Back to California Disability

Mateo Martinez

How long after SDI payment can determine overpayment and ask for repayment

So I got an overpayment notice in the mail this week and honestly I'm kind of panicking. I was on SDI for about three months earlier this year after a pretty rough recovery from abdominal surgery, and I reported everything I could think of, including the two weeks I did some light desk work part time before my doctor officially cleared me. Now EDD is saying I was overpaid for some of those weeks and I owe money back. What I can't figure out is how long after SDI payment can determine overpayment and ask for repayment? Like is there a window, or can they come after you years later? And does appealing it do anything or is it basically already decided once you get that notice?

Getting one of those notices out of nowhere is genuinely unsettling, so I understand the worry. The notice itself, the one that says you owe money back, should have an appeal deadline on it. EDD's rule is 30 days from the date printed on the notice to file an appeal using the Appeal Form, DE 1000A. If you've already passed that date you can still appeal but you'd need to explain why it was late, and an administrative law judge looks at that reason. So the first thing to do is find that date on your notice and count your days.

0 coins

The notice came Saturday so I still have time, I think. Does filing the appeal stop them from trying to collect while it's pending?

0 coins

EDD's official materials don't spell that out the way you're hoping. File the appeal right away and include your pay stubs and anything showing what you reported during those weeks. That documentation is what actually matters at the hearing.

0 coins

Not sure if this helps but I think you send the appeal to the address on the notice itself, not EDD's main address? At least that's what I've read.

0 coins

That's right. EDD's instructions say to mail it to the return address on the notice. The DE 1000A has a spot for your explanation; a detailed letter works too if you've misplaced the form.

0 coins

I went through almost this exact mess last spring. Worked a few hours a week from home while still on SDI and thought I was doing everything right by reporting it. Got the overpayment notice about four months after my last payment. Nobody at EDD could tell me how far back they can go because the phone line either rings into nothing or hangs up after the hold music stops. What's the point of a customer service number if you can't reach a human.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my stack around the same time I got hit with an overpayment question on my own claim. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what finally got me to an actual EDD agent. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the DE 2593 had been received and marked complete, which settled one part of my issue right there. Video on getting a live person on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

I've tried that line before the sun comes up and at four in the afternoon and it still cuts me off. How is some service going to do better than me sitting there hitting redial for two hours straight? I'm genuinely asking.

0 coins

You just end up talking to an EDD agent, that's what happened for me. I didn't do anything except answer my phone when they were on the line. The agent confirmed my DE 2593 status and then I could move on.

0 coins

I had the DE 2525XX extension issue going on the same week and also used Claimyr. The agent told me the extension form had been received but not yet matched to my claim ID. That was actually useful to know because I'd been assuming it just hadn't arrived.

0 coins

Fine, I'll try it. Still annoyed it takes a third-party service to have a normal conversation with a state agency but I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

The part about how far back EDD can go is worth looking at carefully. EDD's own materials don't publish a hard cutoff window the way some people assume. What they do say is that an overpayment notice comes with an appeal deadline of 30 days from the issue date. That doesn't mean EDD only has 30 days to find an overpayment; it means you have 30 days to dispute one once you're notified. For payments from several months ago showing up now, that is apparently within normal range based on what other people have reported here.

0 coins

So there's no limit at all on how far back they can go? That's pretty stressful to hear.

0 coins

EDD's published rules don't state a specific lookback window. What matters most right now is your 30-day appeal deadline from the notice date.

0 coins

Sounds about right. EDD is slow to pay and apparently faster than you'd expect to ask for it back.

0 coins

My cousin got one of these notices about six months after her last SDI payment. She thought the same thing you do, that maybe it was too late for them to ask. Nope. She ended up appealing with her pay stubs from those weeks and it actually went better than she expected. The key was she had written proof of exactly what she reported and when.

0 coins

Pay stubs and what I reported online, is that enough to bring to an appeal?

0 coins

That's what she brought. Plus the original confirmation emails from when she certified. Anything that shows what you told EDD at the time.

0 coins

Keeping those confirmation records is so easy to forget when you're just trying to get through a recovery. Good reminder for anyone still on a claim right now.

0 coins

The overpayment notice is actually a Notice of Determination, the DE 2517. Had one myself and sat on it too long thinking I could figure it out without calling. Don't do that.

0 coins

Did you end up appealing it? What was the outcome?

0 coins

Appealed it, yes. Took a while but the judge reviewed my hours reporting and adjusted the amount. File the appeal, don't ignore the notice.

0 coins

Didn't know that was the actual form name. Good to know.

0 coins

wait so they can just decide you owe money like months later and theres nothing you can do except appeal? that seems wild

0 coins

The appeal is actually meaningful if you have documentation. It goes to an administrative law judge who looks at both sides, so it's not just EDD deciding again on its own.

0 coins

ok that makes it sound less hopeless i guess

0 coins

Appealing is worth it if the amount is wrong. If the amount is correct and you just don't want to pay it, the appeal probably won't go your way.

0 coins

Mine might actually be wrong. I think they counted a week I reported partial hours as a full week of benefits. Would that be enough to appeal?

0 coins

Yes, that's exactly the kind of discrepancy worth appealing. Bring whatever you have showing what you reported that week.

0 coins

Pull your certification records from SDI Online if you can still access that claim. That's your clearest paper trail for what you submitted at the time.

0 coins

ugh this thread is too real. i got hit with an overpayment thing after my knee surgery claim and it took forever to sort out. partially because i couldn't figure out if i was supposed to appeal or just pay it and then ask for a correction, anyway

0 coins

For anyone in that situation, appeal first if you think the amount is wrong. Paying it doesn't waive your right to dispute, but appealing within that 30-day window is the cleaner path.

0 coins

wish someone had told me that at the time. i just paid it and then tried to argue after, which was a whole extra headache.

0 coins

I'm not sure about this but I think if you're still on a claim and you get an overpayment notice at the same time, EDD can deduct from your ongoing payments? Has anyone dealt with that?

0 coins

That can happen. EDD's materials mention offset of ongoing benefits. It's one more reason to appeal right away if you disagree with the overpayment amount, because the appeal creates a formal record of your dispute.

0 coins

That's actually what I was afraid of. Good to know the appeal covers that side of it too.

0 coins

Notice of Determination on my claim last year had a number I was pretty sure wasn't right. Getting anyone to explain how they calculated it was a whole other battle. Ended up reaching a live EDD agent through Claimyr. The agent looked at the specific weeks flagged on my claim and read back the payment amounts EDD had on record for each one, so I could compare them to what I had.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Never heard of it.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's disability line for you, your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's about all there is to it.

0 coins

Huh. My Notice of Determination has an amount I want to question too. Might actually be useful for that.

0 coins

Glad you got through. Those week-by-week breakdowns are hard to piece together without an agent pulling the actual file.

0 coins

For the original poster: when you file the DE 1000A, write out the specific weeks you're disputing and the hours you reported for each. The more specific the better. Vague explanations don't give the judge much to work with.

0 coins

Should I include copies of my pay stubs even if the amounts are small?

0 coins

Yes. Even small amounts matter because the dispute is about whether EDD's calculation was accurate for each week, not just the total.

0 coins

Print everything. Judges apparently like having actual paper in front of them rather than just verbal explanations.

0 coins

People forget that the appeal isn't just 'please forgive this debt.' It's a formal process where you're saying EDD's math was wrong or EDD didn't apply its own rules correctly. That's a real argument and it has a real chance if you have the receipts.

0 coins

That framing actually helps me think about it differently. I do have records, I was really careful about what I reported.

0 coins

Then put it all together and send it in. Date on the notice starts the clock.

0 coins

For what it's worth, I appealed an overpayment notice a couple of years back and it was way less scary than I expected! The hearing was just me explaining what I'd reported and showing my documentation. The judge was straightforward.

0 coins

The word 'hearing' makes me nervous. Is it in person?

0 coins

Mine was by phone! And it was way shorter than I thought it would be. Have your paperwork in front of you and you'll be fine.

0 coins

I didn't realize it could be a phone hearing. That's a little less intimidating than showing up somewhere.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up was thinking the waiting period days counted against an overpayment calculation. They don't, the first seven days of a claim are non-payable no matter what, so if EDD is counting those as overpaid that would be worth flagging in the appeal.

0 coins

That's actually a good catch. The waiting period is never a payable benefit period so it can't be an overpayment for those days.

0 coins

Mine started on a Monday, so the first week was split across the waiting period. I'll double check if they included any of those days.

0 coins

Look at exactly which week numbers the notice says were overpaid. If week one or two is on there, count the days and see if the waiting period overlaps.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim was mismatched for almost two weeks before I even knew. The agent I eventually spoke with through Claimyr checked and confirmed the medical certification was sitting unattached in the system. They told me which receipt number my provider had used so I could get the office to refile it correctly.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself around the same time for a payment method question. The agent confirmed my direct deposit election had been processed and told me which payment cycle it would apply to first. Useful to hear it straight from EDD instead of guessing.

0 coins

Did they say how long it would take to show up after that?

0 coins

No specific timeline, just that the election was in the system. I watched SDI Online and it updated within that pay cycle.

0 coins

the receipt number thing is such a small detail that causes so many problems

0 coins

File the appeal. Keep it factual. Bring your pay stubs, your certification records, and a written note of what you reported for each disputed week.

0 coins

Is there anything I should NOT include? Like letters from my employer or doctor?

0 coins

Nothing wrong with including them if they support your reporting. A note from your employer confirming your hours during those weeks could actually help.

0 coins

The confusion about what counts as 'going back to work' comes up a lot in these situations. Part-time hours during a disability period aren't automatically disqualifying, but EDD needs to know about them to calculate correctly. If you reported them and EDD still paid you the full amount, that's EDD's calculation error, not yours, and that matters for the appeal.

0 coins

I reported every single hour. The issue might be that EDD still paid me the full weekly amount instead of a reduced one. So the error would be on their end?

0 coins

That's worth making very clear in your appeal. You reported it, EDD issued the payment anyway. The question of how a partial week is paid is EDD's calculation to make, not yours to guess at ahead of time.

0 coins

Document when exactly you submitted that reporting too, not just what it said. If the timestamp predates the payment, that's your strongest argument.

0 coins

been trying to get through to edd for three days on a separate issue. the line just plays music for 40 minutes and disconnects. i feel this whole thread in my bones

0 coins

Three days is nothing, I hit a week once. The disconnect after all that hold time is a special kind of frustrating.

0 coins

at least it's not just me. starting to wonder if anyone actually answers

0 coins

One thing worth checking on the Notice of Determination: it should show the specific weeks EDD says are overpaid and the amounts for each. If any week listed doesn't match your own records of what you were paid and what you reported, note that discrepancy explicitly in the DE 1000A. Vague appeals don't help judges the way week-by-week specifics do.

0 coins

Agreed. The cleaner the breakdown by week, the easier it is for the judge to follow.

0 coins

Makes sense. Too much narrative and not enough numbers probably loses them.

0 coins

Payment date questions also trip people up with overpayments. SDI Online shows when each payment was issued but not always what exact weeks it covers. If you're trying to reconcile the notice amounts against your own records, the payment information line at 1-800-480-3287 can read back payment specifics by week. I actually used Claimyr to get through on that line about a payment's date and the agent confirmed exactly which benefit weeks the payment I received covered, which helped me sort out a discrepancy.

0 coins

Wait, you got through on that number? I've been trying for a week and nothing. How is that even possible, did you just get lucky or is that actually a service?

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first saw Claimyr mentioned somewhere. Sounded like it was just someone's ad. But a friend of mine who was completely stuck on her extension paperwork tried it and said she talked to an actual EDD person. The agent told her the DE 2525XX had been received and what period it covered. So it's real.

0 coins

Okay, the extension thing especially. I've got a date question on my own claim I've been trying to get answered. I'll give it a try.

0 coins

The payment date breakdown by week is actually really helpful to know about. I want to match each payment to the weeks on my overpayment notice before I write up the appeal.

0 coins

For the original poster, once you get the week-by-week payment breakdown sorted, write your appeal as a simple timeline: week by week, what you reported, what EDD paid, and where the two don't match what the notice claims. That format makes it easy for a judge to follow and hard to dismiss.

0 coins

That's the clearest way I've seen it laid out. Week by week, what I reported, what was paid, what the notice says. I can do that.

0 coins

And attach copies of everything behind that timeline. The documentation is what turns an appeal from a complaint into a case.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure