from that. Once EDD has your part and your doctor's certification, most payments go out within two weeks of a completed claim.

0 coins

So I could have waited until day nine to file? Or does it matter when I filed?

0 coins

You can file starting on day nine after your disability begins, and you have up to 49 days from the start date before you risk disqualification. Filing earlier doesn't hurt you, it just means EDD has your part waiting when the certification comes in.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps. I filed on day ten so I should be fine. Now I'm just waiting on my doctor's office to submit their part.

0 coins

Payment method was something I didn't think about until my first payment sat somewhere I couldn't find it. Filed my claim through SDI Online and never picked direct deposit, so it went to the Money Network card. Got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr and she confirmed the payment had been issued to the card and walked me through where to activate it. That cleared up two days of confusion in one call.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I've been trying to reach EDD about my own claim for days.

0 coins

It stays on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Useful to know. I need to ask about my Notice of Computation because the weekly amount looks off to me and I want to understand how they calculated it before I do anything else.

0 coins

notice of computation confused me too when mine came. took me a while to find the wage calculator on edd's site to check it myself.

0 coins

EDD doesn't dispatch physicians to examine your back or your knee. That's not their operation. Workers' comp does that. Different program entirely.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD trusts your own provider. Workers' comp is a whole other animal.

0 coins

Makes sense now. My neighbor works in insurance and probably just got the two mixed up in conversation.

0 coins

Six weeks out from a knee replacement myself and nobody from EDD showed up at my door, ha. The whole claim ran through my surgeon's certification. The only time I had to do anything extra was when the DE 2593 showed up around week ten asking if I was still out.

0 coins

That questionnaire trips a lot of people up because it looks like junk mail. You have 20 days to send it back or the payments can stop.

0 coins

Mine came in a plain envelope and I almost set it aside. Opened it on day two and mailed it right back.

0 coins

Good to know that's coming. I'm only at week six so I've got some time but I'll keep an eye out for it.

0 coins

my roommate went through workers comp and they made him go to some doctor the company picked. totally different from sdi. edd doesnt do that

0 coins

Correct. SDI works off your own provider's certification. The company-selected exam is a workers' comp thing.

0 coins

My claim ran 11 weeks after hip surgery and EDD never once asked me to see a physician on their behalf. Everything went through my orthopedic surgeon, who submitted the initial certification and then the extension form when I needed more time. The process was straightforward once I understood what each form was for.

0 coins

Did your surgeon know to file the extension on their own or did you have to ask them?

0 coins

EDD sent an Electronic Benefit Payment Notification with the final payment, and that notice prompted the extension. I let the office know to watch for it and they submitted the form from there.

0 coins

Good to know the notification goes out automatically. I've been worried I'd miss that step.

0 coins

Medical certification question held up my injury claim longer than anything else. SDI Online kept showing pending even though the office said they'd sent it in. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who found that my provider had submitted the certification but the receipt number they used didn't match the one from my original filing. Agent told me my provider needed to resubmit with the correct number.

0 coins

Had something similar happen on my own extension and was so relieved when the agent sorted it out. The receipt number thing is so easy to get wrong if the office is working from memory.

0 coins

In my case the agent confirmed the DE 2525XX had come through but under the wrong claim ID. The office resubmitted the same day and my extension was processed that week.

0 coins

How did you know to have the receipt number ready when you called?

0 coins

The agent just asked for it on the spot and I had it pulled up in SDI Online. Having the claim ID open on your phone makes those calls faster.

0 coins

Filed January 14th, medical certification came in January 20th, first payment issued February 1st. That was my timeline after a procedure last winter. No independent exam, no extra step, just the two parts of the claim and then the payment.

0 coins

Two weeks from complete claim to first payment, that tracks with what others are saying here. Mine's been six weeks total on the claim, payment started around week two.

0 coins

Yours sounds like it went smoothly. The notice that comes before the first payment, the Notice of Computation, is worth reading closely so you know what to expect each week.

