Back to California Disability

Cynthia Love

How is disability calculated in California? What actually goes into your SDI amount

Okay so I've been out of work for about three weeks now after a procedure on my shoulder that went longer than expected recovery-wise. My surgeon cleared me for light activity but said I definitely can't go back to my actual job for at least another month. I filed my SDI claim through SDI Online pretty quickly after and my doctor submitted the medical certification within the first week, so that part went smoothly. The Notice of Computation showed up and I just stared at it because I genuinely don't understand how they came up with the number on there. It's lower than I expected based on my salary. I make decent money during the season but I had a slower stretch last spring which I guess might be dragging things down? I work in event production so my income is all over the place depending on the month. I don't know if EDD looked at my best months or just averaged everything. Can anyone break down how the weekly benefit amount actually gets calculated? Like which paychecks are they even looking at?

Waiting period confusion nearly cost me a week of benefits on my own claim, so let me share what I found out. I assumed the seven days at the start were just EDD processing time and that I'd get paid for them once everything was approved. Nope, those seven days are genuinely unpaid no matter what, it's built into every new DI claim and you don't get that money back. I ended up calling EDD because I couldn't tell from SDI Online whether my waiting period had actually been counted correctly from my claim start date. The SDI Online screens weren't giving me enough detail. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to a live person on the disability line without spending all morning redialing. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed exactly which seven days had been designated as my waiting period and when my first payable day was. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Knowing that cleared up why my first payment was smaller than the full two-week amount I'd been expecting.

0 coins

I had it backwards too, thought the waiting period was just how long EDD takes to review things. Finding out it's a permanent unpaid gap, not a delay, changed how I planned my finances at the start of my leave.

0 coins

Wait so the first seven days are just always gone no matter what? That's frustrating but good to know. I was already confused about the amount on my Notice of Computation so I hadn't even gotten to thinking about the waiting period yet.

0 coins

Yeah the waiting period is not the same as processing time. EDD pays from day eight forward, so your first real payment covers days eight through whenever your first certification period ends.

0 coins

My paperwork said the same thing and I completely ignored it the first time I read it. Had to have someone explain it to me the same way before it clicked.

0 coins

The base period thing was what tripped me up when I got my Notice of Computation. I thought EDD looked at my last twelve months of work, but that's not how it works. They pull wages from a specific twelve-month window that ends several months before your claim actually starts, divided into four quarters, and they use the single highest-paid quarter of those four to figure out your weekly benefit amount. So if you had a strong quarter in there, that one carries a lot of weight. If your best earnings happened to fall outside that window, they won't count at all.

0 coins

Okay this is exactly what I needed to hear. So the base period might completely miss my busiest season depending on when it falls? That would explain the number on my notice being lower than I expected.

0 coins

Yep and that tripped me up the same way. My highest earning months happened to land just outside the base period they used and my benefit was noticeably lower than I'd hoped for. EDD's disability calculator on their site can show you the estimate before you even file if you punch in your quarterly wages.

0 coins

I'm going to try that calculator now. I wish I'd done that before the claim so I'd have been mentally prepared for the number.

0 coins

The 70 to 90 percent range confused me too when I first saw it. Higher earners relative to their wage history get closer to 70 and lower earners get closer to 90, but the exact percentage depends on where your highest quarter falls on EDD's schedule. Your Notice of Computation is the actual answer, the calculator just estimates it.

0 coins

Event production income being uneven is exactly the scenario where the base period math can really surprise you. If your highest quarter is inside the base period window, great. If the quieter spring stretch you mentioned lands in the wrong spot it can drag the number down even though you've had strong seasons overall. The benefit isn't based on your average across all your work, just that one best quarter inside a fixed lookback window.

0 coins

The spring I mentioned was probably one of the four quarters they're looking at then. That would make a lot of sense for why the number came out lower.

0 coins

I work freelance in a similar situation and the quarterly variation really does matter. My claim ended up being based on a quarter where I'd had a lot of one-time project income and it worked in my favor that time, but I could easily see it going the other way in a different year.

0 coins

Does EDD ever use a different period if your base period wages are really low? Like is there a fallback?

0 coins

EDD has an alternate base period option if you don't have enough wages in the standard one to qualify, but the standard calculation uses that four-quarter lookback window. If you think EDD used the wrong quarters you can ask them directly. The notice itself shows the wages they found, so compare that to your actual pay records first.

0 coins

The 70 to 90 percent range threw me off when I was reading about this before I filed. I kept seeing people say 'you get about 60 percent of your wages' online and that's just wrong for California SDI. It's 70 to 90 percent of that highest quarter, and lower-income claimants get closer to the higher end. Someone corrected me on this exact point in another thread and I'm glad they did.

0 coins

I saw that same wrong number floating around and believed it for a while. The actual range is higher than a lot of generic 'disability insurance' articles say because they're mixing up different states or different programs.

0 coins

I definitely read something that said 55 or 60 percent somewhere. Good to know that was just bad information.

0 coins

California SDI is generally more generous than a lot of people expect, which is why the numbers on generic sites are so off. The Notice of Computation is the only real answer for your specific situation.

0 coins

The part about at least $300 in SDI-taxed wages being needed during the base period is worth knowing too. If someone had a gap in employment or worked a job that didn't take out the CASDI deduction, they might not qualify at all. For most W-2 employees it's not an issue, but gig workers or people who had a stretch of contract work sometimes get surprised.

0 coins

I had no idea CASDI was even on my paystub until I filed. I'd been seeing that deduction for years and just never looked at what it was.

0 coins

Exactly, that deduction is what funds the whole SDI system. If a job wasn't taking it out, those wages don't count toward the base period calculation.

0 coins

Mine has always been W-2 so I think I'm fine on that front. I can see on my paystubs that CASDI was coming out every period.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone who works seasonally or in variable-income industries like event production: the base period calculation can feel really arbitrary when your income doesn't follow a smooth pattern. The flip side is if you had one monster quarter in there, it can actually work in your favor compared to someone with the same annual income spread evenly across all four quarters.

0 coins

That's an interesting way to frame it. I guess I'd rather have one huge quarter than four medium ones if the math only uses the best single quarter.

0 coins

Exactly right. The single-quarter approach is a feature if you've had one really big stretch, it's just a problem when that big stretch happened to fall outside the lookback window.

0 coins

I never thought about it working in someone's favor. I always assumed the uneven income was a disadvantage.

0 coins

Does the SDI calculation change at all if you go back to work part time partway through the claim? Like if someone starts doing partial weeks, does EDD recalculate the weekly benefit amount or is it fixed once the Notice of Computation is issued?

0 coins

The weekly benefit amount itself is fixed once your Notice of Computation is issued, that's set by the base period wages. What changes when you work part time is how much EDD pays you for that specific week, since you'd be earning some wages. You're supposed to report any work to EDD. How a partial week gets calculated is EDD's call.

0 coins

Got it so the base rate doesn't move, but what actually gets paid in a given week accounts for what I earned that week. I'll make sure I report everything if I end up doing any consulting while I'm out.

0 coins

Reporting the partial work is important. The overpayment notices that come later when someone didn't report are a bigger headache than just being transparent about it at the time.

0 coins

My benefit amount looked off to me too and I eventually phoned EDD to ask which base period quarter they'd used. The quarter they had on file matched my records but the wages for one of the months inside it were lower than what I'd actually earned. Ended up being a discrepancy between what my employer had reported to EDD and what my own pay stubs showed. The agent told me exactly which quarter had been used for the calculation and what wage figure they had for it. Got that corrected and my benefit amount updated on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

That's worth me double checking. I haven't compared the wages on my Notice of Computation to my actual pay stubs yet. I should do that.

0 coins

Employer wage reporting errors are more common than people think. Always worth pulling out your pay stubs and checking what EDD has on file for the base period quarters.

0 coins

I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach EDD because I'd spent two mornings dialing the disability line with no luck. The agent looked up which quarter had been used and what wages were on record for it. Having the actual numbers from EDD let me go back to my employer's payroll department with something specific to point to.

0 coins

The fact that you caught that discrepancy is huge. I would not have thought to compare my pay stubs to what EDD reported.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question? If EDD uses your highest quarter, do they tell you which one it was on the Notice of Computation? Or do you have to calculate it yourself from all four quarters?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows the wages EDD has on record for the base period, so you can see the quarterly breakdown. It's not always immediately obvious which quarter 'won' but you can see the numbers and the resulting weekly benefit amount. If it doesn't match your records, that's when you'd contact EDD.

0 coins

Okay I was overthinking it. I'll just read the notice more carefully.

0 coins

The notice is actually more useful than it looks at first glance. Take time to go through each line and compare it against what you know you earned.

0 coins

Does SDI ever look at tips or cash income? I have a friend who does a lot of shifts where tips make up most of what they actually take home but their base wage is low.

0 coins

Only wages that had the CASDI deduction taken out count toward the base period. If the tips weren't reported as wages and no CASDI was withheld on them, they wouldn't be part of the SDI calculation.

0 coins

That's what I figured but I wanted to confirm. So basically the SDI math only knows about wages EDD can see through the tax and payroll system.

0 coins

Right. The SDI system is built around reported, taxed wages. Under-the-table income isn't in the picture no matter how significant it was to what someone actually lived on.

0 coins

I was also confused about whether the 52-week maximum meant 52 weeks of full payments or something else. My claim is for a pretty serious situation and my doctor thinks recovery could take longer than a few months.

0 coins

The 52 weeks is the maximum duration for a single DI claim, so if you need more time you'd be working with extensions through your doctor, not filing a brand new claim. For anything beyond 52 weeks you'd want to ask EDD about options specific to your situation.

0 coins

Okay so extensions stay on the same claim rather than starting over. That's less paperwork at least.

0 coins

Extensions are handled through a form your doctor completes and submits to EDD, it's called the DE 2525XX. EDD typically sends it along with the final payment notice so your doctor knows one is coming.

0 coins

Good to know the form has a name, I can ask my doctor's office to watch for it.

0 coins

I keep reading conflicting things about whether SDI benefits are taxable. Some sites say yes, some say no. Can anyone clear this up?

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits at the state level. Whether they're taxable at the federal level depends on your specific situation and there are a few factors involved. EDD has tax information on their site, and a tax professional is the right person to answer the federal question for your circumstances.

0 coins

Okay, so definitely not taxed by California but the federal side is more complicated. I'll ask my tax person in the spring.

0 coins

Worth asking early so you're not scrambling. Some people are surprised when they go to file and have questions about what they received during the year.

0 coins

I want to flag something about the pregnancy claim calculation in case anyone reading this is in that situation. The timing of your claim start date relative to the base period can really matter for pregnancy leave since your work history might have been affected by earlier complications or reduced hours. The SDI math is the same, it's still the highest quarter in the base period, but when you file and what your earnings looked like in the months before can affect things.

0 coins

This is actually really helpful. I'm planning to file in a few months for maternity leave and I hadn't thought about how my hours reduction now might affect the base period calculation.

0 coins

The base period looks back to wages from several months before the claim, so recent hours reductions affect your current paycheck but the quarters that actually count in the calculation are the ones from that earlier lookback window. EDD's calculator on their site can show you an estimate if you plug in your quarterly wages.

0 coins

I'm going to run those numbers tonight. I'd rather know now than be surprised when my notice arrives.

0 coins

Payment method question tripped me up. I'd been expecting a Bank of America card like a friend had used for unemployment years ago and was confused when I got something different. EDD's disability payments now go onto a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you set up direct deposit in SDI Online when you filed. I ended up calling EDD because I didn't know if my payment had been issued or if something had gone wrong since I wasn't seeing what I expected. I had a hard time getting through on the disability line and went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach an agent. The agent confirmed my payment had been issued to the Money Network card and gave me the date it was sent.

0 coins

The Bank of America card is old news for unemployment too. EDD moved to Money Network across the board.

0 coins

I actually went into SDI Online when I filed and set up direct deposit, so I haven't had to deal with the card at all. Good call doing that upfront if you're able to.

0 coins

I'll remember to set up direct deposit if I ever file. The card situation always seems to cause confusion.

0 coins

Direct deposit in SDI Online is definitely the cleaner option. I wish I'd done it at filing instead of ending up with the card situation.

0 coins

The DE 2593 caught me completely off guard about five weeks into my claim. EDD sent this questionnaire asking whether I was still unable to work, and I didn't realize there was a deadline to send it back. Almost lost benefits because I sat on it thinking it was just informational paperwork.

0 coins

Twenty days is the window on that one. It's easy to miss because it doesn't look as urgent as the initial claim forms, but EDD stops payments if it doesn't come back in time.

0 coins

I had no idea there was a time limit on it. The form itself should have a bigger warning honestly.

0 coins

That form shows up around ten weeks in, after EDD has issued five payments under automatic payment. If you're not on automatic payment you'd be getting a DE 2500A every two weeks instead, which keeps you more actively in the loop.

0 coins

This is the kind of thing nobody tells you at the start. Good to know before it's a problem.

0 coins

Medical certification being unmatched was what held up my claim for almost two weeks. My physical therapist had filled out some paperwork for me but the SDI system wasn't accepting it. Called EDD and the agent told me right away that physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD after spending several days failing to reach anyone on the disability line. The agent confirmed no valid medical certification had been received yet and that I needed a physician, nurse practitioner, or another provider on EDD's approved list to certify it instead. Had my doctor's office submit the actual certification and the claim moved within days.

0 coins

I did not know physical therapists couldn't certify. I would have assumed any licensed medical professional could do it.

0 coins

Who else can do it besides a regular doctor? I have an NP I see more than my actual physician.

0 coins

Nurse practitioners are on EDD's approved list, so your NP can certify. The list also includes physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, and psychologists, among others. It's pretty broad, just not physical therapists.

0 coins

Physical therapist being left off is surprising to me. They deal with recovery and injury constantly.

0 coins

The list is based on who's licensed to certify a diagnosis and functional limitation, not just who treats the condition. Physical therapists work within what a physician orders, which is probably why they're not independent certifiers for SDI purposes.

0 coins

Is there a way to estimate what your SDI benefit would be before you actually need to file? Like for financial planning purposes?

0 coins

EDD has a disability benefits calculator on their site. You'd enter your quarterly wages from your base period and it gives you an estimate. It won't be exact since the real number depends on what EDD has on record from your employer, but it gets you in the ballpark.

0 coins

That's really useful to know. I'd want to plan ahead rather than get a surprise notice after I've already committed to taking leave.

0 coins

Running the calculator before you need to file is genuinely smart. I wish I'd done it earlier and adjusted my savings buffer accordingly.

0 coins

My HR department told me that SDI and my employer's short-term disability policy might overlap and I might not get both. Has anyone dealt with sorting out how those two interact?

0 coins

How SDI interacts with an employer's own plan depends on what kind of plan it is and how it's set up, that's really a question for HR and EDD. What I'd say is file your SDI claim regardless and let EDD and your HR department work out the coordination. Don't assume one cancels out the other without asking both.

0 coins

Okay, so just file and ask questions rather than waiting to understand the full picture first. That makes sense.

0 coins

Filing late can get you disqualified if you miss the 49-day window from your disability start date. File first and sort out the coordination after, 49 days goes faster than it sounds.

0 coins

What happens if you disagree with the benefit amount on your Notice of Computation? Like if you think EDD used the wrong wages?

0 coins

Start by comparing the wages on your notice against your own pay stubs for each of the base period quarters. If there's a discrepancy, contact EDD with your documentation. If EDD issued a decision you disagree with, you can appeal it, the notice will have an appeal form included and you'd have 30 days from the date on the notice to file it.

0 coins

So I should do my own math first before calling, then reach out if the numbers don't match. Got it.

0 coins

Bring your actual pay stubs or W-2 information when you contact EDD. Having the documentation ready makes the conversation much more productive.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD reach out to verify employment or wages during the claim? I got a letter asking me to submit some pay records and I wasn't sure if that was routine or a sign something was flagged on my claim.

0 coins

EDD does verify wages in some cases, especially when the employer's reported amounts don't match what EDD expects. It's not necessarily a problem with your claim, they just need to reconcile the numbers. Send exactly what they asked for and nothing extra.

0 coins

Okay that's reassuring. I was worried it meant my claim was about to be denied. I'll pull together the pay records they asked for.

0 coins

Respond to any EDD request quickly and within the timeframe on the letter. Letting those requests sit is what turns a routine verification into a delayed or denied payment.

0 coins

Makes sense. The letter had a date so I'll make sure I'm well within it.

0 coins

Does filing a DI claim affect your unemployment eligibility later? Like once you're recovered and able to work again?

0 coins

DI and unemployment are separate. DI is for when you can't work, unemployment is for when you can work but don't have a job. Once you're recovered and available for work again, you can file for unemployment if you need it. EDD handles both programs but they're completely independent claims.

0 coins

That's what I figured but I wanted to hear it confirmed. Good to know one doesn't cancel out your eligibility for the other later.

0 coins

The key thing is you can't collect both at the same time for the same days. EDD's rule is you can't receive unemployment and disability for overlapping days.

0 coins

For what it's worth, once you understand the base period and highest-quarter approach the Notice of Computation actually makes a lot more sense. It still might not be the number you wanted but at least you can see the logic. I went through this twice and the second time I understood it well enough to actually verify that EDD got it right before I even called.

0 coins

Yeah I think I'm getting there. I know enough now to actually audit my own notice instead of just being confused by it. Going to compare those quarterly wages tonight.

0 coins

EDD's calculator is also worth bookmarking for future reference. Even after a claim closes it's useful to know how to run the estimate if your work situation changes.

0 coins

This thread ended up being way more informative than the EDD website honestly. I came in confused about basic terms and now I actually understand what the notice is telling me.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure