How does SDI calculate benefits — what actually goes into the number?
Okay so I've been out of work for about three weeks now after a pretty rough abdominal surgery and I finally got my claim moving, got the medical certification in from my surgeon's office, and then this Notice of Computation showed up in the mail. I was expecting a certain amount based on what I earn and honestly the number on the notice threw me off a little. I make decent money but the weekly benefit amount on there felt lower than I thought it would be. I work in restaurant management so my pay varies a lot depending on bonuses and slow seasons and stuff like that. Does anyone actually understand how EDD lands on that weekly number? I know it has something to do with your past wages but I couldn't really follow the calculation when I tried to look it up. Like which paychecks are they even looking at? Is it your most recent earnings or something from further back? And does the percentage they pay you change based on how much you made? I feel like I've seen different numbers thrown around online and I can't figure out what's accurate for California SDI specifically.
83 comments

Monique Byrd
Start date on your claim matters a lot more than most people realize — which quarter they anchor the base period to depends on when your disability actually began, not when you filed. My claim start date was off by a week in the system and it shifted which quarter they used to calculate my benefit amount. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD disability agent about it. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which quarter was showing as my highest-paid one and what the start date had been entered as, and I was able to tell them the correct date. That cleared up why my Notice of Computation looked the way it did.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorWait, the start date affects which quarter they look at? Can you explain that more — like does one week's difference actually change the whole base period window?
0 coins
Monique Byrd
Exactly that. The base period is a 12-month window made up of four quarters, and EDD works backward from your claim start date to set that window. If your start date slips even slightly, the window shifts and the highest-paid quarter inside it can change. For you, with variable income from bonuses and slow seasons, that could mean a meaningful difference in your weekly amount.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Had no idea the start date had that kind of ripple effect. Assumed it was just about when payments began, not about which wages they look at.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
The percentage piece you're asking about — EDD doesn't pay everyone the same share of their wages. People with lower earnings get a higher percentage of their wages replaced, and people who earned more get a somewhat lower percentage, though still a significant chunk. The range EDD publishes is roughly 70 to 90 percent of wages from that base period quarter, and your Notice of Computation is what tells you where your specific amount landed. The calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate if you want to check the math before calling anyone.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorSo the percentage sliding based on income level is an actual EDD policy thing, not just something people assume?
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Yes, it's how DI is structured in California. It's meant to replace more of a lower earner's income proportionally. The notice you got will show the weekly benefit amount they computed — that's the actual number for your claim, the calculator is just for estimates.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
Didn't realize it scaled like that. I always heard it was just 60 percent flat and wondered why my amount seemed higher than that when I had a claim a couple years ago.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
The 60 percent figure is old and still floats around online. EDD moved to the tiered percentage system a while back. For most claimants it's somewhere in that 70-to-90 range depending on where your wages fall.
0 coins
Asher Levin
Restaurant pay with bonuses complicates it because EDD uses the single highest-paid quarter out of a 12-month base period — four consecutive quarters — and bonuses can make one quarter look really different from another. If your biggest bonus quarter happened to fall outside the base period window, your benefit amount would be lower than you'd expect looking at your total annual earnings.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorThat's probably exactly what happened — I had a really good bonus quarter late last year that might not be in the window they used. How would I even know which quarter they picked?
0 coins
Asher Levin
The Notice of Computation should give you enough information to work backward and figure out which quarter they used. If it's still not clear, you can ask EDD directly through the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online.
0 coins
Serene Snow
Same thing happened to me with tips included in some quarters and not others. The highest quarter thing can really land differently than you expect when your income isn't steady.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
Is the base period always exactly 12 months or does it depend on when you file? I've seen people say 5 to 18 months back and that confused me.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
The 5-to-18-month language describes the range of how far back the base period can reach, depending on your claim start date. The base period itself is always four consecutive quarters — 12 months — but which 12 months those are shifts based on when your disability started. The 18-month end of that range accounts for a quarter that may not be fully reported yet when you file.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
Okay that actually makes sense now. So 5 to 18 months is describing the span of the window, not the length of it.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Exactly right.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
The $300 minimum in SDI-taxed wages during the base period is worth knowing about too. If someone had a gap in work or a lot of untaxed income during those four quarters, their claim might not be payable at all, not just lower than expected. For most W-2 workers it's not an issue but for anyone with unusual employment history it's worth verifying.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
Does gig work count toward that? I freelance part time and have a regular job but I don't know if the freelance income has SDI taken out.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
Whether SDI is withheld from your freelance income depends on how you're classified and whether you opted into the SDI elective coverage as a self-employed person. W-2 wages with the CASDI deduction on your paystubs count automatically; freelance 1099 income typically doesn't unless you enrolled separately. EDD's site has information on the elective coverage option.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
Okay I'll check my paystubs from the regular job, that should be enough to clear the minimum. The freelance side is pretty small.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
Can I ask something that's maybe off topic — does the SDI benefit count as taxable income? My coworker told me California doesn't tax it but she wasn't sure about federal.
0 coins
Asher Levin
Your coworker is right that California doesn't tax SDI benefits. The federal side is less clear-cut and depends on your specific situation — EDD has a tax information page and that's really where you'd want to look, or ask a tax professional for your own case. Not something anyone here can answer with certainty.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
Fair enough, I'll check the EDD page. Just wanted to make sure I wasn't going to get hit with a surprise bill.
0 coins
Alana Willis
I worried about the same thing on my claim last year. The EDD tax info page was actually pretty clear for the California piece, the federal part I ended up asking my accountant about.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
For anyone confused about the waiting period — I mixed this up at first and thought the seven-day wait was processing time EDD was taking, but it's not that at all. It's just the first seven days of the claim that are non-payable no matter what. Your first actual benefit payment covers day eight and onward. Processing time on top of that is a separate thing.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorI did mix those two things up initially. So even if EDD processes everything instantly, those first seven days still wouldn't be paid?
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
Right, it's built into every new DI claim. No matter how fast the certification comes in or how quickly EDD processes it, days one through seven just aren't covered. Day eight is the earliest any payment can be for.
0 coins
Sara Unger
I told my sister the waiting period was just slow processing and she was really confused when her first check was less than expected. This clears it up for me too.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
Pretty common mix-up. The name 'waiting period' makes it sound like you're waiting for EDD to do something, but it's just an unpaid window at the start of every claim.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
My situation was a little different and I want to flag something for people with fluctuating income. I work in events and had one monster quarter followed by two really slow ones. The benefit amount EDD computed was based on that high quarter, which actually worked in my favor — I was surprised it came out higher than I expected rather than lower. The key was that the high quarter fell inside the base period window.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorSo the system actually can work in someone's favor if the timing lines up? I think my issue is the opposite, my good quarter probably just missed the window.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
Yep it really is about timing. If you can figure out from your Notice of Computation which quarter they used and you think a better quarter is just outside it, it's worth asking EDD to verify the start date is recorded correctly, like the first comment in this thread mentioned.
0 coins
Freya Ross
Notice of Computation on my claim showed a weekly amount that seemed low, and I couldn't figure out if they'd used the right quarter. The agent I reached confirmed the exact quarter they'd pulled and what wages were on file for it, which turned out to match my own records. I'd used Claimyr to get on the line with someone at EDD disability because every time I called on my own I hit a recording and got nowhere. Once I had the agent on, I also asked about my maximum benefit — they read me the total off the notice and explained it's the weekly amount times up to 52 weeks, subject to whatever period my doctor certifies.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorDid the agent explain how to dispute the amount if you thought the wages on file were wrong?
0 coins
Freya Ross
She said to gather whatever wage records I had — W-2s, paystubs — and contact EDD in writing through SDI Online if the number didn't match. The Request Claim Update option in the portal is the way to do it.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
52 weeks total is a lot longer than I thought DI could last. I always assumed it was way shorter.
0 coins
Freya Ross
Most people's claims end before that — a typical recovery or pregnancy claim is a fraction of that. But yes, 52 weeks is the ceiling for DI benefits on one claim.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
Does the 52-week max reset if you have a new disability later? Like if I used some weeks this year and then got hurt again next year, would I start fresh?
0 coins
Asher Levin
A new disability that's unrelated to the current one and meets the filing requirements would be a new claim, so yes, you'd have a fresh 52-week maximum for that claim. The 52 weeks applies per claim, not as some kind of lifetime cap.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
That's a relief. I had a knee thing earlier this year and I'm now dealing with something separate and was nervous about being close to some limit.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
For the restaurant management situation specifically — are quarterly bonuses considered wages for the SDI calculation, or does EDD treat them differently than regular salary?
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
Bonuses paid through regular payroll with SDI withheld show up in your quarterly wages just like salary does. If the CASDI deduction is on those bonus paystubs, that money counts. The question is just which quarter it landed in and whether that quarter is inside your base period.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
Makes sense, so it's not about the type of compensation but whether SDI was actually deducted from it.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
Exactly. The CASDI line on the paystub is what tells you it's being counted.
0 coins
Sara Unger
What about tips? I work at a restaurant too and tips make up a big chunk of what I earn but I don't think SDI is taken out of cash tips.
0 coins
Asher Levin
Reported tips that go through payroll with SDI withheld would count. Cash tips that never hit payroll and don't have CASDI deducted wouldn't be included in the wage calculation. That's worth knowing if tips are a significant part of your income.
0 coins
Sara Unger
Yeah mine are mostly cash. So my benefit could be a lot lower than what I actually make day to day. That's frustrating but good to know before I file.
0 coins
Serene Snow
Same situation here when I had a claim. The benefit amount felt low because cash tips weren't in the calculation. It's one of those things that really stings when you're out and trying to cover rent.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
My claim right now is pending and I haven't gotten the Notice of Computation yet — does the notice always arrive before the first payment, or can the payment show up first?
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Usually the notice comes before the first payment, since it's EDD telling you what they computed. But processing times can vary. If your claim has been pending for more than a couple of weeks after the medical certification was submitted, it's worth checking SDI Online or contacting EDD to make sure nothing is missing on their end.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
Medical certification has been in for 10 days. I'll give it a few more days and then check through the SDI Online portal.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
My notice and first payment showed up almost the same week. Definitely check SDI Online first before calling — sometimes the status updates there before anything arrives in the mail.
0 coins
Alana Willis
When EDD says they look at the highest-paid quarter, is that the highest of the four quarters in the base period, or can they look at earlier quarters if those are higher?
0 coins
Lia Quinn
The base period is four specific quarters set by your claim start date — EDD doesn't go hunting outside that window for a better quarter. The highest-paid one is the highest among those four, not among any quarter in your work history. That's why the start date matters so much, as a few people in this thread have mentioned.
0 coins
Alana Willis
Got it. So if I had a great quarter two years ago it doesn't help me at all.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Not for a claim filed now, no. It would need to fall inside the base period window tied to this claim's start date.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
Can someone clarify — I keep seeing people mention SDI and DI like they're different things. Are they?
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
SDI stands for State Disability Insurance, which is the overall program. DI — Disability Insurance — is the specific benefit inside it that pays you when you can't work because of your own illness, injury, or pregnancy. Paid Family Leave is also part of SDI but it's a separate benefit for bonding or caregiving. Most people say SDI when they mean the DI part, so you'll see the terms used interchangeably in casual conversation even though they're technically different levels.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
Okay so when someone says their SDI claim is pending they almost certainly mean their DI claim.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
In the vast majority of cases, yes. If someone is out for their own health condition and filed for disability benefits, they're on a DI claim under the SDI program.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Genuine question — I thought you had to be completely unable to work to get SDI. My doctor said I could do light duty but not my regular job. Does that count?
0 coins
Asher Levin
Unable to do your regular or customary work is what matters for DI, not whether you could hypothetically do some lighter version of a job. If your doctor certifies that you can't perform your normal duties, that's the standard EDD is looking at. Whether an employer offers you light duty is a separate question.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
That's really helpful to know. I was worried the light duty comment from my doctor would disqualify me.
0 coins
Tyler Murphy
The medical certification is what drives this. As long as your doctor certifies you can't do your regular work, the claim can move forward regardless of what a hypothetical light duty situation might look like.
0 coins
Juan Moreno
Came off my claim last month and want to flag something for people whose claims run a while — around the 10-week mark EDD sent me a form called the DE 2593 asking if I was still unable to work. I almost missed it because it got buried in my mail. If you don't return that within 20 days you lose benefits. Had an issue with which specific weeks had been paid on my claim because a few payments seemed to have skipped, so I used Claimyr to get in touch with an EDD agent to sort it out. The agent went through each week on my file and identified exactly which ones had been issued and which one was still processing.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorTwenty days sounds like a tight window — do they send that at exactly 10 weeks or is it variable?
0 coins
Juan Moreno
EDD sends the DE 2593 after five automatic payments, which is 10 weeks of benefits. If your payment schedule shifts for any reason it might not land exactly at 10 calendar weeks, but roughly around there is when to expect it. Keep an eye on your mail once you're past the first month.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
I didn't even know that form existed. What happens if you get it and you've already gone back to work by then?
0 coins
Juan Moreno
If you've returned to work before the form arrives, you'd report that on the form rather than certifying you're still unable to work. EDD needs to know either way.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
Does SDI affect unemployment at all? Like if my claim ends before I'm cleared to go back to work, can I switch to unemployment while I wait?
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
Unemployment requires you to be able to work and available for work during every week you claim it. If you're still medically unable to work when your DI claim ends, unemployment wouldn't be the right fit yet. Once your doctor clears you to return and you're actively looking for work, you could file for unemployment at that point. EDD makes the determination on each claim separately.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
So there could be a gap if I'm cleared but haven't found work yet — that's the window to file for unemployment.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
That's the general picture. DI covers the days you can't work, unemployment is for when you're able and available. EDD decides each one based on your situation at the time.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
My surgeon's office submitted the DE 2525XX extension for me and EDD sent me a letter saying they received it but my SDI Online still shows the same end date. Is that normal while it's processing, or should I be concerned? I had to get the extension because recovery is taking longer than expected. Getting nervous watching that date tick closer. I ended up getting through to an EDD agent about the extension — the DE 2525XX — by going through Claimyr after spending two mornings trying the disability line and not reaching anyone. The agent confirmed EDD had the form and told me the end date in the portal doesn't update until the new period is processed.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorHow long did it take for the portal to actually update after the agent confirmed they had it?
0 coins
Sergio Neal
About a week after that call the SDI Online end date finally changed. The agent hadn't given me a timeframe, just confirmed it was in the system, so I just kept checking.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
The extension form coming from the doctor's office rather than the claimant is something I didn't understand at first. I thought I had to file something myself.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
EDD actually sends the DE 2525XX with the final payment notice, so the doctor's office gets it through that or finds it through SDI Online. You just need to make sure your provider submits it — you don't complete the extension yourself.
0 coins
Sara Unger
For the original question about how the weekly amount is calculated — to summarize what I've gathered from this thread: EDD looks at the four-quarter base period set by your claim start date, finds your highest-paid quarter in that window, and uses a percentage of those wages for your weekly benefit. The percentage is tiered so lower earners get a higher replacement rate. The Notice of Computation is what tells you the actual number for your specific claim, and EDD's calculator on their site can estimate it beforehand.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
AuthorThat's the clearest summary I've seen. I think what happened with my claim is the bonus quarter I expected to be counted fell just outside the base period window. I'm going to go through SDI Online and ask EDD to verify the start date they have on file.
0 coins
Asher Levin
That's the right move. If the start date is off even slightly it can shift the whole window, and for someone with variable income the difference can be real. Use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online and be specific about which quarter you expected to be used.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
Exactly what I ran into. Getting the start date confirmed was the first step for me too — once that was right, the rest of the calculation made sense.
0 coins