0 coins

Okay correcting myself from earlier in this thread. I went back to my regular physician and she confirmed she can certify my SDI claim. Already gave her my form receipt number and she's submitting through SDI Online.

0 coins

That's the right move. Receipt number to the provider so they can find the claim, and they submit from their side. You're set.

0 coins

Thank you. Stressful enough being out of work without worrying about whether the paperwork is going to blow up.

0 coins

My own SDI claim two years ago after a minor procedure, nobody called me, nobody sent me anywhere, I just had my doctor fill out her part and payments started coming. EDD really does just go off what your provider submits.

0 coins

That's been everyone's experience here. The certification from your own provider is the whole medical piece of it.

0 coins

And honestly my doctor's office was more on top of it than I expected. They did the online submission the same week.

0 coins

Thirty years of construction, done workers' comp claims, done SDI claims. Workers' comp sends you to their doctor. SDI uses yours. Never once did EDD schedule any kind of exam on my behalf.

0 coins

Same on my end. Twelve years in the warehouse, two SDI claims, never had EDD send me anywhere.

0 coins

This is probably the most direct answer to my original question. Thank you for that.

0 coins

been on sdi three times over the years for different things. edd never sent me to anyone. your own doctor handles all of it.

0 coins

Three times and no independent exam once. That's pretty definitive.

0 coins

Doctor's office just sent me a message saying they submitted the certification this morning. So now I wait for EDD to process it and hopefully the Notice of Computation shows up soon. How long does that usually take after the certification comes in?

0 coins

Most payments go out within two weeks of EDD getting a completed claim. The Notice of Computation usually arrives around the same time or just before the first payment.

0 coins

Okay two weeks from today then I'll start watching for it. And the notice doesn't mean I'm approved, just that it shows what I might get per week?

0 coins

That's right. The Notice of Computation shows the potential weekly and maximum benefit amount based on your wages. It's not a decision on eligibility. Payment showing up is what tells you the claim is moving.

0 coins

Got it. That's a really important distinction. I would've assumed the notice meant everything was finalized.

0 coins

Pretty much everyone here has confirmed the same thing. EDD runs your claim off your provider's certification. The independent exam idea comes from workers' comp territory, not SDI. As long as your surgeon is certified to submit and you got them the receipt number, your end of the claim is done.

0 coins

Genuinely feel a lot better after this whole thread. Receipt number is confirmed, surgeon is on EDD's list, payments are going fine. I think my neighbor just had me spiraling over nothing.

0 coins

Happens to everyone. Workers' comp and SDI sound related but they work really differently.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came in my mail on day eleven after I filed. I nearly panicked because I thought not seeing it in SDI Online meant something was wrong, but it arrived by mail the next morning.

0 coins

EDD mails that notice even if you filed online. It doesn't appear in SDI Online first. Good that you caught that before worrying too much.

0 coins

Nobody mentioned that anywhere in the filing instructions. Would've saved me a few days of checking the portal every hour.

0 coins

workers comp is like a whole lawsuit sometimes. sdi is just paperwork and your doctor clicking submit. completely different vibes

0 coins

That's a reasonable summary actually. SDI is administrative. Workers' comp gets adversarial.

0 coins

Ha, accurate. My back claim on SDI has been pretty low drama compared to what I've heard from people dealing with work injuries.

0 coins

To put the original question to rest: nothing in how EDD runs the SDI program involves sending a claimant to an independent physician. Your own provider's certification is the medical basis for the claim, start to finish. If more time is needed, the same provider submits an extension. EDD doesn't insert a separate examiner into that process.

0 coins

Clear answer, thank you. That's what I needed to hear from someone who actually knows the system.

0 coins

Bookmarking this for my own peace of mind. I've been worried about similar things and this thread answered a lot of it.

0 coins

Glad it helped. File on time, give your doctor the receipt number, and check SDI Online if anything looks off. That covers most of what trips people up.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure